In this paper the author gives his opinion on the existing arrangements for assessment of vocational dental practitioners (VDPs) (outside Scotland), during dental vocational training. He critically evaluates the arrangements in relation to the aims and objectives for dental vocational training. Potential improvements to the existing system are then proposed and new assessment techniques suggested that may help to provide a more robust and relevant educational assessment strategy for dental vocational training in the future.
BaldwinP, DoddM, RennieJ.Postgraduate dental education and the ‘new’ graduate. Br Dent J.1998;185:591–4.
2.
PocockI.A generalist list for dentistry. First Hand (Newsletter of the Faculty of General Dental Practice).2005 July:1–3.
3.
Committee on Vocational Training for England and Wales (CVT).Professional Development Portfolio. London: CVT; 2000.
4.
PrescottL, McKinlayP, RennieJ.The development of an assessment system for dental vocational training and general professional training: a Scottish approach. Br Dent J.2001;190:41–4.
5.
CabotL, RadfordD.Are graduates as good as they used to be?Br Dent J. 1999;186:318–9.
CrossleyJ, HumphrisG, JollyB.Assessing health professionals. Med Educ.2002;36:800–4.
8.
ScallyG, DonaldsonJ.Clinical governance and the drive for quality improvement in the new NHS in England. BMJ.1998;317:61–5.
9.
MorrisZ, BullockA, BelfieldC, ButterfieldS, FrameJ.Assessment in postgraduate dental education: an evaluation of strengths and weaknesses. Med Educ.2001;35:537–43.
10.
RowntreeD.How Shall We Know Them?London: Kogan Page; 1987
11.
National Health Service (General Dental Services) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations No.2224 (S234); 1993.
12.
QuinnF.Principles and Practice of Nurse Education. 4th ed. Cheltenham: Stanley Thornes; 2004.
13.
JollyB, GrantJ.The Good Assessment Guide. London: Joint Centre for Medical Education; 1997.
14.
ReeceI and WalkerS.Teaching Training and Learning. 5th ed. Sunderland: Business Education; 2003.
EvansA, LeesonR, NewtonJohn T, PetrieA.The influence of self-deception and impression management upon self-assessment in oral surgery. Br Dent J.2005;198:765–9.
18.
WoolliscroftJ, TenHakenJ, SmithJ, CalhounJ.Medical students’ clinical self assessments: comparisons with external measures of performance and the students’ self assessments of overall performance and effort. Acad Med.1993;68:285–94.
19.
BullockA, ButterfieldS, MorrisZ, FrameJ.Recommendations for improving the assessment of postgraduate dental education. Br Dent J.2002;192:407–10.
HowardP, HallJ.Guide to the Coursework Module of the MFGDP(UK) Examination. London: Faculty of General Dental Practitioners (UK); 2002.
23.
WolfA.Competence-Based Assessment. Bury St Edmunds: Open University Press; 1995.
24.
ErautM.Developing Professional Knowledge and Competence. London: Falmer Press; 1994.
25.
SchuwirthL, SouthgateL, PageG, PagetN, LescopJ, LewS, . When enough is enough: a conceptual basis for fair and defensible practice performance assessment. Med Educ.2002;36:925–30.
26.
RethansJ, SturmansF, DropM, Van der VleutenC.Assessment of performance in actual practice of general practitioners by use of standardised patients. Br J Gen Pract.1991;41:97–9.
27.
SouthgateL, CampbellM, CoxJ, FoulkesJ, JollyB, McCrorieP, . The General Medical Council's performance procedures: the development and implementation of tests of competence with examples from general practice. Med Educ.2001;35(Suppl. 1):20–8.
