Recently there have been significant advances in developing hybrid techniques combining electromagnetic waves with ultrasound for biomedical imaging, namely photoacoustic, thermoacoustic, and acousto-optic (or ultrasound modulated optical) tomography. All three techniques take advantage of tissue contrast offered by electromagnetic (EM) waves, while achieving good spatial resolution in deeper tissue facilitated by ultrasound. In this review the principles of the three techniques are introduced. A description of existing experimental and image reconstruction techniques is provided. Some recent key developments are highlighted and current issues in each of the areas are discussed.
CheongW. F.PrahlS. A.WelchA. J.‘A review of the optical-properties of biological tissues.’IEEE J. Quantum Electronics26 (12) (1990): 2166–2185
9.
WangL. H. V.‘Ultrasound-mediated biophotonic imaging: A review of acousto-optical tomography and photo-acoustic tomography.’Disease Markers19 (2–3) (2003): 123–138
10.
XuM. H.WangL. H. V.‘Photoacoustic imaging in biomedicine.’Rev. Scientif. Instrum.77 (4) (2006): 041101
11.
TuchinV. Eds. Tissue optics: light scattering methods and instruments for medical diagnosis, edition 2 (SPIE Publications2007)
ScheppsJ. L.FosterK. R.‘The UHF and microwave dielectric-properties of normal and tumor-tissues — variation in dielectric-properties with tissue water-content.’Physics in Medicine and Biology25 (6) (1980): 1149–1159
15.
BurdetteE. C.CainF. L.SealsJ.‘In vivo probe measurement technique for determining dielectric-properties at VHF through microwave-frequencies.’IEEE Trans. on Microwave Theory and Techniques28 (4) (1980): 414–427
16.
StuchlyM. A.‘Dielectric-properties of animal-tissues in vivo at radio and microwave-frequencies — comparison between species.’Physics in Medicine and Biology27 (7) (1982): 927–936
17.
GabrielS.LauR. W.GabrielC.‘The dielectric properties of biological tissues. 2. Measurements in the frequency range 10 Hz to 20 GHz.’Physics in Medicine and Biology41 (11) (1996): 2251–2269
18.
GabrielC.GabrielS.CorthoutE.‘The dielectric properties of biological tissues. 1. Literature survey.’Physics in Medicine and Biology41 (11) (1996): 2231–2249
19.
FosterK. R.SchwanH. P.‘Dielectric-properties of tissues and biological-materials — a critical-review.’Crit. Rev. in Biomed. Engng17 (1) (1989): 25–104
20.
FosterK. R.ScheppsJ. L.‘Dielectric-properties of tumor and normal-tissues at radio through microwave-frequencies.’J. Microwave Power and Electromagnetic Energy16 (2) (1981): 107–119
XuM. H.WangL. H. V.‘Time-domain reconstruction for thermoacoustic tomography in a spherical geometry.’IEEE Trans. on Medical Imaging21 (7) (2002): 814–822
23.
KuchmentP.KunyanskyL.‘A survey in mathematics for industry mathematics of thermoacoustic tomography.’Eur. J. Appl. Mathematics19 (2008): 191–224
24.
HoelenC. G. A.‘Three-dimensional photoacoustic imaging of blood vessels in tissue.’Optics Lett.23 (8) (1998): 648–650
25.
XuM. H.KuG.WangL. H. V.‘Microwave-induced thermoacoustic tomography using multi-sector scanning.’Med. Physics28 (9) (2001): 1958–1963
26.
KuG.WangL. H. V.‘Scanning thermoacoustic tomography in biological tissue.’Med. Physics27 (5) (2000): 1195–1202
27.
De La ZerdaA.‘Carbon nanotubes as photoacoustic molecular imaging agents in living mice.’Nature Nanotechnol.3 (9) (2008): 557–562
28.
ParkS.‘Adaptive beamforming for photoacoustic imaging.’Optics Lett.33 (12) (2008): 1291–1293
29.
KolkmanR. G. M.‘Real-time in vivo photoacoustic and ultrasound imaging.’J. Biomed. Optics13 (5) (2008): 050510
30.
