A SSHAC Level 3 Probabilistic Seismic Hazard Analysis for a New-Build Nuclear Site in South Africa

Abstract

A probabilistic seismic hazard analysis has been conducted for a potential nuclear power plant site on the coast of South Africa, a country of low-to-moderate seismicity. The hazard study was conducted as a SSHAC Level 3 process, the first application of this approach outside North America. Extensive geological investigations identified five fault sources with a non-zero probability of being seismogenic. Five area sources were defined for distributed seismicity, the least active being the host zone for which the low recurrence rates for earthquakes were substantiated through investigations of historical seismicity. Empirical ground-motion prediction equations were adjusted to a horizon within the bedrock at the site using kappa values inferred from weak-motion analyses. These adjusted models were then scaled to create new equations capturing the range of epistemic uncertainty in this region with no strong motion recordings. Surface motions were obtained by convolving the bedrock motions with site amplification functions calculated using measured shear-wave velocity profiles.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abrahamson

N. A.

Birkhauser

Koller

Mayer-Rosa

Smit

Sprecher

Tinic

and Graf

2002. PEGASOS: A comprehensive probabilistic seismic hazard assessment for nuclear power plants in Switzerland, in Proceedings, Twelfth European Conference on Earthquake Engineering, paper 633, London.

Abrahamson

and Silva

2008. Summary of the Abrahamson & Silva NGA ground-motion relations, Earthquake Spectra 24, 67–97.

Al Atik

Abrahamson

N. A.

Bommer

J. J.

Scherbaum

Cotton

and Kuehn

2010. The variability of ground-motion prediction models and its components, Seismological Research Letters 81, 794–801.

Albini

Strasser

F. O.

and Flint

2014. Earthquakes from 1820 to 1936 in Grahamstown and surroundings (Eastern Cape Province, South Africa), Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering 12, 45–78.

Akkar

and Çağnan

2010. A local ground-motion predictive model for Turkey and its comparison with other regional and global ground-motion models, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 100, 2978–2995.

Anderson

J. G.

and Hough

S. E.

1984. A model for the shape of the Fourier amplitude spectrum of acceleration at high frequencies, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 74, 1969–1993.

Atkinson

G. M.

Bommer

J. J.

and Abrahamson

N. A.

2014. Alternative approaches to modeling epistemic uncertainty in ground motion in probabilistic seismic-hazard analysis, Seismological Research Letters 85, 1141–1144.

Bakun

W. H.

and Scotti

2006. Regional intensity attenuation models for France and the estimation of magnitude and location of historical earthquakes, Geophysical Journal International 164, 596–610.

Bakun

W. H.

and Wentworth

C. M.

1997. Estimating earthquake location and magnitude from seismic intensity data, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 87, 1502–1521.

10.

Bazzurro

and Cornell

C. A.

2004. Nonlinear soil-site effects in probabilistic seismic hazard analysis, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 94, 2110–2123.

11.

Bierman

Copppersmith

Hanson

Neveling

Portenga

and Rood

2014. A cosmogenic view of erosion, relief generation, and the age of faulting in Southern Africa, GSA Today 24, 4–11.

12.

Bommer

J. J.

2012. Challenges of building logic trees for probabilistic seismic hazard analysis, Earthquake Spectra 28, 1723–1735.

13.

Bommer

J. J.

Akkar

and Kale

Ö.

2011a. A model for the vertical-to-horizontal response spectral ratios for Europe and the Middle East, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 101, 1783–1806.

14.

Bommer

J. J.

and Coppersmith

K. J.

2013. Lessons learned from application of the NUREG-2117 guidelines for SSHAC Level 3 probabilistic seismic hazard studies for nuclear sites, in Proceedings, 22^nd International Conference on Structural Mechanics in Reactor Technology (SMiRT22), San Francisco, August 18–23 2013.

15.

Bommer

J. J.

Coppersmith

K. J.

Hattingh

and Nel

A. P.

2013a. An application of the SSHAC Level 3 process to the probabilistic seismic hazard assessment for the Thyspunt nuclear site in South Africa, in Proceedings, 22^nd International Conference on Structural Mechanics in Reactor Technology (SMiRT22), San Francisco, August 18–23 2013.

