The high prevalence of pain and other symptoms throughout the HIV disease trajectory, the need for management of side effects related to antiretroviral therapy, the continuing incidence of cancers and new emerging co-morbidities as a result of extended life expectancy under new therapeutic regimes, and the ongoing need for terminal care all prove the curative versus palliative dichotomy to be inappropriate. Although there is evidence for both need and effectiveness of palliative care in HIV patient care, access is often poor and care less than optimal.
This review aimed to identify evidence of barriers and inequalities in HIV palliative care in order to inform policy and service development. Biomedical databases were searched using a specific strategy, and evidence extracted into the barrier and inequity categories of patient, clinician, service and disease factors. A model of the barriers and inequalities is presented from the evidence. Recommendations are made from the evidence for promoting access and outcomes through integrated palliative care from diagnosis to end-of-life, alongside antiretroviral therapy when initiated. Service responses that have attempted to increase access to palliative care are presented.
Laurence J.Editorial: Prevention vs. treatment and the future of HIV medical care . AIDS Patient Care STDs2002; 16: 354-354 .
2.
Larue F , Fontaine A , Colleau SM . Underestimation and undertreatment of pain in HIV disease: multicentre study . Br Med J1997; 314: 23–28 .
3.
Breitbart W.The undertreatment of pain in ambulatory AIDS patients . Pain1996; 65: 243–249 .
4.
Selwyn PA , Rivard M.Palliative care for AIDS: challenges and opportunities in the era of highly active anti-retroviral therapy . Innovations in End-of-Life Care2003; 4-4 .
5.
Heath KV , Montaner JS , Bondy G , Singer J , O'Shaughnessy MV , Hogg RS . Emerging drug toxicities of highly active antiretroviral therapy for human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection . Current Drug Targets2003; 4: 13–22 .
6.
Mary-Krause M , Cotte L , Simon A , Partisani M , Costagliola D.Increased risk of myocardial infarction with duration of protease inhibitor therapy in HIV-infected men . AIDS2003; 17: 2479–2486 .
7.
Rabinstein AA . Stroke in HIV-infected patients: a clinical perspective . Cerbrovasc Dis2003; 15: 37–44 .
8.
Sperber K , Shao L.Neurologic consequences of HIV infection in the era of HAART . AIDS Patient Care STDs2003; 17: 509–518 .
9.
Hicks C , Currier J , Sax P , Sherer R , Wanke C.Current managemnt challenges in HIV: tolerability of antiretrovirals amd metabolic complications . AIDS Patient Care STDs2003; 17: 221–233 .
10.
Tamalet C , Fantini J , Tourres C , Yahi N.Resistance of HIV-1 to multiple antiretroviral drugs in France: a 6-year survey (1997–2002) based on an analysis of over 7000 genotypes . AIDS2003; 17: 2383–2388 .
11.
Dragsted UB , Gerstoft J , Pedersen C , Peters B , Duran A , Obel N , et al. Randomized trial to evaluate indinavir/ ritonavir versus saquinavir/ritonavir in human immunodeficiency virus type 1-infected patients: the MaxCmin1 Trial . J Infect Dis2003; 188: 635–642 .
12.
Brechtl JR , Breitbart W , Galietta M , Krivo S , Rosenfeld B.The use of highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) in patients with advanced HIV infection: impact on medical, palliative care, and quality of life outcomes . J Pain Symptom Manage2001; 21: 41–51 .
13.
Breitbart W , McDonald MV , Rosenfeld B , Passik SD , Hewitt D , Thaler H , et al. Pain in ambulatory AIDS patients. I: Pain characteristics and medical correlates . Pain1996; 68: 315–321 .
14.
Fantoni M , Ricci F , Del Borgo C , Bevilacqua N , Izzi I , Damiano F , et al. Symptom profile in terminally ill AIDS patients . AIDS Patient Care STDs1996; 10: 171–173 .
15.
Matheny SC . Clinical dilemmas in palliative care for HIV infection . J R Soc Med2001; 94: 449–451 .
16.
Yeguez JF , Martinez SA , Sands DR , Sands LR , Hellinger MD . Colorectal malignancies in HIV-positive patients . Am Surg2003; 69: 981–987 .
17.
