Lessons from the Behavior of a Monitored 11-Story Building during the 2011 Tohoku Earthquake for Robustness against Design Uncertainties

Abstract

Specifically detailed pin-supported walls with steel dampers have been used to seismically strengthen an 11-story steel reinforced concrete building. By looking at the observed damage and monitored motions of the building during the M9.0 Tohoku earthquake in 2011, it is demonstrated that nonstructural reinforced concrete partition walls have had a major effect on its seismic behavior during the earthquake, the neglect of which constitutes a major design uncertainty. A finite element model used to assist the retrofit design is calibrated, taking advantage of the accelerograms obtained during the earthquake. The results of nonlinear time-history analysis investigations with the modified model identify both the positive and negative effects of the nonstructural walls at various ground motion intensities, and suggest that the pin-supported wall-frame system exhibits higher robustness against both record-to-record and modeling uncertainties than its bare-frame counterpart does.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Architectural Institute of Japan (AIJ), 1997. Report on the Hanshin-Awaji Earthquake Disaster-Building Series Volume 1: Structural Damage to Reinforced Concrete Building (in Japanese).

Architectural Institute of Japan (AIJ), 1999. Design Guidelines for Earthquake Resistant Reinforced Concrete Buildings based on Inelastic Displacement Concept (in Japanese).

Akiyama

and Takahashi

1986. Generalization of damage-dispersing type multi-story frames, Journal of Structural and Construction Engineering, Transaction of AIJ, 365, 20–27 (in Japanese).

Alavi

and Krawinkler

2004. Strengthening of moment-resisting frame structures against near-fault ground motion effects, Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamics 33, 707–720.

Asahi Kasei Construction Materials (Asahi Kasei), 2013. Hebel Lite, Web page, http://www.asahikasei-kenzai.com/akk/hebel/structure/original/hrc.html (last accessed 23 September 2013) (in Japanese).

Chaker

A. A.

and Cherifati

1999. Influence of masonry infill panels on the vibration and stiffness characteristics of R/C frame buildings, Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamics 28, 1061–1065.

Gulec

C. K.

Whittaker

A. S.

and Stojadinovic

2008. Shear strength of squat rectangular reinforced concrete walls, ACI Structural Journal 105, 488–497.

Haselton

C. B.

Goulet

C. A.

Mitrani-Reiser

Beck

J. L.

Deierlein

G. G.

Porter

K. A.

Stewart

J. P.

and Taciroglu

2008. An Assessment to Benchmark the Seismic Performance of a Code-Conforming Reinforced Concrete Moment-Frame Building, PEER Report 2007/12, 304–324.

Hashemi

and Mosalam

K. M.

2006. Shake-table experiment on reinforced concrete structure containing masonry infill wall, Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamics 35, 1827–1852.

10.

Hirano

Midorikawa

Miura

Motoyui

and Wada

2011. Seismic behavior of SRC building retrofitted by rocking wall: Part 1. Change of natural period of building, Summaries of Technical Papers of the AIJ Annual Meeting B2, 347–348 (in Japanese).

11.

Hitaka

and Imadzu

2008. Seismic behavior of R/C non-structural walls, in Proc. 14th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, CD-ROM, Beijing.

12.

and Xiang

W. Z.

2011. Effective stiffness of squat structural wall, Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE, 137, 1470–1479.

13.

Miura

Midorikawa

Hirano

Motoyui

and Wada

2011. Seismic behavior of SRC building retrofitted by rocking wall: Part 2. Seismic behavior during the 2011 Tohoku earthquake, Summaries of Technical Papers of the AIJ Annual Meeting B2, 349–350 (in Japanese).

14.

Negro

and Colombo

1997. Irregularities induced by nonstructural masonry panels in framed buildings, Engineering Structures 19, 576–585.

15.

Pujol

and Fick

2010. The test of a full-scale three-story RC structure with masonry infill walls, Engineering Structures 32, 3113–3121.

16.

2010. Study on Seismic Damage Mechanism Control and Design of Rocking Wall-Frame Structures, Ph.D. Thesis, Tsinghua University, Beijing, 11–25 (in Chinese).

17.

Wada

Motoyui

Sakada

and Kishiki

2012. Pin-supported walls for enhancing the seismic performance of building structures, Earthquake Engineering & Structural Dynamics 41, 2075–2091.

18.

Sezen

Whittaker

A. S.

Elwood

K. J.

and Mosalam

K. M.

2003. Performance of reinforced concrete buildings during the August 17, 1999 Kocaeli, Turkey earthquake, and seismic design and construction practice in Turkey, Engineering Structures 25, 103–114.

19.

Stavridis

Koutromanos

and Shing

P. B.

2012. Shake-table tests of a three-story reinforced concrete frame with masonry infill walls, Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamics 41, 1089–1108.

20.

Sugiyama

Matsuzaki

and Nakano

2004. Design for structural performances of reinforced concrete frame with cast-in-place non-structural reinforced concrete walls, in Proc. 13th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Paper No. 1277, CD-ROM, Vancouver, BC, Canada.

21.

The Japan Building Disaster Prevention Association, 2001. Guideline of Seismic Retrofit Design of Existing Reinforced Concrete Buildings, Tokyo, 64–74 (in Japanese).

22.

Villaverde

1991. Explanation for the numerous upper floor collapses during the 1985 Mexico City earthquake, Earthquake Engineering & Structural Dynamics 20, 223–241.

23.

Wood

S. L.

1990. Shear strength of low-rise reinforced concrete walls, ACI Structural Journal 87, 99–107.

24.

Zhao

Taucer

and Rossetto

2009. Field investigation on the performance of building structures during the 12 May 2008 Wenchuan earthquake in China, Engineering Structures 31, 1707–1723.