This article examines the ways in which geographers have written about the history of geography in the early modern period (c. 1600–1850). It is argued that geography was a clearly defined practice in that period, but that a century of writing about the period by geographers has consistently effaced that definition. This practice began with modern geography's ‘founding fathers’, of whom Mackinder, Hartshorne and Sauer are considered. They developed an ‘essentialist’ historiography – postulating what geography is as a science ‘in essence,’ judging geography's history in the light of this essence and placing the early modern period in a precritical era. This model proved highly influential with historians of geography, and even contemporary work has not escaped from its framework to take on board the alterity of the early modern conception of geography.
Andrewes, W.1996: The quest for longitude. Cambridge, MA: Collection of Historical Scientific Instruments.
2.
Baker, J.N.L.1931: A history of geographical discovery and exploration. London: Harvill.
3.
Baker, J.N.L.1968: The history of geography: papers by J.N.L. Baker. Oxford: Blackwell.
4.
Bevir, M.1999: The logic of the history of ideas. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
5.
Bowen, M.1981: Empiricism and geographical thought: from Francis Bacon to Alexander von Humboldt. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
6.
Bradley, F.H.1874: The presuppositions of critical history. Oxford: James Parker & Co.
7.
Clarke, K.1999: Between geography and history: Hellenistic constructions of the Roman world. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
8.
Collingwood, R.G.1946: The idea of history. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
9.
Condren, C.1994: The language of politics in seventeenth-century England. London: Macmillan.
10.
Cormack, L.1991: ‘Good fences make good neighbours’: geography as self-definition in early-modern England. Isis82, 639–661.
11.
Cormack, L.1997: Charting an empire: geography at the English universities, 1580–1620. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.
12.
Cosgrove, D.1984: Social formation and symbolic landscape. Beckenham: Croom Helm.
13.
Domosh, M.1991: Towards a feminist historiography of geography. Transactions, Institute of British Geographers16, 95–104.
14.
Downes, A.1971: The bibliographical dinosaurs of Georgian geography (1714–1830). Geographical Journal137, 379–387.
15.
Edney, M.1997: Mapping an empire: the geographical construction of British India, 1765–1843. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
16.
Eliot Hurst, M.1985: Geography has neither existence nor future. In Johnston, R.J., editor, The future of geography, London: Methuen, 59–91.
17.
Godlewska, A.1999a: From Enlightenment vision to modern science? Humboldt's visual thinking. In Livingstone, D. and Withers, C., editors, Geography and Enlightenment, Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 236–275.
18.
Godlewska, A.1999b: Geography unbound: French geographic science from Cassini to Humboldt. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Hartshorne, R.1939: The nature of geography: a critical survey of current geographical thought in the light of the past. Lancaster, PA: AAAG.
21.
Harvey, D.1984: On the history and present condition of geography: an historical materialist manifesto. Professional Geographer3, 1–11.
22.
Harvey, D.1989: The condition of postmodernity: an enquiry into the origins of cultural change. Oxford: Blackwell.
23.
Lefebvre, H.1991: The production of space. Oxford: Blackwell.
24.
Livingstone, D.1992: The geographical tradition: episodes in the history of a contested enterprise. Oxford: Blackwell.
25.
Mackinder, H. 1887: On the scope and methods of geography. Proceedings of the Royal Geographical Society 9, 141–174.
26.
Mackinder, H.1903: Geography in education. Geographical Teacher2, 95–101.
27.
Mackinder, H.1914: The teaching of geography and history: a study in method. London: George Philip & Son.
28.
Mackinder, H.1942: Geography, an art and a philosophy. Geography27, 122–130.
29.
Maddrell, A.1998: Discourses of race and gender and the comparative method in geography school texts, 1830–1918. Society and Space16, 81–103.
30.
Martin, G. and James, P.1993: All possible worlds: a history of geographical ideas(3rd edn). New York: Wiley.
31.
Mayhew, R.1998: The character of English geography, c. 1660–1800: a textual approach. Journal of Historical Geography24, 385–412.
32.
McEwan, C.1998: Gender, science and physical geography in nineteenth-century Britain. Area30, 215–223.
33.
Miller, D. and Reill, P., editors, 1996: Visions of empire: voyages, botany, and representations of nature. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
34.
Oakeshott, M.1933: Experience and its modes. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
35.
Oakeshott, M.1983: On history and other essays. Oxford: Blackwell.
36.
Oakeshott, M.1991: The activity of being an historian. In Fuller, T., editor, Rationalism in politics and other essays. Indianapolis, IN: Liberty Press, 151–183.
37.
Ogborn, M.1998: Spaces of modernity: London's geographies, 1680–1780. New York: Guilford Press.
38.
Salmon, T.1749: A new geographical and historical grammar. London: William Johnston.
39.
Sauer, C.1923 [1963]: The morphology of landscape. In Leighty, J., editor, Land and life: a selection from the writings of Carl Ortwin Sauer, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 315–350.
40.
Scargill, I.1999: The Oxford school of geography, 1899–1999. Oxford: School of Geography Research Papers.
41.
Sherratt, Y. 1999: Adorno's critique of enlightenment: a positive interpretation. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Cambridge.
42.
Sidaway, J.1997: The (re)making of the western ‘geographical tradition’: some missing links. Area29, 72–80.
43.
Sobel, D.1996: Longitude: the true story of the lone scientific genius who solved the greatest scientific problem of his age. London: Fourth Estate.
44.
Stoddart, D.1986: On geography and its history. Oxford: Blackwell.
Taylor, E.G.R.1934: Late Tudor and early Stuart geography, 1583–1650. London: Methuen.
47.
Taylor, E.G.R.1954: The mathematical practitioners of Tudor and Stuart England. Cambridge: Institute of Navigation.
48.
Taylor, E.G.R.1966: The mathematical practitioners of Hanoverian England, 1714–1840. Cambridge: Institute of Navigation.
49.
Tully, J.1988: Meaning and context: Quentin Skinner and his critics. Cambridge: Polity Press.
50.
Withers, C.1995: How Scotland came to know itself: geography, national identity and the making of a nation, 1680–1790. Journal of Historical Geography21, 371–397.
51.
Withers, C.1996a: Encyclopaedism, modernism and the classification of geographical knowledge. Transactions, Institute of British Geographers21, 275–298.
52.
Withers, C.1996b: Geography, science and national identity in early-modern Britain: the case of Scotland and the work of Sir Robert Sibbald. Annals of Science53, 29–73.
