This paper uses the experience of a recent programme of action research in Eastern
India to reflect on the use of participatory ideals within governance reform. In a
situation where there are profound difficulties in local governance, it assesses the
potential for participatory forms of stakeholder engagement to begin a process of
reform. It criticizes views of reform put forward by both the World Bank and Robert
Chambers, and argues instead that critical self-reflection and the construction of
alliances among a variety of reform-minded actors are important first steps in
building political capabilities to challenge structural blockages to pro-poor governance.
Blackburn, J.
and
Holland, J.
editors 1998: Who changes? Institutionalizing participation
in development.
London: Intermediate Technology Publications
.
2.
Chambers, R.1994:
Participatory Rural Appraisal (PRA): challenges, potentials and paradigm
. World Development22(10),
1437-1454
.
3.
Chambers, R.1997: Whose reality counts?: Putting the first last.
London: IT Publications
.
4.
Chambers, R.2001:
The World Development Report: concepts, content, and a chapter 12
. Journal of International Development13(3),
299-306
.
5.
Cleaver, F.2001: Institutions, agency and the limitations of participatory
research. In
Cooke, B.
and
Kothari, U.
, editors, Participation: the new tyranny?London: Zed Books
.
6.
Cooke, B.
and
Kothari, U.
, editors 2001: Participation: the new tyranny?London: Zed Books
.
7.
Corbridge, S.
,
Williams, G.
,
Srivastava, M.
and
Véron, R.2002: Brainstorming, modified logframes and the conversion of
research hypotheses into field questions: reflections from Eastern India (mimeo).
8.
Francis, P.2001: Participatory development at the World Bank: the primacy of
process. In
Cooke, B.
and
Kothari, U.
, editors, Participation: the new tyranny?London: Zed Books
.
9.
Grindle, M.1997:
Divergent cultures? When public organizations perform well in developing countries
. World Development25(4),
481-495
.
10.
Guijt, I.
and
Shah, M.
, editors 1998: The myth of community: gender issues in
participatory development.
London: Intermediate Technology Publications
.
11.
Henkel, H.
and
Stirrat, R.2001: Participation as spiritual duty; empowerment as secular
subjection. In
Cooke, B.
and
Kothari, U.
, editors, Participation: the new tyranny?London: Zed Books
.
12.
Holland, J.
and
Blackburn, J.
, editors 1998: Whose voice? Participatory research and policy
change.
London: Intermediate Technology Publications
.
13.
Hubbard, M.2001:
Attacking poverty - a strategic dilemma for the World Bank
. Journal of International Development13(3),
293-298
14.
Johnson, H.
and
Wilson, G.2000:
Biting the bullet: civil society, social learning and the transformation of
local governance
. World Development28(11),
1891-1906
15.
Kapoor, I.2002:
The devil’s in the theory: a critical assessment of Robert
Chambers’ work on participatory development
. Third World Quarterly23(1)
101-117
.
16.
Kohli, A.1990: Democracy and discontent: India’s growing crisis of
governability.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
17.
Kothari, U.2001: Power, knowledge and social control in participatory
development. In
Cooke, B.
and
Kothari, U.
, editors, Participation: the new tyranny?London: Zed Books
.
18.
Mitra, S.2001: Making local government work: local elites, panchayati raj
and governance in India. In
Kohli, A.
, editor, The success of India’s democracy.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
19.
Mohan, G.
and
Stokke, K.2000:
Participatory development and empowerment: the dangers of localism
. Third World Quarterly21(2),
247-268
.
20.
and
World Bank, Washington DC
.
21.
Mosse, D.1994:
Authority, gender and knowledge: theoretical reflections on the practice of
participatory rural appraisal
. Development and Change25,
497-526
.
22.
Mosse, D.2001: ‘People’s knowledge’,
participation and patronage: operations and representations in rural
development. In
Cooke, B.
and
Kothari, U.
, editors, Participation: the new tyranny?London: Zed Books
.
23.
Nelson, N.
and
Wright, S.
, editors 1995: Power and participatory development: theory
and practice.
London, IT Publications
.
24.
Rahnema, M.1992: Participation. In
Sachs, W.
, editor, The development dictionary: a guide to knowledge as
power.
London: Zed Books
.
25.
Srivastava, M.
,
Corbridge, S.
,
Véron, R.
and
Williams, G.2001a: Making sense of the local state: the employment assurance
scheme in Eastern India (mimeo).
26.
Srivastava, M.
,
Williams, G.
,
Corbridge, S.
and
Véron, R.2001b: Building a pro-poor state-society partnership: a search for
pathways. Final Report (Bihar),
Enhancing Pro-Poor Governance in West Bengal and Bihar Project
, DFID contract CNTR 001533 (mimeo).
27.
Véron, R.Corbridge, S.
,
Williams, G.
and
Srivastava, M.2002:
The everyday state and political society in Eastern India: structuring
access to the employment assurance scheme
. Journal of Development Studies39(5).
28.
Wade, R. H.2001:
Making the world development report 2000: attacking poverty
. World Development29(8),
1435-1441
.
29.
Williams, G.
,
Véron, R.
,
Corbridge, S.
and
Srivastava, M.2002: Poverty, participation and power: poor people’s
engagement with India’s Employment Assurance Scheme (mimeo).
30.
World Bank2000: World development report 2000/2001: attacking poverty.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
