For geographers and economists, urban agglomeration remains an enduring feature of the industrial landscape and a perennial source of theoretical and empirical interest. Curiously, despite this long-standing interest, there has been a remarkable tendency to explain agglomeration with reference to Alfred Marshall's trinity of external economies and industrial district model. In this paper, we seek to draw some contrasts in the form and causes of agglomeration. Our discussion proceeds by developing a simple and highly schematic taxonomy of what could be considered the emblematic forms of agglomeration in proto-industrial, industrial and post-industrial urban contexts. Highly simplified though they are, such contrasts highlight the changes in the spatial extent of agglomeration, the contribution of particular industrial sectors and types of external economy and of exports to the process of agglomeration over time. As such, there is an urgent need to reconcile the perspectives of economists and geographers in a renewal of the theory of agglomeration.
Alonso, W.1973: Urban zero population growth. Daedalus102, 191–206.
2.
Allen, J.1992: Services and the UK space economy: regionalization and economic dislocation. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers NS 17, 292–305.
Amin, A.and Robins, K.1990: The re-emergence of regional economies? The mythical geography of flexible accumulation. Environment and Planning D, Society and Space8, 7–34.
5.
Amin, A.and Thrift, N.1992: Neo-Marshallian nodes in global networks. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research16, 571–587.
6.
Bairoch, P.1988: Cities and economic development: from the dawn of history to the present. London: Mansell.
7.
Bairoch, P. and Kozul-Wright, R.1998: Globalization myths: some historical reflections on integration, internationalisation and growth in the world economy. In Kozul-Wright, R. and Rowthorn, R., editors, Transnational companies and the global economy, London: Macmillan, 37–68.
8.
Barnes, T.J.1996: Logics of dislocation: metaphors, models and meaning in economic geography. London: Guilford Press.
9.
Batten, D.1995: Network cities: creative urban agglomerations for the 21st century. Urban Studies32, 313–327.
10.
Bennett, R.J., Graham, D.J.and Bratton, W.1999: The location and concentration of businesses in Britain: business clusters, business services, market coverage and local economic development. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers NS 24, 393–420.
11.
Bingham, R.D. and Kimble, D.1995: The industrial composition of edge cities and downtowns: the new urban reality. Economic Development Quarterly9, 259–272.
12.
Cantwell, J.1987: The reorganization of European industries after integration: selected evidence on the role of multinational enterprise activity. Journal of Common Market Studies26, 127–151.
13.
Capello, R.2000: The city network paradigm: measuring urban network externalities. Urban Studies37, 1925–1945.
14.
Charlesworth, J.and Cochrane, A.1994: Tales of the suburbs: the local politics of growth in the southeast of England. Urban Studies31, 1723–1738.
15.
Chinitz, B.1961: Contrasts in agglomeration. American Economic Review51, 279–289.
16.
Coe, N.and Townsend, A.1998: Debunking the myth of localized agglomerations: the development of a regionalized service economy in southeast England. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers NS 23, 385–404.
17.
Coffey, W. and Shearmur, R.2002: Agglomeration and dispersion of high-order service employment in the Montreal metropolitan region, 1981–96. Urban Studies39, 359–378.
18.
Driffield, N.and Munday, M.2000: Industrial performance, agglomeration and foreign manufacturing investment in the UK. Journal of International Business Studies31, 21–37.
19.
Garreau, J.1991: Edge city: life on the new frontier. London: Doubleday.
20.
Gershuny, J.1978: After industrial society. London: Macmillan.
21.
Gershuny, J.1992: Are we running out of time?Futures24, 3–22.
22.
Gordon, P. and Richardson, H.W.1996a: Employment decentralization in US metropolitan areas: is Los Angeles an outlier or the norm?Environment and PlanningA 28, 1727–1743.
23.
Gordon, P.1996b: Beyond polycentricity: the dispersed metropolis, Los Angeles, 1970–1990. Journal of the American Planning Association62, 289–295.
24.
Gottdiener, M.2002: Urban analysis as merchandising: the ‘LA school’ and the understanding of metropolitan developments. In Eade, J. and Mele, J., editors, Understanding the city: contemporary and future perspectives, Oxford: Blackwell, 159–180.
25.
Gottman, J.1962: Megalopolis: the urbanised northeastern seabord of the United States. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
26.
Hall, P.G.1962: The industries of London since 1861. London: Hutchinson.
27.
