Insofar as gender is still so often equated with women alone, the move from Women in
Development to Gender in Development has changed very little. Men as a human
category have always been present, involved, consulted, obeyed and disobeyed in
development work. Yet men as a gendered category in a feminist sense - involving
unequal power relations between men and women and between men - have rarely been
drawn into development programmes in any substantial way. This paper addresses
conceptual and operational obstacles to men’s involvement in gender and
development, drawing on interviews with over 40 representatives of development
organizations in Britain and the USA in 1999.
Barker, G.1997: Emerging global trends related to the role of men and
families. Briefing notes for a Brown Bag Discussion organised by the
Chapin Hall Center for Children at the University of Chicago
, October.
2.
Budowski, M.
and
Guzmán, L.
1998:
Strategic gender interests in social policy: empowerment training for
female heads of household in Costa Rica
. Paper prepared for the International Sociological Association
XIV World Congress of Sociology, Montreal,
26 July-1 August.
3.
Campbell, C.1997:
Migrancy, masculine identities and AIDS: the psychosocial context of HIV
transmission on the South African gold mines
. Social Science and Medicine45(2),
273-281
.
4.
Castells, M.1997: The power of identity.
Oxford: Blackwell
.
5.
Chant, S.1997: Women-headed households: diversity and dynamics in the
developing world.
Houndmills, Basingstoke: Macmillan
.
6.
Chant, S.2000a:
From ‘woman-blind’ to ‘man-kind’:
should men have more space in gender and development?IDS Bulletin31(2),
7-17
.
7.
Chant, S.2000b:
Men in crisis? Reflections on masculinities, work and family in northwest
Costa Rica
. European Journal of Development Research12(2),
199-218
.
8.
Chant, S.
and
Gutmann, M. C.2000: Mainstreaming men into gender and development: debates,
reflections, and experiences.
Oxford: Oxfam
.
9.
Chant, S.
and
McIlwaine, C.1998: Three generations, two genders, one world: women and men in a
changing century.
London: Zed
.
10.
Connell, R. W.1997: Gender and power: society, the person and sexual
politics.
Stanford: Stanford University Press
.
11.
Corner, L.1996: Women, men and economics: the gender-differentiated effects of
macro-economics.
New York: UNIFEM
.
12.
Cornwall, A.1998: Gender, participation and the politics of
difference. In
Guijt, I.
and
Kaul Shah, M.
, editors, The myth of community: gender issues in participatory
development.
London: Intermediate Technology Publications
, 46-57.
13.
Cornwall, A.2000:
Missing men? Reflections on men, masculinities and gender in GAD
. IDS Bulletin31(2),
18-27
.
14.
Cornwall, A.
and
White, S.2000:
Men, masculinities and development: politics, policies and practice
. IDS Bulletin31(2),
1-6
.
15.
de Keijzer, B. 1998: El Varón como Factor de Riesgo, Familias y
Relaciones de Género en Transformación: Cambios
Trascendentales en América Latina. Mexico City: Population Council/EDAMAX.
16.
Escobar Latapí, A.1998:
Los hombres y sus historias: reestructuración y masculinidad en México
. La Ventana5,
122-173
.
17.
Färnsveden, U. and Rönquist, A. 1999: Why men? A pilot
study of the existing attitudes among SIDA’s staff towards male
participation in the promotion of gender equality in development. Unpublished
Masters dissertation, Peace and Development Research Institute, Göteborg
University, Sweden.
18.
Foreman, M.1999: AIDS and men: taking risks or taking responsibility.
London: Panos Institute
.
19.
Greig, A.
,
Kimmel, M.
and
Lang, J.2000: Men, masculinities and development: broadening our work
towards gender equality. Monograph No. 10.
New York: UNDP/GIDP
.
20.
Güendel, L.
and
González, M.1998: Integration, human rights and social policy in the context
of human poverty. In
UNICEF
, editor, Adolescence, child rights and urban poverty in Costa
Rica.
San José: UNICEF/HABITAT
, 17-31.
21.
Gutmann, M. C.1996: The meanings of macho: being a man in Mexico City.
Berkeley, CA: University of California Press
.
22.
Gutmann, M. C.1998. Mamitis and the traumas of development in a Colonia Popular
of Mexico City. In
Scheper-Hughes, N.
and
Sargent, C.
