This paper attempts to follow the political resolution of uncertainty within the acid rain debate in relation to science-policy processes in the UK from 1970 to the present day. It is suggested that the emergence of an epistemic community of scientists, policy-makers, and NGOs cohering around the key concept of critical loads, has been a necessary condition for the evolution of ecomodernist air pollution control policies. Finally it is suggested that although the epistemic community has been influential in diffusing critical loads-based approaches to air pollution control within the major supranational environmental regimes in Europe (the UN ECE and European Community), structural political and economic factors still remain the most important drivers of final policy.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdlerE. and HaasP.M.1992. ‘Epistemic communities, world order, and the creation of a reflective research program’, International Organisation, 46(1): 367–390.
2.
AlcamoJ.ShawR. and HordijkL. (eds.) 1990. The RAINS model of acidification: Science and strategies in Europe. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
3.
AnianssonB. (ed.) 1982. Acidification today and tomorrow. Stockholm: Swedish Ministry of Agriculture Environment '82 Committee.
4.
Anonymous1972. Air pollution across national boundaries: The impact on the environment of sulfur in air and precipitation. Sweden's case study for the United Nations Conference on the Human Environment, 1972. Stockholm
5.
Anon.1976‘Report from the international conference on the effects of acid precipitation in Telemark, Norway, June 14–19, 1976’, Ambio5: 201–202.
6.
Anon.1982. Stop acid rain! An international NGO statement to the 1982 Stockholm Conference on Acidification of the Environment. Stockholm: The Swedish NGO Secretariat on Acid Rain.
7.
Anon.1983. ‘Britain funds independent research on acid rain’, New Scientist 8 September, 671.
8.
ArtsB.1998. The Political Influence of Global NGOs. Cases studies on the Climate and Biodiversity Conventions. Utrecht: International Books.
9.
AshmoreM.BellJ.N.B. and GarrettyC. (eds) 1988. Acid rain and Britain's natural ecosystems. London: Imperial College Centre for Environmental Technology.
10.
Boehmer-ChristiansenS.1988. ‘Black mist and acid rain – science as a fig leaf of policy’, Political Quarterly, 59(2): 145–160.
11.
Boehmer-ChristiansenS.1992. ‘How much science does environmental performance really need?’, in Achieving Environmental Goals (ed. LykkeE.). London: Belhaven Press.
12.
Boehmer-ChristiansenS.1995. The domestic basis of international agreements: Modelling national/international linkages. The British case study: Policy formulation and implementation. SPRU contribution to EC Contract EVSV-CT 930.85. Brighton: Science Policy Research Unit, University of Sussex.
13.
Boehmer-ChristiansenS. and SkeaJ.1991. Acid politics: Environmental and energy policies in Britain and Germany. London: Belhaven Press.
14.
BrydgesT.G. and WilsonR.B.1991. ‘Acid rain since 1985 – times are changing’, Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, 97B, 1–16.
15.
CaufieldC.1983. ‘Treasury vetoes action on acid rain’, New Scientist 15 September 1983, 747.
16.
ChadwickM.J. and NilssonJ.1993. ‘Environmental quality objectives – assimilative capacity and critical load concepts in environmental management’, in JacksonT. (ed.) Clean production strategies: Developing preventive environmental management in the industrial economy. Boca Raton: Lewis Publishers.
17.
ChesterP.F.1982. ‘Acid rain, catchment characteristics and fishery status’, in Ecological Effects of Acid Deposition. Report and background papers 1982 Stockholm Conference on the Acidification of the Environment: Expert Meeting I. Report snv pm 1636. Solna: National Swedish Environment Protection Board.
18.
Commission of the European Communities1992. Towards sustainability: A European Community programme of policy and action in relation to the environment and sustainable development, Vol.II Com (92) Final. Brussels: CEC.
19.
Commission of the European Communities1997. Communication to the Council and European Parliament on a Community strategy to combat acidification. COM(97) 88 Final. Brussels: CEC.
20.
Critical Loads Advisory Group1994. Critical loads of acidity in the United Kingdom. Penicuik: Institute of Terrestrial Ecology.
21.
Department of the Environment1976. Effects of airborne sulphur compounds on forests and freshwaters. Pollution Paper No. 7. London: Her Majesty's Stationery Office.
22.
Department of the Environment1991. Acid rain: Critical and target load maps for the United Kingdom. London: Department of the Environment.
23.
