To critically evaluate the quality of hospital medical care at the beginning, during and shortly after regionalization of health boards in Newfoundland and Labrador, and aggregation of hospitals in the StJohn's region.
Methods
Retrospective chart audits for the years 1995/96, 1998/99 and 2000/01 (at the beginning, during and after restructuring) focused on outcomes in cardiology, respiratory medicine, neurology, nephrology, psychiatry, surgery andwomen's health programmes. Where possible, quality of care was judged on measurable outcomes in relation to published statements of likely optimal care. Comparisons were made over time within the StJohn's region, and separately for hospitals in the rest of the province.
Results
There was improvement in the use of thrombolytics and secondary measures post-myocardial infarction in both regions. Mortality and appropriateness of initial antibiotic choice for community-acquired pneumonia remained stable in both regions, with an improvement in admission appropriateness based on the severity in St John's. Aspects of stroke management (referral and time to see allied health professionals, imaging and discharge home) improved in both regions, while mortality remained stable. There was improvement in fistula rate, quality of dialysis and anaemia management in haemodialysis patients, and improvement in the peritoneal dialysis patient peritonitis rate. Readmission rate for schizophrenia remained unchanged. Stable mortality rates were observed for frequently performed surgical procedures. The post-coronaryartery by pass grafting (CABG) morbid event rate improved, although access to CABG was not optimal.
Conclusions
Aggregation of acute care hospitals was feasible without attendant deterioration in patient care, and in some areas care improved. However, access to services continued to be a major problem in all regions.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
SochalskiJ, AikenLH, FaginCM.Hospital restructuring in the United States, Canada, and Western Europe: an outcomes research agenda.Med Care1997; 35(Suppl):OS13–25
2.
KovnerC.The impact of staffing and the organization of work on patient outcomes and health care workers in health care organizations.Joint Commission J Qual Improvement2001; 27: 458–68
3.
AikenLH, ClarkeSP, SloaneDM.Hospital restructuring: does it adversely affect care and outcomes?J Nurs Admin2000; 30: 457–65
4.
FloodAB.The impact of organizational and managerial factors on the quality of care in health care organizations.Med Care Rev1994; 51: 381–428
5.
ChurchJ, BarkerP.Regionalization of health services in Canada: a critical perspective.Int J Health Serv1998; 28: 467–86
6.
TwellsL, DoyleM, GregoryD, BarrettB, ParfreyP.Acute care restructuring in Newfoundland and Labrador: the history and impact on expenditure.J Health Serv Res Policy2005; 10(Suppl 2):4–11
7.
DavisE.The Health Care Corporation of St John's: the first five years of regionalization and restructuring.J Health Serv Res Policy2005; 10(Suppl 2):68–70
8.
SadishW, CookTD, CampbellDT.Experimental and Quasi-Experimental Designs for Generalized Causal Inference.Houghton Mifflin College Div, 2002
9.
The Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada, the Canadian Cardiovascular Society and the Canadian Association of Emergency Physicians for the Emergency Cardiac Care Coalition. Recommendations for ensuring early thrombo-lytic therapy for acute myocardial infarction.Can Med Assoc J1996;154: 483–7
10.
MarkelKN, MarionSA.CQI: improving the time to thrombolytic therapy for patients with acute myocardial infarction in the emergency department.J Emerg Med1996; 14: 685–9
11.
FineMJ, AubleTE, YealyDM. A prediction rule to identify low-risk patients with community-acquired pneumonia.N Engl J Med1997; 336: 243–50
12.
MandellLA, NiedermanM.The Canadian Community Acquired Pneumonia Consensus Conference Group. Antimicrobial treatment of community acquired pneumonia in adults: a conference report.Can J Infect Dis1993; 4: 25–8
13.
MandellLA, MarrieTJ, GrossmanRF, ChowAW, HylandRH.Summary of Canadian guidelines for the initial management of community-acquired pneumonia: an evidence-based update by the Canadian Infectious Disease Society and the Canadian Thoracic Society.Can Resp J2000; 7: 371–82
14.
Collaborative systematic review of the randomised trials of organised inpatient (stroke unit) care after stroke. Stroke Unit Trialists’ Collaboration.Br Med J1997;314: 1151–9
15.
KalraL, EvansA, PerezI, KnappM, DonaldsonN, SwiftCG.Alternative strategies for stroke care: a prospective randomised controlled trial.Lancet2000; 356: 894–9
16.
Stroke Unit Trialists Collaboration. How do stroke units improve patient outcomes? A collaborative systematic review of the randomized trials.Stroke1997;28:2139–44
17.
AdamsR, AckerJ, AlbertsM. Recommendations for improving the quality of care through stroke centers and systems: an examination of stroke center identification options: multidisciplinary consensus recommendations from the Advisory Working Group on Stroke Center Identification Options of the American Stroke Association.Stroke2002; 33:e1–7
18.
Stroke Unit Trialists’ Collaboration.Organised Inpatient (Stroke Unit) Care for Stroke (Cochrane Review).Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, 2004
19.
BarrettBJ, FentonSS, FergusonB. Clinical practice guidelines for the management of anemia coexistent with chronic renal failure. Canadian Society of Nephrology.J Am Soc Nephrol1999; 10(Suppl 13):S292–6
20.
EthierJH, LindsayRM, BarrePE, KappelJE, CarlisleEJ, Common A. Clinical practice guidelines for vascular access. Canadian Society of Nephrology.J Am Soc Nephrol1999; 10(Suppl 13):S297–305
21.