Powles T , Nelson M , Bower M.HIV-related lung cancer–a growing concern?Internatinal Journal of STD and AIDS2003; 14: 647–651 .
18.
Dray-Spira R , Lert F.Social health inequalities during the course of chronic HIV disease in the era of highly active antiretroviral therapy . AIDS2003; 17: 383–390 .
19.
Sabin CA . The changing clinical epidemiology of AIDS in the highly active antiretroviral therapy era . AIDS2002; 16 (Suppl 4): S61–S68 .
20.
Harding R , Karus D , Easterbrook P , Raveis V , Higginson IJ , Marconi K.Does palliative care improve outcomes for patients with HIV/AIDS? A systematic review of the evidence . Sex Transm Infect2005; 81: 5–14 .
21.
Harding R , Higginson IJ . Palliative Care in Sub-Saharan Africa: an appraisal of reported activities, evidence and opportunities . Lancet2005, in press.
22.
Harding R , Stewart K , Marconi K , O'Neill JF , Higginson IJ . Current HIV/AIDS end-of-life care in Sub-Saharan Africa: a survey of models, services, challenges and priorities . BioMed Central Public Health2003; 3-3 .
23.
Fontaine A , Larue F , Lassauniere J.Physicians' recognition of the symptoms experienced by HIV patients: how reliable?J Pain Symptom Manage1999; 18: 263–270 .
24.
Henley LD . End-of-life care in HIV-infected children who died in hospital . Developing World Bioethics2002; 2: 39–54 .
25.
Charlton R , Field S , Faull C , Campbell I , Harper C , Harper L.The effect of the general practice registrar year on perceived skills in palliative care in the West Midlands. [erratum appears in Med Educ 2001; 35: 417–18.] . Medical Education2000; 34: 928–935 .
26.
Butters E , Higginson I , George R , McCarthy M.Palliative care for people with HIV/AIDS: views of patients, carers and providers . AIDS Care1993; 5: 105–116 .
27.
Breitbart W , Kaim M , Rosenfeld B.Clinicians' perceptions of barriers to pain management in AIDS . J Pain Symptom Manage1999; 18: 203–212 .
28.
Curtis JR , Patrick DL , Caldwell E , Greenlee H , Collier AC . The quality of patient–doctor communication about end-of-life care: A study of patients with advanced AIDS and their primary care clinicians . AIDS1999; 13: 1123–1131 .
29.
Curtis JR , Patrick DL , Caldwell E , Collier AC . Why don't patients and physicians talk about end-of-life care?Arch Int Med2000; 160: 1690–1696 .
30.
Kelleher P , Cox S , McKeogh M.HIV infection: the spectrum of symptoms and disease in male and female patients attending a London hospice . Palliat Med1997; 11: 152–158 .
31.
Pozzi G , Del Borgo C , Del Forno A , Genualdo A , Mannelli P , Fantoni M.Psychological discomfort and mental illness in patients with AIDS: implications for home care . AIDS Patient Care STDs1999; 13: 555–564 .
32.
Breitbart W , Passik S , McDonald M.Patient-related barriers to pain management in ambulatory AIDS patients . Pain1998; 76: 9–16 .
33.
Frich LM , Borgbjerg FM . Pain and pain treatment in AIDS patients: a longitudinal study . J Pain Symptom Manage2000; 19: 339–347 .
34.
Aiken LH . Satisfaction with in-patient acquired immunodeficiency syndrome care: A national comparison of dedicated and scattered-bed units . Med Care1997; 35: 948–962 .
35.
Beedham H , Wilson-Barnett J.HIV and AIDS care: consumers' views on needs and services . J Adv Nurs1995; 22: 677–686 .
36.
Salt S , Wilson L , Edwards A.The use of specialist palliative care services by patients with human immunodeficiency virus-related illness in the Yorkshire Deanery of the northern and Yorkshire region . Palliat Med1998; 12: 152–160 .
37.
Armes PJ , Higginson IJ . What constitutes high-quality HIV/AIDS palliative care?J Palliat Care1999; 15: 5–12 .
38.
Guthrie B , Nelson M , Gazzard B.In practice. Are people with HIV in London able to die where they plan?AIDS Care1996; 8: 709–713 .
39.
Pierson CM , Curtis JR , Patrick DL . A good death: A qualitative study of patients with advanced AIDS . AIDS Care2002; 14: 587–598 .