ZempR. J.‘Realtime photoacoustic microscopy in vivo with a 30-MHz ultrasound array transducer.’Optics Express16 (11) (2008): 7915–7928
31.
WygantI. O. ‘Photoacoustic imaging using a two-dimensional CMUT array.’ In 2005 IEEE Ultrasonics Symposium, vols 1–4
32.
GuittetC.‘In vivo high-frequency ultrasonic characterization of human dermis.’IEEE Trans. on Biomed. Engng46 (6) (1999): 740–746
33.
KarabutovA. A.SavateevaE. V.OraevskyA. A.‘Optoacoustic tomography: New modality of laser diagnostic systems.’Laser Physics13 (5) (2003): 711–723
34.
MaslovK.‘Optical-resolution photoacoustic microscopy for in vivo imaging of single capillaries.’Optics Lett.33 (9) (2008): 929–931
35.
MaslovK.WangL. H. V.‘High-resolution photoacoustic vascular imaging in vivo using a large-aperture acoustic lens.’ In Photons plus ultrasound: imaging and sensing vol. 5697, 2005, pp. 7–14.
PramanikM.‘Design and evaluation of a novel breast cancer detection system combining both thermoacoustic (TA) and photoacoustic (PA) tomography.’Med. Physics35 (6) (2008): 2218–2223
38.
WangX. D.‘Noninvasive laser-induced photoacoustic tomography for structural and functional in vivo imaging of the brain.’Nature Biotechnol.21 (7) (2003): 803–806
39.
XuY.WangL. H. V.‘Rhesus monkey brain imaging through intact skull with thermoacoustic tomography.’IEEE Trans. on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics and Frequency Control53 (3) (2006): 542–548
40.
NieL. M.‘Detection of foreign body using fast thermoacoustic tomography with a multielement linear transducer array.’Appl. Physics Lett.90 (17) (2007): 174109
41.
KrugerR. A.‘Thermoacoustic computed tomography using a conventional linear transducer array.’Med. Physics30 (5) (2003): 856–860
42.
NiederhauserJ. J.‘Combined ultrasound and optoacoustic system for real-time high-contrast vascular imaging in vivo.’IEEE Trans. on Medical Imaging24 (4) (2005): 436–440
43.
AndreevV. G.Image reconstruction in 3D optoacoustic tomography system with hemispherical transducer array (SPIE-International Society of Optical Engineering2002)
44.
KostliK. P.BeardP. C.‘Two-dimensional photoacoustic imaging by use of Fourier-transform image reconstruction and a detector with an anisotropic response.’Appl. Optics42 (10) (2003): 1899–1908
45.
ZhangE. Z.‘In vivo high-resolution 3D photoacoustic imaging of superficial vascular anatomy.’Physics in Medicine and Biology54 (4) (2009): 1035–1046
KuG.WangL. H. V.‘Deeply penetrating photoacoustic tomography in biological tissues enhanced with an optical contrast agent.’Optics Lett.30 (5) (2005): 507–509
48.
ZhangH. F.‘Functional photoacoustic microscopy for high-resolution and noninvasive in vivo imaging.’Nature Biotechnol.24 (7) (2006): 848–851
49.
AnastasioM. A.‘Application of inverse source concepts to photoacoustic tomography.’Inverse Problems23 (6) (2007): S21-S35.
50.
XuY.FengD. Z.WangL. H. V.‘Exact frequency-domain reconstruction for thermoacoustic tomography — I: Planar geometry.’IEEE Trans. on Med. Imaging21 (7) (2002): 823–828
51.
XuY.XuM. H.WangL. H. V.‘Exact frequency-domain reconstruction for thermoacoustic tomography — II: Cylindrical geometry.’IEEE Trans. on Med. Imaging21 (7) (2002): 829–833
52.
KostliK. P.‘Temporal backward projection of optoacoustic pressure transients using Fourier transform methods.’Physics in Medicine and Biology46 (7) (2001): 1863–1872
53.
XuY.WangL. H. V.‘Time reversal and its application to tomography with diffracting sources.’Phy. Rev. Lett.92 (3) (2004): 033902
54.
