Interactive Buckling Tests on Cylindrical Shells Subjected to Axial Compression and External Pressure—A Comparison of Experiment,Theory and Various Codes

Abstract

The buckling of welded steel cylindrical shells under the combined action of external pressure and axial compressive loads is of considerable interest to the offshore oil and nuclear industries. However, test results on this subject are scarce and some design rules which have been proposed recently have not been validated experimentally, especially in the plastic buckling region. In order to check these rules, and suggest others, interactive buckling tests were conducted at Liverpool University on cylindrical shells having R/t ≍ 100. One series of tests consisted of 19 machined and stress-relieved steel models having L/R ratios of 0.33, 0.74 and 1.45. The results obtained on these near-perfect machined models were compared with theoretical predictions of the behaviour of perfect cylindrical shells and the agreement between the two was good

The other series consisted of 21 welded steel models and had geometric ratios which were similar to the machined ones. The linear interaction equation S_p + S_x = 1 was used to predict the failure loads of these welded steel models and the predictions were safe in all cases. However, for some combined loading cases the linear equation was rather conservative and, in consequence, some non-linear interaction equations were investigated. These seem promising for design purposes. Irrespective of whether a linear or a non-linear equation is chosen for design, more tests will be needed to establish the scatter bands of the interactive buckling curves for various values of R/t.

Some tests were also carried out on (a) the effect of the loading path on the failure loads and (b) models with localized dents. Other topics discussed in the paper are: the effects of residual stresses and initial geometric imperfections, the general procedure adopted by Codes to predict buckling loads and some discrepancies between the predictions of various Codes.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Weingarten

Morgan

Seide

Development of criteria for elastic stability of thin shell structures. Final Report, STL/TR-60–0000–19425, Space Technology Laboratories Inc., 1960.

Mungan

Buckling stress states of cylindrical shells. Proc. Am. Soc. Civ. Engrs., J. Structural Division, Nov. 1974, 100 (ST 11), 2289–2306.

Miller

C. D.

Summary of buckling tests on fabricated steel cylindrical shells in USA. Buckling of shells in offshore structures (Eds Harding

J. E.

Dowling

P. J.

Agelidis

), 1982 (Granada, London).

ECCS (European Convention for Constructional Steelwork). European recommendations for steel construction, 1981, Section 4.6, Buckling of shells (The Construction Press, London). (Also ECCS Publ. No. 29, Brussels, 1983.).

DASt (Deutscher Ausschuss für Stahlbau). Richtlinie 013, Beulsicherheitsnachweise für Schalen, July 1980, Cologne, Germany.

DnV (Det norske Veritas). Rules for the design, construction and inspection of offshore structures, 1977, Appendix C, Steel Structures, Oslo, Norway. (Reprinted 1979.).

Metal containment shell buckling design methods. Boiler and pressure vessel Code Case N-284, 1980, Section III, Div. 1, Class MC. Supplement No. 2 to Nuclear Code Case Book (ASME, New York).

Galletly

G. D.

The background to forthcoming design proposals for two shell buckling problems. Behaviour of thin-walled structures (Eds Rhodes

Spence

), 1984, pp 179–210 (Elsevier Applied Science Publishers).

Galletly

G. D.

Buckling of fabricated cylinders subjected to compressive axial loads and/or external pressure—A comparison of several codes. PVP-57 Pressure vessel design (Ed. Widera

G. E. O.

), Book No. H00214, 1982, pp 29–47 (ASME, New York).

10.

Flügge

Stresses in shells, 2nd edition, 1973, pp 449 et seq. (Springer-Verlag, New York).

11.

Tennyson

R. C.

Booton

Chan

K. H.

Buckling of short cylinders under combined loadings. Trans. ASME, J. Appl. Mech., September 1978, 45, 574–578.

12.

Galletly

G. D.

Pemsing

Buckling of cylinders under combined external pressure and axial compression. Collapse: the buckling of structures in theory and practice, IUTAM Symp. (Eds Thompson

J. M. T.

Hunt

G. W.

), 1983, pp 505–527 (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).

13.

Bushnell

BOSOR 5—Program for buckling of elastic–plastic complex shells of revolution including large deflections and creep. Computers and Structures, 1976, 6, 221–239.

14.

Walker

A. C.

Segal

McCall

The buckling of thin-walled ring-stiffened steel shells. Buckling of shells (Ed. Ramm

), 1982, pp 275–304 (Springer-Verlag, Berlin).

15.