16.

Bommer

J. J.

Douglas

Scherbaum

Cotton

Bungum

and Fäh

2010. On the selection of ground-motion prediction equations for seismic hazard analysis, Seismological Research Letters 81, 794–801.

17.

Bommer

J. J.

Papaspiliou

and Price

2011b. Earthquake response spectra for seismic design of nuclear power plants in the UK, Nuclear Engineering and Design 241, 968–977.

18.

Bommer

J. J.

Stafford

P. J.

Alarcón

J. E.

and Akkar

2007. The influence of magnitude range on empirical ground-motion prediction, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 97, 2152–2170.

19.

Bommer

J. J.

Strasser

F. O.

Pagani

and Monelli

2013b. Quality assurance for logic-tree implementation in probabilistic seismic hazard analysis for nuclear applications: A practical example, Seismological Research Letters 84, 938–945.

20.

Boore

D. M.

2003. Simulation of ground motion using the stochastic method, Pure and Applied Geophysics 160, 635–676.

21.

Boore

D. M.

and Joyner

W. B.

1997. Site amplifications for generic rock sites, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 87, 327–341.

22.

Brandt

M. B. C.

2014. Focal depth of South African earthquakes and mining events, The Journal of the South African Institute of Mining and Metallurgy 114, 1–8.

23.

Brandt

M. B. C.

Bejaichund

Kgaswane

E. M.

Hattingh

and Roblin

D. L.

2005. Seismic history of South Africa, Seismological Series 37, Council for Geoscience, South Africa, 32 pp.

24.

Brandt

M. B. C.

Grand

S. P.

Nyblade

A. A.

and Dirk

P. H. G. M.

2012. Upper mantle seismic structure beneath southern Africa: Constraints on the buoyancy supporting the African Superswell, Pure and Applied Geophysics 169, 595–614.

25.

Broad

D. S.

Jungslager

E. H. A.

McLachlan

I. R.

Roux

and Van der Spuy

2012. South Africa's offshore Mesozoic basins, in Phanerozoic Passive Margins, Cratonic Basins and Global Tectonic Maps, Roberts

D. G.

and Bally

A. W.

(eds.), pp. 535–564, Elsevier, Rotterdam

26.

Brown

R. W.

Gallagher

Gleadow

A. J. W.

and Summerfield

M. A.

2000. Morphotectonic evolution of the South Atlantic margins of Africa and South America, in Geomorphology and Global Tectonics, Summerfield

M. A.

(ed.), pp. 255–280, John Wiley, New York.

27.

Budnitz

R. J.

Apostolakis

Boore

D. M.

Cluff

L. S.

Coppersmith

K. J.

Cornell

C. A.

and Morris

P. A.

1997. Recommendations for Probabilistic Seismic Hazard Analysis: Guidance on Uncertainty and Use of Experts, NUREG/CR-6372, two volumes, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, D.C.

28.

Campbell

K. W.

2003. Prediction of strong ground motion using the hybrid empirical method and its use in the development of ground-motion (attenuation) relations in eastern North America, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 93, 1012–1033.

29.

Chiou

B. S.-J.

and Youngs

R. R.

2008. An NGA model for the average horizontal component of peak ground motion and response spectra, Earthquake Spectra 24, 173–215.

30.

Choi

W. K.

2008. Dynamic properties of ash-flow tuffs. PhD Thesis, University of Texas at Austin, Austin TX.

31.

Clark

McPherson

and Collins

D. C. N.

2011. Australia's seismogenic neotectonic record: A case for heterogeneous intraplate deformation: Record 2011/11, Geoscience Australia, Canberra.

32.

Dangkua

D. T.

and Cramer

C. H.

2011. Felt intensity versus instrumental ground motion: A difference between California and Eastern North America?, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 101, 1847–1858.

33.

Darandeli

M. B.

and Stokoe

K. H.

II , 2001. Development of a New Family of Normalized Modulus Reduction and Material Damping Curves, Geotechnical Engineering Report GD01-1, University of Texas, Austin.

34.

Drouet

Souriau

and Cotton

2005. Attenuation, seismic moment, and site effects for weak-motion events: Application to the Pyrenees, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 95, 1731–1748.

