The Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill proposed to legalise both euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide for those with a terminal illness in the UK. A House of Lords Select Committee was convened to scrutinise this Bill and has recently published its report, which will be debated in Parliament on October 10th 2005.
The written and oral evidence submitted to the Select Committee represented a wide range of views on 'assisted dying'. Much of the evidence from those countries which have legalised euthanasia/physician-assisted suicide (The Netherlands, Belgium, Switzerland and Oregon, USA) dealt with the practicalities of ending life, and the legal procedures and safeguards instigated in these countries.
All the written and oral evidence in the public domain was scrutinised by the authors whilst the Select Committee was sitting. We have extracted those themes relevant to specialist palliative care practice and present them in this paper. We hope that this will provide a useful resource to inform the forthcoming public debate on assisted dying. The evidence of harms inherent in making such a change in the law, as presented to the Select Committee, has moved all three authors to oppose a change in the law.
House of Lords Select Committee on Medical Ethics . Report of the Select Committee on medical ethics 1994, HL Paper 21. London: HMSO , 1994.
2.
Northern Territory Government . Rights of the Terminally Ill Amendment Act 1996. Northern Territory: Northern Territory Government , 1996.
3.
Mr. Kronenberg, Chief Operating Officer, Oregon Medical Association, Q1022.
4.
Association for Palliative Medicine of Great Britain and Ireland . Submission from the Ethics Committee to the Select Committee of the House of Lords on the Assisted Dying Bill. Southampton: Association for Palliative Medicine of Great Britain and Ireland , 2004.
5.
Dr. Legemaate, Legal Counsel, KNMG (Royal Dutch Medical Association), Q1230.
6.
Legemaate J . The Dutch Euthanasia Act and related issues . J Law Med2004; 11: 312–323 .
7.
Professor van den Eynden, Professor in Palliative Care, Antwerp University, Q1855.
8.
Mr. Minelli, Secretary General, Dignitas, Switzerland, Q2325.
9.
Dr. Brunner, Attorney General for the Canton of Zurich, Q2252.
10.
Bowman P . Right to Life submission to the House of Lords Select Committee on the Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill. London: Right to Life , 2004.
11.
Professor Jochemsen, Lindeboom Professor of Medical Ethics, Free University Amsterdam, Q1491.
12.
Dr. Zylicz, Medical Director, Hospice Rozenheuvel, Rozendaal, The Netherlands, Q1510.
13.
The Linacre Centre for Healthcare Ethics . Submission to the House of Lords Select Committee on the Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill on behalf of The Linacre Centre for Healthcare Ethics. UK: The Linacre Centre for Healthcare Ethics , 2004.
14.
Ms. Glidewell, Department of Patient Relations, Oregon Health and Science University, Q652.
15.
Mr. Kronenberg, Chief Operating Officer, Oregon Medical Association, Q1048.
16.
Dr. Parshley, Medical Director, Oregon Board of Medical Examiners, Q925.
17.
Dr. Alberda, Ministry of Health, Welfare and Sport, The Netherlands, Q1367.
18.
Professor van den Eynden, Professor in Palliative Care, Antwerp University, Q1894.
19.
Dr. Alberda, Ministry of Health, Welfare and Sport, The Netherlands, Q1362.
20.
Deliens L . Memorandum to the House of Lords. Belgium: End-of-Life Care Research Group , 2004.
21.
Dr. van den Muijsenburgh, General Practitioner with a specialist interest in palliative care, The Netherlands, Q1491.
22.
Dr. Legemaate, Legal Counsel, KNMG (Royal Dutch Medical Association), Q1289.
23.
Lord Walton of Detchant, Q2051.
24.
Professor Blackburn, Professor of Philosophy, University of Cambridge and Vice-President, British Humanist Association, Q1810.
25.
Professor Maughan, Professor of Oncology, Cardiff University, Q165.
26.
Miss Annetts, Chief Executive, Voluntary Euthanasia Society, UK, Q1.
27.
Medical Ethics Alliance . Written submission to the House of Lords Select Committee on the Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill. Worcester: Medical Ethics Alliance , 2004.
28.
Professor Catto, Chairman, General Medical Council, London, Q325.
29.
Dr. Wilks, Chairman of the Medical Ethics Committee, British Medical Association, London, Q287.
30.
Mental Capacity Act, UK, 2005.
31.
Lord Walton of Detchant, Q2051.
32.
Lord Joffe, sponsor of the Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill, UK, Q98.
33.
Randall F . Personal communication to the House of Lords Select Committee on the Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill. UK, 2005.
34.
Ms. Robinson, Nurse Consultant, St Christopher's Hospice and National Group of Nurse Consultants in Palliative Care, London, Q354.
35.
Dr. Nathanson, Director of Professional Activities, British Medical Association, London, Q306.
36.
Dr. George, Consultant in Palliative Medicine, University College London Medical School and National Council for Hospice and Specialist Palliative Care Services, Q354.
