The Subject-Experimenter Contract: A Reexamination of Subject Pool Contamination

Abstract

We conducted three experiments to investigate: (a) the extent to which student research participants believe they will disclose details of their experiences, (b) how much subjects actually will disclose immediately following a request not to reveal information, and (c) how much they will disclose after a 2-week interval. Disclosure rates increased across the experiments. In the first experiment, one fifth of the subjects indicated that they probably would not preserve confidentiality, whether or not they believed it was important to do so. In the second experiment, signing a pledge not to discuss the experiment resulted in less disclosure, but over one third of the subjects revealed information to a confederate. In the third experiment, promising students anonymity increased disclosure; 85% of the subjects disclosed information. The results indicate that failure to heed requests for confidentiality may be a widespread problem in college subject pools.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aronson

(1966). Avoidance of intersubject communication. Psychological Reports, 19, 238.

Britton

B. K.

(1987). Comment on Coulter and Daniel. American Psychologist, 42, 268–269.

Coulter

(1986). Academic value of research participation by undergraduates. American Psychologist, 41, 317.

Diener

Matthews

Smith

(1972). Leakage of experimental information to potential future subjects by debriefed subjects. Journal of Experimental Research in Personality, 6, 264–267.

Farrow

J. M.

Lohss

W. E.

Farrow

B. J.

Taub

(1975). Intersubject communication as a contaminating factor in verbal conditioning. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 40, 975–982.

Horka

S. T.

Farrow

B. J.

(1970). A methodological note on intersubject communication as a contaminating factor in psychological experiments. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 10, 363–366.

Kimble

G. A.

(1987). The scientific value of undergraduate research participation. American Psychologist, 42, 267–268.

Korn

J. H.

(1988). Students' roles, rights, and responsibilities as research participants. Teaching of Psychology, 15, 74–78.

Levy

L. H.

(1967). Awareness, learning, and the beneficient subject as expert witness. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 6, 365–370.

10.

Lichtenstein

(1970). Please don't talk to anyone about this experiment: Disclosure of deception by debriefed subjects. Psychological Reports, 26, 485–486.

11.

Marans

D. G.

(1988). Addressing research practitioner and subject needs: A debriefing-disclosure procedure. American Psychologist, 43, 826–827.

12.

Walsh

W. B.

Stillman

S. M.

(1974). Disclosure of deception by debriefed subjects. Journal of Counseling and Clinical Psychology, 21, 315–319.

13.

Wuebben

P. L.

(1967). Honesty of subjects and birth order. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 5, 350–352.