Electrical stimulation of human tibialis anterior: (A) contractile properties are stable over a range of submaximal voltages;(B) high- and low-frequency fatigue are inducible and reliably assessable at submaximal voltages

Abstract

Objectives: To investigate the validity and reliability of submaximal voltage stimulation for assessing the ‘fresh’ contractile properties of human tibialis anterior muscle (TA) and the efficacy of such stimulation in inducing and assessing high- and low-frequency fatigue.

Interventions: (A) Contractile properties of fresh TA were assessed in six normal volunteers using multifrequency stimulation trains (comprising 2 seconds at each of 10, 20 and 50 Hz, arranged contiguously) over a range of submaximal voltages. (B) On three separate occasions, fatigue was induced in the TA of 10 normal volunteers by means of a 3-minute unbroken sequence of the described multifrequency stimulation trains, delivered at a ‘standardized’ submaximal voltage. This fatiguing protocol was preceded by discrete multifrequency stimulation trains, at the same standardized voltage, but followed by discrete multifrequency trains delivered over a range of submaximal voltages (which included the standardized voltage).

Outcome measures: In experiment A the 10:50 Hz and 20:50 Hz force ratios were analysed for between-voltages variability using coefficients of variation (CVs), and for trends using Friedman tests and post-hoc Wilcoxon tests. In experiment B low-frequency fatigue was detected using 10:50 Hz and 20:50 Hz force ratios derived from the discrete multifrequency trains. High-frequency fatigue was calculated from the decline in high-frequency force which occurred during the fatiguing protocol itself. Each parameter was assessed for between-days repeatability using CVs.

Results: In experiment A the ‘fresh’ 10:50 Hz force ratio was clearly unreliable at voltages which generated <10% of maximal voluntary contractile force (MVC) (CV ≤29.7%), but was reasonably reliable at voltages which generated 20–30% of MVC (CV ≤11.5%; p = 0.847). The ‘fresh’ 20:50 Hz force ratio was, in contrast, extremely reliable throughout the tested voltage range (CV ≤5.8%; p = 0.636) in fresh muscle. In experiment B paired t-tests indicated that the fatiguing protocol induced significant high-frequency fatigue (p <0.0037) and low-frequency fatigue (p <0.0008 for ‘fresh’ versus ‘fatigued’ 10:50 Hz force ratio; p <0.0001 for ‘fresh’ versus ‘fatigued’ 20:50 Hz force ratio). In muscle thus fatigued, the 20:50 Hz force ratio was extremely reliable in the 20–33% of MVC range (CV ≤7.3%; p = 0.847). Between-days repeatability was poor for the 10:50 Hz force ratio in both fresh and fatigued muscle (CV ≤23.8 and 44.4% respectively), but was highly acceptable for both voluntary and stimulated fatigue indices and for the 20:50 Hz force ratio, the latter in both fresh and fatigued muscle.

Conclusions: These results confirm the validity and reliability of submaximal voltages in assessing contractile properties (including low-frequency fatiguability) and inducing fatigue of human TA.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Liberson WT , Holmquest HJ , Scott D et al. Functional electrotherapy: stimulation of the peroneal nerve synchronised with the swing phase of the gait of hemiplegic patients. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1961; 42: 101–105.

Cooper RG , Stokes MJ , Gibson H , Edwards RHT . Minimising fatigue for functional electrical stimulation of muscle. Clin Rehabil 1989; 3: 333–340.

Cooper RG , Edwards RHT , Gibson H , Stokes MJ . Human muscle fatigue: frequency dependence of excitation and force generation. J Physiol 1988; 397: 585–599.

Davies CT , White MJ . Muscle weakness following dynamic exercise in humans. J Appl Physiol: Resp, Environ Exerc Physiol 1982; 53: 236–241.

Edwards RHT , Newham DJ . Force: frequency relationship determined by percutaneous stimulation of the quadriceps muscle. J Physiol 1984; 353: 128P-128P.

Edwards RHT , Hill DK , Jones DA , Merton PA . Fatigue of long duration in human skeletal muscle after exercise. J Physiol 1977; 272: 769–778.

Binder-Macleod SA , Halden EE , Jungles KA . Effects of stimulation intensity on the physiological responses of human motor units. Med Sci Sports Exerc 1995; 27: 556–565.

Scott OM , Vrbova G , Hyde SA , Dubowitz V . Effects of chronic low frequency stimulation on normal human tibialis anterior muscle. J Neurol, Neurosurg Psychiatry 1985; 48: 774–781.

Davis H , Davis PA . Fatigue in skeletal muscle in relation to the frequency of stimulation. Am J Physiol 1932; 101: 339–356.

10.

Jones DA , Bigland-Ritchie B , Edwards RHT . Excitation frequency and muscle fatigue: mechanical responses during voluntary and stimulated contractions. Exp Neurol 1979; 64: 401–413.

11.

Bigland-Ritchie B , Jones DA , Woods JJ . Excitation frequency and muscle fatigue: electrical responses during human voluntary and stimulated contractions. Exp Neurol 1979; 64: 414–427.

12.

Edwards RHT , Hill DK , Jones DA , Merton PA . Fatigue of long duration in human skeletal muscle after exercise. J Physiol 1977; 272: 769–778.

13.

