Fatigue Strength of Cobalt-Base Alloys with High Corrosion Resistance for Artificial Hip Joints

Abstract

Loosening of the anchorage in the bone is a problem in hip-joint arthroplasty which up to now has not been entirely solved. In the loosened condition, anchorage stems of artificial joints are subject to alternating overload which causes rupture if the fatigue strength is exceeded by the stress amplitude.

At Sulzer a hip-joint anchorage stem made from wrought CoNiCrMo alloy Protasul-10 has been developed which has substantially higher fatigue strength than stems made from stainless steel of grade AISI-316L or CoCrMo cast alloy. It is therefore essentially safe from fatigue cracking and this offers the possibility of significantly easier removal in case of re-operation after loosening.

This paper deals with some rules to be observed in choice or development of materials for long-term implants subject to fatigue. The results of laboratory investigations on the fatigue behaviour of cobalt-base alloys for surgical implants are discussed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ahier

S. J. H.

Ginsburg

K. M.

(1966) Influence of carbide distribution on the wear and friction of Vitallium. Proc. Instn mech. Engrs, 181, Part 3J, 137.

Andriacchi

T. P.

Galante

J. O.

Belytschko

T. B.

Hampton

(1976) A stress analysis of the femoral stems in total hip prostheses. J. Bone Jt Surg., 58A, No 5, 618–624.

Bechtol

C. O.

(1975) Failure of femoral implant components in total hip operations. Orthopaedic Review, IV No 11, 23–29.

Bechtol

C. O.

(1976) Durability of femoral implant parts in total hip replacement; the ultimate test. Scientific Exhibit, AAOS Convention, New Orleans.

Chapchal

(1973) Arthroplasty of the Hip. Georg-Thieme Publishers, Stuttgart, FRG.

Charnley

(1970a) Total hip replacement by low-friction arthroplasty. Clin. Orthop., 72, 7.

Charnley

(1970b) Acrylic cement in orthopaedic surgery. Livingstone, Edinburgh, Great Britain.

Charnley

(1975) Fracture of femoral prostheses in total hip replacement. Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, 111, 124.

Cotta

Schulitz

K. P.

(1973) Der totale Hüftgelenkersatz. George-Thieme-Verlag, Stuttgart, FRG.

10.

Dobbs

H. S.

(1977) Survey of fractured femoral components—prostheses and patients. Transactions of 3rd Annual Meeting, Society for Biomaterials, New Orleans, Paper No 92, p. 97.

11.

Drapier

J. M.

Viatour

Coutsouradis

Habraken

(1970) Hardening mechanisms in multiphase alloy MP35N. Cobalt, 49, 171–186.

12.

Ducheyne

De Meester

Aernoudt

Martens

Mulier

C. J.

(1975) Fatigue fractures of the femoral component of Charnley and Charnley-Müller type total hip prostheses. Journal of Biomedical Materials Research, No 6, 199–219.

13.

Endo

Komai

(1973) Einfluss der mittleren Spannungen auf den Verlauf der Korrosionsermüdung. Metalloberfläche. Angewandte Elektrochemie, 27, 378.

14.

Escales

Galante

Rostocker

Coogan

P. S.

(1975) MP-35 N, a corrosion resistant, high strength alloy for orthopaedic surgical implants: Bio-assay results. Journal of Biomedical Materials Research, 9, No 3, 303–313.

15.

Forte

Murray

J. P.

(1975) Structural analysis of the femoral stem of total hip prostheses. XIII. SICOT-Congress, Copenhagen, Paper No 2113.

16.

Forte

(1976) Longterm complications of hip arthroplasty; fracture of the femoral prosthesis stem. 2nd Annual Meeting, Society for Biomaterials, Philadelphia, Paper No 66.

17.

Frank

Zitter

(1971) Metallische Implantate in der Knochenchirurgie. Springer-Verlag, Vienna, New York, p 105.

18.

Gaechter

Galante

Rostocker

(1976) MP-35 N—A corrosion resistant, high strength alloy for orthopaedic or surgical implants: Two-year bio-assay results. Journal of Biomedical Materials Research, 10, No 5, 829–831.

19.

Galante

J. O.

Rostocker

Doyle

J. M.

(1975) Failed femoral stems in total hip prostheses. J. Bone Jt Surg., 57A, No 2, 230–236.

20.

Gilbertson

L. N.

(1977) Fatigue testing of orthopaedic biomaterials. Transactions of 3rd Annual Meeting, Society for Biomaterials, New Orleans, Paper No 86, p 91.

21.

Gschwend

Debrunner

U. (1976) Total hip prosthesis. Hans Huber Publishers, Bern, Stuttgart, Vienna.

22.

Heipertz

Willert

H. G.

Zichner

(1976) Das Risiko der Implantatlockerung—eine Analyse unseres Krankengutes. Orthopädische Praxis, XII, No 12, 1104–1109.

23.

Hirschfeld

Müller

(1976) Eigenschaften und Einsatzmöglichkeiten eines verbesserten metallischen Implantatwerkstoffes auf Kobalt-Chrom-Basis (Endocast) 118th Meeting of the Orthopaedic Surgeons' Association of West Germany, Hamburg, Paper No 58. Reprint No 2.30–71.Od 677, Fried. Krupp Ltd.

24.

Jacoby

(1976) Verfahren der Schwingfestigkeitsprüfung. VDI-Ber., No 268.

25.

Knotek

Seifahrt

Kiefer

(1968) Beitrag zur Untersuchung der kobaltreichen Ecke im System Kobalt-Chrom-Wolfram-Kohlenstoff. Arch. EisenhüttWes., 39, 869–875.

26.

