Following the optical error hypothesis, information provided by extra lines across the width of a football (soccer) field (comparable to an American football field) could help assistant referees to judge offside. Therefore, we investigated whether extra lines across the width of a football field influence the positioning of assistant referees and their offside judgments. Eight expert assistant referees each judged potential offside situations played by several attackers and defenders on two different fields, one field with and one field without extra lines. The extra lines resulted in better positioning of the assistant referees but not in less incorrect decisions. A possible explanation for not finding better performance results in the number of incorrect decisions is that the assistant referees first have to learn to use the information provided by the additional lines for judging offside.
FIFA, Laws of the Game, Fédération Internationale de Football Association, Zurich, Switzerland, 2006.
2.
SanabriaJ.CenjorC.MarquezF.GutierrezR.MartinezD.Prados-GarciaJ.L., Oculomotor Movements and Football's Law 11, Lancet, 1998, 351(9098), 268.
3.
Belda MaruendaF., Can the Human Eye Detect an Offside Position During a Football Match?, British Medical Journal, 2004, 329(7480), 1470–1472.
4.
OudejansR.R.D.VerheijenR.BakkerF.C.GerritsJ.C.SteinbrücknerM.BeekP.J., Errors in Judging ‘Offside’ in Football, Nature, 2000, 404(6773), 33.
5.
OudejansR.R.D.VerheijenR.BakkerF.C.GerritsJ.C.SteinbrücknerM.BeekP.J., How Position and Motion of Expert Assistant Referees in Soccer Relate to the Quality of their Offside Judgments During Actual Match Play, International Journal of Sport Psychology, 2005, 36, 3–21.
6.
HelsenW.GilisB.WestonM., Errors in Judging “Offside” in Association Football: Test of the Optical Error versus the Perceptual Flash-Lag Hypothesis, Journal of Sports Sciences, 2006, 24, 521–528.
7.
BaldoM.V.RanvaudR.D.MoryaE., Flag Errors in Soccer Fames: The Flash-Lag Effect Brought to Real Life, Perception. 2002, 31, 1205–1210.
8.
GilisB.HelsenW.CatteeuwP.WagemansJ., Offside Decisions by Expert Assistant Referees in Association Football: Perception and Recall of Spatial Positions in Complex Dynamic Events, Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 2008, 14, 21–35.
9.
GilisB.HelsenW.CatteeuwP.Van RoieE.WagemansJ., Interpretation and Application of the Offside Law by Expert Assistant Referees: Perception of Spatial Positions in Complex Dynamic Events On and Off the Field, Journal of Sports Sciences, 2009, 27, 551–63.
10.
OudejansR.R.D.BakkerF.C.BeekP.J.HelsenGilisWeston (2006) Err in Testing the Optical Error Hypothesis, Journal of Sports Sciences, 2007, 25, 987–990.
11.
HelsenW.GilisB.WestonM.HelsenGilisWeston (2006) Do Not Err in Questioning the Optical Error Hypothesis as the Only Major Account for Explaining Offside Decision-Making Errors, Journal of Sports Sciences, 2007, 25, 991–994.
12.
CatteeuwP.GilisB.WagemansJ.HelsenW., Offside Decision Making of Assistant Referees in the English Premier League: Impact of Physical and Perceptual-Cognitive Factors on Match Performance, Journal of Sports Sciences, 2010, 28, 471–481.
13.
OudejansR.R.D., Judging Offside in Football: Can Attention of Assistant Referees be Educated?, in: CabriJ.AraujoD.ReillyT. eds., Science & Football V: Proceedings of the Fifth World Congress on Science and Football, Lisbon 11–15th April 2003, E&FN Spon, 2005, London, 604–613.
14.
CuttingJ.E.VishtonP.M., Perceiving the Layout and Knowing Distances: The Integration, Relative Potency, and Contextual Use of Different Information about Depth, in: EpsteinW.RogersS. eds., Perception of Space and Motion, Academic Press, San Diego, CA, 1995, 69–117.
15.
GibsonJ.J., The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception, Houghton Mifflin, Boston, MA, 1979.
16.
AnderssonH.EkblomB.KrustrupP., Elite Football on Artificial Turf versus Natural Grass: Movement Patterns, Technical Standards, and Player Impressions, Journal of Sports Sciences, 2008, 26, 113–122.
17.
CatteeuwP.GilisB.Garcia-ArandaJ.M.TresacoF.WagemansJ.HelsenW., Offside Decision Making in the 2002 and 2006 FIFA World Cups, Journal of Sports Sciences, 2010, 28, 1027–32.
18.
JacobsD.M., On Perceiving, Acting, and Learning, PhD Thesis, VU University Amsterdam, 2001.
19.
JacobsD.M.MichaelsC.F., On the Apparent Paradox of Learning and Realism, Ecological Psychology, 2002, 14, 127–139.
20.
AdolpheR.M.VickersJ.N.LaplanteG., The Effects of Training Visual Attention on Gaze Behavior and Accuracy: A Pilot Study, International Journal of Sports Vision, 1997, 4, 28–33.
21.
FarrowD.AbernethyB., Can Anticipatory Skills be Learned Through Implicit Video-Based Perceptual Training?, Journal of Sports Sciences, 2002, 20, 471–485.
22.
HarleS.K.VickersJ.N., Training Quiet Eye Improves Accuracy in the Basketball Free Throw, The Sport Psychologist, 2001, 15, 289–305.
23.
OudejansR.R.D., Effects of Visual Control Training on the Shooting Performance of Elite Female Basketball Players, International Journal of Sports Science and Coaching, 2012, 7(3), 471–482.
24.
OudejansR.R.D.HeubersS.RuitenbeekJ-R.J.A.C.JanssenT.W.J., Training Visual Control in Wheelchair Basketball Shooting, Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 2012, 83(3).
25.
OudejansR.R.D.KoedijkerJ.BleijendaalI.BakkerF.C., The Education of Attention in Aiming at a Far Target: Training Visual Control in Basketball Jump shooting, International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 2005, 3, 197–221.
26.
SavelsberghG.J.P.WilliamsA.M.Van der KampJ.WardP., Visual Search, Anticipation and Expertise in Soccer Goalkeepers, Journal of Sports Sciences, 2002, 20, 279–287.
27.
WilliamsA.M.GrantA., Training Perceptual Skill in Sport, International Journal of Sport Psychology, 1999, 30, 194–220.
28.
WilliamsA.M.WardP., Perceptual Expertise, in: StarkesJ.EricssonA. eds., Expert Performance in Sport, Human Kinetics, Champaign, IL, 2003, 219–249.
