This paper reviews the literature regarding the use of applying conventional low-frequency vibration analysis as a possible diagnostic tool in the orthopaedic field. Although a considerable number of investigations have been carried out, including the effects of soft tissue, the technique has not been widely accepted clinically. The application of ultrasound appears to be a more realistic alternative.
LippmannR. K.The use of auscultatory percussion for the examination of fractures. J. Bone Jt Surg., 1932, 14, 118.
2.
Van der PerreG.InMonitoring of Fracture Healing by Vibration Analysis and Other Mechanical Methods (Eds Van der PerreG.Borgwardt-ChristensenA.), Proceedings of the Specialists Consensus Meeting, Louvain, 1985 (Amerfoort, Louvain, Belgium).
3.
Van der PerreG.LowittG.ChristensenA. (Eds) In-vivo assessment of bone quality by vibration and wave propagation techniques: Part 2. In Proceedings of the COMAC-BME Meeting, Durham, 11–13 April 1991.
4.
BurturlaF.PopeM.A finite element wave propagation model of pathogenic and healing bone. In Proceedings of the First Annual New England Conference onBioengineering, 1973, pp. 36 (Pergamon Press, Oxford).
5.
JuristJ. M.In-vivo determination of the elastic response of bone. I. Method of ulnar resonant frequency determination. Phys. Med. Biol., 1970, 15, 417.
6.
VayoH. N.Wave propagation in bone media. Bull. Math. Biophys., 1971, 33, 463.
7.
PelkerR. R.SahaS.A theoretical investigation of wave propagation in long bones. In Advances in Bioengineering (Eds BellA. C.NeremR. M.), 1975, pp. 98 (American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York).
8.
LewisJ. L.A dynamic model of a healing fractured lone bone. J. Biomechanics, 1975, 8, 17.
9.
SonstegardD. A.MatthewsL. S.Sonic diagnosis of bone fracture healing—a preliminary study. J. Biomechanics, 1976, 9, 689.
10.
PughJ. W.Studies of the impact response of human limbs. In Proceedings of the 28th Annual Conference onEngineering in Medicine and Biology, New Orleans, September 1975, pp. 171.
11.
StreitmanA.MillerA.PughJ.The response of the lower extremity to impact forces. Bull. Hosp. Jt Dis., 1979, 39, 120.
12.
SekigushiT.HirayamaT.Assessment of fracture healing by vibration. Acta Orthop. Scand., 1979, 50, 391.
13.
PetersA.Monitoring of the rate of fracture healing by acoustic percussion. Presented at the Second International Symposium onInternal Fixation of Fractures, Lyon, France, 1982.
14.
WongF. Y.PalS.SahaS.The assessment of in-vivo bone condition in humans by impact response measurement. J. Biomechanics, 1983, 16, 849.
15.
NokesL. D. M.System modelling and analysis of human structures. PhD thesis, University of Wales Institute of Science and Technology, Cardiff, 1983.
16.
PelkerR. R.SahaS.Wave propagation across a bony discontinuity simulating a healing fracture. J. Biomechanics, 1985, 18, 745.
17.
DoemlandH. H.JacobsR. R.SpenceJ.RobertsF. G.Assessment of fracture healing by spectral analysis. J. Med. Engng Tech., 1986, 10, 180–187.
18.
CornelisenM.CornelisenP.Van der PerreG.ChristensenA. B.AmmitzbollF.DyrbyeC.Assessment of tibial stiffness by vibration testing in situ, the sensitivity of different modes and interpretation of vibration measurements. J. Biomechanics, 1987, 20, 333–342.
19.
PocockI. R.RichardsJ.BrandonJ. H.Choosing a signal for vibration analysis of fracture healing. In Conference Proceedings onInterfaces in Medicine and Mechanics, University College Swansea, 1988.
20.
ThomsenJ. J.Modelling human tibia structural vibrations. J. Biomechanics, 1990, 23, 215–228.
21.
CunninghamJ. L.KenwrightJ.KershawC. J.Biomechanical measurement of fracture healing. J. Med. Engng Tech., 1990, 14 (3), 92–101.
22.
