Compliant layer bearings in artificial joints. Part 2: Simulator and fatigue testing to assess the durability of the interface between an elastomeric layer and a rigid substrate

Abstract

Artificial joints have been much improved since their introduction but they still have a limited lifetime. In an attempt to increase their life by improving the lubrication acting within these prostheses, compliant layered polyurethane (PU) joints have been devised. These joints mimic the natural synovial joint more closely by promoting fluid film lubrication. In this study, tests were performed on compliant layer joints to determine their ability to function under a range of conditions. Both static and dynamic compression tests were undertaken on compliant artificial hip joints of two different radial clearances. Friction tests were also performed before and after static loading. In addition to this, knee wear tests were conducted to determine the suitability of a compliant layer in these applications. In the knee tests, variations in experimental testing conditions were investigated using both active and passive rotation and severe malalignment of the tibial inserts. The static compression tests together with the friction studies suggest that a small radial clearance is likely to result in ‘grabbing’ contact between the head and cup. The larger radial clearance (0.33 μm) did not exhibit these problems. The importance of the design of the compliant layer joints was highlighted with delamination occurring on the lateral bearings during the knee wear studies. The bearings with a layer 2 mm thick performed better than the bearings with a layer 3 mm thick. Tests conducted on flat PU bearings resulted in no delamination; therefore, it was concluded that the layer separation was caused by design issues rather than by material issues. It was found that, with careful material choice, consideration of design, and effective manufacturing techniques, the compliant layer joint functioned well and demonstrated durability of the union between the hard and soft layers. These results give encouragement for the suitability of these joints for clinical use.

Keywords

compliant layer hip and knee joints tribology endurance testing

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Berry

D. J.

Harmsen

W. S.

Cabanela

M. E.

Morrey

B. F.

‘Twenty-five-year survivorship of two thousand consecutive primary Charnley total hip replacements — factors affecting survivorship of acetabular and femoral components.’

J. Bone Jt Surg. Am. 84 (2) (2002): 171–177

McMinn

Treacy

Lin

Pynsent

‘Metal on metal surface replacement of the hip — experience of the McMinn prosthesis.’

Clin. Orthop. Related Res. 329 (1996) S89-S98.

Nizard

R. S.

Sedel

Christel

Muenier

Soudry

Witvoet

‘Ten year survivorship of cemented ceramic—ceramic total hip prosthesis.’

Clin. Orthop. Related Res. 282 (1992): 53–63

‘The Swedish Total Hip Replacement Register.’ Annual Report 2003, The Swedish National Hip Arthroplasty Register, 2004, Gothenburg.

Unsworth

Roberts

B. J.

Thompson

‘The application of soft layer lubrication to hip prostheses.’

J. Bone Jt Surg Br. 63 (1981): 297

Khan

Smith

Jones

Finch

D. S.

Cameron

R. E.

‘Analysis and evaluation of a biomedical polycarbonate urethane tested in an in vitro study and an ovine arthroplasty model. Part I: materials selection and evaluation.’

Biomaterials 26 (6) (2005): 621–631

Khan

Smith

Jones

Finch

D. S.

Cameron

R. E.

‘Analysis and evaluation of a biomedical polycarbonate urethane tested in an in vitro study and an ovine arthroplasty model. Part II: in vivo investigation.’

Biomaterials 26 (6) (2005): 633–643

Unsworth

‘The lubrication of human joints.’ In Mechanics of human joints: physiology, pathophysiology, and treatment (Eds Wright

Radin

E. L.

), 1993, pp. 137–162 (Marcel Dekker, New York).

Fein

R. S.

‘Are synovial joints squeeze-film lubricated?’

Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs 181 (3J) (1966–67): 125–128

10.

Higginson

G. R.

‘Elastohydrodynamic lubrication in human hip joints.’

Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs 191 (1977): 217–223

11.

Medley

J. B.

Dowson

Wright

‘Transient elastohydrodynamic lubrication models for the human ankle joint.’

Engng Medicine 13 (3) (1984): 137–151

12.

Dowson

‘Bio-tribology of natural and replacement synovial joints.’ In Biomechanics of diarthrodal joints (Eds Mow

V. C.

Ratcliffe

Woo

S. L. Y.

), 1990, pp. 305–345 (Springer-Verlag, New York).

13.

Scholes

S. C.

Smith

S. L.

Ash

H. E.

Unsworth

‘The lubrication and friction of conventional UHMWPE, novel compliant layer and hard bearing surfaces for use in total hip prostheses.’ In Friction, lubrication and wear of artificial joints (Ed. Hutchings

), 2002, pp. 59–74 (Professional Engineering Publishing London).

