Two studies examined effects of computer-assisted (CA) teaching methods in introductory psychology classes. In Study 1, we provided students with lectures supplemented with either overhead transparencies or CA visuals. In Study 2, we compared students who used an optional Web site with students who did not. In both studies we held constant lecture content, course instructor, exams, and assignments. Results of the two studies showed that students liked the CA teaching interventions, although CA instruction had no effect on student performance in the courses. Based on these and other published findings, we recommend that universities examine closely their goals and priorities when devoting resources to instructional technology.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbersonC. L.BergerD. E.HealyM. R.KyleD. J.RomeroV. L. (2000). Evaluation of an interactive tutorial for teaching the central limit theorem. Teaching of Psychology, 27, 289–291.
2.
BrothenT. (1997). Psychology on a disk: Then what?Teaching of Psychology, 24, 213–216.
3.
ErwinT. D.RieppiR. (1999). Comparing multimedia and traditional approaches in undergraduate psychology classes. Teaching of Psychology, 26, 58–61.
4.
ForsythD. R.ArcherC. R. (1997). Technologically assisted instruction and student mastery, motivation, and matriculation. Teaching of Psychology, 24, 207–212.
5.
GrahamR.B. (1997). A computer tutorial on consequences in operant conditioning. Teaching of Psychology, 24, 216–217.
6.
HallR. H.WatkinsS. E.ErcalF. (2000, April). The horse and the cart in Web-based instruction: Prevalence and efficacy. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, New Orleans, LA.
7.
HamiltonK. (2001). Historically Black colleges strive to bring campus communities up to technological speed: But are they catching up?Black Issues in Higher Education, 18, 30–33.
8.
HudiburgR. A. (1989). Psychology of computer use: 17. The Computer Technology Hassles Scale: Revision, reliability and some correlates. Psychological Reports, 65, 1387–1394.
9.
HudiburgR. A. (1995). Psychology of computer use: 34. The Computer Hassles Scale: Subscales, norms, and reliability. Psychological Reports, 77, 779–782.
10.
JohnstoneS.M.PoulinR. (2002). So, how much do educational technologies really cost?Change, 34, 21–23.
11.
KazmerskiV. A.BlaskoD. G. (1999). Teaching observational research in introductory psychology: Computerized and lecture-based methods. Teaching of Psychology, 26, 295–298.
12.
LangstonW. (1998). A demonstration of research methodologies used in psycholinguistics. Teaching of Psychology, 25, 61–63.
13.
MatthewsT. D. (1999). A World Wide Web-based research project. Teaching of Psychology, 26, 227–230.
NeuhoffJ. (2000). Classroom demonstrations in perception and cognition using presentation software. Teaching of Psychology, 27, 142–144.
16.
NewcombA. F.BerkebileN. M.NewmanJ. E.ParkerS. W. (1998). Student projects embracing new computer technologies: Opportunities for student scholarship on the World Wide Web. Teaching of Psychology, 25, 52–58.
17.
PaneroJ. C.LaneD. M.NapierH. A. (1997). The Computer Use Scale: Four dimensions of how people use computers. Journal of Educational Computing Research, 16, 297–315.
18.
PittengerD. J. (1997). Computers and the teaching of psychology: A call for papers. Teaching of Psychology, 24, 57–58.
19.
PlousS. (2000). Tips on creating and maintaining an educational World Wide Web site. Teaching of Psychology, 27, 63–70.
20.
RinioloT. C. (1997). Publication bias: A computer-assisted demonstration of excluding nonsignificant results from research interpretation. Teaching of Psychology, 24, 279–282.
21.
ShermanR. C. (1998). Using the World Wide Web to teach everyday applications of social psychology. Teaching of Psychology, 25, 212–216.
22.
SmithS. M.WoodyP. C. (2000). Interactive effect of multimedia instruction and learning styles. Teaching of Psychology, 27, 220–223.
23.
StoloffM. (1995). Teaching physiological psychology in a multimedia classroom. Teaching of Psychology, 22, 138–141.
24.
TorkzadehR.PflughoeftK.HallL. (1999). Computer self-efficacy, training effectiveness and user attitudes: An empirical study. Behaviour and Information Technology, 18, 299–309.
25.
VarnhagenC. K.DrakeS. M.FinleyG. (1997). Teaching statistics with the Internet. Teaching of Psychology, 24, 275–278.
26.
WelshJ. A.NullC. H. (1991). The effects of computer-based instruction on college students' comprehension of classic research. Behavior Research Methods, Instruments, & Computers, 23, 301–305.
27.
WorthingtonE. L.Jr.WelshJ. A.ArcherC. R.MindesE. J.ForsythD. R. (1996). Computer-assisted instruction as a supplement to lectures in an introductory psychology class. Teaching of Psychology, 23, 175–181.