37.
Professor Richards, National Cancer Director, Department of Health, London, Q423.
38.
National Council for Hospice and Specialist Palliative Care Services . Submission on the Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill 2004. London: National Council for Hospice and Specialist Palliative Care Services , 2004.
39.
Disability Rights Commission . Assisted dying policy statement March 2005. London: Disability Rights Commission , 2005.
40.
Dr. Goy, Assistant Professor, Department of Psychiatry, Oregon Health and Science University, Q753.
41.
Dr. George, Consultant in Palliative Medicine, University College London Medical School and National Council for Hospice and Specialist Palliative Care Services, Q387.
42.
Jackson A . Response to call for written evidence for HL Bill 17, session 2003–04. Oregon: Oregon Hospice Association , 2004.
43.
Ganzini L , Nelson HD , Schmidt TA , et al. Physicians' experiences with the Oregon Death with Dignity Act . N Engl J Med2000; 342: 557–563 .
44.
Dr. van Coervorden, General Practitioner with a specialist interest in palliative care and SCEN doctor, The Netherlands, Q1325.
45.
Dr. Zylicz, Medical Director, Hospice Rozenheuvel, Rozendaal, The Netherlands, Q1484.
46.
Dr. Zylicz, Medical Director, Hospice Rozenheuvel, Rosendale, The Netherlands, Q1535.
47.
Dr. Toffler, Professor of Family Medicine, Oregon Health and Science University, Q949.
48.
Dr. Hamilton, Consultant Psychiatrist and Co-founder, Physicians for Compassionate Care, Oregon, Q949.
49.
Ms. Jackson, Executive Director and Chief Executive, Oregon Hospice Association, Q802.
50.
Dr. van der Schalk, Nursing Home Doctor with a specialist interest in palliative care, The Netherlands, Q1711.
51.
Kissane DW , Street A , Nitschke P . Seven deaths in Darwin: case studies under the Rights of Terminally Ill Act, Northern Territory, Australia . Lancet1998; 352: 1097–1102 .
52.
Help the Hospices . Help the Hospices submission on the Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill, summary 2004. London: Help the Hospices , 2004.
53.
Ms. Glidewell, Department of Patient Relations, Oregon Health and Science University, Q623.
54.
Onwuteaka-Philipsen BD , van der Heide A , Koper D , et al. Euthanasia and other end-of-life decisions in The Netherlands in 1990, 1995 and 2001 . Lancet2003; 362: 395–399 .
55.
Dr. George, Consultant in Palliative Medicine, University College London Medical School and National Council for Hospice and Specialist Palliative Care Services, Q354.
56.
Ms. Robinson, Nurse Consultant in Palliative Care, St. Christopher's Hospice and National Group of Nurse Consultants in Palliative Care, UK, Q354.
57.
Dr. Randall, Consultant in Palliative Medicine, Bournemouth and Christchurch Hospital, Dorset, Q1973.
58.
Ms. Wates, Patient, UK, Q1973.
59.
Mak Y , Elwyn G . Voices of the terminally ill: uncovering the meaning of the desire for euthanasia . Palliat Med2005; 19: 343–350 .
60.
Dr. Gilbert, Medical Director, Exeter Hospice Care, Q2025.
61.
Professor Glover, Centre of Medical Law and Ethics, King's College London, Q28.
62.
Dr. Harris, MP, UK, Q1.
63.
Professor McLean, Professor in Law and Ethics in Medicine, University of Glasgow, Q1.
64.
Miss Annetts, Chief Executive, Voluntary Euthanasia Society, UK, Q7.
65.
Dr. Gideonse, Medical Director and Associate Residency Director, Oregon Health and Science University, Q839.
66.
Mr. Minelli, Secretary General, Dignitas, Switzerland, Q2326.
67.
Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill, Appendix 4, HL Paper 86-I. London: HMSO , 2005.
68.
Hughes-Hallett T . Submission to the House of Lords Select Committee on the Assisted Dying Bill. London: Marie Curie Cancer Care , 2004.
69.
Dr. Jeffrey, Chairman of Ethics Committee, Association for Palliative Medicine of Great Britain and Ireland, Q354.
70.
Ms. Robinson, Nurse Consultant, St Christopher's Hospice and National Group of Nurse Consultants in Palliative Care, UK, Q364.
71.
Professor Saunders, Chairman Elect of Ethics Committee, Royal College of Physicians, London, Q244.
72.
Dr. Cox, Royal College of General Practitioners, London, Q244.
73.
Professor Leigh, Neurologist, Institute of Psychiatry and Association of British Neurologists, London, Q1131.
74.
Dr. Cole, Consultant Clinical Oncologist, Oxford Radcliffe NHS Trust, Q1907.
75.
Royal College of General Practitioners . Evidence from the Royal College of General Practitioners to the Select Committee on the Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill (HL). London: Royal College of General Practitioners , 2004.
76.
Underwood J . Letter to the House of Lords Select Committee on the Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill. London: 2004.
