Current knowledge of the factors affecting the performance of rotary mechanical seals is reviewed in depth under the following main headings: seal performance, operational considerations, materials, face topography, fluid film lubrication, film vaporization, face contact conditions, structural analysis and vibration and runout.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
NauB. S.Rotary mechanical seals in process duties: an assessment of the state of the art. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part A, 1985, 199 (A1), 17–31.
2.
Summers-SmithJ. D.Mechanical seal practice for improved performance, 1988 (Mechanical Engineering Publications Limited, London).
3.
FlitneyR. K.NauB. S.Vapour emission from rotary shaft seals in petro-chemical plants. Ann. Occup. Hyg., 1986, 30, 241–247.
4.
DennyD. F.Some measurements of fluid pressures between plane parallel thrust surfaces with special reference to the balancing of radial face seals. Wear, 1961, 4(1), 64–83.
5.
PapeJ. G.Fundamental aspects of radial-face seals. Doctoral thesis, October 1969, Technische Hochschule, Delft.
6.
FlitneyR. K.NauB. S.A study of factors affecting mechanical seal performance. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part A, 1987, 201(A1), 17–28.
7.
EtsionI.Dynamic analysis of noncontacting face seals. Trans. ASME, J. Lubric. Technol., 1982, 104, 460–468.
8.
EtsionI.DanY.An analysis of mechanical face seal vibrations. ASME preprint 80-C2/Lub-8, 1980.
9.
GreenI.Dynamic response to axial oscillation and rotating seal runout in contacting mechanical face seals. Tribology Trans. (in press).
RowlesR. T.Dynamic behaviour of rotary mechanical seals. Doctoral thesis, 1980, University of Aston in Birmingham.
12.
MetcalfeR.Dynamic tracking of angular misalignment in liquid lubricated end-face seals. ASLE Trans., 1981, 24, 509–516.
13.
MetcalfeR.Dynamic tracking of angular misalignment in liquid lubricated end-face seals. ASLE Trans., 1982, 25, 1–6.
14.
TournerieB.FreneJ.Computer modelling of the functioning modes of non-contacting face-seals. Tribology Int., 1984, 17, 269–276.
15.
NauB. S.Vibration and rotary mechanical seals. Tribology Int., February 1981, 14, 55–59.
16.
CameronA.The principles of lubrication, 1966 (Longmans Green, London).
17.
YasunaJ. A.HughesW. F.A continuous boiling model for face seals. Trans. ASME, J. Tribology, 1990, 112, 266–274.
18.
LymerA.An engineering approach to the selection and application of mechanical seals. Proceedings of Fourth International Conference on Fluid sealing, 1969, paper 25 (BHRA, Cranfield).
19.
KogaJ. K.KoschmeiderE. L.Taylor vortices in short fluid columns. Phys. Fluids, 1989, A1(9), 1475–1478.
NauB. S.Centripetal flow in face seals. Lubric. Engng, 1969, 25, 161–168.
22.
NauB. S.Observations and analysis of mechanical seal film characteristics. Trans. ASME, J. Lubric. Technol., 1980, 102, 341–349.
23.
GazleyC.Heat-transfer characteristics of the rotational and axial flow between concentric cylinders. Trans. ASME, 1958, 80, 79–89.
24.
TachibanaF.FukuiS.MitsumuraH.Heat transfer in an annulus with an inner rotating cylinder. Bull. J. Soc. Mech. Engrs, 1960, 3(9), 119–122.
25.
WalowitJ.TsaoS.DiPrimaR. C.Stability of flow between arbitrarily spaced concentric cylindrical surfaces including the effect of a radial temperature gradient. Trans. ASME, J. Appl. Mech., 1964, 00, 585–593.
26.
SavageR. H.Graphite lubrication. J. Appl. Phys., 1948, 19(1), 1–10.
27.
SavageR. H.Physically and chemically adsorbed films in the lubrication of graphite sliding contacts. Ann. New York Acad. Sci., 1951, 53, 862–869.
28.
