Soon after the third-world state was declared impotent, contradictory evidence pointing to the importance of state leadership in development in the Asian miracles came to the fore. This article, through a critical review of the literature, pushes this argument further and claims that geographers have much to contribute to the analysis of the state and its role in development. An appropriate framework for this kind of work is a marriage of radical political economy and certain strands of neo-Weberianism. We suggest that this conceptual union allows for broad theorizing of the capitalist state in the periphery while minding the institutional details of third-world states in particular regions and countries. This approach can help explain the differential performances of various third-world states within the confines of the world system. Thailand and Botswana are used as comparative cases to demonstrate the utility of this framework.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Agnew, J. and Corbridge, S.1995: Mastering space: hegemony, territory and international political economy. New York: Routledge.
2.
Amin, S.1974: Accumulation and development: a theoretical model. Review of African Political Economy1, 9–26.
3.
Amsden, A.1989: Asia's next giant: South Korea and late industrialization. New York: Oxford University Press.
4.
Amsden, A.1990: Third world industrialization: ‘global Fordism’ or a new model?New Left Review182, 5–31.
5.
Anderson, B.1983: Imagined communities: reflections on the origins and spread of nationalism. London: Verso.
6.
Anan Ganjanapan. 1989: Conflicts over the deployment and control of labor in a northern Thai village. In Hart, G., Turton, A. and White, B., editors, Agrarian transformations: local processes and the state in southeast Asia, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
7.
Anderson, J.1978: Geography, political economy, and the state. Antipode, 10, 87–93.
8.
Armstrong, W. and McGee, T.G.1985: Theatres of accumulation: studies in Asian and Latin American urbanization. London and New York: Methuen.
9.
Bardhan, P.1984: The political economy of development in India. London: Blackwell.
10.
Becker, B.K.1985: The crisis of the state and the region: regional planning questioned. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space3, 141–154.
11.
Block, F.1977: The ruling class does not rule. Socialist Review, 7, 6–28.
12.
Block, F.1980: State managers as historical subjects: beyond relative autonomy. Socialist Register227–242.
13.
Bowles, S. and Gintis, H.1982: The crisis of liberal democratic capitalism: the case of the United States. Politics and Society11, 51–93.
14.
Brohman, J.1996: Postwar development in the Asian NICs: does the neoliberal model fit reality?Economic Geography72, 107–131.
15.
Browett, J.G.1986: Industrialization in the global periphery: the significance of the NICS of east and southeast Asia. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space4, 401–418.
16.
Brugger, E.A.1982: Regional policy in Costa Rica: the problems of implementation. Geoforum13, 177–192.
17.
Carney, J.1993: Converting the wetlands, engendering the environment: the intersection of gender with agrarian change in The Gambia. Economic Geography69, 329–348.
18.
Chai-anan Samudavanija. 1995: Economic development and democracy. In Medhi, K., editor, Thailand's industrialization and its consequences, New York: St Martin's Press.
19.
Chase-Dunn, C.1990: World-state formation: historical process and emergent necessity. Political Geography9, 108–130.
20.
Chouinard, V. and Fincher, R.1987: State formation in capitalist societies: a conjunctural approach. Antipode19, 329–353.
21.
Clapp, R.A.1995: Creating competitive advantage: forest policy as industrial policy in Chile. Economic Geography71, 273–296.
22.
Clark, G.L. and Dear, M.J.1978: The state in capitalism and the capitalist state. Discussion Paper D78-18. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University, Department of City and Regional Planning.
23.
Clark, G.L. and Dear, M.J.1984: State apparatus: structures of language and legitimacy. Boston, MA: Allen & Unwin.
24.
Clark, G.L. and Kim, W.B., editors, 1995: Asian NIEs and the global economy: industrial restructuring and corporate strategy in the 1990s. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
25.
Corbridge, S.1990: Development studies. Progress in Human Geography14, 391–403.
26.
Corbridge, S.1991: Ousting Singbonga: the struggle for India's Jharkhand. In Dixon, C. and Heffernan, M., editors, Colonialism and development in the contemporary world, London: Mansell.
27.
Corbridge, S., Martin, R. and Thrift, N., editors, 1994: Money, power and space. Oxford and Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.
28.
Cowie, W.J.1980: Articulation, global capitalism, and the spatial organization of colonial society: the case of Zambia. Antipode12, 47–56.