Stokes MJ , Edwards RHT , Cooper RG . Effect of low frequency fatigue on human muscle strength and fatiguability during subsequent stimulated activity. Eur J Appl Physiol 1989; 59: 278–283.

14.

Baker LL . Neuromuscular electrical stimulation in the restoration of purposeful limb movements. In: Wolf SL ed. Electrotherapy. New York: Churchill Livingstone. 1981: 25–48.

15.

Marsden CD , Meadows JC , Merton PA . ‘Muscular wisdom’ that minimises fatigue during prolonged effort in man: peak rates of motoneuron discharge and slowing of discharge during fatigue. In: Desmedt JE ed. Motor control mechanisms in health and disease. New York: Raven Press, 1983: 161–211.

16.

Binder-Macleod SA , Guerlin T . Preservation of force output through progressive reduction of stimulation frequency in human quadriceps femoris muscle. Phys Ther 1990; 70: 619–625.

17.

Binder-Macleod SA , Barker CB . Use of a catchlike property of human skeletal muscle to reduce fatigue. Muscle Nerve 1991; 14: 850–857.

18.

Edwards RHT , Jones DA , Newham DJ . Lowfrequency stimulation and changes in human muscle contractile properties. J Physiol 1982; 328: 29–30P.

19.

Rutherford OM , Jones DA . Contractile properties and fatiguability of the human adductor pollicis and first dorsal interosseuos: a comparison of the effects of two chronic stimulation patterns. J Neurol Sci 1988; 85: 319–331.

20.

Stein RB , Gordon T , Jefferson J et al. Optimal stimulation of paralyzed muscle after human spinal cord injury. J Appl Physiol 1992; 72: 1393–1400.

21.

Burke RE , Levine DN , Tsairis P , Zajac FE . Physiological types and histochemical profiles in motor units of the cat medial gastrocnemius. J Physiol 1973; 234: 723–748.

22.

Edwards RHT , Young A , Hosking GP , Jones DA . Human skeletal muscle function: description of tests and normal values. Clin Sci Mol Med 1977; 52: 283–290.

23.

Mellor R , Stokes MJ . Detection and severity of low frequency fatigue in the human adductor pollicis muscle. J Neurol Sci 1992; 108: 196–201.

24.

Lopes MD , Russell DR , Whitwell J , Jeejeebhoy KN . Skeletal muscle function in malnutrition. Am J Clin Nutr 1982; 36: 602–610.

25.

Russell DR , Leiter LA , Whitwell EB , Marliss EB , Jeejeebhoy KN . Skeletal muscle function during hypocaloric diets and fasting: a comparison with standard nutritional assessment parameters. Am J Clin Nutr 1983; 37: 133–138.

26.

Newham DJ . Nutritional status and skeletal muscle contraction. Br J Parent Ther 1986; July/Aug: 93–96.

27.

Marsh E , Sale D , McComas AJ , Quinlan J . Influence of joint position on ankle dorsiflexion in humans. J Appl Physiol: Resp Environ Exerc Physiol 1981; 51: 160–167.

28.

Belanger AY , McComas AJ . A comparison of contractile properties in human arm and leg muscles. Eur J Appl Physiol 1985; 54: 326–330.

29.

Krarup C . Enhancement and diminution of mechanical tension evoked by staircase and by tetanus in rat muscle. J Physiol 1981; 311: 355–372.

30.

Vandervoort AA , McComas AJ . Contractile changes in opposing muscles of the human ankle joint with aging. J Appl Physiol 1986; 61: 361–367.

31.

Stokes MJ . Reliability and repeatability of methods for measuring muscle in physiotherapy. Physiother Pract 1985; 1: 71–76.

32.

Solomonow M . External control of the neuromuscular system. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 1984; 31: 752–763.

33.

Sinacore DR , Delitto A , King DS , Rose SJ . Type II fibre activation with electrical stimulation: a preliminary report. Phys Ther 1990; 70: 416–422.

34.

Trimble MH , Enoka RM . Mechanisms underlying the training effects associated with neuromuscular electrical stimulation. Phys Ther 1991; 71: 273–280.

35.

Knaflitz M , Merletti R , De Luca CJ . Inference of motor unit recruitment order in voluntary and electrically stimulated contractions. J Appl Physiol 1990; 46: 451–456.

36.

Williams PL , Warwick R , Dyson M , Bannister LH eds. Gray's anatomy: 37th edition. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone, 1989.

37.

Mannion AF , Dolan P , Adams GG , Adams MA , Cooper RG . Prediction of maximal back extensor strength using submaximal contractions with twitch superimposition. Br J Rheumatol 1996; 36(suppl 1): 103-103.

38.

Merton PA . Voluntary strength and fatigue. J Physiol 1954; 123: 553–564.

39.

Gibson H , Cooper RG , Stokes MJ , Edwards RHT . Mechanisms resisting fatigue in isometrically contracting human skeletal muscle. Q J Exp Physiol 1988; 73: 903–914.

40.

Barcroft H , Millen JLE . The blood flow through muscle during sustained contraction. J Physiol 1939; 97: 17–31.

41.

Scott OM , Vrbova G , Hyde SA , Dubovitz V . Responses of muscles of patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy to chronic electrical stimulation. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1986; 49: 1427–1434.