Simplified approach for modelling pilot pursuit control behaviour in multi-loop flight control tasks

Abstract

A control-theoretic procedure for modelling human pilot pursuit control behaviour is presented. The procedure allows for the development of human pilot behavioural models in multi-loop flight control tasks in a simplified framework emphasizing frequency-domain techniques. Beginning with the primary control loops, each control loop is closed using a combination of output-rate feedback and output-error feedback. It is demonstrated that this approach can accommodate any vehicle dynamics that can be stabilized by a human pilot. In addition, the modelling approach identifies vehicle dynamics that approach the limits of human pilot controllability. The well-documented increase in pilot effective time delays that have been shown to accompany vehicle dynamics requiring lead compensation is also replicated by this modelling approach. A method for predicting handling-qualitiy levels that would be assigned to a particular vehicle and task is presented. A visual cue model is included, which can approximate the effects of degraded visual cues. It is shown that this model can be used to reproduce the three most important measurable effects of visual cue quality upon human operator dynamics, namely, an increase in ‘effective’ pilot time delay, a decrease in crossover frequency, and an increase in error-injected remnant. The ability of the modelling procedure to accommodate different levels of pilot aggressiveness in completing manoeuvres is demonstrated. Finally, an application to a multi-axis rotorcraft flight control problem is presented.

Keywords

pilot models handling qualities manual control

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

McRuer

Human dynamics in man-machine systems. Automatica, 1980, 16, 237–253.

Hess

R. A.

Unified theory for aircraft handling qualities and adverse aircraft-pilot coupling. J. Guid. Control Dyn., 1997, 20, 1141–1148.

Hess

R. A.

Zeyada

Heffley

R. K.

Modeling and simulation for helicopter task analysis. J. Am. Helicopter Soc., 2002, 47, 243–252.

Zeyada

Hess

R. A.

Computer-aided assessment of flight simulator fidelity. J. Aircraft, 2003, 40, 173–180.

Smith

R. H.

A theory for handling qualities with applications to MIL-F-8785B, AFFDL-TR-75–119. Air Force Flight Dynamics Lab., WPAFB, OH, October 1976.

Hess

R. A.

Identification of pilot-vehicle dynamics from simulation and flight test. Control and dynamic systems. In Advances in aerospace systems dynamics and control systems (Ed. Leondes

C. T.

) 1990, vol. 33, pp. 157–175 (Academic Press, London).

Mitchell

D. G.

Aponso

B. L.

Klyde

D. H.

Effects of cockpit lateral stick characteristics on handling qualities and pilot dynamics. NASA CR 4443, June 1992.

McRuer

D. T.

Ashkenas

Graham

Aircraft dynamics and automatic control, 1973 (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ).

McRuer

D. T.

Krendel

E. S.

Mathematical models of human pilot behavior. AGARDograph No. 188, 1974.

10.

Hess

R. A.

Pursuit tracking and higher levels of skill development in the human pilot. IEEE Trans. Syst. Man Cybern., 1981, SMC-11 (4), 262–273.

11.

Wasicko

R. J.

McRuer

D. T.

Magdaleno

R. E.

Human pilot dynamic response in single-loop systems with compensatory and pursuit displays. AFFDL-TR-66–137, Air Force Flight Dynamics Lab., WPAFB, OH, December 1966.

12.

Jex

H. R.

Allen

R. W.

Research on a new human dynamic response test battery. Proceedings of the Sixth Annual Conference on Manual Control 1970, pp. 743–778 (Wright Patterson AFB, OH).

13.

McDonnell

J. D.

Pilot rating techniques for the estimation and evaluation of handling qualities. AFFDL-TR-68–76, Air Force Flight Dynamics Lab., WPAFB, OH, December 1968.

14.

Anon.

Aeronautical design standards, performance specification, handling qualities design requirements for military rotorcraft, ADS-33E-PRF, U.S. Army Aviation and Missile command, Redstone Arsenal, AL, March 2000.

15.

Hess

R. A.

Malsbury

Atencio

Jr.

Flight simulator fidelity assessment in a rotorcraft lateral translation maneuver. J. Guid. Control Dyn., 1993, 16, 79–85.

16.

Hess

R. A.

Siwakosit

Assessment of flight simulator fidelity in multiaxis tasks including visual cue quality. J. Aircraft, 2001, 38, 607–614.

17.

Hess

R. A.

Modeling the effects of display quality upon human pilot dynamics and perceived handling qualities. IEEE Trans. Syst. Man Cybern., 1995, 25, 338–344.

18.

Hoh

R. H.

Mitchell

D. G.

Handling-qualities specification - a functional requirement for the flight control system. In Advances in flight control (Ed. Tischler

M. B.

) 1996, ch. 1 (Taylor & Francis, London).

19.

Heffley

R. K.

Jewell

W. F.

Lehman

J. M.

Van Winkle

R. A.

A compilation and analysis of helicopter handling qualities data. Data Compilation, NASA CR-3144, March 1979, vol. 1.