The purpose of this paper is to review critically the current trend in automobile engineering toward automation of many of the functions previously performed by the driver. Working on the assumption that automation in aviation represents the basic model for driver automation, the costs and benefits of automation in aviation are explored as a means of establishing where automation of drivers’ tasks is likely to yield benefits. It is concluded that there are areas where automation can provide benefits to the driver, but there are other areas where this is unlikely to be the case. Automation per se does not guarantee success, and therefore it becomes vital to involve human factors into design to identify where automation of driver functions can be allocated with a beneficial outcome for driving performance.
Quest. The man-machine. Adventures in the World of Science, 1989 (Marshall Cavendish, London).
2.
FittsP. M.Human engineering for an effective air navigation and traffic control system, 1951 (National Research Council, Washington).
3.
SwainA. D.Design techniques for improving human performance in production. US Navy Technical Report, Albuquerque, New Mexico, 1980.
4.
BainbridgeL.The ironies of automation. Automatica, 1983, 19 (6), 775–779.
5.
BillingsC. E.Human-centred aircraft automation: A concept and guidelines, NASA Technical Memorandum, NASA TM-103885, 1991 (Ames Research Center, California).
6.
MarsdenP.HollnagelE.HCI and the accidental user. Proceedings of ECCE-7, Bonn, Germany, 1994.
AndersonJ. R.Cognitive Psychology and its Implications, 1990 (Freeman, New York).
14.
SchlegelR. E.Driver mental workload. In Automotive Ergonomics (Eds PeacockB.KarwowskiW.), 1993 (Taylor and Francis, London).
15.
WildeG. J. S.Social interaction patterns in driver behaviour: An introductory review. Human Factors, 1976, 18 (5), 477–492.
16.
WildeG. J. S.Risk homeostasis theory and traffic accidents: Propositions, deductions and discussions of dissension in recent reactions. Ergonomics, 1988, 31 (4), 441–468.
17.
WildeG. J. S.Target Risk, 1995 (PDE Publications, Toronto).
18.
NormanD. A.The Psychology of Everyday Things, 1988 (Basic Books, New York).
19.
WeinerE. L.Cockpit automation: In need of a philosophy. SAE Technical Report 851956, 1985 (SAE, Warrendale, Pennsylvania).
20.
WeinerE. L.Human factors of advanced (“glass cockpit”) transport aircraft, NASA CR-177528, 1989 (University of Miami, Coral Gables, Florida).
21.
WeinerE. L.CurryR. F.Flight deck automation: Promises and problems, NASA TM-81206, 1980 (Moffet Field, California).
22.
BarleyS.The Final Call: Air Disasters…When will they ever learn?, 1990 (Sinclair-Stevenson, London).
SingletonW. T.The Mind at Work, 1989 (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
25.
KirwanB.AinsworthA. I. (Eds) A Guide to Task Analysis, 1992 (Taylor and Francis, London).
26.
MarsdenP.The Analysis and Allocation of Function: A review of recent literature, 1991 (Human Reliability Associates, Wigan).
27.
WebsterE.TolandC.McLoughlinH. B.Task analysis for GIDS situations, Research Report DRIVE/GIDS-DIA, 1990 (Department of Computer Science, University College Dublin, Dublin, Eire).
28.
PriceH. E.The allocation of system functions. Human Factors, 1985, 27, 33–45.
29.
McLoughlinH. B.MichonJ. A.Van WinsumW.WebsterE.GIDS intelligence. In Generic Intelligent Driver Support (Ed. MichonJ.), 1993 (Taylor and Francis, London).
30.
MeisterD.Conceptual Aspects of Human Factors, 1989 (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore).