29.
Cravey, A. 1996: Engendering the Latin American state. Paper presented at the Association of American Geographers annual meeting, Charlotte, NC, 10 April.
30.
Cumings, B.1984: The origins and development of the northeast Asian political economy: industrial sectors, product cycles, and political consequences. International Organization38, 1–40.
31.
Dahl, R.1956: A preface to democratic theory. Chicago, IL and London: University of Chicago Press.
32.
Daly, M.T.1994: The road to the twenty-first century: the myths and miracles of Asian manufacturing. In Corbridge, S., Martin, R. and Thrift, N., editors, Money, power and space, Oxford and Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.
33.
de Janvry, A.1981: The agrarian question and reformism in Latin America. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
34.
Dicken, P.1987: A tale of two NICs: Hong Kong and Singapore at the crossroads. Geoforum18, 151–164.
35.
Dixon, C., Drakakis-Smith, D. and Watts, H.D., editors, 1986: Multinational corporations and the third world. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
36.
Dixon, C. and Heffernan, M., editors, 1991: Colonialism and development in the contemporary world. London: Mansell.
37.
Douglass, M.1984: Regional integration of the capitalist periphery: the central plains of Thailand. The Hague: Institute for Social Affairs.
38.
Drakakis-Smith, D.1987: Urban and regional development in Zimbabwe. In Forbes, D. and Thrift, N., editors, The socialist third world: urban development and territorial planning, Oxford: Blackwell.
39.
Driver, F.1991: Political geography and state formation in disputed territory. Progress in Human Geography15, 268–280.
40.
Duangmanee Laovakul. 1993: Decomposition of income inequality and poverty in Thailand. PhD thesis, Thammasat University.
41.
Dutt, A.K. and Costa, F.K.1980: An evaluation of national economic planning in the People's Republic of China. Geoforum11, 1–16.
42.
Elliott, J.1991: Environmental degradation, soil conservation and the colonial and post-colonial state in Rhodesia/Zimbabwe. In Dixon, C. and Heffernan, M., editors, Colonialism and development in the contemporary world, London: Mansell.
43.
Enloe, C.1989: Bananas, beaches and bases: making feminist sense of international politics. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
44.
Eriksen, T.1993: Ethnicity and nationalism: anthropological perspectives. London: Pluto Press.
45.
Evans, P.1979: Dependent development: the alliance of multinational, state, and local capital in Brazil. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
46.
Eriksen, T.1995: Embedded autonomy: states and industrial transformation. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
47.
Falkus, M.1995: Thai industrialization: an overview. In Medhi, K., editor, Thailand's industrialization and its consequences, New York: St Martin's Press.
48.
Foot, S.P.H. and Webber, M.1990a: State, class and international capital. I. Background to the Brazilian steel industry. Antipode22, 93–120.
49.
Foot, S.P.H. and Webber, M.1990b: State, class, and international capital. II. The development of the Brazilian steel industry. Antipode22, 233–252.
50.
Giddens, A.1984: The constitution of society: outline of a theory of structuration. Cambridge and Berkeley, CA: Polity Press and University of California Press.
51.
Giddens, A.1985: A contemporary critique of historical materialism. Vol. 2. The nation-state and violence. Cambridge and Berkeley, CA: Polity Press and University of California Press.
52.
Girling, J.1981: Thailand: society and politics. Ithaca, NY and London: Cornell University Press.
53.
Good, K.1992: Interpreting the exceptionality of Botswana. Journal of Modern African Studies30, 1-1.
54.
Gotlieb, Y.1992: Retrieving life-place from colonized space: transcending the encumbrances of the post-colonial state. Political Geography11, 461–474.
55.
Gray, F. and Dicken, P.1978: Ideology and the state: the case of local authority housing. Antipode10, 38–43.
56.
Grice, K. and Drakakis-Smith, D.1985: The role of the state in shaping development: two decades of growth in Singapore. Transactions, Institute of British Geographers10, 347–359.
57.
Haines, G.1989: The Americanization of Brazil: a study of United States cold war diplomacy in the third world. Wilmington, DE: Scholarly Resources Books.
58.
Hart, G., Turton, A. and White, B., editors, 1989: Agrarian transformations: local processes and the state in southeast Asia. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
59.
