Because of popular fears about death and dying, his personal interest in the subject and a lack of empirical data regarding the dying process, William Osler conducted a novel ‘Study of the Act of Dying’ of 486 patients at the Johns Hopkins Hospital between 1900 and 1904. Osler never wrote a manuscript describing the results of this study However, in his lecture ‘Science and Immortality’ Osler mentioned the study briefly and reported that 104 patients (21%) experienced physical, mental or spiritual discomforts. He concluded that for most patients ‘death was a sleep and a forgetting’. To better understand the results of Osler's study, the original data collection cards and a spreadsheet of the study data used by Osler were carefully examined. One hundred and eighty-six unique patients (38%) experienced discomforts, 79% higher than Osler reported in ‘Science and Immortality’. Overall, 76 cards contained data discrepant with Osler's spreadsheet (McNemar's test, P < 0.05). A number of factors, including haste, may account for the discrepant results. Nevertheless, the results shed light on the dying process during Osler's time. Furthermore, the results suggest that many dying patients during Osler's time experienced discomforts.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
OslerW. A study of dying, typewritten c1900-04; stored at the Osler Library of the History of Medicine, McGill University, Montreal, Canada (Bibliotheca Osleriana no. 7644)
2.
BryanCS. Fever, famine, and war: William Osler as an infectious diseases specialist. Clinical Infectious Diseases1996; 23: 1139-19
3.
DavisonWC. Memories of Sir William Osler. Journal of the American Medical Association1969; 210: 2219-22
4.
BlissM. William Osler: a Life in Medicine.New York: Oxford University Press, 1999
5.
OslerW. Science and Immortality.Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1904
6.
Twelfth Report of the Superintendent of the Johns Hopkins Hospital for the Year Ending January 31, 1901.Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins Press, 1901
7.
Thirteenth Report of the Superintendent of the Johns Hopkins Hospital for the Year Ending January 31, 1902.Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins Press, 1902
8.
Fourteenth Report of the Superintendent of the Johns Hopkins Hospital for the Year Ending January 31, 1903.Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins Press, 1903
9.
Fifteenth Report of the Superintendent of the Johns Hopkins Hospital for the Year Ending January 31, 1904.Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins Press, 1904
10.
Sixteenth Report of the Superintendent of the Johns Hopkins Hospital for the Year Ending January 31, 1905.Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins Press, 1905
11.
List of graduates of Johns Hopkins School of Nursing. The Johns Hopkins Nurses Alumnae Magazine1938; 4
12.
Courtesy of The Alan Mason Chesney Medical Archives of The Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions, The Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine 1900-06 catalogue
13.
WheelerM. Death. In: Heaven, Hell, and the Victorians.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994: 28-19
14.
JallandP. The revival and decline of the good Christian death. In: Death in the Victorian Family.Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1996: 39-58
15.
BenolielJQ, DegnerLF. Institutional dying: a convergence of cultural values, technology, and social organization. In: WassH, NeimeyerRA, eds. Dying: Facing the Facts.3rd edn.Washington, DC: Taylor and Francis, 1995: 117-42
16.
ComperFMM. The Book of the Craft of Dying and Other Early English Tracts Concerning Death.London: Longmans, Green, and Co, 1917
17.
JallandP. Death and the Victorian doctors. In: Death in the Victorian Family.Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1996: 77-97
18.
CarringtonHHL, MeaderJR. Death: Its Causes and Phenomena, with Special Reference to Immortality.London: William Rider & Son, Ltd, 1911
19.
BichatX. Physiological Researches Upon Life and Death: (English translation revised and edited by Watkins T) Philadelphia: Smith and Maxwell, 1809
20.
Avicenna. Traités Mystiques d'Abou Alî al-Housain b. Abdallah b. Sênâ ou d'Avicenne, IIIeine fascicule (French translation revised and edited by Mehran AF). Leyde: EJ Brill, 1894
21.
