Developmental toxicity studies are designed to assess the potential adverse effects
of an exposure on developing fetuses. Safe dose levels can be determined using
dose-response modelling. To this end, it is important to investigate the effect of
misspecifying the dose-response model on the safe dose. Since classical polynomial
predictors are often of poor quality, there is a clear need for alternative
specifications of the predictors, such as fractional polynomials. By means of
simulations, we will show how fractional polynomial predictors may resolve possible
model misspecifications and may thus yield more reliable estimates of the benchmark doses.
Aerts M
,
Declerck L
,
Molenberghs G
(1997)
Likelihood misspecification and safe dose determination for clustered
binary data
. Environmetrics, 8,
613-627
.
2.
Aerts M
,
Geys H
,
Molenberghs G
,
Ryan L
(2002) Topics in modelling of clustered data.
London: CRC Press
.
3.
Altham PME
(1978)
Two generalizations of the binomial distribution
. Applied Statistics, 27,
162-167
.
4.
Cox DR
(1972)
The analysis of multivariate binary data
. Applied Statistics, 21,
113-120
.
5.
Cox DR
,
Wermuth N
(1994)
A note on the quadratic exponential binary distribution
. Biometrika, 81,
403-408
.
6.
Crump KS
,
Howe RB
(1983) A review of methods for calculating statistical
confidence limits in low dose extrapolation. In
Clayson DB
,
Krewki D
,
Mundro I
eds. Toxicological Risk Assessment. Volume I: Biological and Statistical
Criteria.
Boca Raton: CRC Press
, 187-203.
7.
Crump KS
(1984)
A new method for determining allowable daily intakes
. Fundamental and Applied Toxicology, 4,
854-871
.
8.
Davidian M
,
Giltinan DM
(1995) Nonlinear models for repeated measurement data.
London: Chapman and Hall
.
9.
Declerck L
,
Molenberghs G
,
Aerts M
,
Ryan L
(2000)
Litter-based methods in developmental toxicity risk assessment
. Environmental and Ecological Statistics, 7,
57-76
.
10.
Kimmel GL
,
Gaylor DW
(1988)
Issues in qualitative and quantitative risk analysis for developmental toxicology
. Risk Analysis, 8,
15-20
.
11.
Kupper LL
,
Portier C
,
Hogan MD
,
Yamamoto E
(1986)
The impact of litter effects on dose-response modeling in teratology
. Biometrics, 34,
69-76
.
12.
Molenberghs G
,
Declerck L
,
Aerts M
(1998)
Misspecifying the likelihood for clustered binary data
. Computational Statistics and Data Analysis, 26,
327-350
.
13.
Molenberghs G
,
Ryan LM
(1999)
An exponential family model for clustered multivariate binary data
. Environmetrics, 10,
279-300
.
14.
Morgan BJT
(1992) Analysis of quantal response data.
London: Chapman and Hall
.
15.
Price CJ
,
Kimmel CA
,
Tyl RW
,
Marr MC
(1985)
The developmental toxicity of ethylene glycol in rats and mice
. Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology, 81,
113-127
.
16.
Price CJ
,
Kimmel CA
,
George JD
,
Marr MC
(1987)
The developmental toxicity of diethylene glycol in mice
. Fundamental and Applied Toxicology, 8,
115-126
.
17.
Rotnitzky A
,
Wypij D
(1994)
A note on the bias of estimators with missing data
. Biometrics, 50,
1163-1170
.
18.
Royston P
,
Altman DG
(1994)
Regression using fractional polynomials of continuous covariates:
parsimonious parametric modelling
. Applied Statistics, 43,
429-467
.
19.
Sauerbrei W
,
Royston P
(1999)
Building multivariate prognostic and diagnostic models: transformation of
the predictors by using fractional polynomials
. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A,
162,
71-94
.
20.
Scientific Committee of the Food Safety Council
(1980)
Proposed system for food safety assessment
. Food and Cosmetic Toxicology, 16, (Supplement
2),
1-136
(1978). Revised report published June 1980 by the
Food Safety Council, Washington, DC
.
21.
Skellam JG
(1948)
A probability distribution derived from the binomial distribution by
regarding the probability of success as variable between the sets of trials
. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B,
10,
257-261
.
22.
Williams DA
(1975)
The analysis of binary responses from toxicology experiments involving
reproduction and teratogenicity
. Biometrics, 38,
150-150
.
23.
Williams PL
,
Ryan LM
(1996) Dose—response models for developmental
toxicology. In
Hood RD
ed. Handbook of developmental toxicology.
New York: CRC Press
, 635-666.