Hart-Landsberg, M.1993: The rush to development: economic change and political struggle in South Korea. New York: Monthly Review Press.
60.
Harvey, C. and Lewis, S. Jr1990: Policy choice and development performance in Botswana. London: Macmillan.
61.
Harvey, D.1976: The Marxian theory of the state. Antipode8, 80–89.
62.
Harvey, D.1982: The limits to capital. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
63.
Harvey, D.1985: The geopolitics of capitalism. In Gregory, D. and Urry, J., editors, Social relations and spatial structures, London: Macmillan.
64.
Hecht, S. and Cockburn, A.1990: The fate of the forest: developers, destroyers and defenders of the Amazon. New York: Harper.
65.
Hepple, L.W.1986: Geopolitics, generals, and the state in Brazil. Political Geography (suppl) 5, S79–S90.
66.
Hewison, K.1989: Bankers and bureaucrats: capital and the role of the state in Thailand. Yale University Southeast Asia Studies Monograph Series 34. New Haven, CT: Yale Center for International and Area Studies.
67.
Higgott, R.1984: Export-oriented industrialisation, the new international division of labour, and the corporate state. Australian Geographical Studies22, 58–71.
68.
Hirsch, P.1990: Development dilemmas in rural Thailand. Singapore, Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.
69.
Hirsch, P.1993: Political economy of the environment in Thailand. Manila: Journal of Contemporary Asia Publishers.
70.
Hirsch, P.1995a: A state of uncertainty: political economy of community resource management at Tab Salao, Thailand. Sojourn10, 172–197.
71.
Hirsch, P.1995b: Thailand and the new geopolitics of southeast Asia: resource and environmental issues. In Rigg, J., editor, Counting the costs: economic growth and environmental change in Thailand, Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies.
72.
Hirsch, P. 1996: Resource tenure, management, and competition in three Thai watersheds. In Proceedings of the 6th international conference on Thai studies, theme II, cultural crisis and the Thai capitalist transformation, Chiang Mai, Thailand, 14–17October.
73.
Hussey, A.1993: Rapid industrialization in Thailand. Geographical Review83, 14–28.
74.
Jansen, K.1991: Thailand: the next NIC?Journal of Contemporary Asia21, 13–30.
75.
Jessop, B.1990: State theory: putting capitalist states in their place. University Park, PA: Pennsylvania State University Press.
76.
Johnston, R.J.1982: Geography and the state: an essay in political geography. New York: St Martin's Press.
77.
Johnston, R.J.1984: Marxist political economy, the state, and political geography. Progress in Human Geography8, 473–492.
78.
Johnston, R.J., Knight, D.B. and Kofman, E., editors, 1988: Nationalism, self-determination and political geography. New York: Croom Helm.
79.
Kafkalas, G.1987: State and capital as the agents of spatial integration in the world economy. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space5, 303–318.
80.
Khosa, M.M.1995: Transport and popular struggles in South Africa. Antipode27, 167–188.
81.
Klak, T.1995: A framework for studying Caribbean industrial policy. Economic Geography71, 297–317.
82.
Krü ger, K.1982: Regional policy in Malaysia. Geoforum13, 133–150.
83.
Lovering, J.1987: Militarism, capitalism, and the nation-state: toward a realist synthesis. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space5, 283–302.
84.
Luxmon Wongsuphasuwat and Parnwell, M. 1996: Between the global and the local: extended metropolitanization and industrial location decision-making in Thailand. In Proceedings of the 6th international conference on Thai studies, theme I, globalization: impact on and coping strategies in Thai society, Chiang Mai, Thailand, 14–17October.
85.
Mackintosh, M.1989: Gender, class and rural transition: agribusiness and the food crisis in Senegal. London: Zed Books.
86.
Mann, M.1986: The sources of social power. Vol. 1. A history of power from the beginning to AD 1760. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
87.
Mann, M.1988: States, war and capitalism: studies in political sociology. Oxford: Blackwell.
88.
Martin, R.1994: Stateless monies, global financial integration and national economic autonomy: the end of geography? In Corbridge, S., Martin, R. and Thrift, N., editors, Money, power and space. Oxford and Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.
89.
McMichael, P.1993: World food system restructuring under a GATT regime. Political Geography12, 198–214.
90.
