The present state of knowledge of methods of hardening and of strengthening materials and the use of hard materials for tribological applications is summarized. The essential properties of materials for various types of mechanisms such as rolling bearings, gears, cams, etc. are reviewed. Mechanisms of failure and controlling factors are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
‘New engineering materials’, Proc. Instn mech. Engrs1965–66180 (Pt 33).
2.
SemchyshenM.HarwoodJ. J. (eds) Refractory metals and alloys1960 (Interscience Publishers Inc., London).
3.
WoldmanN. E.Engineering alloys1962 (Reinhold Publishing Corporation, New York; Chapman and Hall, London).
4.
KellyP. M.NuttingJ.‘Strengthening mechanisms in steel’, I.S.I. Special Report 76: High strength steels 1962, 7 (Iron and Steel Institute, London).
5.
MorroghH.‘Cast iron as an engineering material’, Engineering Materials and Design Conference 1960, T1 (Engineering Materials and Design, London).
6.
SmithA. I.ScottD.‘The technical basis of steel specifications’, I.S.I. Special Report 88: National steel specifications 1966, 18 (Iron and Steel Institute, London).
7.
Institution of MetallurgistsBehaviour of metals at elevated temperatures1956 (Iliffe and Sons Ltd, London).
8.
KoenigJ. H.SmokeE. J.‘Characteristic properties of modern ceramics’, in Modern materials (HausnerH. H., ed.), 19581, 243 (Academic Press, London).
9.
DuckworthW. E.‘Progress in the metallurgical properties and applications of steel’, Engrs’ Dig., Lond. Silver Jubilee Issue1965.
10.
BrandonD.NuttingJ.‘Dislocations in α iron’, J. Iron Steel Inst.1960196, 160.
11.
HoneycombeR. W. K.‘Some strengthening mechanisms in alloy steels’, I.S.I. Special Report 86: Metallurgical developments in high alloy steels 1964, 1.
ZackayV. F.JustussanM. V.‘The properties of martensitic steels formed from strain-hardened austenite’, I.S.I. Special Report 76, 1962, 14 (Iron and Steel Institute, London).
15.
DuckworthW. E.LeakD. A.PhillipsR.‘Ductility in high strength steels, its achievement and importance’, I.S.I. Special Report 76, 1962, 22 (Iron and Steel Institute, London).
16.
ZackayV. F.ParkerE. R.‘Some fundamental considerations in design of high strength metallic materials’, in High strength materials (ZackayV. F., ed.) 1965, 130 (J. Wiley and Sons, London).
17.
ThomasG.SchmatzD.GerberichW.‘Structure and strength of some ausformed steels’, in High strength materials (ZackayV. F., ed.) 1965, 251 (J. Wiley and Sons, London).
18.
DuckworthW. E.TaylorP. R.‘Ausforming of high alloy steels’, I.S.I. Special Report 86, 1964 (Iron and Steel Institute, London).
19.
JustussanW. M.‘Half million psi steels by ausforming’, Material in Design1964 (May), 92.
20.
DuckworthW. E.‘The strengthening of steel—II: Maraging steels’, Iron Steel, Lond.1964 (Oct.).
21.
StevenW.‘Maraging steels’, I.S.I. Special Report 86: Metallurgical developments in high alloy steels 1964, 115.
CratchleyD.‘Experimental aspects of fibre reinforced metals’, Metall. Rev.196510 (37), 79 (Institute of Metals, London).
29.
ThomasA. G.HuffadineJ. A.MooreN. C.‘Preparation, properties and application of metal–ceramic mixtures’, Metall. Rev.19638 (32), 461 (Institute of Metals, London).
HarmanC. G.‘Non-glassy inorganic fibres and composites’, N.A.S.A. SP-5055, 1966 (Aug.).
32.
MorleyJ. G.‘Strong fibres and fibre reinforced metals’, Proc. Roy. Soc., A1964282 (1388), 43.
33.
McDanelsD. J.JechR. W.WeetonJ. W.‘Metals reinforced with fibres’, Metal Prog.196078 (6), 118.
34.
TinkelpaughJ. R.CrandallW. B. (eds.) Cermets1960 (Chapman and Hall, London).
