Properties of Wrought CoNiCrMo Alloy Protasul-10,a Highly Corrosion and Fatigue Resistant Implant Material for Joint Endoprostheses *

Abstract

Loosening of prosthetic components in the bone is a problem that has not been fully explored as yet. When loosening has occurred, the metallic anchorage stem may become overloaded and in extreme cases it may ultimately lead to stem fracture if the fatigue limit of the metallic material is exceeded.

In order to preclude the possibility of these undesirable fatigue fractures of loosened prosthesis stems requiring re-operations, the Sulzer research laboratories have developed wrought alloys of extremely high strength and corrosion resistance such as Protasul-10.^†

The chemical composition, structure, mechanical properties, corrosion resistance and present state of the art of this implant material, which has been in clinical use since 1971, are specified in national and international standards.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

American Society for Testing and Materials ASTM (1978) Standard Specification for wrought CoNiCrMo alloy for surgical implant application. ANSI/ASTM F 562–78 (May 1978).

Baumann

Semlitsch

(1974) Biological and mechanical behaviour of newly developed implant materials in animal studies. Sulzer Technical Review. 56, No. 2, 118–125.

Charnley

(1970) Acrylic cement orthopaedic surgery, Livingstone, Edingburgh.

Dockal

Corrosion behaviour of implantation materials for artificial joints. (1972) Sulzer Technical Review, Research Number, 14–18.

Escales

Galante

Rostocker

Coogan

P. S.

(1976) MP-35N, a corrosion resistant high-strength alloy for orthopaedic surgical implants, bioassay results. J. Biomed. Matls Res., 9, No. 3, 303–313.

Fletcher

S. G.

Yates

D. H.

(1968) Multiphase, a unique alloy system for high strength and corrosion resistance. ASM Technical Report No, D 8–71, 1–8.

Gaechter

Galante

(1976) MP-35N, a corrosion resistant high-strength alloy for orthopaedic or surgical implants, two year bioassay. J. Biomed. Matls Res. 10, 829–831.

Gerber

Perren

S. M.

(1978) Die Gewebeverträglichkeit der CoNiCrMo-Schmiedelegierung Protasul-10, geprüft bei in-vitro Organkulturen embryonaler Rattenfemora. Personal communication.

Graham

A. H.

(1969) Strengthening of Multiphase alloys during aging at elevated temperatures. Trans. Am. Soc. Metals, 62, 930–935.

10.

Graham

A. H.

Youngblood

J. L.

(1970) Workstrengthening by a deformation induced phase transformation in Multiphase alloys. Metall. Trans. 1, Feb, 413–430.

11.

ISO/TC-150/SC-1/WG-1 (1974) Comments on the biocompatibility of CoNiCrMoTi-Forging Alloy Protasul-10. SNV Swiss Proposal 056 509, Part 2, Davos, June 1974.

12.

International Organization for Standardization ISO, TC-150 (1977) Material for metal surgical implants, part VI, Wrought CoNiCrMo Alloy. ISO Draft Proposal No. 37, ISO/DIS 5832/vi, Philadelphia, June 1977.

13.

Kuehne

(1975) Die Gewebsverträglichkeit verschiedener metallischer Implantat-Werkstoffe in Pulverform. Dissertation Orthopädische Univ. Klinik, Frankfurt a.M., Sulzer Reprint No, 28.75.00 Dgc 10, 1975, 1–40.

14.

Lorenz

Semlitsch

Panic

Weber

Willert

H. G.

(1978) Fatigue strength of cobalt-base alloys with high corrosion resistance for artificial hip joints. Engineering in Medicine, 7, No. 4, 241–250.

15.

Normenvereinigung

Schweizerische SNV

(1975) Chirurgische Implantate, Werkstoff CoNiCrMoTi-Schmiedelegierung. SNV Nr. 056509, April 1975.

16.

Semlitsch

(1972) Implant metals for plates, screws and artificial joints in bone surgery. Sulzer Technical Review, (1972), No. 3, 1–11. and Engineering in Medicine 1973, 2, No. 3, 68–74.

17.

Semlitsch

(1971) Metals and plastics for artificial hip joints — investigation of surfaces by scanning electron microscopy. Sulzer Technical Review, Research Number 1971, 1–13, and in: Der totale Hüftgelenkersatz, Georg Thieme Verlang Stuttgart, 1973, pp 33–44.

18.

Semlitsch

(1974) Technical progress in artificial hip joints. Sulzer Technical Review, 1974 No. 4, 235–245 and in Total hip prosthesis, Hans Huber Publishers, Bern, Stuttgart, Vienna, 1976, pp 256–278.

19.

Semlitsch

Willert

H. G.

(1976) Kobaltbasis-Legierungen in Guss- und Schmiedezustand als Implantatwerkstoffe. Medizinisch-Orthopädische Technik, No. 4, 86–90.

20.

Smith

G. D.

Yates

D. H.

(1968) High strength, ductility, corrosion resistance, Multiphase alloys have all three. Metal. Progress, 93, Mar., 100–102.

21.

Suery

(1975) Untersuchungen zum Korrosionsverhalten gegossener und geschmiedeter Implantat-Werkstoffe. Werkstoffe und Korrosion, 1975 No. 4, 278–287.

22.

Suery

(1976) Korrosionseigenschaften gegossener und geschmiedeter Werkstoffe für künstliche Gelenke. Medita, 6, No. 4, 19–24.

23.

Suery

(1977) Corrosion behaviour of cast and forged implant materials for artificial joints, particularly with respect to compound designs. Corrosion Science, 17, 155–169.

24.

Suery

Semlitsch

(1976) Gefügeaufbau und Korrosionseigenschaften von Kobaltlegierungen für künstliche Gelenke in Sonderbände der praktischen Metallographie, Band 6: Metallographie, Schadensfallanalyse und Werkstoffentwicklung pp 107–117.

25.

Suery

Semlitsch

(1978) Corrosion behaviour of cast and forged cobalt-based alloys for double-alloy joint endoprostheses. J. Biomed. Matls Res., 12, No. 5, 723–741.

26.

Thull

Schaldach

(1976a) Elektrochemie mechanisch beanspruchter Metallimplantate. Biomedizinische Technik, 21, Medex, 355.

27.

Thull

Schaldach

(1976b) Corrosion of highly stressed orthopaedic joint replacements, in Engineering in medicine, No. 2: Advances in artificial hip and knee joint technology, Springer Verlag Berlin, Heidelberg, New York, pp. 242–256.

28.

Willert

H. G.

(1978) Clinical experience with Mueller total hip endoprostheses of different design and materials (CoCrMo-cast alloy and CoNiCrMo-wrought alloy Protasul-10) Transaction of 3rd conference on Materials for use in Medicine and Biology, Keel, Great Britain, Sept. 1978, Session 1, Paper No. 5.

29.

Willert

H. G.

Kuehne

Eckert

K. D.

Semlitsch

Doerre

(1977) A morphological comparison of the foreign body reactions to metal, plastic and ceramic particles in animal experiments. Transactions of 3rd Annual Meeting of Society for Biomaterials, April 1977, p. 143.

30.

Zichner

Willert

H. G.

(1977) Clinical experience with Mueller total hip endoprostheses with stems made of wrought CoNiCrMoTi alloy Protasul-10. Transaction of 3rd Annual Meeting, Society for Biomaterials, New Orleans, April 1977, p. 98.