, editors, Small wars: the cultural politics of childhood.
Berkeley, CA: University of California Press
, 130-148.
23.
Gutmann, M.C. 1999: A manera de conclusión: solteras y hombres,
cambio e historia. In González de la Rocha, M., editor, Divergencias del
modelo tradicional: hogares de jefatura femenina en América Latina.
Mexico City: CIESAS, 163-72.
24.
Harrison, E.1997: Fish, feminists and the FAO: translating
‘gender’ through different institutions in the development
process. In
Marie Goetz, A.
, editor, Getting institutions right for women in development.
London: Zed
, 61-74.
25.
International Planned Parenthood Federation (IPPF)1996: Africa link: just for men: involving men in sexual and
reproductive health programmes.
London: IPPF
.
26.
Jahan, R.1995: The elusive agenda: mainstreaming women in development.
London: Zed
.
27.
Jiménez, R. 1996: Adiós al patriarca. In Instituto
Latinamericano de Naciones Unidas para la Prevención y Tratamiento del
Delincuente (ILANUD), Construcción de la identidad masculina. San
José: ILANUD, 43-46.
28.
Kabeer, N.
and
Subrahmanian, R.1996: Institutions, relations and outcomes: framework and tools for
gender-aware planning. Discussion Paper No.357.
Brighton: Institute of Development Studies
University of Sussex
.
29.
Kajifusa, H. 1998: Towards mainstreaming gender issues in development
institutions: the possibilities and limitations of men’s involvement in
WID/GAD. Unpublished MSc dissertation. Brighton: Institute of Development Studies
University of Sussex.
30.
Kaztman, R.1992:
Por qué los hombres son tan irresponsables?Revista de la CEPAL46,
1-9
.
31.
Large, J.1997: Disintegration conflicts and the restructuring of
masculinity. In
Sweetman, C.
, editor, Men and masculinity.
Oxford: Oxfam
, 23-30.
32.
Levy, C.1992:
Gender and the environment: the challenge of cross-cutting issues in
development policy and planning
. Environment and Urbanisation4(1),
134-149
.
33.
Levy, C.1996: The process of institutionalising gender in policy and
planning: the ‘web’ of institutionalisation. Working
Paper No. 74.
London: Development Planning Unit, University
College London
.
34.
Lumsden, I.1996: Machos, maricones and gays: Cuba and homosexuality.
Philadelphia/London: Temple University
Press/Latin America Bureau
.
35.
MacDonald, M.
,
Sprenger, E.
and
Dubel, I.1997: Gender and organisational change: bridging the gap between
policy and practice.
Amsterdam: Royal Tropical Institute
.
36.
Montoya Tellería, O. 1998: Nadando contra corriente: buscando
pistas para prevenir la violencia masculina en las relaciones de pareja. Managua:
Puntos de Encuentro.
37.
Moore, H.1994: Is there a crisis in the family? Occasional Paper 3,
World Summit for Social Development.
Geneva: UNRISD
.
38.
Morrell, R.2001: The times of change: men and masculinity in South
Africa. In
Morrell, R.
, editor, Changing men in Southern Africa.
Pietermaritzburg/London: University of Natal Press/Zed
, 3-37.
39.
Moser, C.
and
McIlwaine, C.1999: A guideline on conceptual and methodological issues for
designing and analysing the results of participatory urban appraisals, PUAs, in
the context of violence.
Mimeo. Washington DC: LCSES, World Bank
.
40.
Neaz, A.1996: Converting Bangladesh’s influential religious
leaders. In International Planned Parenthood Federation (IPPF),
Challenges: men’s needs and responsibilities.
London: IPPF
, 38-40.
41.
Obote Joshua, M.2001: Gender training with men: experiences and reflections from
East Africa. In
Sweetman, C.
, editor, Men’s involvement in gender and development policy
and practice.
Oxford: Oxfam
, 35-43.
42.
Pineda, J.2000:
Partners in women-headed households: emerging masculinities
. European Journal of Development Research12(2),
72-92
.
43.
Porter, F.
,
Smyth, I.
and
Sweetman, C.1999: Introduction. In
Porter, F.
,
Smyth, I.
and
Sweetman, C.
, editors, Gender works: Oxfam experience in policy and practice.
Oxford: Oxfam
, 1-13.
44.
