During the course of expansion of steam in turbines, the state path crosses the saturation line and hence subsequent turbine stages operate with wet steam. These stages have lower thermodynamic efficiencies than those operating in the superheated region, and currently the phenomena contributing to the increased losses are not fully understood. The development of the nucleation theory has opened the way for the study of condensing flows in turbines. As, with the advances in numerical methods, the equations describing droplet nucleation and growth rates can be combined with the field conservation equations and the set treated numerically, which allows the behaviour of complex nucleating and wet steam flows in turbines to be analysed. This paper outlines and reviews wet steam calculation methods and discusses comparisons between numerical and experimental results. For the most part, the comparisons presented are based on work of the authors and their co-workers, but some more recent calculations by other investigators are also included.
OswatitschE.Kondensationsercheinungen in Uber-schalldusen. Z. Agnew. Math. U. Mech., 1942, 22 (1), 1–14.
2.
GyarmathyG.Basis for a theory for wet steam turbines, Bull. 6, Inst. for Thermal Turbo-machines, Federal Technical University, Zurich, 1962 (CEGB Translation No T 781).
3.
GyarmathyG.MeyerH.Spontaneous condensation phenomena - Parts 1 and 2 VDI Forschungsheft, VDI-Verlag, 1965, Vol. 508 (CEGB Translation No. 4160).
4.
HillP. G.Condensation of water vapour during supersonic expansion in nozzles. J. Fluid Mech., 1966, 25 (3), 593–620.
5.
DeychM. Ye.KurshakovA. V.SaltanovG. A.YatcheniI. A.A study of the structure of two-phase flow behind a condensation shock in supersonic nozzles. Heat Transfer Soviet Res., 1969, 1 (5), 95–105.
6.
PuzyrewskiR.Theoretical and experimental studies in formation and growth of water drops in LP steam turbines. Trans. Inst. Fluid Flow Mach., 1969, 42–44, 289–303, Gdansk, Poland.
7.
WegenerP. P.Gas dynamics of expansion flows with condensation and homogeneous nucleation of water vapour. In Gas DynamicsVol. 1, Pt. 1 (Ed. WegenerP. P.) 1969 (Marcel Deckker, New York).
8.
PetrV.Measurement of average size and number of droplets during spontaneous condensation of supersaturated-steam. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, 1970, 184(3G), 73–79.
9.
CampbellB. A.BakhtarF.Condensation phenomena in high speed flow of steam. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, 1970–1971, 185(25/71), 395–405.
10.
BarschdorffD.DunnimngW. J.WegenerP. P.WuB. J. C.Homogeneous nucleation in steam nozzle condensation. Nature Phys. Sci., 1972, 240, 166–167.
11.
RyleyD. J.TubmanK. A.Spontaneous condensation in high pressure steam. Trans. Inst. Fluid Flow Mach., 1974, 70–72, 273–284, Gdansk, Poland.
12.
MooreM. J.WaltersP. T.CraneR. I.DavidsonB. J.Predicting the fog-drop size in wet steam turbines. In Proceedings of IMechE Conference on Heat and fluid flow in turbine plant, London, 1973, Vol. 3 (Mechanical Engineering Publications, Bury St Edmunds and London).
13.
BarschdorffD.Carrier gas effects on homogeneous nucleation of water vapour in a shock tube. Phys. Fluids, 1975, 18, 529–535.
14.
BakhtarF.RyleyD. J.TubmanK. A.YoungJ. B.Nucleation studies in flowing high-pressure steam. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, 1975, 189(41/75), 427–436.
15.
MooreM. J.SieverdingC. H.Two phase steam flow in turbines and separators, 1976 (Hemisphere Publishing, Washington).
16.
SaltonovG. A.Non-equilibrium and unsteady processes in gas dynamics of single phase and two-phase interfaces (in Russian), 1979, (Nauka, Moscow).
17.
BakhtarF.ZidiK.Nucleation phenomena in flowing high pressure steam part 2: Theoretical analysis. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part A: J. Power and Energy, 1990, 204, 233–242.
18.
LaaliA. R.CollignanB.Condensation process in high pressure nuclear turbines, Proceedings of the International Joint. Power Generation Conference, ASME/JSME, Phoenix, Arizona, Oct 1994, PWR-Vol 26, Advances in Steam Turbine Technology for the Power Generation Industry, ASME, 1994.
19.
BakhtarF.Mohammadi TochaiM. T.An investigation of two-dimensional flows of nucleating and wet steam by the time-marching method. Int. J. Heat and Fluid Flow, 1980, 2 (1), 5–18.
20.