Tsang

S. K.

Harding

J. E.

Walker

A. C.

Andronicou

Buckling of ring-stiffened cylinders subjected to combined pressure and axial compressive loading. ASME 4th Natn. Congr. of Pressure Vessels and Piping Technology, Portland, Oregon, June 1983.

16.

Galletly

G. D.

Pemsing

On design procedures for the buckling of cylinders under combined axial compression and external pressure. Trans. ASME, J. Press. Vess. Tech., 1984, 134–142.

17.

Galletly

G. D.

Pemsing

James

Buckling of cylinders under biaxial compression. Proc. 3rd Int. Colloquium on Stability of Metal Structures, Paris, November 1983, pp 375–382.

18.

Odland

On the strength of welded ring-stiffened cylindrical shells primarily subjected to axial compression. Dr-Ing thesis, June 1981, University of Trondheim, Norway.

19.

Harding

J. E.

Ring-stiffened cylinders under axial and external pressure loading. Proc. Instn. Civ. Engrs., Lond. September 1981, 71 (2), 863–878.

20.

Reis

A. J.

Walker

A. C.

Virtuoso

F. E.

Externally pressurized cylindrical shells: Buckling and collapse under combined loading. Collapse: the buckling of structures in theory and practice, IUTAM Symp. (Eds Thompson

J. M. T.

Hunt

G. W.

) 1983, pp 481–491 (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).

21.

Croll

J. G. A.

Elasto-plastic buckling of pressure and axial loaded cylinders. Proc. Instn. Civ. Engrs., Part 2, Paper 8558, September 1982, pp 633–652.

22.

Bushnell

Effect of cold-bending and welding on buckling of ring-stiffened cylinders. Computers and Structures, 1980, 12, 291–307.

23.

Odland

Buckling resistance of unstiffened and stiffened circular cylindrical shell structures. Norwegian Maritime Res., 1978, 6 (3), 2–22.

24.

Bushnell

Buckling of shells—Pitfall for designers. AIAA J., September 1981, 19 (9), 1183–1226.

25.

Almroth

B. O.

Brogan

F. A.

Stanley

G. M.

Structural analysis of general shells, Vol. II: User instructions for STAGS C. Report LMSC-D633873, Lockheed Missiles and Space Co. Inc., Palo Alto, California, January 1979.

26.

Tvergaard

On the transition from a diamond mode to an axisymmetric mode of collapse in cylindrical shells. DCAMM Report No. 254, Technical University of Denmark, December 1982.

27.

DnV Buckling strength analysis. Classification Note No. 30.1, Høvik, Norway, July 1982.

28.

Sridharan

Walker

A. C.

Experimental investigation of the buckling behaviour of stiffened cylindrical shells. Department of Energy, Report OT-R7835, London, 1980.

29.

Bushnell

Plastic buckling of shells. Trans. ASME, J. Press. Vess. Tech., May 1982, 104, 51–71.

30.

Pascoe

K. J.

Strength of cold-formed cylindrical steel plates. J. Strain Analysis, 1971, 6 (3), 167–176.

31.

Arbocz

Babcock

C. D.

Predictions of buckling loads based on experimentally-measured initial imperfections. Proc. IUTAM Symp. on Buckling of Structures, 1976, pp 291–311, Springer-Verlag, Berlin.

32.

Kendrick

S. B.

The influence of shape imperfections and residual stresses on the collapse of stiffened cylinders. Proc. Instn. Mech. Engrs. Conf. on Significance of Deviations from Design Shapes, London, March 1979, pp 25–35.

33.

Baker

E. H.

Kovalevsky

Rish

F. L.

Structural analysis of shells, 1972 (McGraw-Hill, New York).

34.

BS 5500: 1982 Specification for unfired fusion welded pressure vessels, Section 3.6 (British Standards Institution, London).

35.

Lee

L. H. N.

Inelastic buckling of cylindrical shells under axial compression and external pressure. Proc. 4th US Natn. Cong. on Applied Mechanics, 1962, pp 989–998 (ASME, New York).

36.

Slankard

R. C.

Nash

W. A.

Tests of the elastic stability of a ring-stiffened shell model BR-5 (λ = 1.705) subjected to hydrostatic pressure. DTMB Report 822, May 1953, US Navy, Washington, DC.

37.

Miller

C. D.

Buckling of axially compressed cylinders. Proc. ASCE, March 1977, 103 (ST3), 695–721.

38.

Private communication..

39.

Richards

Private communication.

40.

Grove

Didriksen

Buckling experiments on 4 large ring-stiffened cylindrical shells subjected to axial compression and lateral pressure. DnV Report No. 77–431, Oslo, Norway, 1977.