Quesada, E. 1996: La masculinidad patriarcal y el anhelo de poder. In
Instituto Latinamericano de Naciones Unidas para la Prevención y
Tratamiento del Delincuente (ILANUD), Construcción de la Identidad
Masculina. San José: ILANUD, 47-49.
45.
Rathgeber, E.1995: Gender and development in action. In
Marchand, M.
and
Parpart, J.
, editors, Feminism/postmodernism/development.
London: Routledge
, 204-220.
46.
Rivera Fuentes, C.1996: Todas locas, todas vivas, todas libres: Chilean lesbians
1980-95. In
Reinfelder, M.
, editor, Amazon to Zami: towards a global lesbian feminism.
London: Cassell
, 138-151.
47.
Safa, H.1995: The myth of the male breadwinner: women and industrialization
in the Caribbean.
Boulder, CO: Westview
.
48.
Safa, H.1999: Women coping with crisis: social consequences of export-led
industrialization in the Dominican Republic. North-South Agenda Paper No.
36.
Miami FL: North-South Center, University of Miami
.
49.
Safilios-Rothschild, C.1990: Socio-economic determinants of the outcomes of
women’s income-generation in developing countries. In
Stichter, S.
and
Parpart, J.
, editors, Women, employment and the family in the international division
of labour.
Houndmills, Basingstoke: Macmillan
, 221-228.
50.
Silberschmidt, M.1999: ‘Women forget that men are the masters’:
gender, antagonism and socioeconomic change in Kisii District, Kenya.
Uppsala: The Nordic Africa Institute
.
51.
Sternberg, P.2001: Challenging machismo to promote sexual and reproductive
health: working with Nicaraguan men. In
Sweetman, C.
, editor, Men’s involvement in gender and development policy
and practice.
Oxford: Oxfam
, 59-67.
52.
Sweetman, C.1997: Editorial. In
Sweetman, C.
, editor, Men and masculinity.
Oxford: Oxfam
, 2-6.
53.
Sweetman, C.
1998:
‘Sitting on a rock’: integrating men and masculinities
into gender and development
. Paper presented at ESRC Seminar ‘Men, Masculinities
and Gender Relations in Development’, Development Project and Planning
Centre, University of Bradford, 8-9 September.
54.
Sweetman, C.
, editor, 2001: Men’s involvement in gender and
development policy and practice: beyond rhetoric.
Oxford: Oxfam
.
55.
Tadele, F.1999: Men in the kitchen, women in the office? Working on gender
issues in Ethiopia. In
Porter, F.
,
Smyth, I.
and
Sweetman, C.
, editors, Gender works: Oxfam experience in policy and practice.
Oxford: Oxfam
, 31-36.
56.
United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF)1997: The role of men in the lives of children.
New York: UNICEF
.
57.
United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation (UNESCO)1997: Male roles and masculinities in the perspective of a culture
of peace. Report, Expert Group Meeting, Oslo, Norway, 24-28 September.
Paris: UNESCO
.
58.
Wasser, N.2001: Male involvement in perpetuating and challenging the
practice of female genital mutilation in Egypt. In
Sweetman, C.
, editor, Men’s involvement in gender and development policy
and practice: beyond rhetoric.
Oxford: Oxfam
, 44-51.
59.
Wegner, M. N.
,
Landry, E.
,
Wilkinson, D.
and
Tzanis, J.1998:
Men as partners in reproductive health: from issues to action
. Family Planning Perspectives24(1),
1-9
.
60.
White, S. C.1994: Making men an issue: gender planning for the other
half. In
MacDonald, M.
, editor, Gender planning in development agencies: meeting the
challenge.
Oxford: Oxfam
, 98-110.
61.
White, S. C.2000:
‘Did the Earth move?’ The hazards of bringing men and
masculinities into gender and development
. IDS Bulletin31(2),
33-41
.
62.
Whitehead, A.2000:
Continuities and discontinuities in political constructions of the working
man in rural Sub-Saharan Africa: The ‘lazy man’ in
African agriculture
. European Journal of Development Research12(2),
23-52
.
63.
Wood, K.
and
Jewkes, R.1997: Violence, rape and sexual coercion: everyday love in a
South African township. In
Sweetman, C.
, editor, Men and masculinity.
Oxford: Oxfam
, 41-46.