HobathoM. C.DarmanaR.PastorP.BarrauJ. J.LarozeS.MorucciJ. P.Development of three dimensional finite element modelling of human tibia using experimental modal analysis. J. Biomechanics, 1991, 24, 371–383.
23.
BenirschkeS. K.MirelsH.JonesD.TensorA. F.The use of resonant frequency measurements for the non-invasive assessment of mechanical stiffness of the healing tibia. J. Orthop. Trauma, 1993, 7, 64–71.
24.
TowerS. S.BealsR. K.DuweliusP. J.Resonant frequency analysis of the tibia as a measure of fracture healing. J. Orthop. Trauma, 1993, 7, 552–557.
25.
FlintT.NokesL.MahesonM.WoodcockJ. P.Using the Doppler effect to measure the vibration of human bones, an in-vitro study. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part H, Journal of Engineering in Medicine, 1994, 208, 127–129.
26.
FlintA.NokesL. D.M.MahesonM.Determination of fracture healing by transverse vibration measurement—a preliminary report. J. Engng Technol., 1994, 18, 205–207.
27.
RostedtM.BromanH.HansonT.Resonant frequency of a pin accelerometer system mounted in bone. J. Biomechanics, 1995, 28, 625–629.
28.
NakatsuchiY.TsuchikaneA.NomuraA.The vibrational mode of the tibia and assessment of bone union in experimental fracture healing using the impulse response method. Med. Engng Phys., 1996, 18, 575–583.
29.
ChengS.TimonenJ.SuominenH.Elastic wave propagation in bone in vivo: methodology. J. Biomechanics, 1995, 28, 471–478.
SelleW.JuristJ. M.Acoustical detection of senile osteoporosis. Proc. Soc. Expl Biol. Medicine, 1966, 121, 150.
32.
DenckerH.MobergE.Early diagnosis of interposition in fractures with the aid of a vibrator. Acta Orthop. Scand., 1967, 38, 396.
33.
KernbergerH.A method of acoustic registration of fracture healing. Acta Orthop. Scand., 1967, 38, 393.
34.
NoyesD. H.ClarkJ. W.WatsonC. E.The use of mechanical impedance to analyse the structure of teeth. Med. Biol. Engng, 1968, 6, 487.
35.
HodgsonV. R.NakamuraG. S.Mechanical impedance and impact response of the human cadaver zygoma. J. Biomechanics, 1968, 1, 73.
36.
GurdjianE. S.HodgsonV. R.ThomasL. M.Studies on mechanical impedance of the human skull. A preliminary report. J. Biomechanics, 1970, 3, 239.
37.
BrashJ. I.SkoreckiJ.Determination of the modulus of elasticity of bone by a vibration method. Med. Biol. Engng, 1970, 8, 389.
38.
CampbellJ. N.JuristJ. M.Mechanical impedance of the femur: A preliminary report. J. Biomechanics, 1971, 4, 319.
39.
ThompsonG. A.In-vivo determination of bone properties from mechanical impedance measurements. In Aerospace Medical Association Annual Science Meeting (Abstr.), Las Vegas, May 1973.
40.
DohertyW. P.BovillE. G.WilsonE. L.Evaluation of the use of resonant frequencies to characterise physical properties of human long bones. J. Biomechanics, 1974, 7, 559.
41.
MarkeyE. L.JuristJ. M.Tibial resonant frequency measurements as an index of the strength of fracture union. Wis. Med. J., 1976, 73, 62.
42.
ThompsonG. A.YoungD. R.OrneD.In-vivo determinations of mechanical properties of the human ulna by means of mechanical impedance tests: Experimental result and improved mathematical models. Med. Biol. Engng, 1976, 14, 253.
43.
ChristensenA. B.Resonance of human tibia, method, reproducibility and effect of transection. Acta Orthop. Scand., 1982, 53, 867.
44.
NokesL. D. M.Natural frequency of fracture fragments in the assessment of tibial fracture healing. J. Biomed. Engng, 1984, 6, 227.
45.
CollierR. J.DonarskiG.Non-invasive method of measuring resonant frequencies of a human tibia in-vivo Part 1. J. Biomed. Engng, 1987, 9, 321–328.