35.
BlockE. A.‘Dispersion strengthened aluminium alloys’, Metall. Rev.19616 (22), 193 (Institute of Metals, London).
36.
HausenN.LilholtI.‘Bibliography on dispersion strengthened materials’, Risö Report No. 48 (Roskilde, Denmark) 1962 (Danish Atomic Energy Commission).
37.
CratchleyD.BakerA. A.Metallurgia1964 (Apr.), 153.
38.
SuttonW. H.ChorneJ.Metals Engng Quart.19633.
39.
CottrellA. H.‘Strong solids’, Proc. Roy. Soc., A1964282 (1388), 2.
40.
LoveR. W.EstyC. C.WheildonW. M.‘High temperature materials and coatings for the aerospace industry’, in Materials science research (OtteH. M.LockeS. R., eds.) 19652, 211 (Plenum Press, New York).
41.
GillR. M.SpenceG.‘Wear resistant ceramics’, New Scientist196214 (291), 574.
BurlsJ. (ed.). Diamond abrasives and tools1964 (Pergamon Press, London).
44.
BruntonJ. H.‘Diamonds as an engineering material’, Chart. mech. Engr196613 (1), 2 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
45.
FordC. E.BushongR. M.StroutR. D.‘The new graphites’, Metal Prog.196282 (6), 101.
46.
ForresterP. G.‘Bearing metals’, Metall. Rev.19605 (20), 508 (Institute of Metals, London).
47.
ForresterP. G.‘Soft-metal bearings’, Paper 22 of this Conference.
48.
ForresterP. G.‘Materials for plain bearings’, in Modern materials19644, 174 (Academic Press, London).
49.
GoodzeitC. L.‘Compatibility of metals in bearing contact’, Am. Soc. Mech. Engrs Paper 58-MD-9, 1958.
50.
BowdenF. P.TaborD.The friction and lubrication of solids Pt I, 1950 (Clarendon Press, Oxford).
51.
DawsonP. H.FidlerF.‘The behaviour of chromium steel in large high speed bearings’, A.E.I. Engng Rev.19622 (2).
52.
DawsonP. H.FidlerF.RowleyP.‘Wire-wool type failures in 3 per cent chromium–½ per cent molybdenum steel journals—a preliminary evaluation of some palliatives’, Proc. Instn mech. Engrs1964–65179 (Pt 3J), 27.
53.
DawsonP. H.FidlerF.‘Wire-wool type bearing failures: the formation of the wire wool’, Proc. Instn mech. Engrs1965–66180 (Pt 1, No. 21), 522.
54.
BarwellF. T.ScottD.‘The investigation of unusual bearing failures’, Proc. Fourth Lubrication and Wear Convention (Holland) 1966 (May), Paper 10 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
55.
AmateauM. F.NicholsonD. W.GlaeserW. A.‘Survey of materials for high temperature bearings and sliding applications’, O.T.S. PB 171625, 1961.
56.
Proc. Intern. Conference on Gearing 1958 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
57.
FletcherH. A. G.CollierP.‘Endurance tests on En 8-En 9 gears with hobbed and shaved finishes’, N.E.L. Report No. 223, 1966 (National Engineering Laboratory, East Kilbride, Glasgow).
58.
DawsonP. H.‘The effect of metallic contact and sliding on the shape of the S-N curve for pitting fatigue’, Proc. Fatigue in Rolling Contact 1963, Paper 4, 41 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
59.
DawsonP. H.‘Effect of metallic contact on the pitting of lubricated rolling surfaces’, J. mech. Engng Sci.19624, 16.
60.
MattsonR. L.RobertsJ. G.Internal stresses and fatigue of metals1959 (Elsevier Press, London).
61.
KirkD.NelmsP. R.ArnoldB.‘Residual stresses and fatigue life of case-carburized gears’, Metallurgia196674 (446), 225.
62.
ChestersW. T.‘The effect of material combination on resistance to surface fatigue’, Proc. Symposium on Fatigue in Rolling Contact 1964, 86 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
63.
WaterhouseR. B.‘Formation, structure and wear properties of certain non-metallic coatings on metals’, Wear1965 (Nov.–Dec).