40.
Karasz A , Dyche L , Selwyn P.Physicians' experiences of caring for late-stage HIV patients in the post-HAART era: challenges and adaptations . Soc Sci Med2003; 57: 1609–1620 .
41.
Cochrane J.The experience of uncertainty for individuals with HIV/AIDS and the palliative care paradigm . Int J Palliat Nurs2003; 9: 382–388 .
42.
Moons M , Kerkstra A , Biewenga T.Specialized home care for patients with AIDS: an experiment in Rotterdam, The Netherlands . J Adv Nurs1994; 19: 1132–1140 .
43.
Baker NT , Seager RD . A comparison of the psychosocial needs of hospice patients with AIDS and those with other diagnoses . Hospice Journal-Physical, Psychosocial, & Pastoral Care of the Dying1991; 7: 61–69 .
44.
Stajduhar KI , Davies B.Palliative care at home: reflections on HIV/AIDS family caregiving experiences . J Palliat Care1998; 14: 14–22 .
45.
Harding R , Higginson IJ . What is the best way to help caregivers in cancer and palliative care? A systematic literature review of interventions and their effectiveness . Palliat Med2002; 17: 63–71 .
46.
Andersen H , MacElveen-Hoehn P.Gay clients with AIDS: new challenges for hospice programs . Hospice Journal-Physical, Psychosocial, & Pastoral Care of the Dying1988; 4: 37–54 .
47.
Geis S , Fuller RL . The impact of the first gay AIDS patient on hospice staff . Hospice Journal-Physical, Psychosocial, & Pastoral Care of the Dying1985; 1: 17–36 .
48.
Vermette L , Godin G.Nurses' intentions to provide home care: the impact of AIDS and homosexuality . AIDS Care1996; 8: 479–488 .
49.
Moss V.Caring for persons with AIDS: initiatives. The Mildmay approach . J Palliat Care1988; 4: 102–106 .
50.
Rondahl G , Innala S , Carlsson M.Nursing staff and nursing students' attitudes towards HIV-infected and homosexual HIV-infected patients in Sweden and the wish to refrain from nursing . J Adv Nurs2003; 41: 454–461 .
51.
Wishnie E.Children with AIDS: Pain syndromes and unique issues of assessment and management . Child Adolesct Psychiatr Clin N Am1997; 6: 863–878 .
52.
Gaughan DM , Hughes MD , Seage GR, III , Selwyn PA , Carey VJ , Gortmaker SL , et al. The prevalence of pain in pediatric human immunodeficiency virs/acquired immunodeficiency syndrome as reported by participants in the pediatric late outcomes study (PACTG 219) . Pediatrics2002; 109: 1144–1152 .
53.
Sambamoorthi U , Walkup J , McSpiritt E , Warner L , Castle N , Crystal S.Racial differences in end-of-life care for patients with AIDS . AIDS and Public Policy Journal2000; 15: 136–148 .
54.
Cox C.Hospice care for persons with AIDS: findings from a national study . Hospice Journal-Physical, Psychosocial, & Pastoral Care of the Dying1998; 13: 21–34 .
55.
Wenger NS , Kanouse DE , Collins RL , Liu H , Schuster MA , Gifford AL , et al. End-of-life discussions and preferences among persons with HIV . JAMA2001; 285: 2880–2887 .
56.
O'Neill J , Marconi K.Access to palliative care in the USA: why emphasize vulnerable populations?J R Soc Med2001; 94: 452–454 .
57.
Smith G.Palliative care in Toronto for people with AIDS: The impact of class on poor PWAs . J Palliat Care2000; 10: 46–50 .
58.
Daneault S , Labadie J.Terminal HIV disease and extreme poverty: a review of 307 home care files . J Palliat Care1999; 15: 6–12 .
59.
Heckman TG , Peters J , Kelly J.Barriers to care among persons living with HIV/AIDS in urban and rural areas . AIDS Care1998; 10: 365–375 .
60.
Lockman-Samkowiak J.Care of patients with acquired immune deficiency syndrome in rural areas . J Intraven Nurs1994; 17: 206–209 .
61.
Neubecker J.Hospice: a comprehensive program . Health Progress1994; 75: 28–31 .
62.