BurgholzerP.‘Exact and approximative imaging methods for photoacoustic tomography using an arbitrary detection surface.’Phy. Rev. E75 (4) (2007): 046706, Part 2.
55.
HristovaY.KuchmentP.NguyenL.‘Reconstruction and time reversal in thermoacoustic tomography in acoustically homogeneous and inhomogeneous media.’Inverse Problems24 (5) (2008): 055006
KunyanskyL. A.‘Thermoacoustic tomography with detectors on an open curve: An efficient reconstruction algorithm.’Inverse Problems24 (5) (2008): 055021
58.
PaltaufG.‘Experimental evaluation of reconstruction algorithms for limited view photoacoustic tomography with line detectors.’Inverse Problems23 (6) (2007): S81-S94.
59.
XuY.‘Reconstructions in limited-view thermoacoustic tomography.’Med. Physics31 (4) (2004): 724–733
60.
CoxB. T.ArridgeS. R.BeardP. C.‘Photoacoustic tomography with a limited-aperture planar sensor and a reverberant cavity.’Inverse Problems23 (6) (2007): S95-S112.
61.
PanX. C.ZouY.AnastasioM. A.‘Data redundancy and reduced-scan reconstruction in reflectivity tomography.’IEEE Trans. on Image Processing12 (7) (2003): 784–795
62.
XuY.WangL. H. V.‘Effects of acoustic heterogeneity in breast thermoacoustic tomography.’ In Biomedical optoacoustics IV vol. 4960, 2003, pp. 30–39.
63.
JinX.WangL. V.‘Correction of the effects of acoustic heterogeneity on thermoacoustic tomography using transmission ultrasound tomography.’ In Photons plus ultrasound: imaging and sensing vol. 6086, 2006, article 60860W, pp. W860–W860.
64.
ZhangJ.‘Simultaneous reconstruction of speed-of-sound and optical absorption properties in photoacoustic tomography via a time-domain iterative algorithm.’ In Photons plus ultrasound: imaging and sensing, The Ninth Conference on Biomedical thermoacoustics, optoacoustics, and acoustic-optics vol. 6856, 2008, article 68561F, pp. F8561–F8561.
65.
LiC. H.‘Image distortion in thermoacoustic tomography caused by microwave diffraction.’Phy. Rev. E77 (3) (2008): 031923, Part 1.
66.
JinX.LiC. H.WangL. V.‘Effects of acoustic heterogeneities on transcranial brain imaging with microwave-induced thermoacoustic tomography.’Med. Physics35 (7) (2008): 3205–3214
67.
YuanZ.JiangH. B.‘Quantitative photoacoustic tomography: Recovery of optical absorption coefficient maps of heterogeneous media.’Appl. Physics Lett.88 (23) (2006): 231101
68.
YuanZ.WangQ.JiangH. B.‘Reconstruction of optical absorption coefficient maps of heterogeneous media by photoacoustic tomography coupled with diffusion equation based regularized Newton method.’Optics Express15 (26) (2007): 18076–18081
69.
CoxB. T.‘Quantitative photoacoustic imaging: Fitting a model of light transport to the initial pressure distribution.’ In 6th Conference on Biomedical thermoacoustics, optoacoustics, and acousto-optics, San Jose, California, 2005.
70.
LauferJ.‘Quantitative spatially resolved measurement of tissue chromophore concentrations using photoacoustic spectroscopy: Application to the measurement of blood oxygenation and haemoglobin concentration.’Physics in Medicine and Biology52 (1) (2007): 141–168
71.
HaischC.‘Quantitative analysis in medicine using photoacoustic tomography.’Analyt. Bioanalyt. Chemistry393 (2) (2009): 473–479
72.
La RiviereP. J.ZhangJ.AnastasioM. A.‘Image reconstruction in optoacoustic tomography for dispersive acoustic media.’Optics Lett.31 (6) (2006): 781–783
73.
BurgholzerP.‘Compensation of acoustic attenuation for high resolution photoacoustic imaging with line detectors.’ In Photons plus ultrasound: imaging and sensing vol. 6437, 2007, article 643724, pp. 43724–43724.
