Background: Disability scores, such as the Functional Independence Measure (FIM) and Barthel Index, have been shown to correlate with care needs but cannot be used to assess them directly, as they do not indicate the number of people required to help with a task, nor the time taken. The Northwick Park Dependency Score (NPDS) is an ordinal scale that can be used to assess impact on nursing time. It takes 3–5 minutes to complete. Together with a short set of additional questions, it may be used directly to assess care needs in the community and to facilitate discharge planning.
Aims: To develop and evaluate the NPDS for use in a rehabilitation setting.
Methods: (1)Development: Following a survey of existing instruments, tasks were selected on the basis of their impact on nursing time and divided into Basic Care Needs (BCN) and Special Nursing Needs (SNN). Cut-off points were devised to reflect the number of helpers needed and time taken. Following evaluation of the NPDS version 5, minor changes were made to produce version 6 which was re-evaluated on a smaller scale. (2)Evaluation: Inter-rater and intra-rater reliability were tested in a cohort of 23 inpatients using five senior nurses. Analysis included assessment of degree of association, significant differences, absolute agreement, and agreement ±1 level. Although there is no gold standard, the BCN section should correlate inversely with independently assessed Barthel scores. Re-evaluation of version 6 was undertaken using the same method of analysis in a cohort of 21 patients using three senior nurses.
Results: On initial evaluation inter-rater reliability testing showed an excellent level of association in total composite score between each pair of nurses (rho = 0.73–0.92, p <0.01) and agreement ±1 level for individual items ranged from 73 to 100%. Significant disagreements were in six items. On reevaluation following minor modification, high levels of association were still seen for total BCN, SNN and composite scores both between and within raters, with very satisfactory levels of agreement for individual items. The BCN section of the NPDS showed good inverse correlation with Barthel scores (rho = 0.91, p <0.01).
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Disler PB , Roy CW , Smith BP . Predicting hours of care needed . Arch Phys Med Rehabil1993; 74: 139–143 .
2.
Granger CV , Cotter AC , Hamilton BB , Fiedler RC . Functional assessment scales: A study of persons after stroke . Arch Phys Med Rehabil1993; 74: 133–138 .
3.
Lovett RB , Reardon MB , Gordon BK , McMillan SC . Validity and reliability of medical and surgical oncology patient acuity tools . Oncol Nurs Forum1994; 21: 1709–1712 .
4.
Marsee VD , Lovett RB , McMillan SC . Validity and reliability of an oncology critical care patient acuity tool . Oncol Nurs Forum1995; 22: 967–971 .
5.
McNaughton N . Emergency department patient classification system . Nurs Management1995; 26: 34–38 .
6.
Meyer G , James C . Matching staff to patient dependency . Nurs Times1990; 86: 40–42 .
7.
O'Brien GJ . The intuitive method of patient dependency . Nurs Times1986; June 4: 57–61 .
8.
Stevens J , Goucher J . Measurement of patient dependency . Nurs Times1985; January 23: 54–55 .
9.
Soeken KL , Prescott PA . Patient intensity for nursing index: the measurement model . Res Nurs Health1991; 141: 297–304 .
10.
Santopaolo R . Developing a patient classification system (PCS) in a rehablitation setting using the GRASP system . Rehabil Nurs1986; 11: 20–24 .
11.
McPherson K , Pentland B , Cudmore SF , Prescott RJ . An inter-rater reliability study of the Functional Assessment measure (FIM+FAM) . Disabil Rehabil1996; 18: 341–347 .
