Surface cracks and wear of rail: A full-scale test on a commuter train track

Abstract

Damage mechanisms such as surface cracks and wear on a rail can reduce the service life of a railway track. The purpose of this investigation was to study the development of these two damage mechanisms on new and 3-year-old rails in a commuter railway track over a period of 2 years. Four curves were studied with radius between 303 and 616m. In two of the curves, two different kinds of rail steel grade (UIC 900A grade with ultimate strength 900N/mm2 and UIC 1100 grade with ultimate strength 1100N/mm²) were used in each curve. In the other two curves, only the lower-strength rail was used. Four pieces of new rail, each 20m long, were inserted in the two curves with both UIC 900A and UIC 1100 grade rail. Lubrication was applied on the high rail of one of the curves with both UIC 900A and UIC 1100 grade rail and on one of the curves with only UIC 900A grade rail. The two remaining curves were not lubricated. Surface cracks in the form of headchecks could be noted on the surface of the new 1100 grade rails after 1 month of traffic. By contrast, the surface of the UIC 900A grade rails showed visible surface cracks in only two of four curves and that after approximately 2 years of traffic. Both materials seemed to be similarly sensitive to crack initiation but the 1100 grade rail was more sensitive to crack propagation and also more sensitive to the formation of headcheck cracks. Lubrication, as expected, reduced the profile change. A less expected outcome was that lubrication also reduced the rate of crack propagation; however, the lubricated UIC 1100 grade rail was as sensitive to crack initiation as the unlubricated UIC 1100 grade rail. By comparing the wear depth in the headcheck zone with the crack length, equilibrium between these two damage mechanisms was found for the lubricated UIC 1100 grade rail. Both the crack length and the wear depth showed low values. By using a lubricant with friction modifiers the stresses was low enough to prevent crack propagation; at the same time, the rail was hard enough to reduce the wear rate. This is probably the most favourable state in terms of rail maintenance cost.

Keywords

rail surface cracks wear lubrication

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Jendel

Prediction of wheel profile wear-comparison with field measurements. In Proceedings of the 5th International Conference on

Contact Mechanics and Wear of Rail/Wheel Systems, Tokyo, Japan, 25-28 July 2000, pp. 117–124.

Frederick

C. O.

Future rail requirements. In Proceedings of the Conference on

Rail Quality and Maintenance for Modern Railway Operation, 1993, pp. 3–14 (Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht).

Cannon

D. F.

Pradier

Rail rolling contact fatigue-research by the European Rail Research Institute

Wear, 1996, 191, 1–13.

Johnson

K. L.

The mechanism of plastic deformation of surface and subsurface layers in rolling and sliding contact

Material Science Forum: The Role of Subsurface Zone in Wear of Materials, 1988, pp. 33–40 (Trans Tech, Aeder-manns derf).

Jones

C. P.

Tyfor

W. R.

Beynon

J. H.

Kapoor

The effect of strain hardening on shakedown limits of a pearlitic rail steel

Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part F, Journal of Rail and Rapid Transit, 1997, 211 (F2), 131–140.

Olofsson

Andersson

Björklund

Simulation of mild wear in boundary lubricated spherical roller thrust bearings

Wear, 2000, 241, 180–185.

Garnham

J. E.

Beynon

J. H.

Dry rolling-sliding wear of bainitic and pearlitic steels

Wear, 1992, 157, 81–109.

Muster

Schmedders

Wick

Pradier

Rail rolling contact fatigue: The performance of naturally hard and head-hardened rails in track

Wear, 1996, 191, 54–64.

Williams

J. A.

Wear modelling: Analytical, computing and mapping: A continuum mechanics approach

Wear, 1999, 225-229, 1–17.

10.

Broster

Pritchard

Smith

D. A.

Wheel-rail adhesion: Its relation to rail contamination on British railways

Wear, 1974, 29, 309–321.

11.

Sullivan

J. L.

Boundary lubrication and oxidational wear

J. Physics Appl. Physics, 1986, 19, 1999–2011.

12.

Way

Pitting due to rolling contact

J. Appl. Mechanics, 1935, 2, 49–56.

13.

Beynon

J. H.

Brown

M. W.

Kapoor

Initiation, growth and branching of cracks in railway track. In Proceedings of the Conference on

Engineering Against Fatigue, 1999, pp. 461–472 (Balkema, Rotterdam).

14.

Boulanger

Girardi

Galtier

Baudry

Prediction and prevention of rail contact fatigue. In Proceedings of the Conference of the International Heavy Haul Association, Specialist Technical Session (IHHA'99 STS), Moscow, Russia, 14-17 June 1999, Conference Proceedings Vol.1, pp. 229–237.

15.

Olofsson

Nilsson

Initial wear of a commuter train track. In Proceedings of the Conference NORDTRIB ‘98, Ebeltoft, Denmark, 7-10 June 1998, pp. 269–276.

16.

Olofsson

Telliskivi

Wear, plastic deformation and friction of two pearlitic rail steels-full-scale test and laboratory study. 2001 (submitted).

17.

Nilsson

Wheel and rail wear-measured profiles and hardness changes during 2.5 years for Stockholm commuter traffic. In Proceedings of the Hannover Colloquium (EUROMECH 409), Hannover, Germany, 6-9 March 2000.

18.

Knothe

Theiler

Güney

Investigation of contact stresses on the wheel/rail-system at steady state curving. In Proceedings of the 16th IAVSD Conference on

The Dynamics of Vehicles on Roads and on Tracks, Pretoria, South Africa, 30 August-3 September 1999, Vol. 33, pp. 616–628.

19.

Esveld

Gronskov

MINIPROF wheel and rail profile measurement. In Proceedings of the 2nd Mini-conference on

Contact Mechanics and Wear of Rail/Wheel Systems, Budapest, Hungary, 29-31 July 1996, pp. 69–75.

20.

Olofsson

Verification of the MINIPROF rail profile measurement system. Report TRITA-MMK, Department of Machine Design, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden, 1998, p. 4.

21.

Alfredsson

A study on contact fatigue mechanisms. Doctoral thesis, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden, 2000.

22.

Ringsberg

Rolling contact fatigue of railway rails with emphasis on crack initiation. Doctoral thesis, Chalmers University of Technology, Göteborg, Sweden, 2000.