Application of Quick Environment Exposure Sensitivity Inventory (QEESI©) for Japanese population: study of reliability and validity of the questionnaire

Abstract

A standardized questionnaire has not been established for screening or diagnostic assessment of patients with multiple chemical sensitivity (MCS) in Japan. In the US, Miller and Prihoda (1999a, b) developed a questionnaire that could be used internationally, the Quick Environment Exposure Sensitivity Inventory (QEESI©), to assist researchers and clinicians in evaluating patients and populations for chemical sensitivity. The Japanese version of QEESI©was subsequently translated by Ishikawa and Miyata (1999). The present study was performed to investigate the reliability and validity of QEESI©(Japanese version) for research purposes and for evaluation of patients with MCS in Japan.

A total of 498 subjects were recruited from the general population of Miyagi prefecture, Japan. The factor structure in QEESI©was analyzed with 40 items on four subscales except for the items in ‘Masking’ using principal components analysis with Promax rotation. The results showed that 30 items on three subscales, ‘Chemical Inhalant Intolerances,’ ‘Symptom Severity,’ and ‘Life Impact’ except for ‘Other Intolerances’ were consistent with those reported for the US population by Miller and Prihoda (1999a). Cronbach’s a reliability coefficient ranged between 0.87 and 0.94 indicating high internal consistency in the 30 items on three subscales.

Next, we compared the mean scores on three subscales of QEESI©in two groups: 131 self-reported MCS group who were new outpatients at the Environmental Medical Center in Kitasato Institute Hospital, and 131 members of the general population (controls) who were matched for both gender and age with the self-reported MCS group. Mean scores on each subscale for the self-reported MCS group were significantly greater than those for controls (PB < 0.001). Mean scores on all of the 30 items on three subscales for the self-reported MCS group were also significantly greater than for the controls (PB < 0.001). These findings indicated that the 30 items on three subscales in QEESI©can be used for surveys and for diagnostic assessment of patients with MCS as well as for comparative studies between patients in Japan and in other countries.

Keywords

multiple chemical sensitivity questionnaire reliability validity factor analysis

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ashford, N. A. and Miller, C. S. 1998: Appendix C: Environmental Exposure and Sensitivity Inventory: Chemical exposure: Low levels and high Stakes, Second edition, John Wiley and Sons, New York; 371-384.

Bascom, R. 1992: Multiple Chemical Sensitivity: a respiratory disorder?, Toxicology and Industrial Health 8, 221-228.

Bell, I. R. , Miller, C. S. and Schwartz, G. E. 1992: An olfactory-limbic model of multiple chemical sensitivity syndrome: possible relationships to kindling and affective spectrum disorders, Biological Psychiatry 32, 218-242.

Bell, I. R. , Baldwin, C. M. , Fernandez, M. and Schwartz, G. E. 1999: Neural sensitization model for multiple chemical sensitivity: overview of theory and empirical evidence, Toxicology and Industrial Health 15, 295-304.

Caccappolo, E. , Kipen, H. , Kelly-McNeil, K. , Knasko, S. , Hamer, R. M. , Natelson, B. and Fiedler, N. 2000: Odor perception: multiple chemical sensitivities, chronic fatigue and asthma, Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine 42, 629-638.

Doty, R. L. 1994: Olfaction and multiple chemical sensitivity, Toxicology and Industrial Health 10, 359-368.

Dalton, P. and Hummel, T. 2000: Chemosensory function and response in idiopathic environmental intolerance, Occupational Medicine 15, 539-556.

Fiedler, N. and Kipen, H. 1997: Chemical sensitivity: the scientific literature, Environmental Health Perspectives 105, 409-415.

Fincher, C. E. , Chang, T. S. , Harrell, E. H. , Kettlhut, M. C. , Rea, W. J. , Johnson, A. , Hickey, D. C. and Simon, T. R. 1997: Comparison of single photon emission computed tomography findings in cases of healthy adults and solvent-exposed adults, American Journal of Industrial Medicine 32, 693-694.

10.

Graveling, R. A. , Pilkington, A. , George, J. P. K. , Butler, M. P. and Tannahill, S. N. 1999: A review of multiple chemical sensitivity, Occupational and Environmental Medicine 56, 73-85.

11.

Hojo, S. 2002: A Questionnaire Survey of Multiple Chemical Sensitivity in Japan by Using QEESI, Neuro-ophthalmology, Japan 19, 169-175.

12.

