Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

The operating conditions, performance, existing and desirable standards for rotary mechanical seals are discussed. Research needs are reviewed and the need for functional rather than dimensional standards is emphasized.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anno

J. N.

Walowit

J. A.

Allen

C. M.

Microasperity lubrication. 3rd Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper E2, BHRA, 1967.

Austin

R. M.

Flitney

R. K.

Nau

B. S.

Rotary seal vapour emission. BHRA Report RR1616, Sept. 1980.

Banerjee

B. N.

Burton

R. A.

Thermoelastic instability in lubricated sliding between solid surfaces. Nature, June 1976b, 261, 399–400.

Banerjee

B. N.

Burton

R. A.

An instability for parallel sliding of solid surfaces separated by a viscous liquid film. Trans. ASME, J. Lubric. Tech., Jan. 1976a 157–165.

Banerjee

B. N.

Burton

R. A.

Experimental studies on thermoelastic effects in hydrodynamically lubricated face seals. Trans. ASME, Lubric. Tech. July 1979, 101, 275–282.

Barnard

P. C.

Weir

R. S. L.

A theory for mechanical seal face thermodynamics. 8th Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper H1, BHRA, 1978.

Batch

B. A.

Iny

E. H.

Pressure generation in radial-face seals. 2nd Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper F4, BHRA, 1964.

Bisson

E. E.

Johnson

R. L.

Anderson

W. J.

On friction and lubrication at temperatures to 1000°F with particular reference to graphite. ASME Preprint No. 57-Lub-1, 1957.

Buck

G. S.

A methodology for design and application of mechanical seals. Trans. ASLE, 1980, 23(3), 244–252.

10.

Bupara

S. S.

Walowit

J. A.

Allen

C. M.

Gas lubrication and distortion of high pressure mainshaft seals for compressors. 3rd Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper B3, BHRA, 1967.

11.

Burton

R. A.

. The influence of thermoelastic instabilities on face seal contact. Proc. 1976 Tribology Convention 1978, pp 53–57 (IMechE, London).

12.

Cheng

H. S.

Snapp

R. B.

A study of the radial film and pressure distribution of high pressure face seals. 3rd Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper E3, BHRA, 1967.

13.

Cheng

H. S.

Castelli

Chow

C. Y.

Performance characteristics of spiral-groove and shrouded Rayleigh step profiles for high-speed non-contacting gas seals. ASME Paper 68-LubS-38, 1968.

14.

Clark

W. T.

Lancaster

J. K.

Breakdown and surface fatigue of carbons during repeated sliding. 1963, Wear, 6, 467–482.

15.

Davies

A. R.

O'Donoghue

J. P.

The lubrication of high pressure face seals. ASME Preprint 66WA. Lub-7, 1966.

16.

Denny

D. F.

Some measurements of fluid pressures between plane parallel thrust surfaces with special reference to radial-face seals. Wear, 1961, 4, 64–83.

17.

Dray

Inter-relationship between carbon-graphite structures and wear. Proc. 4th NASA/Navy workshop on liquid lubricated seals, Univ. of New Mexico, Oct. 1981.

18.

Dziedzic

Siliconised graphite and silicon carbide as face materials for mechanical seals in 12 per cent boric acid nuclear service. Trans. ASLE 1980, 36(11), 643–651.

19.

Etsion

Dynamic analysis of non-contacting face seals. NASA Tech. Mem. 79294, 1980.

20.

Etsion

Dan

An analysis of mechanical face seal vibrations. Trans. ASME, J. Lubric. Tech., July 1981, 103(3), 428–435.

21.

Findlay

Cavitation in mechanical face seals. Master's Thesis, Union College, Schenectady, 1967.

22.

Fisher

M. J.

An analysis of the deformation of the balanced ring in high pressure radial-face seals. 1st Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper D4, BHRA, 1961.

23.

Fisher

M. J.

A study of the suitability of a hydrostatic seal for boiler feed pumps. BHRA Report RR776, 1963.

24.

Fisher

M. J.

Nau

B. S.

An experimental investigation of face seal behaviour at sealed pressures up to 3000 lb/in². BHRA Report RR878, Feb. 1967.

25.