64.
PrenosialB.‘The relationship between retained austenite and the fatigue strength of carbo-nitrided components’, International Conference on Heat Treatment (Bremen) 1966 (Soc. Française de Métallurgie and Inst. fur Hütten Technik).
65.
RazinC.‘The influence of the edge structure of case hardened gears on the tendency to pitting’, International Conference on Heat Treatment (Bremen) 1966 (Soc. Française de Métallurgie and Inst. fur Hütten Technik).
ScottD.‘The effect of material properties, lubricant and environment on rolling contact fatigue’, Proc. Symposium on Fatigue in Rolling Contact 1964, 103 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
68.
BissonE. E.AndersonW. J.‘Advanced bearing technology’, N.A.S.A. SP-38, 1964 (National Aeronautics and Space Administration, Washington, D.C.).
69.
BidwellJ. B. (ed.). Rolling contact phenomena1962 (Elsevier Press, London).
70.
ScottD.BlackwellJ.‘Study of the effect of material and hardness combination in rolling contact’, Proc. Fourth Lubrication and Wear Convention (Holland) 1966 (May), Paper 4 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
71.
ZaretskyE. V.ParkerR. J.AndersonW. J.‘Effect of component differential hardness on rolling contact fatigue and load capacity’, N.A.S.A. tech. Note D-2640, 1965 (National Aeronautical and Space Administration, Washington, D.C.).
72.
ZaretskyE. V.‘Effect of component differential hardness on residual stress and rolling contact fatigue’, N.A.S.A. tech. Note D-2664 1965 (National Aeronautical and Space Administration, Washington, D.C.).
73.
StyriH.‘Fatigue strength of ball bearing races and heat treated 52100 steel specimens’, Proc. Am. Soc. Test. Mater.195151, 682.
74.
FrithP. H.‘Fatigue tests on rolled alloy steels made in electric and open hearth furnaces’, I.S.I. Special Report No. 50, 1954 (Iron and Steel Institute, London).
75.
CarterT. L.ZaretskyE. V.AndersonW. J.‘Effect of hardness and other mechanical properties on rolling contact fatigue life of four-high temperature bearing steels’, N.A.S.A. tech. Note D-270, 1960 (National Aeronautical and Space Administration, Washington, D.C.).
76.
MikusE. B.‘The dimensional stability of a precision ball bearing material’, Trans. Am. Soc. Metals196052, 307.
77.
FrankelH. E.BennettJ. A.PenningtonW. A.‘Fatigue properties of high strength steels’, Trans. Am. Soc. Metals196052, 257.
78.
CastlemanL. S.AverbachB. L.CohenM.‘Effect of retained austenite upon mechanical properties’, Trans. Am. Soc. Metals195244, 240.
79.
AverbachB. L.LornsS. G.CohenM.‘Stress induced transformation of retained austenite in hardened steel’, Trans. Am. Soc. Metals195244, 746.
80.
ScottR. L.KeppleR. K.MillerM. H.‘The effect of processing—Induced near surface residual stress on ball bearing fatigue’, in Rolling contact phenomena (Bid-WellJ. B., ed.) 1962, 301 (Elsevier Press, London).
81.
HelbigF.‘The pitting of rolled surfaces’ (German), WerkstTech. und MaschBau194939 (4), 111.
82.
WayS.‘Pitting due to rolling contact’, J. appl. Mech.19352 (3), A110.
83.
CarterT. C.‘Effect of fibre orientation in races and balls under rolling contact fatigue conditions’, N.A.S.A. tech. Note 4216, 1958 (National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics, Washington, D.C.).
84.
ScottD.BlackwellJ.‘The effect of the steel-making process on rolling contact fatigue’, Proc. Second Lubrication and Wear Convention 1964178 (Pt 3N), 81 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
85.
NortonC. E.BakerP. J.‘The effect of new materials and processing developments on ball bearing fatigue life’, S.A.E. Automotive Engineering Congress, (Detroit) 1964, Preprint 779B.
86.
HustedT. E.‘Consideration of cylindrical roller bearing load rating formula’, S.A.E. Paper 569A, 1962 (Society of Automotive Engineers, New York).
