Comparing the steering performances of skid- and Ackermann-steered vehicles

Abstract

Skid steering has advantages for military armoured vehicles because it gives greater internal hull volume and improved manoeuvrability. The steering performance of an 18t 6×6 skid-steered vehicle is analysed and compared with that of a similar Ackermann-steered vehicle. The basic properties of the double-differential mechanism used for steering most modern skid-steered vehicles are analysed. A tyre model is used that enables the force characteristics at combined slip to be established from the relatively small amount of pure slip data that are available for truck-sized tyres. A spreadsheet analysis is used for solving the equations of motion. This shows that the skid-steered vehicle is generally neutral to oversteer whereas the Ackermann-steered vehicle is understeer. The skid-steered vehicle is also shown to require more power when cornering because of the power required by the steering mechanism. This will increase the fuel consumption and reduce the range of the skid-steered vehicle.

Keywords

skid steering Ackermann steering steering performance double differential tyre forces combined slip spreadsheet analysis understeer oversteer power requirements

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Merritt

H. E.

The evolution of a tank transmission. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, 1946, 154, 412–428.

Steeds

Tracked vehicles, an analysis of factors involved in steering. Auto. Engr, April 1950, 143–148.

Wormell

P. J. H.

Purdy

D. J.

Handling of tracked vehicles at low speed. J. Battlefield Technol, 2004, 7(1), 21–26.

Wong

J. Y.

Chiang

C. F.

A general theory for skid steering of tracked vehicles on firm ground. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs Part D: J. Automobile Engineering, 2001, 215(3), 343–355.

Kitano

Kuma

An analysis of horizontal plane motion of tracked vehicles. J. Terramechanics, 1974, 14(4), 211–255.

Ehlert

Hug

Schmid

I. C.

Field measurements and analytical models as a basis of test stand simulation of the turning resistance of tracked vehicles. J. Terramechanics, 1992, 29(1), 57–69.

Pott

Friction between rubber track pads and ground surface with regard to the turning resistance of tracked vehicles. In Proceedings of the Fifth European Conference of the International Society for Terrain Vehicle Systems, Budapest, Hungary, 1991, pp. 105–112 (European Office of ISTVS, Stockholm).

Maclaurin

A skid steering model with track pad flexibility. J. Terramechanics, 2007, 44(1), 95–110.

Weiss

K. R.

Skid-steering. Auto. Engr, April 1971, 61(4), 22–25; June 1971, 61(6), 36–39.

10.

Ogorkiewicz

R. M.

Design and development of fighting vehicles, 1968 (Macdonald, London).

11.

Maclaurin

E. B.

Crolla

D. A.

Wheel spin control for on/off road vehicles. In Proceedings of the IMechE Conference on Traction control and anti-wheel spin systems for road vehicles, London, 1988, pp. 33–46 (Mechanical Engineering Publications Limited, London).

12.

Hasluck

P. N.

The automobile: a practical treatise on the construction of modern motor cars, steam, petrol, electric and petrol-electric, vol. 3, 1909, pp. 718–721 (Cassell, London).

13.

Pacejka

H. B.

Tyre and vehicle dynamics, 2002 (Butterworth Heinemann, Oxford).

14.

Gohring

E. C.

von Glasner

E. C.

Pflug

H.-C.

Contribution to the force transmission of commercial vehicle tyres. SAE Paper 912692, 1991.

15.

15 Bosch Automotive Handbook, 6th edition, 2004, pp. 778–781 (John Wiley, New York).

16.

Ervin

R. D.

Winkler

C. B.

Bernard

J. E.

Gupta

R. K.

Effects of tyre properties on truck and bus handling. Final Report, 1976, Highway Safety Research Institute, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA.

17.

Wilkins

H. A.

Riley

B. S.

The road grip of commercial vehicle tyres. In Proceedings of the IMechE Conference on Road vehicle handling, 1983, paper C135/83 (Mechanical Engineering Publications Limited, London).

18.

Sharp

R. S.

Bettella

Tyre shear force and moment descriptions by normalisation of parameters and the ‘magic formula’. Veh. System Dynamics, 2003, 39(1), 27–56.

19.

Sharp

R. S.

Testing and improving a tyre shear force computation algorithm. Veh. System Dynamics, 2004, 41(3), 223–247.

20.

Bayle

Forissier

J. F.

Lafon

A new tyre model for vehicle dynamics simulations. Automot. Technol. Int., 1993, 193–198.