Flitney

R. K.

Nau

B. S.

Seal survey: Part 1-rotary mechanical face seals. BHRA Report CR1386, Dec. 1976.

26.

Flitney

R. K.

Nau

B. S.

Reddy

M. D.

Mechanical seal reliability study 1. BHRA Report CR2165, 1984.

27.

Gabriel

R. P.

Fundamentals of spiral groove non-contacting face seals. ASLE Paper 78-AM-3D-1, 1978.

28.

Golubiev

A. I.

Gordeev

V. V.

Investigation of wear of mechanical seals in liquids containing abrasive particles. 7th Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper B3, BHRA, 1975.

29.

Grant

W. S.

Recirculating pump seal investigation. MPR Associates Inc. Technical Report NP 351 Vol. 1, Washington, DC, 1977.

30.

Haardt

Les joints d'étancheite à faces radiates. Doctoral Thesis, Univ. of Lyon, July 1975.

31.

Hill

H. H.

Post separation behaviour of mechanical systems subjected to harmonic excitation. Doctoral thesis, North Carolina State Univ., Raleigh, 1969.

32.

Hirabayashi

Ishiwata

Kato

Excessive abrasion of mechanical seals caused by salt solutions. 3rd Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper B1, BHRA, 1967.

33.

Hooke

C. J.

O'Donoghue

J. P.

Elastohydrodynamic lubrication of high pressure face seals. J. Mech. Engng Sci., 1968, 10(1), 59–63.

34.

Hooke

C. J.

O'Donoghue

J. P.

The elastohydrodynamic lubrication of high pressure face seals. 4th Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper 16, BHRA, 1969.

35.

Hughes

W. F.

Chao

N. H.

Phase change in liquid face seals II—isothermal and adiabatic bounds with real fluids. Trans. ASME, J. Lubric. Tech., July 1980, 102(3), 350–359.

36.

Ikeuchi

Mori

Pumping action of seal-like surfaces under hydrodynamic lubrication. J. of JSLE (Int. Edition), Nov. 1980, 1, 83–86.

37.

Ikeuchi

Mori

Pumping action in face seals with elastic deformation. J. of JSLE (Int. Edition), April 1981, 2, 111–114.

38.

Ikeuchi

Mori

The pumping in face seals with elastic deformation–sealing of pressurised liquid surrounded with air. J. of JSLE (Int. Edition), 1982a, 3, 87–90.

39.

Ikeuchi

Mori

Hydrodynamic lubrication in seals with cavitation: 1st report—effect of cavity pressure on lubricating film. Bull. JSME, June 1982b, 25, 204, 1002–1007.

40.

Ikeuchi

Mori

Hydrodynamic lubrication in seals with cavitation: 2nd report—effect of cavity pressure on leakage. Bull. JSME, June 1982c, 25, 204, 1008–1013.

41.

Iny

E. H.

The design of hydrodynamically lubricated seals with predictable operating characteristics. 5th Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper H1, BHRA, 1971a.

42.

Iny

E. H.

A theory of sealing with radial face seals. Wear, 1971b, 18, 51–69.

43.

Ishiwata

Hirabayashi

Friction and sealing characteristics of mechanical seals. 1st Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper D5, BHRA, 1961.

44.

Janetz

R. W.

Mechanical seals in pumps for hydronic systems. Lub. Engng., Sept. 1965, 372–380.

45.

Johnson

R. L.

Swikert

M. A.

Bailey

J. M.

Wear of typical carbon-base sliding seal materials. NACA Report No.TN3595, 1956.

46.

Kanasaki

Schoenherr

Sealing boric acid solutions with mechanical seals in nuclear service. JSLE–ASLE Int. Lubn. Conf, June 1975.

47.

Kaneta

Fukahori

Hirano

Dynamic characteristics of face seals. 8th Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper A2, BHRA, 1978.

48.

Karpe

S. A.

Microscopic examination of high cobalt base super-alloy face seal mating inserts. Proc. 4th NASA/Navy workshop on liquid lubricated seals, Univ. of New Mexico, Oct. 1981.

49.

Kennedy

F. E.

Thermocracking of a mechanical face seal. Proc. 4th NASA/Navy workshop on liquid lubricated seals, Univ. of New Mexico, 1981.

50.

