The development of novel control valve diagnostic software based on the Visual Basic programming language

Abstract

A number of commercially available control valve fault diagnostic systems were considered by the authors and it was established that they produce test results that require specialist knowledge to interpret them fully and, therefore, to diagnose faults accurately in control valves. This provided the incentive to develop a graphical user-interface diagnostic program, as reported in this paper, which can be used easily by field technicians and operators to diagnose faults in control valves and actuators.

A commercially available diagnostic system had been used to generate a large number of test results for various faults in a typical control valve and actuator. These results were incorporated into the newly developed control valve diagnostic program as its database. Then, when tests are conducted and available information is entered into the program, a diagnostic statement is produced. The statement is based on the comparison between the entered value for given valve performance parameters and those which are in the established database. In addition, an option was included which enables the user to import certain types of test data directly from the commercially available diagnostic system so that the condition of the control valve can be established with a higher degree of accuracy and without any additional hardware components.

The diagnostic program has three options. They are as follows: determine condition, estimate condition and step response analysis. The determine condition option enables the types of fault to be determined with absolute certainty. However, this option can only be used if all the 12 valve performance parameters are known and are entered into the diagnostic program. On the other hand, the estimate condition option was developed in such a way that faults can be predicted when at least one of the valve's performance parameters is entered into the program. This is because, when the valve's performance parameters are entered and the estimate condition option is selected, the diagnostic result is produced in the form of a distribution table showing the conditions that are satisfied by the input variables (the performance parameters) and the extent to which each variable has satisfied the conditions.

The step response analysis option enables the condition of a control valve and its actuator to be determined, either by importing test data that are produced when the control valve is cycled and the commercially available diagnostic system is used to monitor the valve stem position or by monitoring the pressure that is developed in the actuator's upper diaphragm casing, using a pressure transducer and a data acquisition system.

The reliability and the accuracy of determining a number of faults within a control valve were established. Faults considered included the gradual blockage of the actuator's vent hole, damaged valve stem and damaged valve stem packing rings, and the accuracy of determining the type of fault was dependent on the selected diagnostic option. The paper concludes by providing result screens for a number of conditions using all the available options and outlines the limitations of the current version of the developed program.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Wetherold

R. G.

Rosebrook

D. D.

Tichenor

B. A.

Assessment of atmospheric emissions from petroleum refining. Research and Development Report EPA-600/S2–80-075, US Environmental Protection Agency, USA, January 1981, pp. 1–5.

Dimmick

J. G.

Nicholas

J. R.

Acoustical valve leak detector for fluid system maintenance. Nav. Engrs J., April 1979, 71–83.

Ellingson

W. A.

Sullivan

J. W.

Acoustic valve leak detection. In Proceedings of the Sixth Annual Conference on Materials for Coal Conversion and Utilization, USA, October 1981, pp. 24–28.

Pollock

A. A.

Hsu

Leak detection using acoustic emission. Japan J. Acoustic Emission, 1982, 237–243.

Badinier

Dimmick

J. G.

Nuclear valve leak detection by passive acoustic spectrum analysis. In Proceedings of the Conference on Non-destructive Evaluation in the Nuclear Industry, Zurich, Switzerland, 28 November-2 December 1983, pp. 367–372.

Salter

Analytical assessment of the packed gland for reciprocating valve stems. In Proceedings of IMechE International Conference on Valves for Power Plant Development and Testing, 1989, pp. 35–47 (Mechanical Engineering Publications Limited, London).

Smith

T. R.

Development and use of an effective acoustic valve leak detection system. In Proceedings of the American Power Conference, 1993, Vol. 55, Part 1, pp. 899–904.

Renfrey

Total valve management—the key to better process plant operations. Sensor Rev., 1995, 15 (4), 25–27.

Drouillard

A history of acoustic emission. J. Acoustic Emission, 1996, 14 (1), 1–34.

10.

Germain

J. L.

Granal

Provost

Touillez

Inspection systems for valves monitoring at EDF. In Proceedings of the International Conference on Condition Monitoring and Diagnostic Engineering Management, Sheffield, 1996, pp. 411–420.

11.

