Practising Virtue: A challenge to the view that a virtue centred approach to ethics lacks practical content

Abstract

A virtue centred approach to ethics has been criticized for being vague owing to the nature of its central concept, the paradigm person. From the perspective of the practitioner the most damaging charge is that virtue ethics fails to be action guiding and, in addition to this, it does not offer any means of act appraisal. These criticisms leave virtue ethics in a weak position vis-à-vis traditional approaches to ethics. The criticism is, however, challenged by Hursthouse in her analysis of the accounts of right action offered by deontology, utilitarianism and virtue ethics. It is possible to defend the action guiding nature of virtue ethics: there are virtue rules and exemplars to guide action. Insights from Aristotle’s practical approach to ethics are considered alongside Hursthouse’s analysis and it is suggested that virtue ethics is also capable of facilitating action appraisal. It is at the same time acknowledged that approaches to virtue ethics vary widely and that the challenges offered here would be rejected by those who embrace a radical replacement virtue approach.

Keywords

action guidance midwifery nursing practical ethics professional conduct virtue ethics

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Hursthouse R. On virtue ethics. Oxford: Oxford University Press , 1999.

Benn P. Ethics. London: UCL Press , 1998.

Anscombe GEM. Modern moral philosophy . Philosophy 1958; 33: 1-19 .

Watson G. On the primacy of character. In: Flanagan O , Rorty A eds. Identity, character and morality. Cambridge: MIT Press , 1990: 449-469.

MacIntyre A. After virtue: a study in moral theory, second edition. London: Duckworth , 1985: 121-164.

Barnes J. Aristotle. (Past masters series.) Oxford: Oxford University Press , 1996.

Solomon R. Corporate roles, personal virtues . Business Ethics Quarterly 1992; 2(3): [pagination not available].

Kupperman J. Character and ethical theory . Midwest Studies in Philosophy 1988; 13: 115-125 .

McDowell J. Virtue and reason . The Monist 1979; 62: 331-350 .

10.

Pellegrino ED. Towards a virtue-based normative ethics for health professions . Kennedy Inst Ethics J 1975; 5: 253-277 .

11.

Dreier J. Structures of normative theories . The Monist 1993; 76: 22-40 .

12.

Statman D. ed. Virtue ethics: a critical reader. (Introduction) Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press , 1997: 1-41.

13.

Hursthouse R. Virtue theory and abortion . Philosophy and Public Affairs 1991; 20: 223-246 .

14.

Peterson S. Apparent circularity in Aristotle’s account of right action in the Nicomachean Ethics . Apeiron, 1992; (Jun): [pagination not available].

15.

Santas G.

The structure of Aristotle’s ethical theory - is it teleological or a virtue ethics?

TOPOI 1996; 15: 59-80 .

16.

Kristjansson K. Virtue ethics and emotional conflict . Am Philos Q 2000; 37(3): 193-207 .

17.

van Zyl L. Death and compassion. Aldershot: Ashgate , 2000.

18.

Cited in: Statman D ed. Virtue ethics: a critical reader. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press , 1997: 145-164.

19.

Urmson JO. Aristotle’s ethics. Oxford: Blackwell , 1998.

20.

Williams B. A critique of utilitarianism. In: Smart JJC , Williams B eds. Utilitarianism: for and against. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press , 1973 [pagination not available].

21.

Hauerwas S. Toward an ethic of character . Theological Studies 1972; 33: 698-715 .

22.

Nagel T. Mortal questions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press , 1979.

23.

Sher G. Ethics character and action . Social Philosophy and Policy 1998; 15(1): 1-17 .

24.

Hobart RE. Free will as involving determination and inconceivable without it. In: Berofsky B ed. Free will and determinism. New York: Harper and Row , 1966: 84-84.

25.

Walton DN. On defining death. Montreal: McGill-Queens University Press , 1979.

26.

McDowell J.

Are moral requirements hypothetical imperatives?

Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 1978; suppl. vol. 52: 13-29 .

27.

Aristotle . The ethics of Aristotle, the Nicomachean ethics, revised translation. (Thompson JAK trans.) London: Penguin , 1976.

28.

Campbell AV. The virtues (and vices) of the four principles . J Med Ethics 2003; 29: 292-296 .

29.

Carney F. The virtue-obligation controversy . J Religious Ethics 1973; 1(1): 5-19 .

30.

Pellegrino ED. Professionalism, profession and the virtues of the good physician . Mt Sinai J Med 2002; 69: 378-384 .

31.

Scott PA. Aristotle, nursing and health care ethics . Nurs Ethics 1995; 2: 279-285 .

32.

Scott PA. Virtue, nursing and the moral domain of practice. In: Tschudin V. ed Approaches to ethics. Edinburgh: Butterworth Heinemann , 2003: 25-32.

33.

Sellman D. The virtues in the moral education of nurses: Florence Nightingale revisited . Nurs Ethics 1997; 4: 3-11 .

34.

Sellman D. Alasdair MacIntyre and the professional practice of nursing . Nurs Philos 2000; 1(1): 26-33 .

35.

Statman D ed. Virtue ethics: a critical reader. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press , 1997. (The introduction presents a more critical approach to virtue ethics and introduces some excellent essays, particularly Chapter 13: Virtue theory and abortion). (R Hursthouse). pp. 228-244.

36.

Vardy P , Grosch P. The puzzle of ethics. London: Fount , 1999. (Chapters: Two: Plato - Virtue and knowledge pp. 6-17; Three: Aristotle and virtue theory pp. 19-35; Eight: MacIntyre: virtue theory revisited pp. 94-108; Nine: Virtue ethics pp. 109-22. This book presents a sound basic introduction to ancient and modern virtue ethics.)