YeohC. C.YoungJ. B.Non-equilibrium through-flow analysis of low-pressure wet steam turbines. Trans. ASME J. Engng for Gas Turbine and Power, 1984, 106, 716–724.
21.
MohebanM.YoungJ. B.A time-marching method for the calculation of blade-to-blade non-equilibrium wet steam flows in turbine cascades. In Proceedings of IMechE Conference on Computational methods in turbomachinery, 1984, paper C76/84, Vol. 3 (Mechanical Engineering Publications, Bury St Edmunds and London).
22.
SnoeckJ.Two Dimensional condensing flow in transonic turbine cascades. In (Eds. MooreM. J.SieverdingC. H., Eds) Aerothermodynamics of low pressure steam turbines and condensers, 1987, pp 113–133 (Hemisphere Publishing Corporation, Washington).
23.
BakhtarF.BamkoleB. O.An examination of the throughflow of steam in a turbine stage by a time-marching method. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part A: J. Power and Energy1989, 203(A4), 233–243.
24.
SchnerrG. H.DohrmannU.Transonic flow round airfoils with relaxation and energy supply by homogeneous condensation. AIAA J., 1990, 28 (7), 1187–1193.
25.
BakhtarF.SoK. S.A Study of Nucleating Flow of Steam in a Cascade of Supersonic Blading by the Time-Marching Method. Int. J. Heat and Fluid Flow, 1991, 12 (1), 54–62.
26.
YoungJ. B.Two-dimensional, non-equilibrium, wet steam calculations for nozzles and turbine cascades. Trans. ASME. J. Turbomachinery, 1992, 114, 569–579.
27.
WhiteA. J.YoungJ. B.A time-marching method for the prediction of two-dimensional, unsteady flows of condensing steam. J. Propulsion and Power, 1993, 9, 579–587.
28.
SejnaM.Numerical modelling of unsteady wet steam flow. Z. Angew Math. Mech., 1993, 73 (6), T578–T581.
29.
LibersonA.KosolapovY.ReigerN.HeslerS.Calculation of 3D condensing flows in nozzles and turbine stages. Proceedings of EPRI Nucleation Workshop, Rochester, New York, October 1995, EPRI TR-108942, 1997.
30.
KatchurinerYu Ya.TrevgodaA. M.Calculations of condensing steam flows in turbines with the account of nucleation kinetics, Proceedings of EPRI Nucleation Workshop, Rochester, New York, October 1995, EPRI TR-108942, 1997.
31.
SinghG.HuntR.McCallumM.Wet steam analysis using Eulerian method for two-dimensional droplet growth and nucleation rate equations. In Proceedings of IMechE, Third European Conference on Turbomachinery, London, 1999, paper C557/099/99, pp. 783–801 (Professional Engineering Publishing, Bury St Edmunds and London).
32.
SinghU.Method for nucleating steam flow in low-pressure turbine stages. In Proceedings of IMechE, Third European Conference on Turbomachinery, London, 1999, paper C557/010/99, pp. 827–836 (Professional Engineering Publishing, Bury St Edmunds and London).
33.
HillP. G.MiyagawaK.DentonJ. D.Fast and accurate inclusion of steam properties in two- and three-dimensional steam turbine flow calculations. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part C: J. Mechanical Engineering Science, 2000, 214(C7), 903–919.
34.
GerberA. G.Two-phase Eulerian/Lagrangian model for nucleating steam flow. J. Fluids Engng, 2000, 124, 465–475.
35.
LibersonA. S.HeslerS. H.McCloskeyT. H.A unified CFD approach to a variety of condensation processes in low pressure steam turbines. In Proceedings of the EPRI/VGB Conference-Steam Chemistry: Interaction of Chemical Species with Water, Steam and Materials During Evaporation, Superheating and Condensation, Freiburg, Germany, June 1999, EPRI, TR-114837.
36.
DentonJ. D.An improved time-marching method for turbomachinery flow calculations. ASME paper 82-GT-239, 1982.
37.
BakhtarF.PiranM.Thermodynamic properties of supercooled steam. Int. J. Heat and Fluid Flow, 1979, 1 (2), 53–62.
38.
MiyagawaK.HillP. J.A tabular Taylor series expansion method for fast calculation of steam properties. Trans. ASME J. Engng for Gas Turbine and Power, 1996, 119, 485–491.
39.
WhiteA. J.HounslowM. J.Modelling droplet size distributions in polydispersed wet steam flows. Int. J. Heat and Mass Transfer, 2000, 43, 1873–1884.
40.
BakhtarF.MahpeykarM. R.On the performance of a cascade of turbine rotor tip section blading in nucleating steam Part 3: Theoretical treatment. Proc. IMechE, Part C: J. Mechanical Engineering Science, 1997, 211(C3), 195–210.