87.
MorrisonT. W.WalpH. O.RemorenkoR. P.‘Materials in rolling element bearings for normal and elevated (450°F) temperatures’, Trans. Am. Soc. lubric. Engrs19592 (1), 129.
88.
JohnsonR. F.SewellJ. F.‘The bearing properties of 1% C–Cr steel as influenced by steel-making practice’, J. Iron Steel Inst.1960196, 414.
89.
MurrayJ. D.JohnsonR. F.‘The effect of inclusions on the properties of 1% C–Cr bearing steels’, I.S.I. Special Report No. 77: Clean steels 1963, 110 (Iron and Steel Institute, London).
90.
UhreesL. D.‘Through hardening steels for ball bearings—Effect of inclusions on endurance’, I.S.I. Special Report No. 77: Clean steels 1963, 104 (Iron and Steel Institute, London).
91.
MorrisonT. W.‘The effect of trace-element content and multiple vacuum melting on the fatigue life of ball bearings made from A.I.S.I. 52100 steel’, Proc. Symposium on Fatigue in Rolling Contact 1963, Paper 7, 78 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
92.
BarwellF. T.ScottD.‘The effect of lubricant on the pitting failure of balls’, Engineering, Lond.1956182, 9.
93.
ScottD.‘Study of the effect of lubricant on the pitting failure of balls’, Proc. Intern. Conference on Lubrication and Wear 1957, Paper 58, 463 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
94.
ScottD.BlackwellJ.‘Study of the effects of some elevated temperature lubricants on materials for rolling elements’, Proc. Fifth Lubrication and Wear Convention (Plymouth) 1967 (May), Paper 7 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
95.
CordianoH. V.CochranE. P.WolfR. J.‘A study of combustion resistant hydraulic fluids as ball bearing lubricants’, Lubric. Engng195612 (4), 261.
96.
AndersonW. J.CarterT. L.‘Effect of lubricant viscosity and type on ball fatigue life’, Trans. Am. Soc. lubric. Engrs19581 (2), 266.
97.
RoundsF. G.‘Effects of base oil viscosity and type on bearing ball fatigue’, Am. Soc. Lubric. Engrs, Preprint 61-LC-13, 1961.
98.
ScottD.BlackwellJ.‘The lubrication of rolling contacts at elevated temperatures’, Proc. Industrial Lubrication Symposium 1965, 53 (Scientific Publications (GB) Ltd, Broseley, Shropshire).
99.
ScottD.JamiesonD. T.‘Molybdenum disulphide as lubricant additive in rolling contact—a study of compatibility with other additives’, J. Inst. Petrol.196248 (460), 91.
100.
GrunbergL.ScottD.‘The acceleration of pitting failure by water in the lubricant’, J. Inst. Petrol.195844 (419), 406.
101.
GrunbergL.ScottD.‘The effect of additives on the water induced pitting of ball bearings’, J. Inst. Petrol.196046 (440), 259.
102.
ScottD.‘Further data on the effect of additives on the water induced pitting of ball bearings’, J. Inst. Petrol.196248 (457), 69.
103.
GrunbergL.JamiesonD. T.ScottD.‘Hydrogen penetration in water accelerated surface failure’, Phil. Mag.19638 (93), 1553.
104.
ScottD.ScottH. M.‘The application of electron microscopy to the study of pitting failure of rolling bearings’, Proc. European Regional Conference on Electron Microscopy (Delft)1, 539.
105.
HoyleG.‘Recent developments in high speed steels’, Metall. Rev.19649 (33), 49.
106.
ScottD.BlackwellJ.‘Study of materials for unlubricated and elevated temperature rolling elements’ (French), Revue Métall., Paris1966 (March), 257.
107.
ScottD.BlackwellJ.‘An accelerated test for the study of materials under rolling contact’, Proc. First Lubrication and Wear Convention 1963, 291 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
108.
ScottD.BlackwellJ.‘Some effects of lubricant and temperature on failure in rolling contact’, Proc. Second Lubrication and Wear Convention 1964178 (Pt 3N), 75 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
109.