McMichael, P. and Mhyre, D.1990: Global regulation vs. the nation-state: agro-food systems and the new politics of capital. Review of Radical Political Economics22, 59–77.
91.
Medhi Krongkaew, editor, 1995: Thailand's industrialization and its consequences. New York: St Martin's Press.
92.
Mies, M.1986: Patriarchy and accumulation on a world scale: women in the international division of labour. London: Zed Books.
93.
Miliband, R.1969: The state in capitalist society. London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson.
94.
Mingsarn, S.K. et al. 1995: Women in development: enhancing the status of rural women in northern Thailand. Bangkok: Thailand Development Research Institute.
95.
Muscat, R.J.1994: The fifth tiger: a study of Thai development policy. New York: M.E. Sharpe and the United Nations Press.
96.
Mustafa, H.N. 1997: Practicing beauty: crisis, value and the challenge of self-mastery in Dakar, 1970–1994. PhD dissertation, Harvard University.
97.
O'Brien, R.1992: Global financial integration: the end of geography. London: Pinter.
98.
O'Connor, J.1973: The fiscal crisis of the state. New York: St Martin's Press.
99.
O'Connor, J.1984: Accumulation crisis. New York: Blackwell.
100.
Pasuk Pongpaichit and Baker, C.1995: Thailand: economy and politics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
101.
Porpora, D., Lim, M.H. and Prommas, U.1989: The role of women in the international division of labor: the case of Thailand. Development and Change20, 269–294.
102.
Porteous, D.1973: The company state: a Chilean case-study. Canadian Geographer17, 113–126.
103.
Poulantzas, N.1973: Political power and social classes. London: New Left Books.
104.
Rakodi, C.1986: State and class in Africa: a case for extended analysis of the form and functions of the nation-state to the urban local state. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space4, 419–446.
105.
Rakodi, C.1995: From a settler history to an African present: housing markets in Harare, Zimbabwe. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space13, 91–115.
106.
Rambousek, W.H.1982: Regional policy in Cameroon: the case of planning without facts. Geoforum13, 163–176.
107.
Roberts, S.1994: Fictitious capital, fictitious spaces: the geography of offshore financial flows. In Corbridge, S., Martin, R. and Thrift, N., editors, Money, power and space, Oxford and Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.
108.
Roberts, S.1995a: Global regulation and trans-state organization. In Johnston, R.J., Taylor, P.J. and Watts, M.J., editors, Geographies of global change: remapping the world in the late twentieth century, Oxford and Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.
109.
Roberts, S.1995b: Small place, big money: the Cayman Islands and the international financial system. Economic Geography71, 257–272.
110.
Robinson, J.1990: ‘A perfect system of control’? State power and native locations in South Africa. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space8, 135–162.
111.
Rogerson, C.M.1986: A strange case of beer: the state and sorghum beer manufacturing in South Africa. Area18, 15–24.
112.
Rogerson, C.M. and Tucker, B.A.1986: Multinational corporations, the state and indigenous beer production in central Africa. In Dixon, C., Drakakis-Smith, D. and Watts, H.D., editors, Multinational corporations and the third world, Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
113.
Saiyud Kerdphol1986: The struggle for Thailand: counter-insurgency, 1965–1985. Bangkok: S. Research Center Co. Ltd.
114.
Samatar, A.1989: The state and rural transformation in northern Somalia. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press.
115.
Samatar, A.1993: Structural adjustment as a development strategy. Economic Geography69, 25–43.
116.
Samatar, A.1994: Empty bowl: agrarian political economy in transition and the crisis of accumulation. In Samatar, A., editor, The Somali challenge: from catastrophe to renewal?Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner.
117.
Samatar, A. forthcoming: An African miracle: state and class leadership, and colonialism in Botswana.
118.
Sayer, A.1995: Radical geography: a critique. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.
119.
Sayer, A. and Walker, R.1992: The new social economy: reworking the division of labor. Cambridge, MA and Oxford: Blackwell.
120.
Scarritt, J.R.1987: Review essay: explaining the state and state–society relations in Africa. Political Geography6, 369–376.
121.
Seksan Prasertkul 1989: The transformation of the Thai state and economic change (1855–1945). PhD thesis, Cornell University.
122.
Seth, V.K.1986: State and spatial aspects of industrialization in post-independence India. Political Geography5, 331–350.