MackennaRW. The Adventure of Death.London: John Murray, 1916
SmithA. Dreamthorp: a Book of Essays Written in the Country.London: Strahan & Co, 1863
24.
WilliamsCB. Euthanasia. The Medical and Surgical Reporter1894; 70: 909-11
25.
KeyesEL. The fear of death. Harper's Magazine1909; 58: 208-12
26.
SavoryWS. On Life and Death: Four Lectures Delivered at the Royal Institution of Great Britain.London: Smith, Elder and Co, 1863
27.
BrowneT. A Letter to a Friend, upon Occasion of the Death of His Intimate Friend.London: C. Brome, 1690
28.
WeberFP. Aspects of Death and Correlated Aspects of Life in Art, Epigram, and Poetry: Contributions Toward an Anthology and an Iconography of the Subject.3rd edn.London: T Fisher Unwin, 1918
29.
WaltersG. Is there such a thing as a good death?Palliative Medicine2004; 18: 404-8
30.
JallandP. Victorian death and its decline: 1850-1918. In: JuppPC, GittingsC, eds. Death in England: an Illustrated History.New Brunswick, New Jersey: Rutgers University Press, 2000
31.
FarrellJJ. The dying of death: historical perspectives. Death Education1982; 6: 105-23
32.
AriesP. The reversal of death: changes in attitudes toward death in Western societies. In: FultonR, MarkusenE, OwenG, SchieberJL, eds. Death and Dying: Challenges and Change.Reading, MA: Addis on-Wesley Publishing Company, 1978: 52-7
33.
WolffeJ. Great Deaths: Grieving, Religion, and Nationhood in Victorian and Edwardian Britain.Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000
34.
FrielPB. Death and dying. Annals of Internal Medicine1982; 97: 767-71
35.
CorCA. Death in modern society. In: DoyleD, HanksGWC, MacDonaldN, eds. Oxford Textbook of Palliative Medicine.2nd edn.Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999: 31-10
36.
ArièsP. Western Attitudes toward Death: From the Middle Ages to the Present.Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1974
37.
CushingH. The Life of Sir William Osler.2 volumes. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1925: vol. I, p. 294
38.
HinoharaS. Sir William Osler's philosophy on death. Annals of Internal Medicine1993; 118: 638-12
39.
GoldenRL. Sir William Osler: humanistic thanatologist. OMEGA: Journal of Death and Dying1997-1998;36: 241-58
40.
LeilaJW. Constructing history in biography: a symposium on William Osler: a life in medicine. Bliss's Osler. Bulletin of the History of Medicine2001; 75: 760-6
41.
HowardRP. The men who inspired William Osler. Southern Medical Journal1972; 65: 232-6
42.
OslerW. Sir W Osler and Maeterlinck (letter). Spectator 4 November 1911
43.
CushingH (op. cit. ref. 37): vol. I, p. 85
44.
SchnabelTG. William Osler at the Philadelphia Hospital. Medical Life1934; 41: 75-88
45.
MacDermotHE. Osler's original autopsy books. Archives of Internal Medicine1949; 84: 7-11
46.
Courtesy of The Alan Mason Chesney Medical Archives of The Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions, MacCallum WG. Papers, Box 8, Folder 3. MacCallumWG. Osler at Blockley: The Dedication of the Osler Memorial Building at Old Blockley, 1940 (unpublished manuscript)
47.
OslerW. The Treatment of Disease: the Address in Medicine Before the Ontario Medical Association, Toronto, 3 June 1909.London: Frowde, 1909
48.
OslerW. Memorandum books, handwritten cl872-1919; stored at the Osler Library of the History of Medicine, McGill University, Montreal, Canada (Bibliotheca Osleriana no. 7665)
49.
RolandCG. Sir William Osler's dreams and nightmares. Bulletin of the History of Medicine1980; 54: 418-46
50.
JonesS. Sir William Osler's views on euthanasia. Osler Library Newsletter1994; 77: 1-3
51.