SavageR. H.SchaeferD. L.Vapor lubrication of graphite sliding contacts. J. Appl. Phys., 1956, 27(2), 136–138.
29.
FischerT. E.Tribochemistry. Ann. Rev. Mater. Sci., 1988, 18, 303–323.
30.
FischerT. E.Friction and wear of ceramics. Scripta Metallurgica et materialia, 1990, 24, 833–838.
31.
FisherM. J.NauB. S.An experimental investigation of face seal behaviour at sealed pressures up to 3000 lb/sq. in. BHRA research report RR855, 1966.
32.
LancasterJ. K.Additive effects on the friction and wear of graphite carbons. In Proceedings of Third Leeds-Lyon Symposium on Tribology, The wear of non-metallic materials, 1976, 187–195 (Mechanical Engineering Publications, London).
33.
WilliamsJ. A.On the dry wear of carbon-graphite materials running against 316 stainless steel. Cambridge University Engineering Department report CUED/C-Mech/TR23, 1982.
34.
MidgleyJ. W.TeerD. G.An investigation of the mechanism of friction and wear of carbon. Trans. ASME, J. Basic Engng, 1963, 85, 488–494.
BissonE. J.JohnsonR. L.AndersonW. J.Friction and lubrication with solid lubricants at temperatures to 1000°F with particular reference to graphite. Proceedings of Conference on Lubrication and wear, 1957, paper 23 (Institution of Mechanical Engineers, London).
37.
HadyW. F.AllenG. P.JohnsonR. L.Wear and friction of mechanical carbons in liquid oxygen as influenced by transfer films. ASLE Trans., 1963, 6, 201–208.
38.
LongleyR. I.MidgleyJ. W.StrangA.TeerD. G.Mechanism of the frictional behaviour of high, low and non-graphitic carbon. Proceedings of Convention on Lubrication and wear, 1963, paper 17 (Institution of Mechanical Engineers, London).
39.
PaxtonR. R.ShobertW. R.Testing high speed seal carbons. ASLE Trans., 1962, 5, 308–314.
40.
PaxtonR. R.HulburtH. T.Rubbing friction in radial face seals. Lubric. Engng, 1980, 36, 89–95.
KatoK.Tribology of ceramics. Wear, 1990, 136, 117–133.
43.
TomizawaH.FischerT. E.Friction and wear of silicon nitride at 150°C to 800°C. ASLE Trans., 1986, 29, 481–488.
44.
JahanmirS.FischerT. E.Friction and wear of silicon nitride lubricated by humid air, water, hexadecane, and hexadecane +0.5% steric acid. Tribology Trans., 1988, 31, 32–43.
45.
TomizawaH.FischerT. E.Friction and wear of silicon nitride and silicon carbide in water: hydrodynamic lubrication at low sliding speed obtained by tribochemical wear. ASLE Trans., 1987, 30, 41–46.
46.
KlimekE. J.Selection, properties and quality assurance of face materials for rotating mechanical seals. Lubric. Engng, 1988, 44, 1–8.
47.
SasakiS.The effects of the surrounding atmosphere on the friction and wear of alumina, zirconia, silicon carbide and silicon nitride. Wear, 1989, 134, 185–200.
48.
WasilT. J.McClearyG. P.Sealing corrosive materials with hard carbide alloys. ASLE preprint 67AM 5C-4, 1967.
49.
KennedyP.,An assessment of the performance of Refel silicon carbide under conditions of thermal stress. Proc. Br. Ceram. Soc., 1973, 22, 67–87.
50.
AsklofC. A.Cemented carbides in radial face seals. Proceedings of Sixth International Conference on Fluid sealing, 1973, paper A4 (BHRA, Cranfield).
GolubievA.Thermocracking of seal faces in mechanical seals. Proceedings of Fifth International Conference on Fluid sealing, 1971, paper A2 (BHRA, Cranfield).
HasselmanD. P. H.Thermal stress resistance parameters for brittle refractory ceramics: a compendium. Ceram. Bull., 1970, 49, 1033–1037.