Kilaparti

S. R.

Burton

R. A.

Pressure distribution for patchlike contact in seals with frictional mating, thermal expansion and wear. ASME Preprint No. 76-Lub5–11, 1976.

51.

Kittner

C. A.

Metcalfe

An inside view of rotary seal dynamics. Proc. 5th Symposium on Engineering Applications of Mechanics, University of Ottawa, 1980.

52.

Kojabashian

Richardson

H. H.

A micropad model for the hydrodynamic performance of carbon face seals. 3rd Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper E4, BHRA, 1967.

53.

Kupperman

D. S.

Dynamic tracking of non-contacting face seals. Trans. ASLE, 1978, 18(4), 306–311.

54.

Labus

T. J.

The influence of rubbing materials and operating conditions on the power dissipated by mechanical seals. Lubn. Engng., July 1981, 387–394.

55.

Lancaster

J. K.

Transition in the friction of wear of carbons and graphites sliding against themselves. Trans. ASLE, 1975, 18(3), 187–201.

56.

Lancaster

J. K.

Additive effects on the friction and wear of graphite carbons. 5th Leeds–Lyon Symposium on Tribology: The wear of non-metallic materials, 1978, (Mech. Engng. Publns, London).

57.

Lebeck

A. O.

Causes and effects of waviness in contacting mechanical face seals. Univ. of New Mexico Tech. Report ME68(76) NSF271–1, Jan. 1976a.

58.

Lebeck

A. O.

Theory of thermoelastic instability of rotating rings in sliding contact with wear. Trans. ASME, J. Lubric. Tech. April 1976b 277–284.

59.

Lebeck

A. O.

A study of mixed lubrication in contacting mechanical face seals. 4th Leeds–Lyon Symposium on Tribology: Surface roughness effects in lubrication, 1977, 46–57, (Mech. Engng Publns, London).

60.

Lebeck

A. O.

Teale

J. L.

Pierce

R. E.

Hydrodynamic lubrication and wear in wavy contacting face seals. Trans. ASME, J. Lubric. Tech., Jan. 1978, 100, 81–91.

61.

Lebeck

A. O.

Hydrodynamic lubrication with wear and asperity contact in mechanical face seals. Univ. of New Mexico, Bureau of Engng. Res., Tech. Report ME95(79) ONR414–1, Jan. 1979.

62.

Lebeck

A. O.

The effect of ring deflection and heat transfer on the thermoelastic instability of rotating face seals. Wear, 1980a, 59, 121–133.

63.

Lebeck

A. O.

A mixed friction hydrostatic face seal model with phase change. Trans. ASME, J. Lubric. Tech., April 1980b, 102, 133–138.

64.

Lebeck

A. O.

A mixed friction hydrostatic mechanical face seal model with thermal rotation and wear. Trans. ASLE, Oct. 1980c 23(4), 357–387.

65.

Lebeck

A. O.

Experimental evaluation of a mixed friction hydrostatic mechanical face seal model considering radial taper, thermal taper and wear. ASME Preprint No. 81-Lub-38, 1981a.

66.

Lebeck

A. O.

A test apparatus for measuring the effects of waviness in mechanical face seals. Trans. ASLE, 1981b 24(3), 371–378.

67.

Lebeck

A. O.

Hydrodynamic lubrication in wavy contacting face seals–a two dimensional model. Trans. ASME, J. Lubric. Tech., Oct. 1981c, 103, 578–586.

68.

Lebeck

A. O.

Design of an optimum moving wave and tilt mechanical face seal for liquid applications. 9th Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper E2, BHRA, 1981d.

69.

Lohou

Hydrodynamique des joints d'étancheite du type radial. Doctoral Thesis, Univ. of Lyon, June 1970.

70.

Lohou

Godet

Angular misalignments and squeeze-film effects in radial face seals. 6th Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper D2, BHRA, 1973.

71.

Ludwig

L. P.

Self-acting shaft seals. Proc. AGARD Conf. on Seal Technology in Gas Turbine Engines, Paper 16, 1978.

72.

Mayer

Unbalanced mechanical seals for liquids. 1st Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper E2, BHRA, 1961.

73.

Metcalfe

Performance analysis of axisymmetric flat face mechanical seals. Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd, Report AECL-4432, Feb. 1973.