35.

Ebinger

C. J.

Yemane

Harding

D. J.

Tesfaye

Kelley

and Rex

2000. Rift deflection, migration and propagation: Linkage of the Ethiopian and Eastern rifts, Africa, Geological Society of America Bulletin 112, 163–176.

36.

Edwards

Rietbrock

Bommer

J. J.

and Baptie

2008. The acquisition of source, path, and site effects from microearthquake recordings using Q tomography: Application to the United Kingdom, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 98, 1915–1935.

37.

Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI), 2013. EPRI (2004, 2006) Ground-Motion Model (GMM) Review Project, EPRI Report 3002000717, Palo Alto, CA.

38.

Erlanger

E. D.

Granger

D. E.

and Gibbon

R. J.

2012. Rock uplift rates in South Africa from isochron burial dating of fluvial and marine terraces, Geology 40, 1019–1022.

39.

Fernández

L. M.

and Guzmán

J. A.

1979. Seismic history of Southern Africa, Seismological Series 9, Geological Survey of South Africa, 22 pp.

40.

Flowers

R. M.

and Schoene

2010. (U-Th)/He thermochronometry constraints on unroofing of the eastern Kaapvaal Craton and significance for uplift of the Southern African Plateau, Geology Boulder 38, 827–830.

41.

Foster

A. N.

and Jackson

J. A.

1998. Source parameters of large African earthquake: Implications for crustal rheology and regional kinematics, Geophysical Journal International 134, 422–448.

42.

Fukushima

1996. Scaling relations for strong ground motion prediction models with M² terms, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 86, 329–336.

43.

Gardner

J. K.

and Knopoff

1974. Is the sequence of earthquakes in Southern California, with aftershocks removed, Poissonian?, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of the America 64, 1363–1367.

44.

Goedhart

M. L.

and Booth

P. W. K.

2009. Early Holocene extensional tectonics in the southeastern Cape Fold Belt, South Africa, Paper presented at Ancient Rocks to Modern Techniques, 11th South African Geophysical Association (SAGA) Biennial Technical Meeting and Exhibition, Inkaba yeAfrica Phase II workshop, 16 September, Manzini, Swaziland.

45.

Gülerce

and Abrahamson

N. A.

2011. Site-specific design spectra for vertical ground motion, Earthquake Spectra 27, 1023–1047.

46.

Johnston

A. C.

Coppersmith

K. J.

Kanter

L. R.

and Cornell

C. A.

1994. The Earthquakes of Stable Continental Regions, Final report for Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI), EPRI TR-102261, Palo Alto, CA.

47.

Kijko

2004. Estimation of the maximum earthquake magnitude, m_max, Pure and Applied Geophysics 161, 1–27.

48.

Krüger

and Scherbaum

2014. The 1969 Ceres, South Africa, intraplate earthquake: Full waveform moment tensor inversion for point source and kinematic source parameters, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 104, 576–581.

49.

Martin

A. K.

and Hartnady

C. J. H.

1986. Plate tectonic development of the southwest Indian Ocean: A revised reconstruction of East Antarctica and Africa, Journal of Geophysical Research 91, 4767–4786.

50.

McGuire

R. K.

Silva

W. J.

and Costantino

C. J.

2001. Technical Basis For Revision Of Regulatory Guidance On Design Ground Motions: Hazard- And Risk-Consistent Ground Motion Spectra Guidelines, NUREG/CR-6728, US Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, D.C.

51.

Midzi

Bommer

J. J.

Strasser

F. O.

Albini

Zulu

B. S

Prasad

and Flint

2013. An intensity database for earthquakes in South Africa from 1912 to 2011, Journal of Seismology 17, 1183–1205.

52.

Midzi

Hlatywayo

D. J.

Chapola

L. S.

Kebede

Atakan

Lombe

D. K.

Turyomurugyendo

and Tugume

F. A.

1999. Seismic hazard assessment in Eastern and Southern Africa, Annali di Geofisica 42, 1067–1083.

53.

Morgan

W. J.

1983. Hotspot tracks and early rifting of the Atlantic, Tectonophysics 94, 123–139.

54.

Musson

R. M. W.

2009. MEEP 2.0 User Guide, Earth Hazards and Systems Programme Open Report OR/09/045, British Geological Survey, 16 pp.

55.