DicksonW.1983. Water acidification – effects and countermeasures. Summary document’, in Ecological Effects of Acid Deposition. Report and background papers 1982 Stockholm Conference on the Acidification of the Environment: Expert Meeting I. Report snv pm 1636. Solna: National Swedish Environment Protection Board.
24.
EdenS.1998. ‘Environmental issues: Knowledge, uncertainty and the environment’, Progress in Human Geography, 22(3), 425–432.
25.
ElsworthS. and ÅgrenC. (eds.) 1987. The limits to nature's tolerance. Göteborg: Swedish NGO Secretariat on Acid Rain.
26.
Environment Committee1984. Acid rain. Volume 1. Session 1983–84, fourth report, House of Commons. London: HMSO.
27.
European Communities Committee1984. Air pollution. Session 1983–84, 22nd report, House of Lords paper 265. London: HMSO.
28.
FarmerA.M.1993. SSSIs at risk from soil acidification, JNCC Report No. 156. Peterborough: JNCC.
29.
FarmerA.M. and BarehamS.A.1993. The environmental implications of UK sulphur emission policy options for England and Wales. JNCC Report No. 176. Peterborough: JNCC.
30.
GeeA. and StonerJ.H.1988. ‘Effecst of acidification on upland freshwaters’, in UsherM.B. and ThompsonD.B.A. (eds.) Ecological change in the uplands. Oxford: Blackwell.
31.
GorhamE.1955. ‘On the acidity and salinity of rain’, Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 7, 231–239.
32.
GorhamE.1958. ‘The influence and importance of daily weather conditions in the supply of chloride, sulphate and other ions to fresh water from atmospheric precipitation’, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Series B 241, 147–178.
33.
HaasP.M.1990. Saving the Mediterranean. New York: Columbia University Press.
34.
HaasP.M.KeohaneR.O. and LevyM.A.1993. Institutions for the Earth. Cambridge MA: MIT Press.
35.
HajerM.A.1995. The politics of environmental discourse: Ecological modernization and the policy process. Clarendon Press, Oxford.
36.
House of Commons Environment Committee1988. First Report: Air pollution. Volume 1. London: Her Majesty's Stationery Office.
37.
HowellsG.D.1982. Letter to B. Rosseland, Directorate for Wildlife and Freshwater Fish, Norway, 28 November, mimeo.
38.
IrwinA.1990. ‘Acid pollution and public policy: The changing climate of environmental decision-making’, in RadojevicM. and HarrisonR.M. (eds) Atmospheric acidity: Sources, consequences and abatement. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
39.
IrwinA.1995. Citizen science: A study of people, expertise and sustainable development. London: Routledge.
40.
LikensG.E.BormannF.H. and JohnsonN.M.1972. ‘Acid rain’, Environment, 14, 33–40.
41.
McCormickJ.1991. British politics and the environment. London: Earthscan.
National Coal Board.1983. ‘£5 million “acid rain” research. NCB welcome “major joint programme”’, press release, 5 September. London: National Coal Board.
44.
NCB.1984. ‘Acid rain – no scientific consensus. Coal Board chairman says UK not a major source’, press release, 27 January. London: National Coal Board.
45.
NilssonJ. (ed.) 1986. Critical Loads for Nitrogen and Sulphur. Miljo Rapport no.11. Copenhagen: Nordic Council of Ministers.
46.
NilssonJ. and GrennfeltP. (eds) 1988. Critical loads for sulphur and nitrogen. Miljo rapport 1988:15. Copenhagen: Nordic Council of Ministers.
47.
OdenS.1968. The acidification of air precipitation and its consequences in the natural environment. Energy Committee Bulletin 1. Stockholm: Swedish Natural Sciences Research Council.
48.
OdenS.1976. ‘The acidity problem – an outline of concepts’, Water, Air and Soil Pollution6: 137–166.
49.
OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development)1979. The OECD programme on long range transport of air pollutants: Measurements and findings. Second edition. Paris: OECD.
50.
O'RiordanT. and JordanA.1996. Social institutions and climate change. In Politics of climate change: A European perspective (eds O'RiordanT. and JagerJ.). London: Routledge.
51.
OverreinL.N.SeipH.M. and TollanA. (eds) 1980. Acid precipitation – effects on forest and fish. Final report of the SNSF project 1972–1980. Research report 19/80. Oslo-Ås: SNSF.
52.
ParkC.C.1987. Acid Rain: Rhetoric and reality. London: Methuen.
53.
PearceF.1993. ‘How Britain hides its acid soils’, New Scientist, 27 February, 29–33.