74.

Metcalfe

End face seals in high pressure water—learning from those failures. Lub. Engng., 1976a 32(12), 625–636.

75.

Metcalfe

The use of finite element deflection analysis in performance predictions for end face seals. Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd, Report AECL 5563, July 1976b.

76.

Metcalfe

Pothier

Rod

B. H.

Diametral tilt and leakage of end face seals with convergent sealing gap. 8th Int. Conf. of Fluid Sealing, Paper A1, BHRA Fluid Engineering, 1978.

77.

Metcalfe

End face seal deflection effects—the problems of two-component stationary or rotating assemblies. Trans. ASLE, 1980a 23(4), 393–400.

78.

Metcalfe

Dynamic whirl in well-aligned, liquid-lubricated end face seals with hydrostatic tilt instability. ASLE Paper 80-LC-1B-1, 1980b.

79.

Metcalfe

Dynamic tracking of angular misalignment in liquid lubricated end face seals. Trans. ASLE Oct. 1981, 24(4), 509–516.

80.

Metcalfe

. Effects of pressure and temperature changes on end-face seal performance. Trans. ASLE, 1982, 25(3), 361–371.

81.

Moores

Marsh

M. G.

The effects of eccentricity and flatness of the sealing face of a carbon mechanical contact face seal. 1st Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper H1, BHRA, 1961.

82.

Nau

B. S.

Turnbull

D. E.

Some effects of elastic deformation on the characteristics of balanced radial-face seals. 1st Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper D3, BHRA, 1961.

83.

Nau

B. S.

An investigation into the nature of the interface film, the pressure-generation mechanism and centripetal pumping in mechanical seals. BHRA Report RR754, 1963.

84.

Nau

B. S.

Further experimental studies of face seal hydrodynamics. BHRA Report RR855, 1966.

85.

Nau

B. S.

Observations of face seal flatness after use. BHRA Report RR877, 1967.

86.

Nau

B. S.

Centripetal flow in face seals. ASLE Paper 68-AM–4B-3 Lub. Engng., 1968, 25(4), 161–8].

87.

Nau

B. S.

Film cavitation observations in face seals. 4th Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper 20, BHRA, 1969.

88.

Nau

B. S.

Observations and analysis of mechanical seal film characteristics. Trans. ASME, J. Lubric. Tech., 1980, 102(3), 341–349.

89.

Nau

B. S.

Vibration and rotary mechanical seals. Tribology Int., Feb. 1981a 14(1), 55–59.

90.

Nau

B. S.

Vibration and rotary mechanical seals: a review. BHRA Report RR1766, Nov. 1981b.

91.

Nau

B. S.

The operation of unbalanced mechanical seals at high pressure. BHRA Report RR1819, Mar. 1982.

92.

Nelson

W. E.

Pump curves can be deceptive. NPRA Refinery and Petrochemical Plant Maintenance Conf., Farrar Assoc, Tulsa, 1980.

93.

Netzel

J. P.

Observations of thermoelastic instability in mechanical face seals. 1980a Wear, 59(1), 135–148.

94.

Netzel

J. P.

Surface disturbances in mechanical face seals from thermoelastic instability. ASLE Preprint 80AM6B-1, 1980b.

95.

Netzel

J. P.

The effect of interface cooling in controlling surface disturbances in mechanical face seals. Wear, 1982, 79, 119–127.

96.

Orcutt

F. K.

An investigation of the operation and failure of mechanical face seals. 4th Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper 22, BHRA, 1969.

97.

Pape

J. G.

Fundamental aspects of radial-face seals. Doctoral Thesis, TH Delft, Oct. 1969.

98.

Paxton

R. R.

Shobert

W. R.

Testing carbon for seals and bearings. Lub. Engng., Jan. 1971, 27–33.

99.

Paxton

R. R.

Strugala

E. W.

Wear rates of impregnated carbons sealing warm water. Lub. Engng., Aug. 1973, 341–346.

100.

Paxton

R. R.

Massaro

A. J.

Strugala

E. W.

Performance of siliconised graphite as a mating face in mechanical seals. Lub. Engng., Dec. 1977, 650–656.

101.