74.
WilleminkR. G. H.‘Imaging of acoustic attenuation and speed of sound maps using photoacoustic measurements.’ In Medical imaging 2008: ultrasonic imaging and signal processing vol. 6920, 2008, article 692013, pp. 92013–92013.
WangX. D.‘Three-dimensional laser-induced photoacoustic tomography of mouse brain with the skin and skull intact.’Optics Lett.28 (19) (2003): 1739–1741
78.
KuG.‘Imaging of tumor angiogenesis in rat brains in vivo by photoacoustic tomography.’Appl. Optics44 (5) (2005): 770–775
79.
SongK. H.StoicaG.WangL. H. V.‘In vivo three-dimensional photoacoustic tomography of a whole mouse head.’Optics Lett.31 (16) (2006): 2453–2455
80.
WangX. D.‘Noninvasive imaging of hemoglobin concentration and oxygenation in the rat brain using high-resolution photoacoustic tomography.’J. Biomed. Optics11 (2) (2006): 024015
81.
ZhangQ.‘Imaging of seizure-onset zone with non-invasive photoacoustic tomography in a rat model of focal seizures.’Epilepsia47 (2006): 313–313
82.
YangS.‘Functional imaging of cerebrovascular activities in small animals using high-resolution photoacoustic tomography.’Med. Physics34 (8) (2007): 3294–3301
83.
YangS. H.‘Noninvasive monitoring of traumatic brain injury and post-traumatic rehabilitation with laser-induced photoacoustic imaging.’Appl. Physics Lett.90 (24) (2007).
84.
YangX. M.WangL. V.‘Photoacoustic tomography of a rat cerebral cortex with a ring-based ultrasonic virtual point detector.’J. Biomed. Optics12 (6) (2007): 060507
85.
ZhangQ. Z.‘Non-invasive imaging of epileptic seizures in vivo using photoacoustic tomography.’Physics in Medicine and Biology53 (7) (2008): 1921–1931
86.
OraevskyA. A.‘Laser opto-acoustic imaging of the breast: detection of cancer angiogenesis.’ In Proceedings of Optical tomography and spectroscopy of tissue III, vol. 3597, 1999, pp. 352–363.
87.
KuG.‘Thermoacoustic and photoacoustic tomography of thick biological tissues toward breast imaging.’Technol. Cancer Res. and Treatment4 (5) (2005): 559–565
88.
NieL. M.‘Microwave-induced thermoacoustic scanning CT for high-contrast and noninvasive breast cancer imaging.’Med. Physics35 (9) (2008): 4026–4032
89.
ManoharS.‘Initial results of in vivo non-invasive cancer imaging in the human breast using near-infrared photoacoustics.’Optics Express15 (19) (2007): 12277–12285
90.
ZhangH. F.‘Imaging of hemoglobin oxygen saturation variations in single vessels in vivo using photoacoustic microscopy.’Appl. Physics Lett.90 (5) (2007): 053901
91.
SiphantoR. I.‘Serial noninvasive photoacoustic imaging of neovascularization in tumor angiogenesis.’Optics Express13 (1) (2005): 89–95
XingJ.‘Imaging of high-intensity focused ultrasound-induced lesions in soft biological tissue using thermoacoustic tomography.’Med. Physics32 (1) (2005): 5–11
94.
WangX. D.‘Imaging of joints with laser-based photoacoustic tomography: An animal study.’Med. Physics33 (8) (2006): 2691–2697
95.
ChamberlandD. L.WangX. D.RoesslerB. J.‘Photoacoustic tomography of carrageenan-induced arthritis in a rat model.’J. Biomed. Optics13 (1) (2008): 011005
96.
ChamberlandD. L.‘Photoacoustic tomography of joints aided by an Etanercept-conjugated gold nanoparticle contrast agent — an ex vivo preliminary rat study.’Nanotechnology19 (9) (2008): 095101
97.
SongK. H.WangL. V.‘Noninvasive photoacoustic imaging of the thoracic cavity and the kidney in small and large animals.’Med. Physics35 (10) (2008): 4524–4529
98.