54.
PoschM.de SmetP.A.M.HettelinghJ.-P. and DowningR.J. (eds) 1999. Calculation and mapping of critical thresholds in Europe: Status Report 1999. Bilthoven: RIVM/UN ECE Cordination Center for Effects.
55.
PrincenT. and FingerM.1994. Environmental NGOs in world politics: Linking the local and the global. London and New York: Routledge.
56.
RoseC.1986. Acid rain: The ecological imperative for pollution controls. Gland, CH: WWF International.
57.
RosselandB.O.1983. Letter to Dr G.D. Howells, Central Electricity Research Laboratory, 28 January, mimeo.
58.
Royal Commission on Environmental Pollution1984. Tenth report. London: HMSO.
59.
SandP.H.1990. Lessons learned in global environmental governance. Washington D.C.: World Resources Institute.
60.
Secretary of State for Environment1990. This Common Inheritance: Britain's environmental strategy. Cm 1200. London: HMSO.
61.
SkeffingtonR.A.1993. ‘Problems with the critical loads approach: A view from industry’, in HornungM. and SkeffingtonR.A. (eds.) Critical loads: Concepts and applications, ITE Symposium no. 28. London: HMSO.
62.
SkeffingtonR.A.1995. ‘Critical loads and energy policy’, in BattarbeeR.W. (ed.) Acid rain and its impact: The critical loads debate. London: Ensis Publishing.
63.
SmithR.A.1852. ‘On the air and rain of Manchester’, Memoirs and Proceedings of the Manchester Literary and Philosophical Society2: 207–217.
64.
SmithR.A.1872. Air and rain: The beginnings of a chemical climatology. London: Longmans Green.
65.
Task Force on Integrated Assessment Modelling1992. Integrated assessment modelling: Progress report by the Chairman of the Task Force. EB.AIR/WG.5/R.27. Geneva: United Nations Economic Commission for Europe.
66.
TickleA.1995. ‘Critical loads and NGO policy’, in BattarbeeR.W. (Ed.) Acid rain and its impact: The critical loads debate. London: Ensis Publishing.
67.
TickleA. and AshmoreM.1988. Critical loads in the United Kingdom. London: Imperial College Centre for Environmental Technology.
68.
TickleA. and SweetJ.1993. Critical loads and UK air pollution policy. London: Friends of the Earth.
69.
UK AWRG1989. Acidity in United Kingdom fresh waters. Second report of the UK Acid Waters Review Group. London: HMSO.
70.
UK RGAR1983. Acid deposition in the United Kingdom. Stevenage: Warren Spring Laboratory.
71.
UK RGAR1987. Acid deposition in the United Kingdom 1981–1985. A second report of the United Kingdom Review Group on Acid Rain. Stevenage: Warren Spring Laboratory.
72.
United Nations1984. Airborne sulphur pollution: Effects and control. Air Pollution Studies 1. New York: United Nations.
73.
United Nations Economic Commission for Europe1988. Executive Body for the Convention on Long-range Transboundary Air Pollution. Report of the sixth session of the Executive Body. Geneva: United Nations Economic and Social Council.
74.
WapnerP.1995. ‘Politics beyond the state: Environmental activism and world civic politics’, World Politics, 47, 311–340.
75.
WarrenS.C.1986. United Kingdom Acid Waters Review Group interim report. London: Department of the Environment.
76.
WatertonC., 1993. The UK case study for acidification and transboundary air pollution – a preliminary survey. Contribution no. H.9 to the project on Social Learning in the Management of Global Environmental Risks. Lancaster: Centre for the Study of Environmental Change, Lancaster University.
77.
WealeA.1992. The new politics of pollution. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
78.
WebbA.H.1982. Collaborative research with Norwegian SNSF project. Internal CERL memorandum to Dr P.F. Chester, 26 August 1982, mimeo.
79.
WrightR.F. and HenriksenA.1980. Regional survey of lakes and streams in southwestern Scotland, April 1979. Intern rapport IR 72/80. Oslo-Ås: SNSF.
80.
WynneB. and SimmonsP.1996. ‘Instititutional cultures and the management of global environmental risks in the U.K.’. Final U.K. contribution to the project on Social Learning in the Management of Global Environmental Risks. Lancaster: Centre for the Study of Environmental Change, Lancaster University.
81.
ZehrS.C.1994. ‘The centrality of scientists and the translation of interests in the U.S. acid rain controversy’, Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology, 31(3), 325–353.