Paxton

R. R.

Hulbert

H. T.

Rubbing friction in radial face seals. Lub. Engng., Feb. 1980, 89–97.

102.

Piehn

L. D.

The application of tungsten carbide for mechanical face seal faces. Lub. Engng., Sept. 1965, 381–385.

103.

Pijcke

A. C.

Vries

Comparative testing of a number of radial face seals. 8th Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper E2, BHRA, 1978.

104.

Rowles

R. T.

Nau

B. S.

An assessment of factors affecting the response of mechanical seals to shaft vibration. 8th Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper A3, BHRA Fluid Engineering, 1978.

105.

Ruddy

A. V.

Dowson

Taylor

C. M.

The prediction of film thickness in a mechanical face seal with circumferential waviness on both the face and the seat. J. Mech. Engng. Sci., 1982, 24(1), 37–43.

106.

Ruddy

A. V.

Summers-Smith

J. D.

The mechanism of film generation in mechanical face seals. Tribology Int., Aug. 1982, 227–231.

107.

Sehnal

Sedy

Zobens

Etsion

Performance of the coned-face end-seal with regard to energy conservation. Trans. ASLE, 1982, 26(4), 415–429.

108.

Smalley

A. J.

Darlow

M. S.

Mehta

R. K.

The dynamic characteristics of O-rings. ASME Paper 77-DET-27, 1977.

109.

Stanghan-Batch

Face lubrication in mechanical seals. Proc. 9th Tribology Conv., 1971, (IMechE, London).

110.

Stanghan-Batch

Iny

E. H.

A hydrodynamic theory of radial-face mechanical seals. J. Mech. Engng. Sci., 1971, 15(1), 17–24.

111.

Strom

T. N.

Ludwig

L. P.

Hudelson

J. C.

Vibration of shaft face seals and stabilising effect of viscous and friction damping. NASA Report TN D-5161, 1969.

112.

Strugala

E. W.

The nature and causes of seal carbon blistering. Lub. Engng., Sept. 1972, 333–339.

113.

Summers-Smith

J. D.

Laboratory investigation of the performance of a radial-face seal. 1st Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper D1, BHRA, 1961.

114.

Summers-Smith

J. D.

Performance of mechanical seals in centrifugal process pumps. 9th Int. Conf. on Fluid Sealing, Paper H1, BHRA, 1981.

115.

Symons

J. D.

Factors contributing to the water pump seal leakage problem. General Motors Research Laboratories Report GMR1736, Nov. 1974.

116.

Taylor

Jones

D. N.

High duty seal tests: some observations on lubrication. Proc. 8th BPMA Technical Conf: Pumps—the heart of the matter, BHRA, 1983.

117.

Teale

J. L.

Lebeck

A. O.

An evaluation of the average flow model for surface roughness effects in lubrication. Trans. ASME, J. Lubric. Tech., July 1980, 102, 360–367.

118.

Tribe

Seawater-lubricated mechanical seals and bearings: Associated materials problems. Lubn. Engng., 1973, 39(5), 292–299.

119.

Trytek

J. J.

The application of mechanical end face seals for hot water service. Lub. Engng., Jan. 1973, 39(1), 17–23.

120.

Watson

R. D.

Endurance tests on large hydrostatic (conical face) and hydrodynamic (taper-face) rotating shaft seals in pressurised water. Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd, Report AECL4367, Jan. 1973.

121.

Watson

R. D.

Effect of seal ring deflection on the characteristics of face-type mechanical shaft seals in high pressure water. Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd, Report AECL2242, April 1965.

122.

Will

T. P.

Experimental observation of a face-contact mechanical shaft seal operating on water. ASLE Preprint 81-LC-1A-1, 1981.

123.

Winn

L. W.

Thorkildsen

R. L.

Wilcock

D. F.

Design of one-piece jet-engine compressor and seal. ASME Paper 68-LubS-14, 1968.

124.

Burton

R. A.

Thermoelastic and dynamic phenomenona in seals. ASME Preprint 80-C2-Lub-9, 1980.

125.

Zuk

Fundamentals of fluid sealing. NASA Technical Note TN D-8151, Mar. 1976.

Rotary Mechanical Seals in Process Duties: An Assessment of the State of the Art

Abstract

Get full access to this article

References