Optimizing the Geographic Distribution of Wind Plants in Iowa for Maximum Economic Benefit and Reliability

Abstract

By the end of June 1999, 250 MW of wind generation had been dedicated in the State of Iowa. This represents the beginning of what is likely to be significant wind capacity development during the next 20 years in the State as a result of possible governmental mandates and consumers' desire for sustainable sources of energy. After accounting for predicted load growth over the next 15 years, we estimate Iowa's potential wind energy portfolio through to the year 2015. Winds in the Midwest are primarily generated by fronts moving through the region. The purpose of this study is to find the best way to distribute wind-generating capacity among several sites by using an electricity-production, cost and reliability model. We calculate this benefit in terms of reduction in the fuel cost of conventional generators. We also consider system reliability in terms of energy not served (ENS). Our findings indicate that it is beneficial to develop wind power plants at several sites, and that there are many possible combinations of wind locations that can be chosen to obtain diversity benefits. We also calculate capacity credit for the composite wind power plants using two different methods, and calculate a trade-off curve between the economically optimal and the most reliable solutions. The methods we use to find the best geographical locations and sizes of wind power plant are based on a dynamic fuzzy search algorithm and a genetic algorithm. Each procedure produces a solution set that can be analyzed further in other contexts, such as voltage and land use constraints. We illustrate the sensitivity of the fuzzy economic benefit solutions to small perturbations of the capacity selections at each wind site. We find that small changes in site capacity and/or location have small effects on the economic benefit provided by wind power plants.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Kahn

, “The Reliability of Distributed Wind Generators,” Electric Power Systems Research. Vol. 2, 1979. Elsevier Sequoia: Lausanne.

Grubb

M. J.

, “The Integration of Renewable Electricity Sources,” Energy Policy, September 1991, pp. 670–688.

Milligan

Artig

, “Optimal Site Selection and Sizing of Distributed Utility-Scale Wind Power Plants,” Proceedings of the 1998 International Conference of the International Association for Energy Economics, pp. 313–322.

Ernst

, Analysis of Wind Power Ancillary Services Characteristics with German 250-MW Wind Data NREL/TP-500-26969. Golden, Colorado, USA. National Renewable Energy Laboratory, 1999.

Varian

, Microeconomic Analysis, New York: Norton, 1978, pp. 27–34.

McConnell

Brue

, Economics, 14th ed., Boston: Irwin/McGraw Hill, 1999, page 429.

Milligan

Miller

Chapman

, “Estimating the Economic Value of Wind Forecasting to Utilities,” Proceedings of WindPower ′95 Conference. NREL/TP-441-7803.

Fukunaga

, Introduction to Statistical Pattern Recognition., 2nd ed. New York: Academic Press, 1990.

United States Department of Energy. “Advanced Horizontal Axis Wind Turbines in Windfarms,” available on the web at www.eren.doe.gov/power/pdfs/turbines.pdf. Supporting data from Joe Cohen, Princeton Economic Research Institute, 1997.

10.

Milligan

, “Variance Estimates of Wind Plant Capacity Credit,” Proceedings of the Windpower ′96 Conference, Denver, Colorado. NREL/TP-440-21311. Golden, Colorado: National Renewable Energy Laboratory, 1996.

11.

Billinton

Allen

, Reliability Evaluation of Power Systems. New York: Plenum Press, 1984.

12.

Billinton

Chen

Ghajar

, “A Sequential Simulation Technique for Adequacy Evaluation of Generating Systems Including Wind Energy,” IEEE/PES Winter Meeting, January 21–25, 1996.

13.

Milligan

Graham

, “An Enumerative Technique for Modelling Wind Power Variations in Production Costing,” Proceedings of the 1997 International Conference on Probabilistic Methods Applied to Power Systems. NREP/CP-440-22828, Golden, Colorado: National Renewable Energy Laboratory, 1997.

14.

Milligan

, “Wind Plant Capacity Variations: A Comparison of Results Using Multiyear Actual and Simulated Wind-Speed Data,” Proceedings of the Wind ′97 Conference, Austin, Texas. NREL/CP-440-23096. Golden, Colorado: National Renewable Energy Laboratory, 1997.

15.

Billinton

Chowdhury

, “Incorporation of Wind Energy Conversion Systems in Conventional Generating Capacity Adequacy Assessment,” IEEE Proceedings–C, Vol. 139, No. 1, January 1992. pp. 47–56.

16.

Wan

, “An Analysis of Current Utility Practice of Rating and Reporting Wind Generating Capacity,” Working Paper. Golden, Colorado: National Renewable Energy Laboratory.

17.

Goldberg

, Genetic Algorithms in Search, Optimization and Machine Learning. Reading, Massachusetts: Addison-Wesley, 1989.