DezielC, HirschDJ, HoultP. Clinical practice guidelines for the delivery of hemodialysis. Canadian Society of Nephrology.J Am Soc Nephrol1999; 10(Suppl 13):S306–10
22.
BargmanJM, BickJ, CartierP. Guidelines for adequacy and nutrition in peritoneal dialysis. Canadian Society of Nephrology.J Am Soc Nephrol1999; 10(Suppl 13):S311–21
23.
Treatment of schizophrenia. The expert consensus guideline series.J Clin Psychiatry1999;60(Suppl 11):3–80
24.
GilbodySM, HouseAO, SheldonTA.Outcome measures and needs assessment tools for schizophrenia and related disorders.Cochrane Database Syst Rev2003, CD003081
25.
FoxGA, O'DeaJ, ParfreyPS.Coronary artery bypass graft surgery in Newfoundland and Labrador.Can Med Assoc J1998; 158: 1137–42
26.
KentGM, PowerL, GregoryDM. Need for coronary artery bypass grafting in Newfoundland and Labrador: the impact of increased demand.Can J Cardiol2004; 20: 399–404
27.
NaylorCD, BaigrieRS, GoldmanBS, BasinskiA.Assessment of priority for coronary revascularisation procedures. Revascularisation Panel and Consensus Methods Group.Lancet1990; 335: 1070–3
28.
RamsayC, WalkerM.Waiting Your Turn: Hospital Wait Lists in Canada6th edn.Vancouver, BC: Fraser Institute, 1996
29.
WilsonG, ZelderM.Waiting Your Turn: Hospital Waiting Lists in Canada9th edn.Vancouver, BC: Fraser Institute, 1999
30.
EsmailN, WalkerM.Waiting Your Turn: Hospital Waiting Lists in Canada12th edn.Vancouver, BC: Fraser Institute, 2002
31.
GregoryD, WayC, BarrettB, ParfreyP.Health care quality from the perspective of health care providers and patients during and shortly after acute care restructuring in Newfoundland and Labrador.J Health Serv Res Policy2005; 10(Suppl 2):48–57
32.
FeaganBG, MarrieTJ, LauCY, WheelerSL, WongCJ, VandervoortMK.Treatment and outcomes of community-acquired pneumonia at Canadian hospitals.Can Med Assoc J2000; 162: 1415–20
33.
MarrasTK, ChanCK.Use of guidelines in treating community-acquired pneumonia.Chest1998; 113: 1689–94
34.
MarrasTK, JamiesonL, ChanCK.Inpatient care of community-acquired pneumonia: the effect of antimicrobial guidelines on clinical outcomes and drug costs in Canadian teaching hospitals.Can Resp J2004; 11: 131–7
35.
JinY, MarrieTJ, CarriereKC. Variation in management of community-acquired pneumonia requiring admission to Alberta, Canada hospitals.Epidemiol Infect2003; 130: 41–51
36.
MarrieTJ, CarriereKC, JinY, JohnsonDH.Mortality during hospitalisation for pneumonia in Alberta, Canada, is associated with physician volume.Eur Resp J2003; 22: 148–55
37.
TuJV, PorterJ.Stroke Care in Ontario: Hospital Survey Results.Toronto: Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences (ICES), 1999
38.
TuJV, GongY.Trends in treatment and outcomes for acute stroke patients in Ontario, 1992-1998.Arch Intern Med2003; 163: 293–7
39.
WayC, GregoryD, DoyleM, TwellsL, BarrettB, ParfreyP.Health care provider outcomes during and shortly after acute care restructuring in Newfoundland and Labrador.J Health Serv Res Policy2005; 10(Suppl 2):58–67
40.
AikenLH, ClarkeSP, SloaneDM.Hospital staffing, organization, and quality of care: cross-national findings.Int J Qual Health Care2002; 14: 5–13
41.
HowardJW, AlidinaS.Multihospital systems increase costs and quality. Results from a national evaluation using time series analysis, audit of patients’ notes, and interviews.Dimens Health Serv1987; 64: 20–4
42.
BrownellMD, RoosNP, BurchillC.Monitoring the impact of hospital downsizing on access to care and quality of care.Med Care1999; 37(Suppl):JS135–50
43.
SheldonTA, CullumN, DawsonD. What's the evidence that NICE guidance has been implemented? Results from a national evaluation using time series analysis, audit of patient's notes, and interviews.Br Med J2004; 329: 999
44.
LiuL, HaderJ, BrossartB, WhiteR, LewisS.Impact of rural hospital closures in Saskatchewan, Canada.Social Sci Med2001; 52: 1793–804
45.
PiloteL, LavoieF, HoV, EisenbergMJ.Changes in the treatment and outcomes of acute myocardial infarction in Quebec, 1988-1995.Can Med Assoc J2000; 163: 31–6
46.
Improving Cardiovascular Outcomes in Nova Scotia (ICONS). ICONS Data Analysis: Report on Acute Myocardial Infarction. Website accessed May 2005
47.
FonarowGC.The role of in-hospital initiation of cardiovascular protective therapies to improve treatment rates and clinical outcomes.Rev Cardiovasc Med2003; 4(Suppl 3):S37–46
SanmartinC, ShorttSE, BarerML, ShepsS, LewisS, McDonaldPW.Waiting for medical services in Canada: lots of heat, but little light.Can Med Assoc J2000; 162: 1305–10
50.
BarrettB, WayC, McDonaldJ, ParfreyP.Hospital utilization, efficiency and access to care during and shortly after restructuring acute care in Newfoundland and Labrador.J Health Serv Res Policy2005; 10(Suppl 2):31–7