Thompson

Zolkiewski

An experimental investigation into the detection of internal leakage of gases through valves by vibration analysis. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part E, Journal of Process Mechanical Engineering, 1997, 211 (E3), 195–207.

12.

Sharif

M. A.

Grosvenor

R. I.

Process plant condition monitoring and fault diagnosis. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part E, Journal of Process Mechanical Engineering, 1998, 212 (E1), 13–30.

13.

Harris

Gardner

Jones

W. E.

Operator workplace design rationale. In Proceedings of the International Conference on Advances in Instrumentation and Control, New Orleans, Louisiana, 1995, Vol. 50, Part 3, pp. 1119–1125 (Instrument Society of America, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina).

14.

Dukovic

J. M.

Joyce

D. T.

An evaluation of object-based programming with Visual Basic. In Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Computers and Communications, Phoenix, Arizona, 1995, pp. 346–351 (IEEE, New York).

15.

Kernighan

B. W.

Vanwyk

C. J.

Timing trials, or the trials of timing: Experiments with scripting and user-interface languages. J. Software Practice Experience, 1998, 28, 819–843.

16.

Lin

Daly

A flexible graphical user-interface for performance modeling. J. Software Practice Experience, 1995, 25, 193–216.

17.

Verma

Visual Basic for SCADA and PLCs. J. Ind. Comput., October 1995, 16–20.

18.

Lobley

R. A.

Evans

G. J.

Haines

N. A.

Condition monitoring of a static power inverter using Visual Basic software. In Proceedings of the Universities Power Engineering Conference, USA, 1995, pp. 690–693.

19.

Klasing

K. S.

Thomas

S. K.

CAPLIM: A Visual Basic program to calculate the capillary limit of an axially-grooved heat pipe. In Proceedings of the Intersociety Energy Conversion Engineering Conference, USA, 1997, pp. 1514–1518.

20.

Gilb

Principles of Software Engineering Management, 1988, pp. 15–40 (Addison-Wesley, Reading, Massachusetts).

21.

Pressman

R. S.

Software Engineering a Practitioner's Approach, 3rd edition, 1992, pp. 26–36 (McGraw-Hill, New York).

22.

Boar

Application Prototyping, 1984, pp. 3–15 (Wiley-Interscience, New York).

23.

Ozcan

M. B.

Siddiqui

Interchanging specifications and implementations in evolutionary prototyping. J. Software Practice Experience, 1996, 26, 1000–1023.

24.

Jain

A. K.

Ting

P. D.

Software quality via rapid prototyping. In Proceedings of the GLOBECOM, Telecommunications Conference and Exhibition, New York, 1989, pp. 642–646.

25.

Jones

C. B.

Systematic Software Development Using VDM, 2nd edition, 1990, pp. 3–25 (Prentice-Hall, Hemel Hempstead, Hertfordshire).

26.

Davies

A. M.

Operational prototyping: A new development approach. In Proceedings of IEEE Software, September 1992, New York, pp. 70–78 (IEEE, New York).

27.

Sharif

M. A.

Grosvenor

R. I.

Fault diagnosis in industrial control valves and actuators. In Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Instrumentation and Measurement Technology, Minnesota, 1998, pp. 770–778 (IEEE, New York).

28.

Sharif

M. A.

Grosvenor

R. I.

The integration of pressure and position sensors into an intelligent control valve diagnostic system. In Proceedings of the 12th European Conference on Solid-State Transducers and Ninth UK Conference on Sensors and Their Applications (Eurosensors XII), Southampton, September 1998, pp. 925–928 (Institute of Physics, Bristol).

29.

Jeffery

C. L.

Griswold

R. E.

Townsend

G. M.

Adding graphics to a high-level programming language. J. Software Practice Experience, 1995, 25, 637–655.

30.

Wright

Beginning Visual Basic 5, 1997 (Wrox Press Limited, Birmingham).

31.

Clocksin

Mellish

Programming in Prolog, 1984, pp. 13–28 (Springer-Verlag, New York).

32.

Doong

Frankl

P. G.

The ASTOOT approach to testing object-oriented programs. ACM

Trans. Software Engng Methodology, 1994, 3 (2), 101–130.