ScottD.BlackwellJ.‘Study of sintered carbides and surface treated materials for unlubricated and elevated temperature rolling elements’, Proc. Fifth Lubrication and Wear Convention (Plymouth) 1967 (May), Paper No. 8 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
110.
BaughmanR. A.BambergerE. N.‘Unlubricated high temperature bearing studies’, J. basic Engng, Trans. Am. Soc. mech. Engrs, Series D196385 (2), 265.
111.
ParkerR. J.GrisaffeS. J.ZaretskyE. V.‘Surface failure of titanium carbide cermet and silicon carbide balls in rolling contact at temperatures to 2000°F’, N.A.S.A. tech. Note D-2459, 1964.
112.
BradleyR. H.‘Extreme temperature bearing development—1600°F’, Am. Soc. Mech. Engrs Paper 61-LUBS-15, 1962.
113.
TaylorK. M.SibleyL. B.LawrenceJ. C.‘Development of a ceramic rolling contact bearing for high temperature use’, Am. Soc. Mech. Engrs Paper 61-LUBS-12, 1961.
114.
ParkerR. J.GrisaffeS. J.ZaretskyE. V.‘Surface failure of alumina balls due to repeated stresses applied in rolling contact at temperatures to 2000°F’, N.A.S.A. tech. Note 2274, 1964.
115.
CarterT. L.ZaretskyE. V.‘Rolling contact fatigue life of a crystallized glass ceramic’, N.A.S.A. tech. Note D259, 1960.
LucasG.‘Surface damage to forged steel rolls and its prevention’, Iron and Steelworks Lubrication 1964–65179 (Pt 3D), 271 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
118.
AkhterM.‘A bibliography of abrasive wear (with abstracts)’, N.E.L. Report No. 123, 1963 (National Engineering Laboratory, East Kilbride, Glasgow).
119.
WrightK. H. R.‘Studies of abrasive wear resistance’, Engineering, Lond.1961191 (4956), 546.
120.
KrushchovM. M.BabichevM. A.‘Investigations into the wear of metals’, Akad. Nauk. SSSR1960, 66.
121.
Larsen-BadseJ.‘The abrasive resistance of some hardened and tempered carbon steels’, Trans. metall. Soc. A.I.M.E.1966236 (10), 1461.
122.
OrowanF. Symposium on Internal Stresses in Metals and Alloys 1948, 451 (Institute of Metals, London).
123.
ScottD.‘Metallurgical aspects of wear’, Symposium on Wear in Textile Machinery (Manchester) 1967 (March), Paper 2 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
124.
TaborD.‘Moh's hardness scale—A physical interpretation’, Proc. Phys. Soc., B195467, 249.
125.
KrushchovM. M.BabichevM. A.‘Investigation of the effect of abrasive hardness on wear of materials’, N.E.L. Trans. 830 (National Engineering Laboratory, East Kilbride, Glasgow).
126.
AleinikovF. K.‘The influence of abrasive powder microhardness on the values of coefficients of volume removal, determination by the lapping method’, Soviet Phys. tech. Phys.19572, (a), 505.
127.
NathanG. K.Derrick-JonesW. J.‘The influence of the hardness of abrasives and the abrasive wear of metals’, Proc. Fifth Lubrication and Wear Convention, (Plymouth) 1967 (May) (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
128.
JesperA. C.‘A consideration of factors affecting the wear resistance of materials used in aircraft gas turbine engines’, Proc. Fourth Lubrication and Wear Convention (Holland) 1966 (May), Paper 15 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
129.
PughH. Ll.D.LeesJ.‘Ultra high pressure research—the synthesis of diamond’, N.E.L. Report No. 9, 1961 (National Engineering Laboratory, East Kilbride, Glasgow).
130.
Materials in design engineering: Materials selector issue196562 (5).
131.
Metals Handbook1961, 8th ed. ‘I: Properties and selection’ (American Society for Metals, Ohio).
132.
WheildonW. M.‘Ceramics for cutting purposes’, in Modern materials 19602, 107 (Academic Press, London).
133.
KoenigJ. H.SmokeE. J.‘Characteristic properties of modern ceramics’, in Modern materials 19581, 243 (Academic Press, London).