58.
BahrH. A.FischerG.WeissH. J.Thermal-shock crack patterns explained by single and multiple crack propagation. J. Mater. Sci., 1986, 21, 2716–2720.
59.
WeaverG. Q.BaumgartnerH. R.TortiM. L.Thermal shock behaviour of sintered silicon carbide and reaction-bonded silicon nitride. Br. Ceram. Res. Ass., Special Ceram., 1975, 23, 261–281.
60.
NauB. S.An investigation into the nature of the interface film, the pressure generation mechanism and centripetal pumping in mechanical seals. BHRA research report RR754, 1963.
61.
NauB. S.Observations of face seal flatness after use. BHRA research report RR877, 1967.
62.
LebeckA. O.Causes and effects of waviness in contacting mechanical seals. The University of New Mexico, College of Engineering technical report ME-68(76)NSF-271-1, 1976.
63.
PalmerK. P.Mechanical seals for fuel systems. Lucas Aerospace Limited internal report L.72847, 1980.
64.
LebeckA. O.Mechanical loading—a primary source of waviness in mechanical seals. ASLE Trans., 1977, 20(3), 195–208.
65.
NauB. S.LeefeS. E.A review of some aspects of the prediction of mechanical seal coning. STLE preprint 90-AM-78-4, 1990.
66.
NauB. S.Mechanical seal film cavitation. Proceedings of First Leeds-Lyon Symposium on Tribology, Cavitation and related phenomena in lubrication, 1974, 227–230 (Mechanical Engineering Publications, London).
67.
NauB. S.Further experimental studies of face seal hydrodynamics. BHRA research report RR855, 1966.
68.
DoustT. G.ParmarA.An experimental and theoretical study of pressure and thermal distortions in a mechanical seal. ASLE Trans., 1986, 29, 151–159.
69.
PapeJ. G.Fundamental aspects of radial face seals. Doctoral thesis, 1969, Technische Hochschule, Delft.
70.
Summers-SmithJ. D.Laboratory investigation of the performance of a radial-face seal. Proceedings of First International Conference on Fluid sealing, 1961, paper D1 (BHRA, Cranfield).
71.
IshiwataH.HirabayashiH.Friction and sealing characteristics of mechanical seals. Proceedings of First International Conference on Fluid sealing, 1961, paper D5 (BHRA, Cranfield).
72.
LebeckA. O.A study of contacting mechanical face seal performance data using mixed friction models. Proceedings of Twelfth International Conference on Fluid sealing, 1989, paper F2 (BHRA, Cranfield).
73.
JakobssonB.FlobergL.The finite journal bearing considering vaporisation. Trans, of Chalmers University of Technology, Gothenberg, report 190, 1957.
74.
FindlayJ.Cavitation in mechanical face seals. Trans. ASME, J. Lubric. Technol., 1968, 90(2), 356–364.
75.
IkeuchiK.MoriH.Hydrodynamic lubrication in seals with cavitation. Bull. J. Soc. Mech. Engrs, June 1982, 25, 1002–1007 and 1008–1013.
76.
VijayaraghavanD.KeithT. G.An efficient, robust, and time accurate numerical scheme applied to a cavitation algorithm. Trans. ASME, J. Tribology, 1990, 112, 44–51.
77.
NauB. S.TurnbullD. E.Some effects of elastic deformation on the characteristics of balanced radial-face seals. Proceedings of First International Conference on Fluid sealing, 1961, paper D3 (BHRA, Cranfield).
HaardtR.GodetM.Axial vibration of a misaligned radial face seal under a constant closure force. ASLE Trans., 1975, 18, 55–61.
80.
RuddyA. V.DawsonD.TaylorC. M.The prediction of film thickness in a mechanical face seal with circumferential waviness on both the face and the seat. J. Mech. Engng. Sci., 1982, 24(1), 37–43.
81.
RuddyA. V.Summers-SmithJ. D.The mechanism of film generation in mechanical face seals. Tribology Int., 1982, 15, 227–231.
82.