41.
BakhtarF.YoungJ. B.WhiteA. J.SimpsonD. A.Classical nucleation theory and its application to condensing steam flow calculations. Proc. IMechE, Part C: J. Mechanical Engineering Science, 2005, 219(C12), 1315–1333.
42.
FordI. J.Statistical mechanics of water droplet nucleation. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part C: J. Mechanical Engineering Science, 2004, 218(C8), 883–899.
43.
CourtneyW. G.Remarks on homogeneous nucleation. J. Chem. Phys, 1961, 35, 2249–2250.
44.
KantrowitzA.Nucleation in very rapid vapour expansion. J. Chem. Phys, 1951, 19 (9), 1097–1100.
45.
YoungJ. B.The spontaneous condensation of steam in supersonic nozzles. Physico Chem. Hydrodynamics, 1982, 3 (1), 57–82.
46.
BakhtarF.MahpeykarM. R.AbbasK. K.An investigation of nucleating flow of steam in a cascade of turbine blading-theoretical treatment. Trans. ASME, J Fluids Engng, 1995, 117, 138–144.
47.
RoeR. L.Characteristic-based schemes for the Euler equations. Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech., 1986, 18, 337–365.
48.
WhiteA. J.A comparison of modelling methods for polydispersed wet steam flow. Int. J. for Numerical Methods in Engng, 2003, 57, 819–834.
49.
AdamS.SchnerrG. H.Instabilities and bifurcation of non-equilibrium two-phase flows. J. Fluid Mech., 1997, 48, 1–28.
50.
YamamotoS.Numerical study of nonequilibrium condensation in unsteady transonic viscous flow problem. European Congress on Computational Methods in Applied Science and Engineering, ECCOMAS, Barcelona, 2000.
51.
SimpsonD. A.WhiteA. J.Viscous and unsteady flow calculations of condensing steam in nozzles. Int. J. Heat and Fluid Flow, 2005, 26 (1), 71–79.
52.
PittoP.Trucco MartinenzoA.NurziaF.Non-equilibrium two-dimensional analysis of wet steam flow in turbine blade cascades and steam tunnel experimentation. International Symposium on Two Phase Flow Modelling and Experimentation, 1995, Rome, October 9–11.
53.
MashmoushyH.MahpeykarM. R.BakhtarF.Studies of nucleating and wet steam flows in two-dimensional cascades. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part C: J. Mechanical Engineering Science, 2004, 218(C8), 843–858.
54.
BakhtarF.WebbR. A.Shojaee-FardM. H.SirajM. A.An investigation of nucleating flows of steam in a cascade of blading. ASME J. Fluids Engng, 1993, 115, 128–134.
55.
BakhtarF.EbrahimiM.WebbR. A.An investigation of nucleating flows of steam in a cascade of blading - wake traverses. ASME J. Fluids Engng, 1994, 116, 121–127.
56.
BakhtarF.EbrahimiM.WebbR. A.On the performance of a cascade of turbine rotor tip section blading in nucleating steam. Part 1: Surface pressure distributions. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part C: J. Mechanical Engineering Science, 1995, 209(C2), 115–124.
57.
BakhtarF.EbrahimiM.BamkoleB. O.On the performance of a cascade of turbine rotor tip section blading in nucleating steam. Part 2: Wake traverses. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part C: J. Mechanical Engineering Science, 1995, 209(C3), 167–177.
58.
WhiteA. J.YoungJ. B.WaltersP. T.Experimental validation of condensing flow theory for a stationary cascade of steam turbine blades. Proc. Royal Soc. A, 1996, 354, 59–80.
59.
BakhtarF.YoungJ. B.A study of choking conditions in the flow of wet steam. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, 1978, 192 (21), 237–242.
60.
BakhtarF.MashmoushyH.JadayelO. C.Calibrati and characteristics of a three-hole probe and a static tube in wet steam. Int. J. Heat and Fluid Flow, 2001, 22 (5), 537–542.
61.
ArnoneA. A.SteccoS. S.Inviscid cascade flow calculations using a multigrid method, ASME paper 80-GT-22, 1980.
62.
HeilerM.Instationäre Phänomene in homogen/ heterogen kondensierenden Dasen- und Turbinen-strömungen. Dissertation Universität Karlsruhe (TH), Fakultät für Maschinenbau, 1999.
63.
SimpsonD. A.Numerical modelling of condensing wet steam flows. PhD Thesis, University of Cambridge, 2004.
64.
WhiteA. J.YoungJ. B.Loss measurements and the interpretation of Pitot pressures in two-phase vapour-droplet flow. Exp. Thermal and Fluid Science, 1997, 15 (3), 279–287.
