A disc to air heat flux error and uncertainty analysis applied to a turbomachinery test rig design

Abstract

This article describes a Monte Carlo simulation-based error and an uncertainty analysis for values of disc to air heat fluxes as part of the design of an experimental axial turbine test rig. This work is of interest for those who study heat transfer and measurement or the design and use of experimental test rigs.

An inverse analysis of theoretical disc surface temperatures was performed for different thermocouple configurations to compare the errors and uncertainties resulting from each to establish whether there was any configuration that would return the lowest magnitudes of error and uncertainty and hence influence the location of the proposed instrumentation.

It is shown that great care needs to be taken when using an analysis of this kind together with temperature measurements having realistic and typical uncertainty values. This is because such an analysis is purely analytical, and any small fluctuations in the inputs, such as typical thermocouple uncertainties and noise, result in the process of an inverse analysis becoming unstable. This instability has two effects: (a) the returned values of heat flux have an inbuilt bias error and (b) the magnitudes of uncertainty can exceed>100 per cent.

Keywords

uncertainty analysis turbomachinery inverse analysis Monte Carlo simulation heat transfer

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Childs

P. R. N.

, Heat transfer at the surface of a cylinder rotating in anannulus with a stator blade row and axial throughflow (UK: University of Sussex 1991) DPhil Thesis.

Childs

P. R. N.

Turner

A. B.

Vaughan

C. M.

Rayner

Bayley

F. J.

, ‘Heat transfer to a rotating drum in an annulus with a stator blade row and axial throughflow’ (1992): ASME paper 92-GT-249.

Childs

P. R. N.

Greenwood

J. R.

Long

C. A.

, ‘Heat flux measurement techniques’ Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part C: J. Mechanical Engineering Science 213 7 (1999): 655–677.

Diller

T. E.

, ‘Advances in heat flux measurement’ Advances in heat transfer (Boston: Academic Press 1993): 279–368.

Diller

T. E.

Kidd

C. T.

, ‘Evaluation of numerical methods for determining heat flux with a null point calorimeter’ In Proceedings of the 42nd International Instrumentation Symposium, ISA, San Diego, CA, 1997, pp. 357–369.

Greenwood

J. R.

, The development of robust heat transfer instrumentation for rotating turbomachinery (UK: University of Sussex 2000) PhD Thesis.

Liebert

C. H.

Weikle

D. H.

, ‘Heat flux measurements’ (1989): ASME paper 89-GT-107.

à–zisik

M. N.

Orlande

H. R. B.

, Inverse heat transfer (US: Taylor & Francis 2000).

Owen

J. M.

, ‘On the computation of heat transfer coefficients from imperfect temperature measurements’ J. Mech. Eng. Sci. 21 5 (1979): 323–334.

10.

Cooke

A. O.

Childs

P. R. N.

Long

C. A.

, ‘An investigation into the uncertainty of turbomachinery disc heat transfer calculations using Monte Carlo Simulation methods’ (2006): ASME paper GT2006-90143.

11.

Dorfman

L. A.

, Hydrodynamic resistance and the heat loss of rotating solids (Edinburgh: Oliver & Boyd 1963).

12.

Hadamard

, Lectures on Cauchy's problem in linear differential equations (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press 1923) 1923.