Multidimensional models of leadership in sport suggest that in order to maximize performance there should be congruence between the actual coaching behaviour and behaviours preferred by players. This study examined the preferred coaching leadership behaviours in prolonged periods of perceived success and failure in eighty-eight elite soccer players in Norway using the Leadership Scale for Sport (LSS). The three preferred behaviours were Positive Feedback, Training & Instruction, and Democratic Behaviour in both scenarios. All preferred behaviours (except Autocratic Behaviour) were higher in the unsuccessful scenario (p <.01). Negative relationships existed between age/experience and Social Support, Democratic Behaviours and Positive Feedback in the successful scenario and between age/experience and Social Support and Democratic Behaviours in the unsuccessful scenario (p <.05). The findings therefore have implications for adapting coaching leadership behaviours when players of different ages and with different levels of experience encounter prolonged periods of success or failure.
ChelladuraiP., Leadership in Sport Organizations, Canadian Journal of Applied Sport Science, 1980, 5, 226–231.
3.
ChelladuraiP., Leadership in Sports: A Review, International Journal of Sport Psychology, 1990, 21, 328–354.
4.
ChelladuraiP., Leadership, in: SingerR.N.MurpheyM.TennantL.K. eds., Handbook of Research on Sport Psychology, Macmillan, New York, 1993, 647–671.
5.
ChelladuraiP., Managing Organization for Sport and Physical Activity: A System Perspective, Holcomb-Hathaway, Scottsdale, AZ, 2001.
6.
ChelladuraiP., Leadership in Sport, in: TenenbaumG.EklundR.C. eds., Handbook of Research on Sport Psychology, 3rd edn., John Wiley & Sons Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey, 2007, 113–135.
7.
ChelladuraiP.SalehS.D., Dimensions of Leader Behaviour in Sports: Development of a Leadership Scale, Journal of Sport Psychology, 1980, 2, 34–45.
8.
HornT, Leadership Effectiveness in the Sport Domain, in: HornT. ed., Advances in Sport Psychology, Human Kinetics, Champaign IL., 2002, 309–354.
9.
ChelladuraiP.SalehS. D., Preferred Leadership in Sport, Canadian Journal of Applied Sport Sciences, 1978, 3, 85–92.
10.
SerpaS.PatacoV.SantosF., Leadership Patterns in Handball International Competition, International Journal of Sport Psychology, 1991, 22, 78–89.
11.
ChelladuraiP.CarronA.V., Athletic Maturity and Preferred Leadership, Journal of Sport Psychology, 1983, 5, 371–380.
12.
TerryP.C., The Coaching Preferences of Elite Athletes Competing at Universiade ′83, Canadian Journal of Applied Sport Sciences, 1984, 9, 201–208.
13.
TurmanP.D., Situational Coaching Styles: The Impact of Success and Athletes Maturity Level on Coaches' Leadership Style Over Time, Small Group Research, 2001, 34, 576–594.
14.
ChelladuraiP.RiemerH.A., Measurement of Leadership in Sport, in: DudaJ.L. ed., Advances in Sport and Exercise Psychology Measurement, Fitness Information Technology, Morgantown, WV, 1998, 227–253.
15.
RiemerH.A.ToonK., Leadership and Satisfaction in Tennis: Examination of Congruence, Gender and Ability, Research Quarterly for Exercise & Sport, 2001, 72, 243–256.
16.
ChelladuraiP., Discrepancy between Preferences and Perceptions of Leadership Behaviour and Satisfaction of Athletes in Varying Sports, Journal of Sport Psychology, 1984, 6, 27–41.
17.
RiemerH.A.ChelladuraiP., Leadership and Satisfaction in Athletics, Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 1995, 17, 276–293.
18.
WeissM.R.FriedrichsW.D., The Influence of Leader Behaviours, Coach Attributes, and Institutional Variables on Performance and Satisfaction of Collegiate Basketball Teams, Journal of Sport Psychology, 1986, 8, 332–346.
19.
McMillinC.J., The Relationship of Athlete Self-Perceptions and Athlete Perceptions of Leader Behaviours to Athlete Satisfaction, PhD thesis, University of Virginia, 1990.
20.
HøigaardR., The Influences of Coaches' Behaviour on Team Cohesiveness in Junior Football Teams, in: 26thInternational Congress of Applied Psychology, CD-Rom of Abstracts, Athens, Greece, 2006.