46.
NikiforidisG.BezerianosA.DimarogonasA.SutherlandC.Monitoring of fracture healing by axial and vibration analysis. J. Biomechanics, 1990, 23, 323–330.
47.
LiP. L.JonesM. B.GregP. J.Vibrational analysis in the detection of total hip prosthetic loosening. Med. Engng Phys., 1996, 18, 596–600.
48.
SahaS.LakesR. S.A non-invasive technique for detecting stress waves in bone using the piezoelectric effect. IEEE Trans. Biomed. Engng, 1977, BME 24, 508.
49.
CollierR. J.NadavO.ThomasT. G.The mechanical resonances of a human tibia. I. In-vitro. J. Biomechanics, 1982, 15, 545.
50.
CornelisenP.Assessment of tibial stiffness by vibration testing in situ. II. Influence of soft tissues, joints and fibula. J. Biomechanics, 1986, 19, 551.
51.
CornelisenM.Van der PerreG.MartemsM.MullierJ. C.Vibration measurements correlated with mechanical stability characteristics. A model with appliance to fracture healing assessment. In Biomaterials and Biomechanics (Eds DucheyneP.Van der PerreG.AubertA. E.), 1983, pp. 215 (Elsevier/North Holland, Amsterdam).
52.
EvansE. J.Vibratory properties of resonances of the isolated human ulna. Department of Anatomy, University College of Cardiff, Cardiff, Wales, 1983.
53.
NokesL.Mintowt-CzyzW. J.Direct and indirect determination of tibial natural frequency—a comparison of frequency domain analysis and Fast Fourier Transformation. J. Biomed. Engng, 1984, 6, 45.
54.
LevineR. S.KingA. I.TennysonS. A.A simplified method of attaching accelerometer packages to bone. J. Biomechanics, 1979, 12, 44.
55.
CollierR. J.DonarskiG.Non-invasive method of measuring resonant frequency of a human tibia in-vivo. Part 2. J. Biol. Engng, 1987, 9, 329–331.
56.
PelkerR. R.SahaS.Stress wave propagation in bone. J. Biomechanics, 1983, 16, 481.
57.
JuristJ. M.KianianK.Three models of the vibrating ulna. J. Biomechanics, 1973, 6, 331.
58.
LewisJ. L.TarrR. R.Fracture healing assessment by impact response: Clinical results. J. Bone Jt Surg., 1975, 57A, 576.
59.
SahaS.LakesR. S.The effect of soft tissue on wave propagation and vibration tests for determining the in-vivo properties of bone. J. Biomechanics, 1977, 10, 393.
60.
ZiegertJ. C.LewisJ. L.The effect of soft tissue on measurements of vibrational bone motion by skin-mounted accelerometers. Trans. ASME, J. Biomech. Engng (US), 1979, 1, 218.
61.
NokesL. D.M.FaircloughJ. A.Vibration analysis of human tibia: The effect of soft tissue on the output from skin mounted accelerometers. J. Biomed. Engng, 1984, 6, 223.
62.
OrneD.The 'in-vivo' driving point impedance of the human ulna—a viscoelastic beam model. J. Biomechanics, 1974, 7, 249.
63.
OrneD.MandleeJ.Influence of musculature on the mechanical impedance of the human ulna, an in-vivo simulated study. J. Biomechanics, 1975, 8, 143.
64.
OrneD.YoungD. A.The effects of variable mass and geometry on the resonant frequencies of intact long bones. J. Biomechanics, 1976, 9, 763.
65.
SpiegleP. V.JuristJ. M.Prediction of ulna resonant frequency. J. Biomechanics, 1975, 8, 213.
66.
WongA. T. C.GoldsmithW.SaebmanJ. L.Flexural wave propagation in discontinuous models and 'in-vivo' tibia. J. Biomechanics, 1976, 9, 689.
67.
KhalilT. B.VianoD. C.TaberL. A.Vibrational characteristics of the embalmed human femur. In Advances in Bioengineering, 1980, pp. 57 (ASME, New York).
68.
