The objective of the study was to determine whether teams providing specialist palliative care improve the health outcomes of patients with advanced cancer and their families or carers when compared to conventional services. The study involved a systematic literature review of published research.
The source of the data included studies identified from a systematic search of computerized databases (Medline, psychINFO, CINAHL and BIDS to the end of 1996), hand-searching specialist palliative care journals, and studying bibliographies and reference lists. The inclusion criteria for articles were that the study considered the use of specialist palliative care teams caring for patients with advanced cancer. Articles were assessed and data extracted and synthesized, with studies graded according to design.
A variety of outcomes were considered by the authors. These addressed aspects of symptom control, patient and family or carer satisfaction, health care utilization and cost, place of death, psychosocial indices and quality of life.
Overall, 18 relevant studies were identified, including five randomized controlled trials. Improved outcomes were seen in the amount of time spent at home by patients, satisfaction by both patients and their carers, symptom control, a reduction in the number of inpatient hospital days, a reduction in overall cost, and the patients' likelihood of dying where they wished to for those receiving specialist care from a multiprofessional palliative care team.
It was concluded that all evaluations were of services considered to be leading the field, or were pioneering training and treatments. However, when compared to conventional care, there is evidence that specialist teams in palliative care improve satisfaction and identify and deal with more patient and family needs. Moreover, multiprofessional approaches to palliative care reduce the overall cost of care by reducing the amount of time patients spend in acute hospital settings.
Higginson IJ. Health care needs assessment: palliative and terminal care. In: Stevens A, Raftery J eds. Health care needs assessment. Oxford: Radcliffe Medical, 1997: 183–160.
2.
Saunders C, Sykes N. The management of terminal malignant disease. London: Edward Arnold, 1993.
3.
Fountain MJ. Key roles and issues of the multiprofessional team. Semin Oncol Nurs1993; 9: 25–31.
4.
Cancer Guidance sub-group of the Clinical Outcomes Group. Improving outcomes in breast cancer–the manual. Leeds: NHS Executive, 1996.
5.
National Council for Hospice and Specialist Palliative Care Services. Specialist palliative care: a statement of definitions. London: National Council for Hospice and Specialist Palliative Care Services, 1995.
6.
Audit Commission Report. What seems to be the matter?London: HMSO, 1993.
7.
The National Cancer Alliance. Patient-centred services? What patients say. Oxford: National Cancer Alliance, 1996.
8.
Fallowfield LJ, Hall A, Maguire P, Baum M. Psychological outcomes of different policies in women with early breast cancer outside a clinical trial. Br Med J1990; 301: 575–580.
9.
Meredith P, Symonds P, Webster L, Lamont D, Pyper E, Gillis CR, Fallowfield L. Information needs of cancer patients in west Scotland: cross-sectional survey of patients' views. Br Med J1996; 313: 724–726.
10.
McWhinney IR, Bass MJ, Donner A. Evaluation of a palliative care service: problems and pitfalls. Br Med J1994; 309: 1340–1342.
11.
Bosanquet N. New challenge for palliative care. Br Med J1997; 314: 1294
12.
Normand C. Economics and evaluation in palliative care. Palliat Med1996; 10: 3–4.
13.
Dickerson K, Scherer E, Lefebvre C. Identification of relevant studies for systematic reviews. Br Med J1994; 309: 1286–1291.
14.
Cancer Guidance sub-group of the Clinical Outcomes Group. Improving outcomes in breast cancer–the research evidence. Leeds: NHS Executive, 1996.
15.
Addington-Hall JM, MacDonald LD, Anderson HR et al. Randomised controlled trial of effects of coordinating care for terminally ill cancer patients. Br Med J1992; 305: 1317–1322.
16.
Raftery JP, Addington-Hall JM, MacDonald LD et al. A randomized controlled trial of the cost-effectiveness of a district co-ordinating service for terminally ill patients. Palliat Med1996; 10: 151–161.
17.
Hughes SL, Cummings J, Weaver F et al. A randomised trial of the cost-effectiveness of VA hospital-based home care for the terminally ill. Health Serv Res1992; 26: 801–817.
18.
Kane RL, Wales J, Bernstein L, Leibowitz A, Kaplan S. A randomised controlled trial of hospice care. Lancet1984; 1: 890–894.
19.
Kane R, Bernstein L, Wales J, Rothenberg R. Hospice effectiveness in controlling pain. J Am Med Assoc1985; 253: 2683–2686.
20.
Kane R, Klein SJ, Bernstein L, Rothenberg R, Wales J. Hospice role in alleviating the emotional stress of terminal patients and their families. Med Care1985; 23: 189–197.
21.
Kane R, Klein SJ, Bernstein L, Rothenberg R. The role of hospice in reducing the impact of bereavement. J Chronic Dis1986; 39: 735–742.
22.
Wales J, Kane R, Robbins S, Bernstein L, Krasnow R. UCLA Hospice evaluation study. Med Care1983; 21: 734–744.
23.
Zimmer JG, Groth-Juncker A, McCusker J. Effects of a physician-led home care team on terminal care. J Am Geriatr Soc1984; 32: 288–292.
24.
Zimmer JG, Groth-Juncker A, McCusker J. A randomized controlled study of a home health care team. Am J Public Health1985; 75: 134–141.
25.
Higginson I, Wade A, McCarthy M. Palliative care: views of patients and their families. Br Med J1990; 301: 277–281.
