The Republic of the Ukraine has a huge prison population and a large prison health care system. Like all other public services in that country it is lacking in sufficient funds to operate adequately and with due respect to the human rights of the prisoners and its health care employees. This report and observations are based on my knowledge of the Ukrainian health care system and a visit to a Ukrainian prison hospital. It includes some ethical reflections stemming from this experience. Although problem-solving exercises can often help to point to areas of potential intervention that could ameliorate a troublesome situation, in this case prison health care conditions cannot be substituted for economic growth, political stability or increased awareness of societal moral obligations.
Allen W, Bell K. Death, neglect and the bottom line - push to cut costs poses risks. St Louis Dispatch 1998 Sep 27; News Sect G1 (special suppl).
2.
Prison health care breaches European standards. BBC News Online: Health. 1999 Mar 28; GMT 18.15. Available at: URL: www.news.bbc.co.uk/low/english/health/newsid_306000/306977.stm
3.
Medical notes - Prison is bad for your health. BBC News Online: Health. 1999 Sep 14; GMT 17.45. Available at: URL: www.news.bbc.co.uk/low/english/health/medical_notes/newsid_447000/447360.stm
4.
McBride J. Another nurse is suspended after death of asthmatic inmate. Milwaukee Journal Sentinel 2000 Apr 20. Available at: URL: www.jsonline.com/news/metro/apr00/taych2004190a.asp
Miller WA.A theory of punishment . Philosophy45 (174): 307-316 . Royal Institute of Philosophy (online journal). 2001. Available at: URL: www.royalinstitutephilosophy.og/articles/miller_punishment.htm
7.
Creighton S , King V.Prisoners and the law. Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann , 1996.
8.
Stern L.Deserved punishment, deserved harm, deserved blame . Philosophy45 (174): 317-329 . Royal Institute of Philosophy (online journal). 2001. Available at: URL: www.royalinstitutephilosophy.org/articles/stern_punish.htm
9.
United Nations . Universal declaration of human rights. New York: UN , 1948.
10.
Sim J.Medical power in prisons: The prison medical service in England 1774-1989. Milton Keynes: Open University Press , 1990.
11.
Council of Europe . The ethical and organisational aspects of health care in prison (no. R (98) 7). Strasbourg: Council of Europe , 1998.
12.
Clark G.Medical ethics in prison. In: Adam S ed. Learning across the walls. London: King’s Fund , 1994: 14-15.
13.
Stern V.Prison reform and public health: The case of tuberculosis in the former Soviet Union . Eur J Public Health2000; 10: 4-4 .
14.
McHugh M.Listening for life: reducing suicide and self-harm . Health in Prison Project (HIPP)1998; (1): 1-1 .
15.
National Prison Hospice Association . Hospice St Johns joins Pennsylvania Department of Corrections [Editorial] . National Prison Hospice Association Newsletter2001; (1): 1-1 .
16.
Schreiber C.Behind bars: Aging prison population challenges correctional systems . Nurseweek1999; (Jul 19): 1-1 . Available at: URL: www.nurseweek.com/features/99-7/prison.html
17.
Her Majesty’s Prison Service and NHS Executive . Nursing in prisons: report by the working group considering the development of prison nursing, with particular reference to health care officers. London: Department of Health , 2000.
18.
NHS Executive . The future organisation of prison health care: report by the Joint Service and National Health Service Executive Working Group. Leeds: NHS Executive , 1999.
19.
Department of Health . Prison health. London: DoH , 2000.
The Ukraine. Available at: URL: www.geographic.org [country profile - Ukraine]
22.
Rosenberg D.Poverty reduction strategy for Ukraine. United Nations Development Programme in Ukraine (UNDP in Ukraine). Kiev: UNDP . 2000. Available at: URL: www.un.kiev.ua:808/new/poverty
23.
Amnesty International . Amnesty International annual report 2001 - Ukraine. 2001 Available at: URL: web.amnesty.org/web/ar2001.nsf/webeurcountries/UKRAINE
24.
US Department of State . 1999 Country reports on human rights practices: Ukraine. Washington: US Department of State , 2000.
25.
Rees S.The health of prisoners. In: Adam S ed. Learning across the walls. London: King’s Fund , 1994: 3-8.
26.
Royal College of Nursing . Caring for prisoners: guidance for nurses. RCN Prison Nurses Forum. London: RCN , 2001.
27.
Gunchenko O.The policy of the Ukrainian penitentiary system on HIV/AIDS in prison establishments . Health in Prison Project (HIPP) Newsletter1998; (5).
28.
World Health Organization (Europe) . European guidelines on HIV/AIDS and hepatitis in prison. Health in prison project (HIPP). Copenhagen: WHO , 1999.
29.
McNulty J.Sociologist examines health care conditions for women prisoners. University of California Santa Cruz - currents August 1999. 1999. Available at: URL: www.uscsc.edu/currents/99-00/08-02/stoller.htm
30.
National Association of Correctional Nursing. Available at: URL: www.correctionalnursing.org
31.
World Health Organization (Europe) . Health promotion in the prison setting. Health in prison project (HIPP). Copenhagen: WHO , 1999.