77.
Dr. Toffler, Professor of Family Medicine, Oregon Health and Science University, Q990.
78.
Ms. Haley, Executive Director, Oregon Board of Medical Examiners, Q943.
79.
Dr. Kimsma, Member, Case Assessment Committee, The Hague, Q1441.
80.
Dr. Brunner, Attorney General for the Canton of Zurich, Q2261.
81.
Help the Aged . Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill. The Help the Aged response. September 2004. London: Help the Aged , 2004.
82.
Association of Catholic Women . Memorandum. Surrey: Association of Catholic Women , 2004.
83.
Groenewoud JH , van der Heide A , Onwuteaka-Philipsen BD , et al. Clinical problems with the performance of euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide in The Netherlands . New Engl J Med2000; 342: 551–556 .
84.
Mr. Hopkins, Data Analyst, Centre for Health Statistics, Oregon, Q568.
85.
Dr. Hedberg, Medical Epidemiologist, Bioterrorism Preparedness Program, Oregon, Q592.
86.
The Shipman Enquiry. Fifth report – safeguarding patients: lessons from the past – proposals for the future. London: HMSO , 2004.
87.
Mrs. Curtis Thomas, MP, UK, Q167.
88.
Professor Maughan, Professor of Oncology, Cardiff University, Q168.
89.
Ms. Wates, Patient, UK, Q1973.
90.
Ms. Buchanan, Deputy President, Royal College of Nursing, London, Q263.
91.
Royal College of Nursing . Royal College of Nursing of the United Kingdom memorandum to the Lords Committee on the Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill [HL]. London: Royal College of Nursing , 2004.
92.
Ms. Glidewell, Department of Patient Relations, Oregon Health and Science University, Q631.
93.
Ms. Glidewell, Department of Patient Relations, Oregon Health and Science University, Q663.
94.
Dr. Tolle, Director, Centre for Ethics in Healthcare, Oregon Health and Science University, Q686.
95.
Dr. van Coevorden, General Practitioner and SCEN doctor, Amsterdam, Q1317.
96.
Dr. Legemaate, Legal Counsel, KNMG (Royal Dutch Medical Association), Q1233.
97.
Dr. Cox, Royal College of General Practitioners, London, Q248.
98.
Dr. Jonquiere, Chief Executive Officer, NVVE, The Netherlands, Q1611.
99.
Dr. Hedberg, Medical Epidemiologist, Bioterrorism Preparedness Program, Oregon, Q587.
100.
Mr. Minelli, Secretary General, Dignitas, Switzerland, Q2326.
101.
Dr. Stevens, Professor of Radiation Oncology, Oregon Health and Sciences University, Q951.
102.
Dr. Hedberg, Medical Epidemiologist, Bioterrorism Preparedness Program, Oregon, Q591.
103.
Professor Leigh, Neurologist, Institute of Psychiatry and Association of British Neurologists, London, Q1134.
104.
Bateman D . Call for evidence: Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill. London: Association of British Neurologists , 2004.
105.
Ling JR . The submission on behalf of Affinity to the Select Committee on the Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill [HL]. UK: Affinity , 2004.
106.
Professor van den Eynden, Professor in Palliative Care, Antwerp University, Q1888.
107.
Professor Jochemsen, Lindeboom Professor of Medical Ethics, Free University Amsterdam, Q1510.
108.
Professor van der Wal, Head of Department of Public Health, Free University Amsterdam, Q1683.
109.
Dr. van den Muijsenburgh, General Practitioner with a specialist interest in palliative care, The Netherlands, Q1483.
110.
Mr Kohnstamm, President of the World Federation of Right-to-Die Societies, Amsterdam Q1587.
111.
Dr. van den Muijsenburgh, General Practitioner with a specialist interest in palliative care, The Netherlands, Q1537.
112.
Lord Joffe, sponsor of the Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill, UK, Q89.
113.
Lord Joffe, sponsor of the Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill, UK, Q124.
114.
Lord Walton of Detchant, Q2043.
115.
Baroness Finlay of Llandaff, Committee member, Q2088 to Lord Goldsmith, Attorney General.
116.
Professor Leigh, Neurologist, Institute of Psychiatry and Association of British Neurologists, London, Q1140.
117.
Dr. Leuthold, Secretary General, Swiss Academy of Medical Sciences, Q2178.
118.
Professor Foley, Attending Neurologist, Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Centre, New York, Q2115.
119.
House of Lords Select Committee on the Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill. Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill [HL], Volumes I–III, HL Paper 86-I-II-III. London: HMSO , 2005.
120.
The Royal College of Physicians of London Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill [HL]. Written evidence collated by The Royal College of Physicians of London On behalf of The Academy of Medical Royal Colleges. London: Royal College of Physicians of London , 2004.
121.
House of Lords Select Committee on the Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill. Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill [HL], Volume 1, HL Paper 86–I. London: HMSO , 2005.
