Worth a Thousand Words? The Usefulness of Immersive Virtual Reality for Learning in Cultural Heritage Settings

Abstract

The goal of this paper is to investigate whether immersive virtual reality is suitable for learning about archaeology and the past in cultural heritage settings. To that end it presents the conclusions related to learning from the visitors' survey undertaken in 2007 by the Museology Laboratory of the University of the Aegean at the Hellenic Cosmos (the exhibition centre of the Foundation of the Hellenic World) in Athens, and contrasts these with other similar studies. This project was aimed at comparing the learning outcomes, perception and use by audiences of two different virtual reality systems and a related exhibition. It included qualitative and quantitative analysis of the data gathered through in situ observations, interviews with museum educators and face-to-face questionnaires with visitors. The results confirmed that, as previous studies have shown, virtual reality systems allow a different kind of learning, but also questioned the common believe about their advantage for children in comparison with other interpretation methods.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Belaën

, 2003. L'immersion Au Service Des Musées De Sciences. IN: Ichim03: Cultural Institutions and Digital Technology. Paris, Ecole du Louvre.

Calvert

S. L.

, 2002. The Social Impact of Virtual Reality. http://vehand.eugr.ucf.edu/handbook/Chapters/chapter38.pdf (accessed 27 Aug. 2004).

Dale

, 1969. Audiovisual Methods in Teaching. New York, Holt, Rinehart & Winston.

Economou

and Pujol

, 2006. Educational Tool or Expensive Toy? Evaluating VR Evaluation and Its Relevance for Virtual Heritage. In: New Heritage: Beyond Verosimilitude. Conference on Cultural Heritage and New Media. Proceedings of the New Heritage Conference, Hong-Kong, 13th–14th March 2006. Kvan

and Kalay

Hong Kong, The Faculty of Architecture, University of Hong-Kong, pp. 284–302.

Forte

Pescarin

, 2006. VR Applications, New Devices and Museums: Visitors' Feedback and Learning. A Preliminary Report. In: The E-Volution of Information Technology in Cultural Heritage. Where Hi-Tech Touches the Past: Risks and Challenges for the 21st Century. VAST06. Eurographics, Nicosia, Cyprus, Short papers volume, pp. 64–69.

Gaitatzes

Christopoulos

, 2000. Hellenic Cultural Heritage through Immersive Virtual Archaeology. In: Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on Virtual Systems and Multimedia, October 3–6, 2000. Ogaki, Japan, pp. 57–64.

Jovet

, 2003. Le Multimedia Dans L'exposition: La Double Problématique De L'appropriation Et De L'intégration D'un Media Marginal. In: Ichim03: Cultural Institutions and Digital Technology. Paris, Ecole du Louvre.

Knipp

, 2003. Design Education in the Era of Technology: Considering Visual Perception. In: Ichim03: Cultural Institutions and Digital Technology. Paris, Ecole du Louvre.

K. H.

, 2002. Mixed Reality Interaction for Group Experience. M. Sc. Dissertation, School of Computer of Computer Science and Information Technologies, The University of Nottingham. Nottingham.

10.

Osberg

K. M.

(1997). Constructivism in Practice: The Case for Meaning-Making in the Virtual World. Department of Education, University of Washington, Washington.

11.

Owen

Buhalis

, 2005. Visitor's Evaluations of Icts Used in Cultural Heritage. In: Vast 2005: 6th International Symposium on Virtual Reality, Archaeology and Intelligent Cultural Heritage. Mudge

Ryan

and Scopigno

Europgrahics, Pisa, pp. 129–136.

12.

Pimentel

and Teixeira

, 1995. Virtual Reality: Through the New Looking Glass. New York, McGraw-Hill.

13.

Pozo

J. I.

Asensio

, 1989. Modelos De Aprendizaje – Ensenñanza De La Historia. In: La Ensenñanza De Las Ciencias Sociales. Carretero

Pozo

J. I.

and Asensio

Visor, Madrid, pp. 211–240.

14.

Pujol

and Champion

, 2007. A Critical Examination of Presence Applied to Cultural Heritage. In: Proceedings of the 10th Annual International Workshop on Presence. Moreno, L. Starlab, Barcelona, pp. 245–256.

15.

Pujol

and Economou

, 2006. Evaluating the Social Context of Ict Applications in Museum Exhibitions. In: The E-Volution of Information Technology in Cultural Heritage. Where Hi-Tech Touches the Past: Risks and Challenges for the 21st Century. VAST06. Eurographics, Nicosia, Cyprus, Full Papers Volume, pp. 219–228.

16.

Pujol

and Economou

, 2007. Exploring the Suitability of Virtual Reality Interactivity for Exhibitions through an Integrated Evaluation: The Case of the Ename Museum. Online International Museology Journal, 4, pp. 84–97.

17.

Reid

D. J.

Zhang

, 2003. Supporting Scientific Discovery Learning in a Simulation Environment. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 19(1), pp. 9–20.

18.

Roussou

, 2000. Immersive Interactive Virtual Reality and Informal Education. In: Proceedings of I3 Spring Days 2000 – Workshop on Interactive Learning Environments for Children.

19.

Schuemie

M. J.

Van der Straaten

, 2001. Research on Vr: A Survey. Cyberpsychology and Behavior, 4(2), pp. 183–201.

20.

vom Lehn

Heath

, 2005. Rethinking Interactivity: Design for Participation in Museums and Galleries. I: Re-Thinking Technolgy in Museums: Towards a New Understanding of People's Experience in Museums. Ciolfi

Cooke

Bannon

and Hall

Limerick, Ireland.

21.

Wheeler

Waite

S. J.

, 2002. Promoting Creative Thinking through the Use of Ict. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 18, pp. 367–378.