FindlayJ.Measurements of leakage in mechanical face seals. Proceedings of Fourth International Conference on Fluid sealing, 1969, paper 19 (BHRA, Cranfield).
83.
TaylorG. I.SaffmanP. G.Effects of compressibility at low Reynolds number. J. Aero. Sci., 1957, 24, 553–562.
84.
ZukJ.LudwigL. P.JohnsonR. L.Quasi-one-dimensional compressible flow across face seals and narrow slots. 1—Analysis. NASA technical report TN D-6668, 1972.
85.
NauB. S.The operation of unbalanced mechanical seals at high pressure. BHRA research report RR1819, 1982.
86.
OrcuttF. K.An investigation of the operation and failure of mechanical face seals. Proceedings of Fourth International Conference on Fluid sealing, 1969, paper 22 (BHRA, Cranfield).
87.
BarnardP.WeirR. S. L.A theory for mechanical seal face thermodynamics. Proceedings of Eighth International Conference on Fluid sealing, 1978, paper H1 (BHRA, Cranfield).
88.
GuYongquanIdentification of phase state and analysis of phase stability of mechanical seals in process pumps. Proceedings of Twelfth International Conference on Fluid sealing, 1989, paper B2 (BHRA, Cranfield).
89.
HughesW. F.,Phase change in liquid face seals. Trans. ASME, J. Lubric. Technol., 1978, 100, 74–80.
90.
HughesW. F.ChaoN. H.Phase change in liquid face seals II—Isothermal and adiabatic bounds with real fluids. Trans. ASME, J. Lubric. Technol., 1980, 102, 350–359.
91.
LebeckA. O.A mixed friction hydrostatic face seal model with phase change. Trans. ASME, J. Lubric. Technol., 1980, 102, 133–138.
92.
SalantR. F.BlasbalgD. A.Dynamic behaviour of two-phase mechanical seals. Tribology Trans. (in press); also STLE Annual Meeting preprint 90-AM-7B-3, 1990.
93.
SalantR. F.HassanS. E.Large-scale thermoelastic instability in hydrostatic mechanical seals. Proceedings of Twelfth International Conference on Fluid sealing, 1989, paper B1 (BHRA, Cranfield).
94.
ParmarA.Thermal distortion control in mechanical seals. Proceedings of Twelfth International Conference on Fluid sealing, 1989, paper B3 (BHRA, Cranfield).
95.
WatsonS.NauB. S.Analysis of a rotary seal operating in a boiling film mode. BHRA report CR 2638, 1986.
96.
BeelerR. M.HughesW. F.Dynamics of two-phase face seals. ASLE Trans., 1983, 27(2), 146–153.
97.
LebeckA. O.A mixed friction hydrostatic mechanical seal model with thermal rotation and wear. ASLE Trans., 1980, 23(4), 375–387.
98.
LebeckA. O.A study of mixed lubrication in contacting mechanical face seals. In Proceedings of Fourth Leeds-Lyon Symposium on Lubrication on Tribology, Surface roughness effects in lubrication, 1979, 46–56 (Mechanical Engineering Publications, London).
99.
LebeckA. O.An evaluation of the average flow model for surface roughness effects in lubrication. Trans. ASME, J. Lubric. Technol., 1980, 102, 360–367.
100.
ChristensenH.A theory of mixed lubrication. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, 1972, 186, 41.
101.
PatirN.ChengH. S.An average flow model for determining effects of three dimensional roughness on partial hydrodynamic lubrication. Trans. ASME, J. Lubric. Technol., 1978, 100, 12–17.
102.
WuY-T.BurtonR. A.Thermoelastic and dynamic phenomena in seals. ASME preprint 80-C2/Lub-9, 1980.
103.
NetzelJ. P.The effect of interface cooling in controlling surface disturbances in mechanical face seals. Wear, 1982, 79, 119–127.
104.
KennedyF. E.ChuahC. K.BroteF. O. W.Thermomechanical contact phenomena in face seals. Wear, 1985, 102, 127–140.
