Because the perception of extensive similarity in introductory psychology textbooks is important in the textbook selection process, we examined whether this perception was accurate. We systematically reviewed extant research encompassing 6 textbook dimensions and found that perceived similarity is the product of 2 salient, easily accessible, global text variables: chapter topics and organization. Beyond these variables, textbook homogeneity disappears. We consider stereotyping due to the arduous, complex nature of the textbook selection process as an explanation for this misperception of similarity and urge teachers to consider introductory texts more thoroughly to make the best choices for their individual courses.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BoneauC. A. (1990). Psychological literacy: A first approximation. American Psychologist, 45, 891–900.
2.
FretzB. R. (1979). Different strokes or reruns?Contemporary Psychology, 24, 485–490.
3.
GorenfloD. W.McConnellJ. V. (1991). The most frequently cited journal articles and authors in introductory psychology textbooks. Teaching of Psychology, 18, 8–12.
4.
GriggsR. A. (1999). Introductory psychology textbooks: Assessing levels of difficulty. Teaching of Psychology, 26, 248–253.
5.
GriggsR. A.JacksonS. L. (1989). The introductory psychology textbook market: Perceptions of authors and editors. Teaching of Psychology, 16, 61–64.
6.
GriggsR. A.JacksonS. L.ChristopherA. N.MarekP. (1999). Introductory psychology textbooks: An objective analysis and update. Teaching of Psychology, 26, 182–189.
7.
GriggsR. A.JacksonS. L.MarekP.ChristopherA.N. (1998). Critical thinking in introductory psychology texts and supplements. Teaching of Psychology, 25, 254–266.
8.
GriggsR. A.JacksonS. L.NapolitanoT. J. (1994). Brief introductory psychology textbooks: An objective analysis. Teaching of Psychology, 21, 136–140.
9.
JacksonS. L.GriggsR. A.KoenigC. S.ChristopherA. N.MarekP. (2000). A compendium of introductory psychology texts: 1997–2000. Retrieved July 22, 2000 from the World Wide Web: http://www.lemoyne.edu/OTRP/introtexts.html.
10.
JacobsB. (1984). Are these books really different?Contemporary Psychology, 29, 464–467.
11.
KenrickD. T.NeubergS. L.CialdiniR. B. (1999). Social psychology: Unraveling the mystery.Needham Heights, MA: Allyn & Bacon.
12.
LandrumR. E. (1993). Identifying core concepts in introductory psychology. Psychological Reports, 72, 659–666.
13.
MarekP.GriggsR. A.ChristopherA. N. (1999). Pedagogical aids in textbooks: Do college students' perceptions justify their prevalence?Teaching of Psychology, 26, 11–19.
14.
McCollumK. (2000, January 14). Company plans Web-based study guides for survey-level courses. The Chronicle of Higher Education, 66, A49.
15.
PedenB.F.HausmannS.E. (2000). Data graphs in introductory and upper level psychology textbooks: A content analysis. Teaching of Psychology, 27, 93–97.
16.
ProctorD. L. (2000, January). The language of introductory psychology. Poster session presented at the meeting of the National Institute on the Teaching of Psychology, St. Petersburg Beach, FL.
17.
QuereshiM. Y. (1993). The contents of introductory psychology textbooks: A follow-up. Teaching of Psychology, 20, 218–222.
18.
QuereshiM. Y.BuchkoskiJ. E. (1979). Logical versus empirical estimates of readability and human interest of general psychology textbooks. Teaching of Psychology, 6, 202–205.
19.
ThomasJ. M. (1984). Four introductions to psychology. Contemporary Psychology, 29, 629–632.
20.
WeitenW.GuadagnoR. E.BeckC. A. (1996). Students' perceptions of textbook pedagogical aids. Teaching of Psychology, 23, 105–107.
21.
WeitenW.WightR. D. (1992). Portraits of a discipline: An examination of introductory psychology textbooks in America. In PuenteA. E.MatthewsJ. R.BrewerC. L. (Eds.), Teaching psychology in America: A history. (pp. 453–504). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
22.
WhitfordF. W. (1996). Teaching psychology: A guide for the new instructor. (2nd ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
23.
ZechmeisterJ. S.ZechmeisterE. B. (2000). Introductory textbooks and psychology's core concepts. Teaching of Psychology, 27, 6–11.
