Standard centrifugal Dumps may be operated in reverse as water turbines, and for hydroelectric plums of less than 100 kW (micro- hydro) they are often cheaper than specifically designed turbines. However, in order to use a pump in a micro-hydro scheme, the turbine performance-must be found either by testing or by calculation. Several methods have been suggested for predicting the turbine performance based on the data for pump performance at best efficiency, but they produce a wide range of results.
In this paper, eight such methods are compared using an analysis of the effects of poor turbine prediction on the operation of a pump as turbine at a typical micro hydro site. The comparison uses the results of turbine tests on 35 pumps of various types and sizes, some of which have come from the author's own tests. None of the eight methods gives an accurate prediction for all of the pumps but one of the methods can be recommended as a first estimate of the turbine performance.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
NèmecJ.Engineering hydrology, 1972, p. 233 (McGraw-Hill, New York).
2.
KnappR. T.Complete characteristics of centrifugal pumps and their use in the prediction of transient behavior. Trans. ASME, November 1937, 638–689.
3.
SwansonW. M.Complete characteristics circle diagram for turbo-machinery. Trans ASME, 1953, 75, 819–826.
4.
StepanoffA. J.Centrifugal and axial flow pumps, 1957, Figs 13.1–3, pp. 270–271 (John Wiley, New York).
5.
BS 5316: Parts 1 and 2: 1977Acceptance tests for centrifugal, mixed flow and axial pumps (British Standards Institution, London).
6.
YedidiahS.Application of centrifugal pumps for power recovery purposes. ASME Conference FED–6, November 1983, pp. 111–119.
7.
ChildsS. M.Convert pumps to turbines and recover HP. Hydrocarbon Processing and Petroleum Refiner, October 1962, 41(10), 173–174.
8.
McClaskeyB. M.LundquistJ. A.Hydraulic power recovery turbines. ASME Conference, 19 September 1976, paper 76–Pet–65.
9.
LueneburgR.NelsonR. M.Hydraulic power recovery turbines. In Centrifugal pumps: design and application (Ed. LobanoffVal. S.), 1985, Ch. 14 (Gulf Publishing Co.).
10.
HancockJ. W.Centrifugal pump or water turbine. Pipe Line News, June 1963, pp. 25–27.
11.
StepanoffA. J.Centrifugal and axial flow pumps, 1957, p. 276 (John Wiley, New York).
12.
EngelL.Die Rücklaufdrehzahlen der Kreiselpumpen. Doctoral dissertation, Tech. Hochschule Braunschweig.
13.
SharmaK. R.Small hydroelectric projects—use of centrifugal pumps as turbines. Kirloskar Electric Co., Bangalore, India, 1985.
14.
Alatorre-FrenkC.ThomasT. H.The pumps-as-turbines approach to small hydropower. World Congress on Renewable energy, Reading, September 1990.
15.
SchmiedlE.Serien-Kreiselpumpen im Turbinenbetrieb. Pumpentagung Karlsruhe, October 1988, Sec. A6.
16.
BuseF.Using centrifugal pumps as hydraulic turbines. Chemical Engineering, January 1981, pp. 113–117.
17.
Lewinsky-KesslitzH.-P.Pumpen als Turbinen fur Kleinkraftwerke. Wasserwirtschaft, 1987, 77(10), 531–537.
18.
GroverK. M.Conversion of pumps to turbines. GSA Inter Corp., Katonah, New York, 1980.
19.
ThomsettA. J.Turbine operation of centrifugal pumps. BEng Mechanical Engineering project thesis, Nottingham Polytechnic, May 1990.
20.
WilliamsA. A.Pumps as turbines used with induction generators for stand-alone micro-hydroelectric power plants. PhD thesis, Nottingham Trent University, October 1992.
21.
ChengW.Reverse running of a centrifugal pump. BEng Mechanical Engineering project thesis, Trent Polytechnic, May 1983.
22.
RodriguezJ. A.Operacion de Bombas Centrifugas como Turbinas Hidraulicas, Investigacion Preliminar. Thesis, Universidad Los Andes, Bogotá, Colombia, August 1989, pp. 68–71.
23.
SenuZ.A centrifugal pump as an inward flow turbine. BEng Mechanical Engineering project thesis, Nottingham Polytechnic, May 1990.
24.
ThomeE. W.Information supplied regarding tests carried out at Worthington-Simpson Pumps, Newark, Notts.
25.
LauxC. H.Reverse-running standard pumps as energy recovery turbines. Sulzer Tech. Rev., 1982, No. 2, 23–27.
26.
Jyoti LimitedCompany Newsletter, Jyoti Ltd, India.
27.
EngedaA.Untersuchungen an Kreiselpumpen mit offenen und geschlossenen Laufrädern im Pumpen- und Turbinenbetrieb. PhD thesis, University of Hannover, 1987.
28.
WilliamsA. A.KeysellM.PrattJ. M. K.SmithN. P. A.Characteristics of a submersible pump unit for use as a micro-hydropower generator. Twenty-third Universities Conference on Power engineering, Trent Polytechnic, Nottingham, September 1988, Sec. 5a.
29.
KnappR. T.Centrifugal pump performance as affected by design features. Trans. ASME, 1941, 63, 251–260.
30.
PeckJ. F.Investigations concerning flow conditions in a centrifugal pump, and the effect of blade loading on head slip. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, 1951, 164, 1–30.
31.
WarrilowJ. H.The turbine performance of a medium-head centrifugal pump. BEng Integrated Engineering project thesis, Nottingham Trent University, 1993.
32.
WilliamsA. A.Report on the running of a Flygt BS2102 submersible pump as a stand-alone turbine and induction generator. Nottingham Polytechnic, 1989.
33.
GiddensE. P.SpitallW.WatsonD. B.Small hydro from a submersible pump. Water Power and Dam Construction, December 1982, pp. 33–35.
34.
CooperP.WorthenR.Feasibility of using large vertical pumps as turbines for small-scale hydropower. Report DOE/ID/12160-T1, US Department of Energy, Idaho National Engineering Laboratory, 1981.