26.
Mor V, Greer DS, Kastenbaum R. The hospice experiment. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University, 1988: 1–269.
27.
Greer DS, Mor V. An overview of national hospice study findings. J Chronic Dis1986; 39: 5–7.
28.
Greer DS, Mor V, Morris JN et al. An alternative in terminal care: results of the national hospice study. J Chronic Dis1986; 39: 9–26.
29.
Morris JN, Mor V, Golberg RJ et al. The effect of treatment setting and patient characteristics on pain in terminal cancer patients: a report from the national hospice study. J Chronic Dis1986; 39: 27–35.
30.
Morris JN, Suissa S, Sherwood S, Wright SM, Greer D. Last days: a study of quality of life of terminally ill cancer patients. J Chronic Dis1986; 39: 47–62.
31.
Goldberg R, Mor V, Wiemann M, Greer DS, Hiris J. Analgesic use in terminal cancer patients: report from the national hospice study. J Chronic Dis1986; 39: 37–45.
32.
Mor V, Stalker MZ, Gralla R et al. Day hospital as an alternative to inpatient care for cancer patients: a random assignment trial. J Clin Epidemiol1988; 41: 771–785.
33.
Mor V, Masterson-Allen S. Hospice care systems: structure, process, costs, and outcome. New York: Springer, 1987.
34.
Mor V, Masterson-Allen S. A comparison of hospice vs conventional care of the terminally ill cancer patient. Oncology (Huntingt)1990; 4: 85–91.
35.
Ventafridda V, De Conno F, Vigano A, Ripamonti C. Comparison of home and hospital care of advanced cancer patients. Tumori1989; 75: 619–625.
36.
Viney LL, Walker BM, Robertson T, Lilley B, Ewan C. Dying in palliative care units and in hospital: a comparison of the quality of life of terminal cancer patients. J Consult Clin Psychol1994; 62: 157–164.
37.
Wakefield M, Ashby M. Attitudes of surviving relatives to terminal care in South Australia. J Pain Symptom Manage1993; 8: 529–538.
38.
Cartwright A, Seale C. The natural history of a survey. London: King Edward's Hospital Fund for London, 1990.
39.
Seale C. A comparison of hospice and conventional care. Soc Sci Med1991; 32: 147–152.
40.
Lunt B, Neale C. A comparison of hospice and hospital: goals set by staff. Palliat Med1987; 1: 136–148.
41.
McCusker J, Stoddard AM. Effects of an expanding home care program for the terminally ill. Med Care1987; 25: 373–384.
42.
Parkes CM. Terminal care: evaluation of inpatient service at St Christopher's Hospice. Postgrad Med J1979; 55: 517–522.
43.
Parkes CM. Terminal care: evaluation of inpatient service at St Christopher's Hospice. Postgrad Med J1979; 55: 523–527.
44.
Parkes CM, Parkes J. ‘Hospice’ versus ‘hospital’ care–re-evaluation after 10 years as seen by surviving spouses. Postgrad Med J1984; 60: 120–124.
45.
Parkes CM. Terminal care: evaluation of an advisory domiciliary service at St Christopher's Hospice. Postgrad Med J1980; 56: 685–689.
46.
Parkes CM. Terminal care: home, hospital or hospice?Lancet1985; 1: 155–157.
47.
Higginson I, Wade A, McCarthy M. Effectiveness of two palliative support teams. J Public Health Med1992; 14: 50–56.
48.
Hinton J. Comparison of places and policies for terminal care. Lancet1979; 1: 29–32.
49.
Jones RVH. Teams and terminal cancer care at home: do patients and cares benefit?J Inter Prof Care1993; 7: 239–245.
50.
Jones RVH, Hansford J, Fiske J. Death form cancer at home: the carers' perspective. Br Med J1993; 306: 249–251.
51.
Rinck GC, van den Bos GAM, Kleijnen J et al. Methodologic issues in palliative cancer care: a systematic review. J Clin Oncol1997; 15: 1697–1707.
52.
National Council for Hospice and Specialist Palliative Care Services. Working party on clinical guidelines in palliative care: information for purchasers. London: National Council for Hospice and Specialist Palliative Care Services, 1995.
53.
Cancer Relief Macmillan Fund. Organisational audit for specialist palliative care services. London: Cancer Relief Macmillan Fund, 1994.
54.
Twycross R. Introducing palliative care. Oxford: Radcliffe Medical, 1995: 1–178.
55.
Doyle D, Hanks GWC, MacDonald N. Oxford textbook of palliative medicine. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1993: 1–845.
56.
Penson J, Fisher R. Palliative care for people with cancer. London: Edward Arnold, 1991.
57.
Dunlop RJ, Hockley JM. Terminal care support teams: the hospital–hospice interface. New York: Oxford University Press, 1990.
58.
World Health Organisation (WHO). Cancer pain relief and palliative care, 2nd edn.Geneva: WHO, 1996.
59.
Stjernswärd J, Koroltchouk V, Teoh N. National policies for cancer pain relief and palliative care. Palliat Med1992; 6: 273–276.
60.
Chief Medical Officers' Expert Advisory Group on Cancer. A policy framework for commissioning cancer services. London: Department of Health, 1995.
61.
Executive letter EL (96/85). A policy framework for commissioning cancer services. Leeds: NHS Executive, October 1996.