SethuramanS.‘Remote temperature estimation in intravascular photoacoustic imaging.’Ultrasound in Medicine and Biology34 (2) (2008): 299–308
99.
LarinK. V.LarinaI. V.EsenalievR. O.‘Monitoring of tissue coagulation during thermotherapy using optoacoustic technique.’J. Physics D — Appl. Physics38 (15) (2005): 2645–2653
100.
OhJ. T.‘Three-dimensional imaging of skin melanoma in vivo by dual-wavelength photoacoustic microscopy.’J. Biomed. Optics11 (3) (2006): 034032
101.
YangX. M.‘Photoacoustic tomography of a rat cerebral cortex in vivo with Au nanocages as an optical contrast agent.’Nano Lett.7 (12) (2007): 3798–3802
102.
LiaoC. K.‘Nanorod-based flow estimation using a high-frame-rate photoacoustic imaging system.’J. Biomed. Optics12 (6) (2007).
103.
LiP. C.‘In vivo photoacoustic molecular imaging with simultaneous multiple selective targeting using antibody-conjugated gold nanorods.’Optics Express16 (23) (2008): 18605–18615
104.
WeiC.‘Photoacoustic flow measurements based on wash-in analysis of gold nanorods.’IEEE Trans. on Ultrasonics Ferroelectrics and Frequency Control54 (6) (2007): 1131–1141
105.
LiP. C.‘Photoacoustic imaging of multiple targets using gold nanorods.’IEEE Trans. on Ultrasonics Ferroelectrics and Frequency Control54 (8) (2007): 1642–1647
106.
KimK.‘Photoacoustic imaging of early inflammatory response using gold nanorods.’Appl. Physics Lett.90 (22) (2007): 223901
107.
EghtedariM.‘High sensitivity of in vivo detection of gold nanorods using a laser optoacoustic imaging system.’Nano Lett.7 (7) (2007): 1914–1918
108.
AgarwalA.‘Targeted gold nanorod contrast agent for prostate cancer detection by photoacoustic imaging.’J. Appl. Physics102 (6) (2007): 064701
109.
WangY. W.‘Photoacoustic tomography of a nanoshell contrast agent in the in vivo rat brain.’Nano Lett.4 (9) (2004): 1689–1692
110.
SharmaP.‘Gold-speckled multimodal nanoparticles for noninvasive bioimaging.’Chemistry of Materials20 (19) (2008): 6087–6094
111.
LooC.‘Immunotargeted nanoshells for integrated cancer imaging and therapy.’Nano Lett.5 (4) (2005): 709–711
112.
WangL. V.‘Prospects of photoacoustic tomography.’Med. Physics35 (12) (2008): 5758–5767
113.
NathC. V. R.RamanN. S. N.‘The diffraction of light by high frequency sound waves: Part 1.’Proc. Indian Acad. Sci.2 (1935): 406–413
114.
WangL. V.‘Mechanisms of ultrasonic modulation of multiply scattered coherent light: An analytic model.’Phys. Rev. Lett.87 (4) (2001): 043903
115.
KempeM.‘Acousto-optic tomography with multiply scattered light.’J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, Optics and Image Sci.14 (5) (1997): 1151–1158
116.
LeutzW.MaretG.‘Ultrasonic modulation of multiply scattered-light.’Physica B204 (1–4) (1995): 14–19
117.
MahanG. D.‘Ultrasonic tagging of light: Theory.’Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. United States of America95 (24) (1998): 14015–14019
118.
WangL. H.JacquesS. L.ZhaoX. M.‘Continuous-wave ultrasonic modulation of scattered laser-light to image objects in turbid media.’Optics Lett.20 (6) (1995): 629–631
119.
WangL. H. V.KuG.‘Frequency-swept ultrasound-modulated optical tomography of scattering media.’Optics Lett.23 (12) (1998): 975–977
120.