Hall, P.G.1997: Modelling the post-industrial city. Futures29, 311–322.
28.
Hall, P.G.2000: Global city-regions in the twenty-first century. In Scott, A.J., editor, Global city regions: trends, theory, policy, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 59–77.
29.
Harrison, B.1992: Industrial districts: old wine in new bottles?. Regional Studies26, 469–483.
30.
Henry, N.1992: The new industrial spaces: locational logic of a new production era?International Journal of Urban and Regional Research16, 375–396.
31.
Hill, E.and Wolman, H.1997: Accounting for the change in income disparities between US central cities and their suburbs. Urban Studies34, 43–60.
32.
Hill, E., Wolman, H.and Ford, C.C.1995: Can suburbs survive without their central cities? Examining the suburban dependence hypothesis. Urban Affairs Review31, 147–174.
33.
Hudson, P.1996: Proto-industrialization in England. In Ogilvie, S. and Cerman, M., editors, European proto-industrialization, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 49–66.
34.
Hughes, H.1993: Metropolitan structure and the suburban hierarchy. American Sociological Review58, 417–433.
35.
Karaska, G.1969: Manufacturing linkages in the Philadelphia economy: some evidence of external agglomeration forces. Geographical Analysis1, 354–369.
36.
Keeble, D. and Tyler, P.1995: Enterprising behaviour and the urban-rural shift. Urban Studies32, 975–997.
37.
Kloosterman, R.C. and Lambregts, B.2001: Clustering of economic activities in polycentric urban areas: the case of the Randstad. Urban Studies38, 717–732.
38.
Krugman, P.1991: Geography and trade. Leuven: Leuven University Press.
39.
Krugman, P.1996a: The localization of the global economy. In Krugman, P., Pop internationalism, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 205–214.
40.
Krugman, P.1996b: The self-organising economy. Oxford: Blackwell.
41.
Lampard, E.E.1955: The history of cities in the economically advanced areas. Economic Development and Cultural Change3, 81–136.
42.
Markusen, A.1996: Sticky places in slippery spaces: a typology of industrial districts. Economic Geography72, 293–313.
43.
Marshall, A.1920: Principles of economics. London: Macmillan.
44.
Martin, R.1999: The new ‘geographical turn’ in economics: some critical reflections. Cambridge Journal of Economics23, 65–91.
45.
Martin, R.and Sunley, P.1996: Paul Krugman's geographical economics and its implications for regional development theory: a critical comment. Economic Geography72, 259–292.
46.
Maskell, P.and Malmberg, A.1999: Localised learning and industrial competitiveness. Cambridge Journal of Economics23, 167–185.
47.
Maskell, P., Eskelinen, H., Hannibalson, I, Malmberg, A.and Vatne, E.1998: Competitiveness, localised learning and regional development: specialisation and prosperity in small open economies. London: Routledge.
48.
McCann, P.1995: Rethinking the economics of location and agglomeration. Urban Studies32, 563–577.
49.
Mogridge, M.and Parr, J.B.1997: Metropolis or region? On the development and structure of London. Regional Studies31, 97–116.
50.
Myint, H.1958: The ‘classical theory’ of international trade and the underdeveloped countries. Economic Journal68, 317–337.
51.
Ó hUallacháin, B.and Satterthwaite, M.A.1992: Sectoral growth patterns at the metropolitan level: an evaluation of economic development incentives. Journal of Urban Economics31, 25–58.
52.
Ozawa, T.1999: Small and medium sized TNCs, industrial clusters and globalization: the Japanese experience. In Hood, N. and Young, S., editors, The globalization of multinational enterprise and economic development, London: Macmillan.
53.
Ozawa, T.and Ferrer, C.1997: Strategic organization and structural dynamism: spatial underpinnings of Japan's phase-based industrial competitiveness. Community of European Management Schools (CEMS) Business Review2 (supplement), s19–s35.
54.
Parr, J.B.2002a: Missing elements in the analysis of agglomeration economies. International Regional Science Review25, 151–168.
55.
Parr, J.B.2002b: Agglomeration economies: ambiguities and confusions. Environment and PlanningA 34, 717–731.
56.
Phelps, N.A.1992: External economies, agglomeration and flexible production. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers NS 17, 35–46.
57.
Phelps, N.A.1993: Branch plants and the evolving spatial division of labour: a study of material linkages in the northern region of England. Regional Studies27, 87–101.
58.