14.

McClure

Jin

Z. M.

Fisher

Tighe

B. J.

‘Determination of lubricating film thickness for permeable hydrogel and non-permeable polyurethane layers bonded to a rigid substrate with particular reference to cushion form hip joint replacements.’

Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part H: J. Engineering in Medicine 210 (2) (1996): 89–93

15.

Stewart

Jin

Z. M.

Fisher

‘Friction of composite cushion bearings for total knee joint replacements under adverse lubrication conditions.’

Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part H: J. Engineering in Medicine 211 (6) (1997): 451–465

16.

Auger

D. D.

Dowson

Fisher

Jin

Z. M.

‘Friction and lubrication in cushion form bearings for artificial hip joints.’

Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part H: J. Engineering in Medicine 207 (1993): 25–33

17.

Auger

D. D.

Dowson

Fisher

‘Cushion form bearings for total knee joint replacement. Part 1: Design, friction and lubrication.’

Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part H: J. Engineering in Medicine 209 (1995): 73–81

18.

Strozzi

Unsworth

‘Axisymmetric finite element analysis of hip replacement with an elastomeric layer: The effect of layer thickness.’

Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part H: J. Engineering in Medicine 208 (3) (1994): 139–149

19.

Unsworth

Strozzi

‘Axisymmetric finite element analysis of hip replacements possessing an elastomeric layer: The effects of clearance and Poisson's ratio.’

Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part H: J. Engineering in Medicine 209 (1) (1995): 59–64

20.

21.

Burgess

I. C.

Jones

Scholes

S. C.

Unsworth

‘Compliant layer bearings in artificial joints. Part 1: Evaluation of the interface between an elastomeric layer and a rigid subsrate.’

Proc. IMechE, Part H: J. Engineering in Medicine 222 (6) (2008): 853–864

22.

Ringer

‘Concerning the influence exerted by each of the constituents of the ventricle.’

J. Physiology 4 (1884): 29–42

23.

Unsworth

Pearcy

M. J.

White

E. F. T.

White

‘Frictional properties of artificial hip joints.’

Engng in Medicine 17 (3) (1988): 101–104

24.

Hall

R. M.

Unsworth

Wroblewski

B. M.

Burgess

I. C.

‘Frictional characterization of explanted Charnley hip prostheses.’

Wear 175 (1–2) (1994): 159–166

25.

Unsworth

Hall

R. M.

Burgess

I. C.

Wroblewski

B. M.

Streicher

R. M.

Semlitsch

‘Frictional resistance of new and explanted artificial hip joints.’

Wear 190 (2) (1995): 226–231

26.

English

T. A.

Kilvington

‘In vivo records of hip loads using a femoral implant with telemetric output (a preliminary report).’

J. Biomed. Engng 1 (2) (1979): 111–115

27.

Unsworth

‘Friction and lubrication of artificial hip joints.’

Ann. Rheumatic Dis. 35 (1976): 539–541

28.

Unsworth

‘Effects of lubrication in hip joint prostheses.’

Physics Medicine Biology 23 (2) (1978): 253–268

29.

Ash

H. E.

Burgess

I. C.

Unsworth

‘Long-term results for Kinemax and Kinematic knee bearings on a six-station knee wear simulator.’

Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part H: J. Engineering in Medicine 214 (5) (2000): 437–447

30.

Seireg

Arvikar

R. J.

‘The prediction of muscular load sharing and joint forces in the lower extremities during walking.’

J. Biomechanics 8 (1985): 89–102

31.

Lafortune

M. A.

Cavanagh

P. R.

Sommer

H. J.

Kalenak

‘Three dimensional kinematics of the human knee during walking.’

J. Biomechanics 25 (4) (1992): 347–357

32.

Unsworth

Ash

Smith

S. L.

‘A tribology study of UHMWPE acetabular cups and polyurethane compliant layer acetabular cups.’

J. Biomed. Mater. Res. 53 (6) (2000): 710–716

33.

Scholes

S. C.

Burgess

I. C.

Marsden

H. R.

Unsworth

Jones

Smith

‘Compliant layer acetabular cups: Friction testing of a range of materials and designs for a new generation of prosthesis that mimics the natural joint.’

Proc. IMechE, Part H: J. Engineering in Medicine 220 (5) (2006): 583–596

34.

Ash

H. E.

Scholes

S. C.

Unsworth

Jones

‘The effect of bone cement particles on the friction of polyethylene and polyurethane knee bearings.’

Physics Medicine Biology 49 (2004): 3413–3425