Wear at the wheel/rail interface when sanding is used to increase adhesion

Abstract

Sanding is used in train operation to improve adhesion at the wheel/rail interface during both braking and traction. An experimental study has been carried out to determine the effect of sanding on the wear of wheel and rail materials. Static tests were performed using actual wheel and rail sections. Dynamic tests were carried out with and without sand on a twin disc machine, where wheel and rail steel discs are loaded together and driven under controlled conditions of rolling and sliding. Sand was fed into the disc contact through a standard compressed air sanding valve.

In both static and dynamic tests, sand caused severe surface damage. During the dynamic tests, because of the application of sand, wear increased by factors between 2 and 10. The wheel steel wear rates showed the largest increases. Wear in wet conditions was higher than that in dry conditions because the wet discs entrained a larger amount of sand through the contact that otherwise was ejected when the discs were run dry.

The mechanisms of sanding wear have been investigated. Severe plastic flow as well as a high material removal rate and surface corrugation takes place. The rail discs are scored by sand particles that embed and stick in the softer wheel disc. As well as wear by abrasion, the discs were subject to a rapid fatigue process and large chunks of material fractured from the surface.

A simple abrasive wear model has been developed to predict wear of rail material caused by sand in the wheel/rail contact, which shows good correlation with test results.

There are a number of idealizations inherent in the test simulations that lead to increased severity over the actual wheel/rail contact. These include the amount of sand entering the contacts in both types of test and the disc geometry and motion in the dynamic tests. While the twin disc specimens have been scaled down, the sand is as used on the railway network, which may lead to surface damage appearing more severe than it would be in an actual wheel/rail contact. Results are therefore only to be taken as a guide to what happens in the full size wheel/rail interface.

Keywords

wheel/rail interface sanding wear

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Beagley

T. M.

Pritchard

Wheel/rail adhesion - the overriding influence of water

Wear, 1975, 35, 299–313.

Nagase

A study of adhesion between the rails and running wheels on mainlines: Results of investigations by slipping adhesion test bogie

Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part F: J. Rail Rapid Transit, 1989, 203, 33–42.

Kumar

Krishnamoorthy

P. K.

Rao

D. L. P.

Wheel-rail wear and adhesion with and without sand for North American locomotive

Trans. ASME, J. Eng. Ind., 1986, 108, 141–147.

Jenks

C. W.

Improved methods for increasing wheel/rail adhesion in the presence of natural contaminants. Transit Co-operative Research Program, Research Results Digest, No. 17, 1997.

Bolton

P. J.

Clayton

McEwen

I. J.

Wear of rail tire steels under rolling/sliding conditions

ASLE Trans., 1982, 1, 17–24.

Kumar

Rao

D. L. P.

Wheel-rail contact wear, work, and lateral force for zero angle of attack - a laboratory study

Trans. ASME, J. Dyn. Syst., Meas. Cont., 1984, 108, 141–147.

Tyfour

W. R.

Beynon

J. H.

Kapoor

The steady state wear behaviour of pearlitic rail steel under dry rolling-sliding contact conditions

Wear, 1995, 180, 79–89.

Garnham

J. E.

Beynon

J. H.

The early detection of rolling-sliding contact fatigue cracks

Wear, 1991, 144, 103–116.

Fletcher

D. I.

Beynon

J. H.

Development of a machine for closely controlled rolling contact fatigue and wear testing

J. Test. Eval, 2000, 28 (4), 267–275.

10.

Railtrack. Base technical specification for the fitting of sanding equipment to multiple units. Issue 1, 2000.

11.

Fischer

Grubisic

Widmayer

Fatigue tests on wheelsets under simulated service strength spectra. Proceedings of the 9th International Wheelset Congress, Montreal, 1988.

12.

Dwyer-Joyce

R. S.

Sayles

R. S.

Ioannides

An investigation into the mechanism of closed three-body abrasive wear

Wear, 1993, 175, 133–142.

13.

Grieve

D. G.

Dwyer-Joyce

R. S.

Beynon

J. H.

Abrasive wear of railway track by solid contaminants

Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part F: J. Rail and Rapid Transit, 2001, 215, 193–205.

14.

Roylance

B. J.

Williams

J. A.

Dwyer-Joyce

R. S.

Wear debris and associated wear phenomena

Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part J: J. Engineering Tribology, 2000, 214, 79–105.

15.

Buttery

T. C.

Archard

J. F.

Grinding and abrasive wear

Proc. IMechE, 1971, 185 (43), 537–551.

16.

Rabinowicz

Dunn

L. A.

Russel

P. G.

Study of abrasive wear under three-body conditions

Wear, 1961, 4, 345–355.