KhalilT. B.VianoD. C.Generalized resonances of the isolated femur. No. GMR 3560R, Biomedical Sciences Department, General Motors Research Laboratories, Warren, Michigan, 26 March 1982.
69.
GuzelsuN.SahaS.A theoretical analysis of piezoelectric wave propagation in long bones. In Advances in Bioengineering, 1986, pp. 61 (ASME, New York).
70.
HightT. K.PizialiR. L.NagelD. A.Natural frequency analysis of a human tibia. J. Biomechanics, 1980, 13, 139.
71.
DyrbyeC.BorgwardtA.A simple model for the tibia vibrating in the BRA set-up. In Monitoring of Fracture Healing by Vibration Analysis and Other Mechanical Methods (Eds Van der PerreG.Borgwardt-ChristensenA.), Proceedings of the Specialists Consensus Meeting, Louvain, 1985 (Amerfoort, Louvain, Belgium).
72.
RobertsS. G.HutchinsonT. M.ArnaudS. B.KiratliB. J.MartinR. B.SteeleC. R.Noninvasive determination of bone mechanical properties using vibrational response: A refined model and validationin vivo. J. Biomechanics, 1996, 29, 91–98.
73.
SiegelI. M.AnastG. T.FieldsT.The determination of fracture healing by measurement of sound velocity across the fracture site. Surg. Gynec. Obstet., 1958, 107, 327.
74.
DenckerH.MobergE.Diagnosis of soft tissue interposition in shaft fractures of the humerus and femur by measuring the conduction of vibrations across the fracture. Acta Chir. Scand., 1968, 134, 540.
75.
JuristJ. M.In-vivo determination of elastic response of bone. II. Ulnar resonant frequency in osteoporotic, diabetic and normal subject. Phys. Med. Biol., 1970, 15, 427.
76.
DaviesI. J. T.Postgraduate Medicine, 3rd edition, 1977, pp. 232 (Lloyd, London).
77.
JuristJ. M.Human ulna bending stiffness, mineral content, geometry and strength. J. Biomechanics, 1977, 10, 455.
78.
JuristJ. M.DymondA. M.Reproducibility of ulna resonant frequency measurement. Aerospace Medicine, 1970, 41, 427.
79.
PughJ. W.RoseR. M.PaulI. L.RadinE. L.Mechanical resonance spectra in human cancellous bone. Science, 1973, 181, 271.
80.
FitzgeraldE. R.Particle Waves and Deformation in Crystalline Solids, 1966, Ch. 2 (Interscience, New York).
81.
BorgwardtA.InMonitoring of Fracture Healing by Vibration Analysis and Other Mechanical Methods (Eds Van der PerreG.Borgwardt-ChristensenA.), Proceedings of the Specialists Consensus Meeting, Louvain, 1985 (Amerfoort, Louvain, Belgium).
82.
NokesL. D. M.FaircloughJ. A.Mintowt-CzyzW. J.MackieI. G.WilliamsJ. H.Direct and indirect determination of tibial natural frequency—comparison of frequency domain analysis and fast Fourier transform. J. Biomed. Engng, 1984, 6, 45.
83.
ChungJ. K.PrattG. W.BabynP. S.PossR.A new diagnostic technique for the evaluation of prosthetic implant fixation. In First Annual Conference onFrontiers of Engineering in Health Care, 1979, pp. 7.5.1 (IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society).
84.
WoskJ.VoloshinA.Wave attenuation in skeletons of young persons. J. Biomechanics, 1981, 14, 261.
85.
WyattM. P.Vibratory response in idiopathic scoliosis. J. Bone Jt Surg., 1981, 14, 261.
86.
ThomasA. M. C.LuoD. Z.DunnJ. W.Response of human femur to mechanical vibration. J. Biomed. Engng, 1991, 13, 58–60.
87.
Van der PerreG.LowitG.In-vivo assessment of bone mechanical properties by vibration and ultrasonic wave propagation analysis in bone. Bone, 1996, 18, 29S–35S.
88.
CollierR. J.NtuiJ. A.in vivo measurements of the phase constants of transverse mechanical waves in a human tibia from 100 to 1000 Hz.Med. Engng Phys., 1994, 16, 379–383.