Hojo, S. , Yoshino, H. , Kakuta, K. and Ishikawa, S. 2003: A Questionnaire Survey among Japanese using the QEESI©, In Murakami, S. and Schonwalder, C. , editors, Proceedings of 2003 International Symposium on Indoor Air Quality and Health Hazards, Tokyo; 177-185.

13.

Hummel, T. , Roscher, S. , Jaumann, M. P. and Kobal, G. 1996: Intranasal chemoreception in patients with multiple chemical sensitivities: a double-blind investigation, Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology 24, S79-S86.

14.

Ishikawa, S. and Miyata, M. 1999: Multiple Chemical Sensitivity-Criteria and Test Methods for Diagnosis; Allergology and Immunology 6, 990-998.

15.

Kakuta, K. , Yoshino, H. , Amano, K. , Hojo, S. , Takeda, A. and Ishikawa, S. 2003: A chemical gas short time inhalation examination and an orthostatic stress test before and after gas inhalation using near infrared spectroscopy in order to diagnosis of sick-house syndrome, Japanese Journal of Clinical Ecology 12, 15-26.

16.

Kakuta, K. , Hojo, S. , Yoshino, H. and Ishikawa, S. 2002: Influence of Chemical Materials on Adolescent Children with Allergic Dieses, Neuro-ophthalmology, Japan 19, 176-187.

17.

Kakuta, K. , Yoshino, H. , Amano, K. , Iida, N. , Takada, M. , Matsumoto, M. , Katagiri, S. , Hojo, S. , Takeda, A. and Ishikawa, S. 2003: Diagnosis and Follow-up of Sick house syndrome, In Murakami, S. and Schonwalder, C. , editors, Proceedings of 2003 International Symposium on Indoor Air Quality and Health Hazards, Tokyo; 69-90.

18.

Meggs, W. J. , Dunn, K. A. , Bloch, R. M. , Goodman, P. E. and Davidoff, A. L. 1996: Prevalence and nature of allergy and chemical sensitivity in a general population, Archives of Environmental Health 51, 275-282.

19.

Miller, C. S. and Mitzel, H. C. 1995: Chemical sensitivity attributed to pesticide exposure versus remodeling, Archives of Environmental Health 50, 119-129.

20.

Miller, C. S. and Prihoda, T. J. 1999: The Environmental Exposure and Sensitivity Inventory (EESI): a standardized approach for measuring chemical intolerances for research and clinical applications, Toxicology and Industrial Health 15, 370-385.

21.

Miller, C. S. and Prihoda, T. J. 1999: A Controlled comparison of symptoms and chemical intolerances reported by Gulf War veterans, implant recipients, and persons with multiple chemical sensitivity, Toxicology and Industrial Health 15, 386-397.

22.

Rea, W. J. , Ross, G. H. , Johnson, A. R. , Smilley, R. E. , Sprague, D. E. , Fenyves, E. J. and Samadi, N. 1991: Confirmation of chemical sensitivity by means of double-blind inhalant challenge of toxic volatile chemicals, Boletin de la Asociation Medica de Puerto Rico 83, 389-393.

23.

Ross, G. H. , Rea, W. J. , Johnson, A. R. , Hickey, D. C. and Simon, T. R. 1999: Neurotoxicity in single photon emission computed tomography brain scans of patients reporting chemical sensitivities, Toxicology and Industrial Health 15, 415-420.

24.

Sakabe, K. , Miyata, M. , Ishikawa, S. and Kakuta, K. 2002: Sick House Syndrome and Brain Circulation, Neuroophthalmology, Japan 19, 162-168.

25.

Simon, T. R. , Hickey, D. C. , Fincher, C. E. , Johnson, A. R. , Ross, G. H. and Rea, W. J. 1994: Single photon emission computedtomographyofthebrainin patientswithchemical sensitivities, Toxicology and Industrial Health 10, 573-577.

26.

Shirakawa, S. , Ishikawa, S. , Miyata, M. , Rea, W. J. and Johnson, A. R. 1990: A pupillographical study on the presence of organochlorine pesticides in autonomic nerve disturbance, Nippon Ganka Gakkai Zasshi 94, 418-423.

27.

Uchiyama, I. and Murayama, R. 2003: Studies on current situation of Chemical Sensitivity in Japan, In Murakami, S. and Schonwalder, C. , editors, Proceedings of 2003 International Symposium on Indoor Air Quality and Health Hazards, Tokyo; 186-188.

28.

Van den Bergh, O. , Devriese, S. , Winters, W. , Veulemans, H. , Nemery, B. , Eelen, P. and Van de Woestijne, K. P. 2001: Acquiring symptoms in response to odors: a learning perspective on multiple chemical sensitivity, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 933, 278-290.