Restricted accessOtherFirst published online 2006-7
Accident and emergency teleconsultation for primary care - a systematic review of technical feasibility,clinical effectiveness,cost effectiveness and level of local management
A systematic review of accident and emergency teleconsultation services was carried out. Studies (English language only) conducted worldwide and published between 1996 and 2003 were included. Evidence relating to technical feasibility, clinical effectiveness, cost effectiveness and level of local management was used as the main outcome measure. Thirty-one studies met the selection criteria. Only two studies were randomized controlled studies. All studies provided evidence that that the service was technically feasible. Of the studies, 97% suggested that the service was clinically effective; 48% (15) of the studies gave figures for the level of local management achieved. The range for local management was 35–100% with a mean of 76%. Only 23% of the studies provided evidence to suggest that the service was cost effective. The case for cost-effectiveness is far from proven and this area of research requires immediate attention if potential users are to be convinced of the value of telemedicine.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
DarkinsA, DeardenCH, RockeLG, MartinJB, SibsonL, WoottonR.An evaluation of telemedical support for a minor treatment centre. J Telemed Telecare1996; 2: 93–9
2.
BlackwellNA, KellyGJ, LentonLM.Telemedicine ophthalmology consultation in remote Queensland. Med J Aust1997; 167: 583–6
3.
LambrechtCJ.Emergency physicians’ roles in a clinical telemedicine network. Ann Emerg Med1997; 30: 670–4
4.
ArmstrongIJ, HastonWS.Medical decision support for remote general practitioners using telemedicine. J Telemed Telecare1997; 3: 27–34
5.
ShanitD, GreenbaumRA.Towards a comprehensive telecardiology monitoring centre for community-based services. J Telemed Telecare1997; 3(Suppl. 1): 60–2.
6.
RosengrenD, BlackwellN, KellyG, LentonL, GlastonburyJ.The use of telemedicine to treat ophthalmological emergencies in rural Australia. J Telemed Telecare1998; 4(Suppl. 1): 97–9.
7.
TachakraS, WileyC, DawoodM, SivakumarA, DuttonD, HayesJ.Evaluation of telemedical support to a free-standing minor accident and treatment service. J Telemed Telecare1998; 4: 140–5
8.
LeeJK, RennerJB, SaundersBFEffect of real-time teleradiology on the practice of the emergency department physician in a rural setting: initial experience. Acad Radiol1998; 5: 533–8
9.
O'ReillyS, SpeddingR, DeardenC, LoaneM.Can X-rays be accurately interpreted using a low cost telemedicine system?J Accid Emerg Med1998; 15: 312–14
10.
RissamHS, KishoreS, SrivastavaS, BhatiaML, TrehanN.Evaluation of cardiac symptoms by trans-telephonic electrocardiographic monitoring (ITEM): preliminary experience. Indian Heart J1998; 50: 55–8
BrennanJA, KealyJA, GerardiLHTelemedicine in the emergency department: a randomized controlled trial. J Telemed Telecare1999; 5: 18–22
13.
ChodroffPH.A three-year review of telemedicine at the community level - clinical and fiscal results. J Telemed Telecare1999; 5(Suppl. 1): 28–30.
14.
HyerRN.Telemedical experiences at an Antarctic station. J Telemed Telecare1999; 5(Suppl. 1): 87–9.
15.
KrupinskiE, GonzalesM, GonzalesC, WeinsteinRS.Evaluation of a digital camera for acquiring radiographic images for telemedicine applications. Telemed J E Health2000; 6: 297–302
16.
PatelT.A cost-benefit analysis of the effect of shipboard telemedicine in a selected oceanic region. J Telemed Telecare2000; 6(Suppl. 1): 165–7.
17.
SalmonS, BrintG, MarshallD, BradleyA.Telemedicine use in two nurse-led minor injuries units. J Telemed Telecare2000; 6(Suppl. 1): 43–5.
18.
TachakraS, LoaneM, UcheCU.A follow-up study of remote trauma teleconsultations. J Telemed Telecare2000; 6: 330–4
19.
TachakraS, LynchM, NewsonRA comparison of tele-medicine with face-to-face consultations for trauma management. J Telemed Telecare2000; 6(Suppl. 1): 178–81.
20.
WoottonR, McKelveyA, McNichollBTransfer of telemedical support to Cornwall from a national telemedicine network during a solar eclipse. J Telemed Telecare2000; 6(Suppl. 1): 182–6.
21.
TachakraS, DuttonD, NewsonRLevel of diagnostic confidence and accuracy in teleradiology for minor injuries work. J Telemed Telecare2000; 6(Suppl. 1): 196–7.
22.
TachakraS, HollingdaleJ, UcheCU.Evaluation of telemedical orthopaedic specialty support to a minor accident and treatment service. J Telemed Telecare2001; 7: 27–31
23.
BrebnerJA, BrebnerEM, Ruddick-BrackenH, WoottonR.The development of a pilot telemedicine network in Scotland: lessons learned. J Telemed Telecare2001; 7(Suppl. 2): 83–4.
24.
RogersFB, RicciM, CaputoMThe use of telemedicine for real-time video consultation between trauma care center and community hospital in a rural setting improves early trauma care: preliminary results. J Trauma2001; 51: 1037–41
25.
TachakraS, Uko UcheC, StinsonA.Four years’ experience of telemedicine support of a minor accident and treatment service. J Telemed Telecare2002; 8(Suppl. 2): 87–9.
26.
BrebnerEM, BrebnerJA, Ruddick-BrackenH, WoottonR, FergusonJ.Evaluation of a pilot telemedicine network for accident and emergency work. J Telemed Telecare2002; 8(Suppl. 2): 5–6.
27.
ScalviniS, ZanelliE, ContiCAssessment of prehospital chest pain using telecardiology. J Telemed Telecare2002; 8: 231–6
28.
TachakraS.Level of diagnostic confidence, accuracy, and reasons for mistakes in teleradiology for minor injuries. Telemed J E Health2002; 8: 111–21
29.
BengerJR, NobleSM, CoastJ, KendallJM.The safety and effectiveness of minor injuries telemedicine. Emerg Med J2004; 21: 438–45
30.
FortinJP, GagnonMP, CloutierA, LabbeF.Evaluation of a telemedicine demonstration project in the Magdalene Islands. J Telemed Telecare2003; 9: 89–94
31.
EllisDG, MayroseJ.The success of emergency telemedicine at the State University of New York at Buffalo. Telemed J E Health2003; 9: 73–9
32.
LobleyD.The economics of telemedicine. J Telemed Telecare1997; 3: 117–25
33.
BrebnerE.Clinical telemedicine: the development and introduction of an accident and emergency teleconsultation service for North East Scotland. Ph.D. Thesis. Aberdeen, UK: University of Aberdeen, 2004