134.
NataroJ.‘Non-lubricated piston rings for high pressure application’, Lubric. Engng196622 (3), 104.
135.
JensenP. W.Cam design and manufacture1965 (The Industrial Press, New York).
136.
HarrisonL.‘Powder metallurgy’, Engineering Materials and Design Conference (London) 1960, Paper S.
137.
HafstadL. R.‘The role of industrial research’, Sci. Jl19662 (9), 79.
138.
RafiqueS. O.‘Failures of plain bearings and their causes’, Proc. Instn mech. Engrs1963–64178 (Pt 3N), 180.
139.
SimpsonF. F.‘Failure of rolling contact bearings’, Proc. Instn mech. Engrs1963–64178 (Pt 3N), 215.
140.
BarwellF. T.‘Wear of metals’, J. Inst. Metals1957–5886, 257.
141.
BarwellF. T.‘Surface contact in theory and practice’, Proc. Instn mech. Engrs1961175, 853.
142.
WelchN. C.J. Inst. Metals195988, 103.
143.
HirstW.‘Wear’, Metall. Rev. 196510 (38), 145 (Institute of Metals, London).
144.
KragelskiiI. V.Friction and wear1965 (Butterworths, London).
145.
ScottD.ScottH. M.‘The electron microscope in the study of wear’, Proc. Conference on Lubrication and Wear (London) 1957, 609 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
146.
WrightK. H. R.‘An investigation of fretting corrosion’, Proc. Instn mech. Engrs1952–53 (Pt IB), 556.
147.
GodfreyD.BaileyJ. M.‘Early stages of fretting of copper, iron and steel’, Lubric. Engng195410 (3), 155.
148.
GalvinG. D.NaylorH.‘Effect of lubricants on the fatigue of steel and other metals’, Proc. Lubrication and Wear Third Convention 1965, 56 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
149.
LikhtmanV. I.RebinderP. A.KarpenoG. U.‘Effect of a surface active medium on the process of deformation of metals’, Akad. Nauk. SSSR (Moscow)1954 (D.S.I.R. Transl. 1958, Her Majesty's Stationery Office, London).
150.
ScottD.LoyB.MillsG. H.‘Metallurgical aspects of rolling contact fatigue’, Proc. Fifth Lubrication and Wear Convention (Plymouth) 1967 (May), Paper 26, (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
151.
BushJ. J.GrubeW. L.RobinsonG. H.‘Microstructural and residual stress changes in hardened steel due to rolling contact’, Proc. Symposium on Rolling Contact Phenomena (BidwellJ. B., ed.) 1962, 363 (Elsevier Press, London).
152.
GentileA. J.JordanE. G.MartinA. D.‘Phase transformations in high carbon, high hardness steels under contact loads’, Trans. Am. Inst. Min. Engrs1965233, 1085.
153.
O'BrienJ. L.KingA. H.‘Electron microscopy of stress induced alterations near inclusions in bearing steels’, Am. Soc. Mech. Engrs Paper 65-WA/CF/1, 1965.
154.
DaviesW. J.DayK. L.‘Surface fatigue in ball bearings, roller bearings and gears in aircraft engines’, Proc. Symposium on Fatigue in Rolling Contact 1963, 27 Paper 3 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
155.
O'BrienJ. L.KingA. H.‘Stress-induced microstructural changes and fatigue damage in hardened steel under contact-loading’, Am. Soc. Mech. Engrs Paper 65-LUBS-14, 1965.
156.
MartinJ. A.BorgeseS. F.EberhardtA. D.‘Microstructural alterations of rolling bearing steel undergoing cyclic stressing’, Am. Soc. Mech. Engrs Paper 65-WA/SF-4, 1965.
157.
BalmforthN.WatsonH. J.‘A practical look at gear tooth damage’, Iron and Steel Works Lubrication 1964–65179 (Pt 3D), 201 (Instn Mech. Engrs, London).
158.
ScwarzkopfP.KiefferR.Refractory hard metals1953 (Macmillan, New York).
159.
Selection materials and design 1967 (Institute of Metallurgists and Institution of Mechanical Engineers, London): in press.