Sidaway, J.D.1992: Mozambique: destabilization, state, society, and space. Political Geography11, 239–258.
125.
Sidaway, J.D. and Power, M.1995: Sociospatial transformations in the ‘postsocialist’ periphery: the case of Maputo, Mozambique. Environment and PlanningA 27, 1463–1491.
126.
Skocpol, T.1979: States and social revolution: a comparative analysis of France, Russia, and China. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press.
127.
Slater, D.1979: Imperialism and limitations on capitalist transformation at the periphery. In Carriére, J., editor, Industrialisation and the state in Latin America, Amsterdam: Cedla Publications.
128.
Slater, D.1989: Territory and state power in Latin America: the Peruvian case. New York: St Martin's Press (theoretical sections of the book are reproduced as ‘Peripheral capitalism and the regional problematic’. In Peet, R. and Thrift, N., editors, New models in geography: the political-economy perspective, London: Unwin Hyman, 1989, Vol. II, 267–94).
129.
Stokke, K.1994: The postcolonial African state and development geography. Norsk Geografisk Tidsskrift48, 123–131.
130.
Stokke, K.1997: Authoritarianism in the age of market liberalism in Sri Lanka. Antipode, forthcoming.
131.
Sungsidh Piriyarangsan1983: Thai bureaucratic capitalism, 1932–1960. Bangkok: Chulalongkorn Social Research Institute.
132.
Surachart Bumrungsuk1988: United States foreign policy and Thai military rule, 1947–1977. Bangkok: Editions Duang Kamol.
133.
Taylor, P.J.1982: A materialist framework for political geography. Transactions, Institute of British Geographers7, 15–34.
134.
Taylor, P.J.1986: An exploration into world-systems analysis of political parties. Political Geography (suppl) 5, S5–S20.
135.
Taylor, P.J.1991: The crisis of the movements: the enabling state as Quisling. Antipode23, 214–228.
136.
Taylor, P.J.1993: Political geography: world-economy, nationstate, and locality (3rd edn). Harlow: Longman.
137.
Thak Chaloemtiarana1979: Thailand: the politics of despotic paternalism. Bangkok: Social Science Association of Thailand, Thai Kadi Institute, Thammasat University.
138.
Timberlake, M., editor, 1985: Urbanization in the world-economy. New York: Academic Press.
139.
Turton, A.1989: Local powers and rural differentiation. In Hart, G., Turton, A. and White, B., editors, Agrarian transformations: local processes and the state in southeast Asia, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
140.
Voravidh Charoenloet1991: Thailand in the process of becoming a NIC: myth or reality?Journal of Contemporary Asia21, 31–41.
141.
Wade, R.1990: Governing the market: economic theory and the role of government in east Asian industrialization. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
142.
Warr, P.G., editor, 1993: The Thai economy in transition. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press.
143.
Watts, M.1983: Silent violence: food, famine and peasantry in northern Nigeria. Berkeley, CA, Los Angeles, CA and London: University of California Press.
144.
Watts, M.1987: ‘Introduction’ and ‘Agriculture and oilbased accumulation: stagnation or transformation?’ In Watts, M., editor, State, oil, and agriculture in Nigeria, Berkeley, CA: University of California Institute of International Studies.
145.
Watts, M.1989: The agrarian crisis in Africa: debating the crisis. Progress in Human Geography13, 1–41.
146.
Watts, M.1994: Oil as money: the devil's excrement and the spectacle of black gold. In Corbridge, S., Martin, R. and Thrift, N., editors, Money, power and space, Oxford and Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.
147.
Watts, M. and Bassett, T.1986: Politics, the state and agrarian development: a comparative study of Nigeria and the Ivory Coast. Political Geography5, 103–126.
148.
Wittayakorn Chiengkul1983: The transformation of the agrarian structure of central Thailand, 1960–1980. Journal of Contemporary Asia13, 340–360.
149.
Wolf, D.1992: Factory daughters: gender, household dynamics, and rural industrialization in Java. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
150.
Wylie, D.1990: The twilight of patriarchy in a southern african chiefdom. Johannesburg: Witwatersrand University Press.
151.
Zaimeche, S.E.1994: Change, the state, and deforestation: the Algerian example. Geographical Journal160, 50–56.