21.
HøigaardR.PetersD.M., The Relationship Between Perceived Coach Behaviour and Perceived Motivational Climate in Youth Football, in: TheodorakisY.GoudasM.PapaioannouA. eds., 12thEuropean Congress of Sport Psychology._Sport and Exercise Psychology Bridges Between Disciplines and Cultures. Book of Abstracts, 2007, 363.
22.
GordonJ., Decision Styles and Coaching Effectiveness in University Soccer, Canadian Journal of Sport Science, 1998, 13(1), 56–65.
23.
HerseyP.BlanchardK.H., Life Cycle Theory of Leadership, Training and Development Journal, 1969, 23(5), 26–35.
24.
HerseyP.BlanchardK.H., Management of Organizational Behaviour: Utilizing Human Resources, 4th edn., Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 1982.
25.
LeUnesA.NationJ. R., Sport Psychology: An Introduction, 2nd edn., Nelson-Hall Publishers, Chicago, 1996.
26.
BanduraA., Self-Efficacy: The Exercise of Control, Freeman, New York, 1997.
27.
FeltzD.L.ShortS.E.SullivanP.J., Self-Efficacy in Sport: Research and Strategies for Working with Athletes, Teams, and Coaches, Human Kinetics, Champaign, IL, 2008.
28.
JonesR.ArmourK.PotracP., Sports Coaching Cultures: From Practice to Theory, Routledge, London, 2004.
29.
McRaeA.E., The Keys to Success: Coaching Styles of Professional Championship Team Sport Coaches, ProQuest Information and Learning Company, Ann Arbor, MI, 2005.
30.
PrattS.EitzenD.S., Contrasting Leadership Styles and Organizational Effectiveness: The Case of Athletic Teams, Social Science Quarterly, 1989, 70, 311–322.
31.
HowellJ.M., Organization Contexts, Charismatic and Exchange Leadership, Kellogg Leadership Studies Monograph, Centre for Political Leadership and Participation, University of Maryland, 1997.
32.
HowellJ.M.AvolioB.J., The Ethics of Charismatic Leadership. Submission or Liberation?Academy of Management Executives, 1992, 6, 43–54.
33.
ValderhaugB., I Fotball Ville Hun Fått Sparken [In Soccer, She Would Have Been Fired], Aftenposten, 2007, October 27, 40.
34.
GammageK.L.CarronA.V.EstabrooksP.A., Team Cohesion and Individual Productivity: The Influence of the Norm for Productivity and the Identifiability of Individual Effort, Small Group Research, 2001, 32 (1), 3–18.
35.
ChelladuraiP.ImamuraH.YamaguchiY.OinumaY.MiyauchiT., Sport Leadership in a Cross-National Setting: The Case of Japanese and Canadian University Athletes, Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 2001, 10, 374–389.
36.
SchliesmanE.S., Relationship Between the Congruence of Preferred and Actual Leader Behaviour and Subordinate Satisfaction with Leadership, Journal of Sport Behaviour, 1987, 10, 157–166.
37.
BlanchardK.ZigarmiP.ZigarmiD., Leadership and the One Minute Manager, Morrow, New York, 1985.
38.
HøigaardR., Team Dynamics in Sport: A Study of Cohesion, Performance Norms, and Motivation in Relation to Performance and Social Loafing, PhD thesis, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, 2006.
39.
EysM.A.BeauchampM.R.BrayS.R., A Review of Team Roles in Sport, in: HantonS.MellalieuS.D. eds., Literature Reviews on Sport Psychology, Nova Science Publisher Inc., New York, 2006, 227–255.
40.
HorneT.CarronA.V., Compatibility in Coach-Athlete Relationships, Journal of Sport Psychology, 1985, 7, 137–149.
41.
HøigaardR.JørgensenA.J., Coaching Conversations: A Way of Fostering Athletes to Peak Performance, Olympic Coach, 2007, 19(3), 4–7.
42.
RiemerH.A., Multidimensional Model of Coach Leadership, inJowettS.LavalleeD. eds., Social Psychology in Sport, Human Kinetics, Champaign, IL, 2007, 57–73.
43.
EysM.A.CarronA.V.BeauchampM.R.BrayS.R., Role Ambiguity in SportTeams, Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 2003, 25(4), 534–550.