LiJ.‘Transmission- and side-detection configurations in ultrasound-modulated optical tomography of thick biological tissues.’Appl. Optics42 (19) (2003): 4088–4094
SuiL.‘Imaging in diffuse media with pulsed-ultrasound-modulated light and the photorefractive effect.’Appl. Optics44 (19) (2005): 4041–4048
123.
BossyE.‘Fusion of conventional ultrasound imaging and acousto-optic sensing by use of a standard pulsed-ultrasound scanner.’Optics Lett.30 (7) (2005): 744–746
124.
LevA.KotlerZ.SfezB. G.‘Ultrasound tagged light imaging in turbid media in a reflectance geometry.’Optics Lett.25 (6) (2000): 378–380
125.
WangL. H.ZhaoX. M.‘Ultrasound-modulated optical tomography of absorbing objects buried in dense tissue-simulating turbid media.’Appl. Optics36 (28) (1997): 7277–7282
126.
LevequeS.‘Ultrasonic tagging of photon paths in scattering media: Parallel speckle modulation processing.’Optics Lett.24 (3) (1999): 181–183
127.
Leveque-FortS.‘Three-dimensional acousto-optic imaging in biological tissues with parallel signal processing.’Appl. Optics40 (7) (2001): 1029–1036
128.
GrossM.GoyP.Al-KoussaM.‘Shot-noise detection of ultrasound-tagged photons in ultrasound-modulated optical imaging.’Optics Lett.28 (24) (2003): 2482–2484
129.
LiJ.KuG.WangL. H. V.‘Ultrasound-modulated optical tomography of biological tissue by use of contrast of laser speckles.’Appl. Optics41 (28) (2002): 6030–6035
130.
WangL. H. V.‘Mechanisms of ultrasonic modulation of multiply scattered coherent light: An analytic model.’Phys. Rev. Lett.8704 (4) (2001): 043903
131.
SakadzicS.WangL. V.‘Modulation of multiply scattered coherent light by ultrasonic pulses: An analytical model.’Phys. Rev. E72 (3) (2005): 036620, Part 2.
132.
SakadzicS.WangL. H. V.‘Correlation transfer and diffusion of ultrasound-modulated multiply scattered light.’Phy. Rev. Lett.96 (16) (2006): 163902
133.
SakadzicS.WangL. V.‘Correlation transfer equation for multiply scattered light modulated by an ultrasonic pulse.’J. Opt. Soc. Am. A — Optics Image Sci. Vision24 (9) (2007): 2797–2806
134.
Rui LiD. S. E.DunsbyC. W.EckersleyR. J.TangMengxing‘A study on optical modulation signal and tissue displacement in ultrasound modulated optical tomography.’ In BIOS 2009, San Jose, California, 2009.
135.
WangL. H. V.‘Mechanisms of ultrasonic modulation of multiply scattered coherent light: A Monte Carlo model.’Optics Lett.26 (15) (2001): 1191–1193
136.
YaoG.WangL. H. V.‘Theoretical and experimental studies of ultrasound-modulated optical tomography in biological tissue.’Appl. Optics39 (4) (2000): 659–664
137.
YaoG.WangL. H. V.‘Signal dependence and noise source in ultrasound-modulated optical tomography.’Appl. Optics43 (6) (2004): 1320–1326
138.
SakadzicS.WangL. H. V.‘High-resolution ultrasound-modulated optical tomography in biological tissues.’Optics Lett.29 (23) (2004): 2770–2772
139.
MurrayT. W.‘Detection of ultrasound-modulated photons in diffuse media using the photorefractive effect.’Optics Lett.29 (21) (2004): 2509–2511
140.
RamazF.‘Photorefractive detection of tagged photons in ultrasound modulated optical tomography of thick biological tissues.’Optics Express12 (22) (2004): 5469–5474
141.
LiY. Z.‘Pulsed ultrasound-modulated optical tomography using spectral-hole burning as a narrowband spectral filter.’Appl. Physics Lett.93 (1) (2008): 011111
142.
KimC.ZempR. J.WangL. H. V.‘Intense acoustic bursts as a signal-enhancement mechanism in ultrasound-modulated optical tomography.’Optics Lett.31 (16) (2006): 2423–2425