CushingH (op. cit. ref. 37): vol. II, pp. 298-301
52.
FrancisWW, HillRH, MallochA, eds. Bibliotheca Osleriana: a Catalogue of Books Illustrating the History of Medicine and Science.Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1929
53.
FlintA. Collected Essays and Articles on Physiology and Medicine: 1855-1902.New York: D Appleton and Co, 1903
54.
PhilipAPW. An Inquiry into the Nature of Sleep and Death.London: Henry Renshaw, 1834
55.
HazlittW. On the fear of death. In: KeynesG, ed. Selected Essays of William Hazlitt.New York: Random House, 1930: 160-71
56.
MunkW. Euthanasia: Medical Treatment in Aid of an Easy Death.London: Longmans, Green and Co, 1887
57.
OslerW. Canada Medical and Surgical Journal1888; 16: 510-1
58.
OslerW. Physic and physician as depicted in Plato. In: HinoharaS, NikiH, eds. Osler's ‘A Way of Life’ and Other Addresses, with Commentary and Annotations.Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2001: 125-50
59.
HarveyA. First Lines of Therapeutics: as Based on the Modes and the Processes of Healing, as Occurring Spontaneously in Disease; and on the Modes and the Processes of Dying, as Resulting Naturally from Disease.London: HK Lewis, 1879
60.
ClevelandWF. The Modes of Dying, and the Means of Obviating the Tendency to Death.London: Churchill, 1870
61.
FaggeCH. On the different modes of dying. Guys Hospital Reports1879; 24: 343-54
62.
AckernechtEH. Death in the history of medicine. Bulletin of the History of Medicine1968; 42: 19-23
63.
HarreilGT. Osler's practice. Bulletin of the History of Medicine1973; 47: 545-68
64.
MacCallumWG. Osler as pathologist. Johns Hopkins Hospital Bulletin1919; 30: 197-8
65.
ThayerWS. Osler, the teacher. Johns Hopkins Hospital Bulletin1919; 30: 198-200
66.
WelchWH. Osler memorial meeting. The Johns Hopkins Alumni Magazine1921; 9: 302-11
67.
EdelsteinL. William Osler's philosophy. Bulletin of the History of Medicine1946; 20: 270-93
68.
TeigenPM. Constructing history in biography: a symposium on William Osler: a life in medicine. William Osler, again. Bulletin of the History of Medicine2001; 75: 745-55
69.
Office of the Director of the Johns Hopkins Hospital School of Nursing. Monthly and Annual Reports, February 1894 - February 1899. Entry by M Adelaide Nutting, 13 December 1898 (Archives of the Johns Hopkins Hospital School of Nursing, the Alan Mason Chesney Medical Archives, Archives of the Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions)
70.
CushingH (op. cit, ref. 37): vol. I, p. 636
71.
FyeWB. William Osler's departure from North America: the price of success. New England Journal of Medicine1989; 320: 1425-31
72.
CushingH. William Osler: the man. Annals of Medical History1919; 2: 157-67
73.
CushingH (op. cit., ref. 37): vol. I, p. 630
74.
Osler Library of the History of Medicine, McGill University, Montreal. Harvey Cushing Fonds, P417, folder 94, 1898
75.
Osler Library of the History of Medicine, McGill University, Montreal. Harvey Cushing Fonds: Ingersoll lectures, P417, folder 100, 1920
76.
The dull business of death. Philadelphia Ledger, 19 September 1915
77.
The adventure of death. Spectator, 19 August 1916, p. 208
78.
GibsonGA. Death and Sleep.Edinburgh: Private Printing, 1907
79.
YoungF. Poor death. English Review1916; 23: 131-5
80.
The sting of death. Spectator, 7 May 1910, p. 761
81.
MaeterlinckM (translated by Teizeira de Mattos A). Death.New York: Dodd, Mead, & Co, 1912
82.
OslerW. A book review by Sir William Osler. Annals of Medical History1919; 2: 84-5
