Teacher Self-Ratings as a Validity Criterion for Student Evaluations

Abstract

Student ratings were validated against instructor self-ratings by assessing student—faculty agreement concerning day-to-day variability within courses. For 15 days, students and instructors in each of four courses made daily evaluations. Analysis showed that student ratings and instructor self-ratings were significantly correlated in three areas: material covered, instructor performance, and overall impressions of the success of the class. These results are consistent with those of other studies that have argued for the ability of students to provide valid course evaluations. In addition, they avoid some of the interpretive problems of other criterion measures that have been used to validate student evaluations.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Baird

J. S.

Jr. (1983). Validity and reliability of student ratings of faculty. Teaching of Psychology, 10, 46.

Bayley

D. H.

(1967). Making college teaching a profession. Improving College and University Teaching, 15, 115–119.

Blass

(1980). What do positive correlations between student grades and teacher evaluations mean? Teaching of Psychology, 7, 186–187.

Bonge

(1982). Using TA ratings to validate student evaluations: A reply to Lamberth and Kosteski. Teaching of Psychology, 9, 102.

Centra

J. A.

(1973). Self-ratings of college teachers: A comparison with student ratings. Journal of Educational Measurement, 10, 287–295.

Cohen

P. A.

(1982). Validity of student ratings in psychology courses: A research synthesis. Teaching of Psychology, 9, 78–82.

Doyle

K. O.

Jr. Crichton

L. I.

(1978). Student, peer, and self evaluations of college instructors. Journal of Educational Psychology, 70, 815–826.

Feldman

K. A.

(1976). Grades and college students' evaluations of their courses and teachers. Research in Higher Education, 4, 69–111.

Howard

G.-S.

Maxwell

S. E.

(1982). Do grades contaminate student evaluations of instruction? Research in Higher Education, 16, 175–188.

10.

Kulik

J. A.

Kulik

C-L. C.

(1974). Student ratings of instruction. Teaching of Psychology, 1, 51–57.

11.

Lamberth

Kosteski

D. M.

(1981). Student evaluations: An assessment of validity. Teaching of Psychology, 8, 8–11.

12.

Levine

J. R.

(1984). When colleagues judge colleagues. Teaching of Psychology, 11, 38–39.

13.

Marsh

Overall

J. U.

Kesler

S. P.

(1979). Validity of student evaluations of instructional effectiveness: A comparison of faculty self-evaluations and evaluations by their students. Journal of Educational Psychology, 71, 149–160.

14.

McKeachie

W. J.

(1979). Student ratings of faculty: A reprise. Academe, 65, 384–397.

15.

Roberts

A. E.

(1981). Making a “successful” course: Faculty and student perspectives. Teaching of Psychology, 8, 234–237.

16.

Rosenthal

(1978). Combining results of independent studies. Psychological Bulletin, 85, 185–193.

17.

Seldin

(1980). Successful faculty evaluation programs. New York: Coventry.