The pregnancy of a 12-year-old girl provides the basis for a consideration of approaches to a dilemma brought about by conflicting expectations. Here, medical opinion is to reject action implied by the lack of Gillick competence and by a ‘parental responsibility’ claim adopted by the girl’s mother. Construction of the dilemma and the subsequent process, which sought resolution, illustrates that the Gillick ruling, and other guidelines intended to be helpful, can prove to be less so.
Gillick v. West Norfolk and Wisbech AHA 1986 AC 112
2.
Department of Health . Seeking consent: working with children . DoH, 2001: 18-18 .
3.
Dickenson D , Fulford KWM.In two minds: a casebook of psychiatric ethics. Oxford University Press , 2000: 27-27.
4.
The Children Act 1989: 5. 3 (1). HMSO, 1989.
5.
Hope RA , Fulford KWM.Medical education: patients, principles and practice skills. In: Gillon R ed. Principles of health care ethics. Wiley , 1993: 27-28.
6.
The Abortion Act 1967. HMSO, 1967.
7.
The Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 1990. HMSO, 1967.
8.
Lifton RJ.The Nazi doctors: medical killing and the psychology of genocide. Papermac (Macmillan) , 1987.
9.
Re W (a minor) (medical treatment) 1992 4 All ER 627
