Abstract
Debate has emerged in Scotland about restructuring the eight police forces into a single national service. The main drivers of that debate are identified and the major elements contributing to the case for such a restructuring are presented. The role of local community policing and changes to police accountability mechanisms within such a national structure are discussed. The article concludes that a national police service is the best way forward for policing in Scotland.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.ACPOS (2006 ) Statement of Strategic Priorities for Policing in Scotland . Edinburgh : ACPOS .
2.
Brookes
S.
(2006 ) ‘The Value of Police Authorities’ , Police Review , 114 (5864 ) 10 February 2006.
3.
Dewar
D.
(1998 ) Secretary of State's Speech to Scottish Police Federation Annual Conference, 22 April.
4.
Dickson
M.
(2005 ) ‘Force for Change’ , Police Review , 113 (5856 ) 16 December.
5.
Donnelly
D.
(2006 ) ‘Wanted: Debate on Future Shape of Scots Policing’ , The Herald , 29 March, p. 26 .
6.
Donnelly
D.
Scott
K. B.
(2002a ) ‘Police Accountability in Scotland - (1) The “New” Tripartite System’ , The Police Journal 75 (March), pp. 1 –12 .
7.
Donnelly
D.
Scott
K. B.
(2002b ) ‘Police Accountability in Scotland - (2) “New” Accountabilities’ , The Police Journal 75 (March), pp. 13 –23 .
8.
Donnelly
D.
Scott
K.
, (eds) (2005a ) Policing Scotland . Cullompton : Willan .
9.
Donnelly
D.
Scott
K.
(2005b ) ‘Devolution, Accountability and Scottish Policing’ , in
Donnelly
Scott
(eds), Policing Scotland . Cullompton : Willan .
10.
Donnelly
D.
Scott
K. B.
Wilkie
R.
(2002 ) ‘A National Police Service – Any Day Now?’ , The Police Journal 75 (4 ), pp. 287 –300 .
11.Grant-Aided Expenditure (GAE) (2004 ) – accessed at www.scotland.gov.uk/News/Releases/2004/12100917. The Herald (2004) ‘Call for Debate on National Police Force’, 13 September.
12.
The Herald
(2005 ) ‘Paying for the Police – A £43m Overtime Bill Implies Serious Inefficiencies’ , September, p. 17 .
13.
The Herald
(2006 ) ‘Police Call to Cut Number of Forces’ , 16 May.
14.
Police, Public Order and Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 2006.
15.
Quirk
R.
(2005 ) ‘Future Force’ , Police , December 2005.
16.Royal Commission on the Police (1962 ) Final Report , Cmnd. 1728. London : HMSO .
17.
Sharp
L.
Sir
(1995 ) ‘Sharp's Vision’ , Police Review 103 (5315 ) 28 April.
18.
The Sunday Times
(2005 ) ‘Police Hit by Merger “Bombshell” from Justice Minister’ , 11 September.
19.
The Sunday Times
(2006 ) ‘Police Chief Wants Scots Forces Halved’ , 2 April.
20.
Tompkins
P.
(2006 ) ‘Force of Change Can Only be Good for Our Police’ , The Scotsman 11 April.