Stephenson J , Woods S , Scott B , Meadway J.Clinical update. HIV-related brain impairment: from palliative care to rehabilitation . Int J Palliat Nurs2000; 6: 6–11 .
63.
Baker A.Dedicated palliative care . Nursing Times1997; 93: 36–37 .
64.
Frank RR , Campbell ML . Caring for terminally ill patients: One hospital's team approach . J Crit Illn1999; 14: 51–55 .
65.
Adelstein W , Burton S.Palliative care in the acute hospital setting . J Neurosci Nurs1998; 30: 200–204 .
66.
Craig EL , Craig RE . Prison hospice: an unlikely success . American Journal of Hospice & Palliative Care1999; 16: 725–779 .
67.
Maull FW . Issues in prison hospice: toward a model for the delivery of hospice care in a correctional setting . Hospice Journal-Physical, Psychosocial, & Pastoral Care of the Dying1998; 13: 57–82 .
68.
Taylor PB . End-of-life care behind bars . Illness, Crisis & Loss2002; 10: 233–241 .
69.
Heath JM . Care of persons with AIDS in the nursing home . Fam Med1998; 30: 436–440 .
70.
Buchanan RJ , Wang S , Huang C.Profiles of nursing home residents with HIV . Journal of Health Care for the Poor & Underserved2002; 13: 379–391 .
71.
Selwyn PA , Forstein M.Overcoming the false dichotomy of curative vs. palliative care for late stage HIV/AIDS . JAMA2003; 290: 806–814 .
72.
Dinat N , Russell A.Palliative care – a clinical approach for adults with HIV/AIDS . The Southern African Journal of HIV Medicine2003; 12: 40–45 .
73.
Lucas C , Glare PA , Sykes JV . Contribution of a liaison clinical pharmacist to an in-patient palliative care unit . Palliat Med1997; 11: 209–216 .
74.
Goldstone I , Kuhl D , Johnson A , Le R , McLeod A.Patterns of care in advanced HIV disease in a tertiary treatment centre . AIDS Care1995; 7 (Suppl 1): S47–S56 .
75.
Manfredi R , Mastroianni A , Coronado O , Chiodo F.Therapeutic and diagnostic procedures in hospitalized AIDS patients with terminal illness . AIDS Care1996; 8: 373–376 .
76.
Crossley ML . Improving AIDS palliative care provision by changing attitudes: Problems and limitations . International Journal of Health Promotion & Education2001; 39: 58–63 .
77.
O'Neill JF , Marconi K , Surapruik A , Blum N.Improving HIV/AIDS services through palliative care: An HRSA perspective . Journal of Urban Health2000; 77: 244–254 .
78.
O'Neill JF , Romaguera R , Parham D , Marconi K.Practicing palliaitve care in resource-poor settings . J Pain Symptom Manage2002; 24: 148–151 .
79.
Raveis VH , Karus D , Marconi K , Higginson IJ , Hanna B , Alexander C , et al. Establishing the evidence base for palliative care to the medically underserved with HIV/ AIDS . XV International AIDS Conference, Bangkok, Thailand, July 11–16, 2004.
80.
Selwyn PA , Rivard M , Kappell D , Goeren B , LaFosse H , Schwartz C , et al. Palliative Care for AIDS at a large urban teaching hospital: program description and preliminary outcomes . Innovations in End-of-Life Care2002; 4-4 .
81.
Higginson IJ . Evaluation of care for HIV/AIDS patients by two community teams in London, UK. Copenhagen: WHO , 1990.
82.
Higginson IJ , McCarthy M.Validity of the support team assessment schedule: do staffs' ratings reflect those made by patients or their families?Palliat Med1993; 7: 219–228 .
83.
Selwyn PA , Arnold R.From fate to tragedy: the changing meanings of life, death and AIDS . Ann Intern Med1998; 129: 899–902 .
84.
Greenberg B , McCorkle R , Vlahov D , Selwyn PA . Palliative care for HIV disease in the era of highly active antiretroviral therapy . Journal of Urban Health2000; 77: 150–165 .
85.
Easterbrook P , Meadway J.The changing epidemiology of HIV infection: New challenges for HIV palliative care . J R Soc Med2001; 94: 442–448 .
86.
Finlay I.UK strategies for palliative care . J R Soc Med2001; 94: 437–441 .