Kühne

(1975) Die Gewebsverträglichkeit verschiedener metallischer Implantatwerkstoffe in Pulverform—Vergleich einer neuentwickelten CoNiCrMoTi-Schmiedelegierung (Protasul-10) mit den bisher gebräuchlichen Implantatwerkstoffen CoCrMo-Guβ (Protasul-2) und FeCrNiMo-Schmiedestahl (AISI-316L). Inaugural Dissertation, Frankfurt-on-Main, FRG. Sulzer Reprint 28.75.00 Dgc 10.

27.

Lautenschlager

E. P.

Moser

J. B.

Bapna

M. S.

Meyer

P. R.

(1977) Alteration of fatigue life of surgical implant alloys by anodic potentials. Transactions of 3rd Annual Meeting, Society for Biomaterials, New Orleans, Paper No 88, p 93.

28.

McKee

G. K.

Watson-Farrar

(1966) Replacement of the arthritic hips by the McKee-Farrar Prosthesis. J. Bone Jt Surg., 48B, 245–259.

29.

McNeice

Amstutz

H. C.

(1976) Stresses in prosthesis stems and supporting acrylic—a finite element study of hip replacement. 22nd Annual ORS, New Orleans, p 172.

30.

McNeice

G. M.

Gruen

T. A.

Mechanical failure modus of femoral components—radiographic examination of total hip replacement. 22nd Annual ORS, New Orleans, p 6.

31.

Markolf

K. L.

Amstutz

H. C.

(1976) Stem fracture in total hip replacement. Scientific Exhibit, AAOS Convention, New Orleans.

32.

Metals Improvement Company (MIC) Shot Peening Applications. 4th Edition.

33.

Rostocker

Galante

J. O.

(1977) Defects in failed stems of hip prostheses. Transactions of 3rd Annual Meeting, Society for Biomaterials, New Orleans, Paper No 91, p 96.

34.

Schaldach

Hohmann

Thull

Hein

(1976) Artificial hip and knee joint technology. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York.

35.

Schmidt

(1971) Werkstoffkennwerte bei Dauerfestigkeitsuntersuchungen. DEW—Technische Berichte, 11, 1–21.

36.

Semlitsch

(1974) Technical progress in artificial hip joints. Sulzer Technical Review, 56, No 4, 235–245.

37.

Semlitsch

(1976) Metallurgical and clinical experience with cast and forged cobalt chromium base implant metals of compound construction for artificial joint endoprostheses. Reconstruction surgery and traumatology. C. Chapchal, Karger-Verlag, Basel, München, Paris, London, New York, Sydney, pp 82–101.

38.

Semlitsch

Lorenz

Wintsch

(1973) Investigation of fractures in cast and forged implant metals with the scanning electron microscope and the possibility of preventing fatigue fractures in hip joint endoprostheses. Beiträge zur elektronenmikroskopischen Direktabbildung von Oberflächen. R. A. Remy-Verlag, Münster, FRG, No 6, pp 263–286.

39.

Semlitsch

Wintsch

(1972) Structural changes on the CoCrMoC implantation precision casting alloy Protasul as a result of high-temperature annealing for optimum properties. Beiträge zur elektronenmikroskopischen Direktabbildung von Oberflächen. R. A. Remy-Verlag, Münster, FRG, No 5, pp 701–721.

40.

Swanson

S. A. V.

Freeman

M. A. R.

Vernon-Roberts

Weightman

(1977) The scientific basis of joint replacement—properties of materials. Pitman Medical Publishing Co. Ltd, pp 1–17.

41.

Taussig

L. M.

(1977) Twenty years of surgical implant failure analysis—a summary. Transactions of 3rd Annual Meeting, Society for Biomaterials, New Orleans, Paper No 90, p 95.

42.

Tisone

T. C.

(1973) The concentration and temperature dependence of the stacking fault energy in face-centred cubic CoFe (and CoNi) alloys. Acta Metall., 21, 229.

43.

Walton

Ellison

E. G.

(1972) Fatigue crack initiation and propagation. International Metallurgical Reviews, 17, 100–116.

44.

Willert

H. G.

Kühne

Eckert

K. D.

Semlitsch

Doerre

(1977) A morphologic comparison of the foreign body reaction to metal-, plastic- and ceramic-particles in animals experiments. Transactions of 3rd Annual Meeting, Society for Biomaterials, New Orleans, Paper No 136, p 143.

45.

Willert

H. G.

Ludwig

Semlitsch

(1974) Reaction of bone to methacrylate after hip arthroplasty. J. Bone Jt Surg., 56A, No 7, 1368–1382.

46.

Woodford

D. A.

(1972) Cavitation—erosion-induced phase transformation alloys. Metallurgical Transactions, 3, 1137–1145.

47.

Zichner

Willert

H. G.

(1977) Clinical experience with Müller total hip endoprostheses with stems made of wrought CoNiCrMoTi alloy Protasul-10. Transactions of 3rd Annual Meeting, Society for Biomaterials, New Orleans, Paper No 93, p 98.

48.

ISO/TC-150/SC-1/WG-3 (1975a) Corrosion fatigue testing of hip joint endoprostheses. National SNV—Draft Proposal No CH-1/18, Copenhagen.

49.

ISO/TC-150/SC-1/WG-3 (1975b) Bone and joint replacements. Draft British Standard Specification for surgical implants. Part 6: orthopaedic joint replacements made of wrought stainless steel materials, bars and forgings.

50.

Papers of the Summer Meeting of Austrian Orthopaedic Surgeons, Linz, Orthopädische Praxis XII (1976), No 6.

51.

Papers of the 26th Annual Meeting of the Orthopaedic Surgeons Association of North-west Germany, Lübeck-Travemünde, Orthopädische Praxis XII (1976), No 12 and XIII (1977), No 1.

52.

This paper was first published (in German) in Biotechnische Umschau 1978 (2). 19.