Unnatural Selection: Comment on the “Teaching Comparative Psychology” Symposium

Abstract

In this discussion of symposium papers, I examine why comparative psychologists do not consider professional associations of psychology to represent the core of the discipline. I review textbooks in terms of their contribution to comparative psychology and argue that psychology avoids its natural epistemology, that of natural selection and ultimate causality, in preference for the meretricious offerings provided by proximate causation. I also examine why many psychologists consider evolution to be dehumanizing and state three goals for the teaching of comparative psychology:

(a) its reliance on a central epistemological premise, (b) its demonstration of the historical ways in which comparative psychology has changed our views of human behavior, and (c) its duty to compel the student and the public to examine the ethical standing and rights of animals.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alverdes

(1927). Social life in the animal world. New York: Harcourt, Brace.

Aristotle, (1928). Metaphysics. In Ross

W. D.

(Ed. & Trans.), The works of Aristotle (Vol. 8). Oxford: Clarendon.

Baldwin

J. M.

(1902). Development and evolution. New York: Macmillan.

Bitterman

M. E.

Wodinsky

Candland

D. K.

(1958). Some comparative psychology. American Journal of Psychology, 71, 94–110.

Boring

E. G.

Langfeld

H. S.

Weld

H. P.

(1948). Foundations of psychology. New York: Wiley.

Brozek

(Ed.). (1984). Explorations in the history of psychology in the United States. Lewisburg, PA: Bucknell University Press.

Comte

(1927). Cours de philosophie positive [A course in positive philosophy]. Paris: Hachette.

Demarest

(Ed.). (1980). Comparative psychology newsletter (Vol. 1). West Long Branch, NJ: Monmouth College.

Dewsbury

D. A.

(1984). Comparative psychology in the twentieth century. Stroudsburg, PA: Hutchinson Ross.

10.

Glaser

R. D.

Thorpe

J. S.

(1986). Unethical intimacy: A survey of sexual contact and advances between psychology educators and female graduate students. American Psychologist, 41, 43–51.

11.

Grier

J. W.

(1984). Biology of animal behavior. St. Louis, MO: Times Mirror/Mosby.

12.

Gross

(1898). The play of animals. London: Chapman & Hall.

13.

Gross

(1901). The play of man. New York: Appleton.

14.

James

(1892). Psychology: Briefer course. New York: Holt.

15.

in 6 female graduate students in psychology reports having sexual contact with a professor. (1986, February 12). The Chronicle of Higher Education, p. 23.

16.

One in six graduate women report sex with professors. (1986, January 28). The New York Times, p. C3.

17.

Romanes

G. J.

(1889). Mental evolution in man. New York: Appleton.

18.

Spencer

(1896). The principles of psychology (3rd ed., Vols. I, II-1, II-2). New York: Appleton.

19.

Titchener

E. B.

(1921). A textbook of psychology. New York: Macmillan.

20.

Walker

E. P.

(1964). Mammals of the world (Vol. 1). Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.

21.

Washburn

M. F.

(1908). The animal mind: A textbook of comparative psychology. New York: Macmillan.

22.

Watson

J. B.

(1919). Psychology from the standpoint of a behaviorist. Philadelphia: Lippincott.

23.

Weld

H. P.

(1928). Psychology as science. New York: Holt.

24.

Wilson

E. O.

(1975). Sociobiology, the new synthesis. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.