Phelps, N.A.1998: On the edge of something big: edge city economic development in Croydon. Town Planning Review69(4): 441–465.
59.
Phelps, N.A., Fallon, R.and Williams, C.2001: Small firms, borrowed size and the urban-rural shift. Regional Studies35(7), 613–624.
60.
Richardson, R.and Marshall, J.N.1996: The growth of telephone call centres in peripheral areas of Britain: evidence from Tyne and Wear. Area28, 308–317.
61.
Robinson, E.A.G.1953 [1931]: The structure of competitive industry. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
62.
Savitch, H.V.1995: Straw men, red herrings... and suburban dependency. Urban Affairs Review31, 175–179.
63.
Sayer, A.and Walker, R.1992: The new social economy: reworking the division of labor. Oxford: Blackwell.
64.
Scott, A.J.1982: Locational patterns and dynamics of industrial activity in the modern metropolis. Urban Studies19, 111–142.
65.
Scott, A.J.1983: Industrial organisation and the logic of intra-metropolitan location, 1: theoretical considerations. Economic Geography59, 233–250.
66.
Scott, A.J.1986: Industrial organisation and location: division of labour, the firm and spatial process. Economic Geography62, 215–231.
67.
Scott, A.J.1988a: Flexible production systems and regional development: the rise of new industrial spaces in North America and Western Europe. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research12, 171–186.
68.
Scott, A.J.1988b: Metropolis: from the division of labor to urban form. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
69.
Scott, A.J.2000: Introduction. In Scott, A.J., editor, Global city-regions: trends, theory, policy, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1–8.
70.
Scott, A.J.and Storper, M.1987: High technology industry and regional development: a theoretical critique and reconstruction. International Social Science Journal112, 215–232.
71.
Skitovsky, T.1954: Two concepts of external economies. Journal of Political Economy62, 143–151.
72.
Smith, A.1983 [1776]: An inquiry into the nature and causes of the wealth of nations. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
73.
Soja, E.2000: Postmetropolis. Oxford: Blackwell.
74.
Stanback, T.M.1995: Putting city-suburb competition in perspective. In Brothcie, J., Batty, M., Blakely, E., Hall, P. and Newton, P., editors, Cities in competition: productive and sustainable cities for the 21st century, Melbourne: Longman Australia, 208–225.
75.
Storper, M.1992: The limits to globalization: technology districts and international trade. Economic Geography68, 60–93.
76.
Storper, M.1995: The resurgence of regional economies, ten years later: the region as a nexus of untraded interdependencies. European Urban and Regional Studies2, 191–222.
77.
Storper, M.1997: The regional world: territorial development in a global economy. London: Guilford Press.
78.
Storper, M.and Harrison, B.1991: Flexibility, hierarchy and regional development: the changing structure of industrial production systems and their forms of governance in the 1990s. Research Policy20, 407–422.
79.
Storper, M.and Walker, R.1989: The capitalist imperative: territory, technology and industrial growth. Oxford: Blackwell.
80.
Suarez-Villa, L.1989: Polycentric restructuring, metropolitan evolution, and the decentralization of manufacturing. Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie80, 194–205.
81.
Suarez-Villa, L. and Walrod, W.1997: Operational strategy, R&D and intra-metropolitan clustering in a polycentric structure: the advanced electronics industries of the Los Angeles basin. Urban Studies34, 1343–1380.
82.
Swann, G.M.P., Prevezer, M. and Stout, D.,editors 1998: The dynamics of industrial clustering: international comparisons in computing and biotechnology. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
83.
Walker, R.1981: A theory of suburbanization: capitalism and the construction of urban space in the USA. In Dear, M. and Scott, A., editors, Urbanization and urban planning in capitalist societies, London: Methuen.
84.
Walker, R.1985: Is there a service economy? The changing capitalist division of labour. Science and Society49, 42–83.
85.
Walker, R. and Lewis, R.D.2001: Beyond the crabgrass frontier: industry and the spread of North American cities, 1850–1950. Journal of Historical Geography27, 3–19.
86.
Wise, M.1949: On the evolution of the jewellery and gun quarters in Birmingham. Transactions and Papers of the Institute of British Geographers15, 59–72.
87.
Young, A.1928: Increasing returns and economic progress. Economic Journal38, 527–542.
88.
Young, S., Hood, N. and Peters, E.1994: Multinational enterprises and regional economic development. Regional Studies28, 657–677.