Park

2013. MASW for geotechnical site investigation, The Leading Edge 32, 936–942.

56.

Portenga

E. W.

and Bierman

2011. Understanding Earth's eroding surface with¹⁰Be, GSA Today 21, 4–10.

57.

Rathje

E. M.

and Ozbey

M. C.

2006. Site specific validation of random vibration theory-based site response analysis, Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, ASCE, 132, 911–922.

58.

Rodriguez-Marek

Rathje

E. M.

Bommer

J. J.

Scherbaum

and Stafford

P. J.

2014. Application of single-station sigma and site-response characterization in a probabilistic seismic-hazard analysis for a new nuclear site, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 104, 1601–1619.

59.

Sandıkkaya

M. A.

Yılmaz

M. T.

Bakır

B. S.

and Yılmaz

Ö.

2010. Site classification of Turkish national strong-motion stations, Journal of Seismology 14, 543–563.

60.

Saunders

Brandt

Steyn

Robin

and Kijko

2008. The South African National Seismograph Network, Seismological Research Letters 79, 203–210.

61.

Saunders

Ottemöller

Brandt

M. B. C.

and Fourie

C. J. S.

2013. Calibration of an M_L scale for South Africa using tectonic earthquake data recorded by the South African National Seismograph Network: 2006 to 2009, Journal of Seismology 17, 437–451.

62.

Scharf

Codilean

A. T.

de Wit

M. J.

Jansen

J. D.

and Kubik

P. W.

2013. Strong rocks sustain ancient postorogenic topography in southern Africa, Geology 41, 21 pp., including supplementary material, doi: 10.1130/G33806.1

63.

Schnabel

P. B.

1973. Effect of Local Geology and Distance From Source on Earthquake Ground Motions, Ph.D. Dissertation, University of California, Berkeley.

64.

Scherbaum

Kuehn

N. M.

Ohrnberger

and Koehler

2010. Exploring the proximity of ground-motion models using high-dimensional visualization techniques, Earthquake Spectra 26, 1117–1138

65.

Stepp

J. C.

Wong

Whitney

Quittmeyer

Abrahamson

Toro

Youngs

Coppersmith

Savy

Sullivan

, and Yucca Mountain PSHA Project Members, 2001. Probabilistic seismic hazard analyses for ground motions and fault displacements at Yucca Mountain, Nevada, Earthquake Spectra 17, 113–151.

66.

Strasser

F. O.

Albini

Beauval

and Flint

2015. 20th century seismicity of the Koffiefontein region (Free State, South Africa): Consistent determination of earthquake catalogue parameters from mixed data types, Journal of Seismology, accepted for publication.

67.

Tezel

Shibutani

and Kaypak

2010. Crustal structure variation in western Turkey from receiver function analyses, Tectonophysics 492, 240–252.

68.

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (USNRC), 2007. A Performance-Based Approach to Define the Site-Specific Earthquake Ground Motion, Regulatory Guide 1.208, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, D.C.

69.

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (USNRC), 2012a. Central and Eastern United States Seismic Source Characterization for Nuclear Facilities, NUREG-2115, US Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, D.C.

70.

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (USNRC), 2012b. Practical Implementation Guidelines for SSHAC Level 3 and 4 Hazard Studies, NUREG 2117, US Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, D.C.

71.

Van Houtte

Drouet

and Cotton

2011. Analysis of the origins of κ (kappa) to compute hard rock to rock adjustments factors for GMPEs, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 101, 2926–2941.

72.

Vanmarcke

E. H.

1976. Structural response to earthquakes, in Seismic Risk and Engineering Decisions, Lomnitz

, and Rosenbleuth

(Eds.), Elsevier, Amsterdam.

73.

Veneziano

and Van Dyck

1985. Statistical discrimination of aftershocks and their contribution to seismic hazard, in Seismic Hazard Methodology for Nuclear Facilities in the Eastern U.S., Volume 2, Appendix A-4, EPRI/SOG Draft 85-1.

74.

Weichert

D. H.

1980. Estimation of the earthquake recurrence parameters for unequal observation periods for different magnitudes, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 70, 1337–1346.